Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables

Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables

07.02.2014 Views

Camilty Wind Farm is of high importance. There would be no physical effect on the SM. There would be an effect on its setting. The change would be detectable but would not fundamentally or materially compromise the ability to understand the setting. The level of effect is therefore assessed as small. The effect of the proposed wind farm on the SM is slight adverse 10.5.43 SM7254 Old West Calder Church, West Calder is located in the centre of West Calder, some 4.6 km to the north-west of the boundary of the proposed wind farm. The structure is also a listed building, listed at Category B (HB number 14212). The effect of the proposed wind farm on the SM is considered with the listed building, at paragraph 10.5.44, below. 10.5.44 Cairns Castle is located at the south-west corner of Harperigg Reservoir, some 2.75 km to the east of the boundary of the proposed wind farm. This is also a listed building (HB number 47559). The effect of the proposed wind farm on the SM is considered with the listed building, at paragraph 10.5.59, below. 10.5.45 SM11210 West Harwood, burial mound 720 m SSE of is located on the edge of the woodland at West Harwood, some 3.4 km to the north-west of the boundary of the proposed wind farm. The setting of the SM is contained by the extensive woodland planting, including on its southeast side. The SM is of high importance. There would be no physical effect on the SM. The effect on its setting would be detectable but would not fundamentally or materially compromise the ability to understand the setting. The level of effect is therefore assessed as small. The effect of the proposed wind farm on the SM is slight adverse. 10.5.46 SM1207 Murieston Castle, Wester Murieston, West Calder is located at Murieston Castle Farm, some 3.2 km to the north of the boundary of the proposed wind farm. This is also a listed building (HB number 18441). The effect of the proposed wind farm on the SM is considered with the listed building, at paragraph 10.5.54, below. Listed Buildings 10.5.47 There are 2 Category A, 23 Category B and 8 Category C Listed Buildings between 1.5 and 5 km of the proposed wind farm and within the ZTV. Linhouse Mansion and Associated Buildings 10.5.48 Linhouse Mansion (HB number 14156) is located some 2.7 km north-east of the boundary of the proposed wind farm, on the north side of Linhouse Water. The building comprises two square towers attached at one corner only and is of three-storeys and a garret. There is an unusual viewing platform above the original stair tower, with views towards the south. The structure is listed at Category A (HB number 14156). The Doocot at Linhouse is listed at Category B (HB number 14157). 10.5.49 The setting of the doocot comprises the mansion and surrounding grounds. The setting of the mansion is primarily formed by its surrounding grounds and woodland, which provide significant screening. The mansion also has views to the south-east, from the viewing platform at roof height. These views are designed and form part of the setting of the listed building. 10.5.50 Figure 10.6 provides the existing view and an indication of the likely proposed view from . The existing view shows trees in the foreground with a view of Camilty Hill over them. Pylons associated with power lines running along the south side of Morton Burn are visible in the middle ground. In the proposed view, six turbines would be visible, in four groups. The March 2013 10-22 ES Chapter 10 Cultural Heritage and Archaeology Copyright Partnerships for Renewables Development Co. Ltd 2013 ©

Camilty Wind Farm turbines would be located between the existing pylons and would appear lower against the skyline. There would be little screening of the turbines from this viewpoint. 10.5.51 Linhouse mansion is of high importance. There would be no physical effect on the listed building. Much of the buildings setting would remain unchanged. The effect on its setting would result from a change to the view towards the proposed wind farm in which turbines would become visible. The change in this view would affect the setting of the listed building materially but not fundamentally, in that turbines would be visible but would not screen any currently available views. On this basis the ability of the setting of the listed building to be understood would be moderately compromised. The level of effect is therefore assessed as medium, but towards the lower end of that range. The effect of the proposed wind farm on the listed building is moderate adverse. Other Listed Buildings 10.5.52 The Railway Viaduct, Linhouse Water was built in 1842 and comprises six segmental arches with dressed stones. The structure is listed at Category A (HB number 7365). 10.5.53 The setting of the listed railway viaduct primarily comprises the valley of the Linhouse Water over which it passes and the corridor of the railway of which it is a part. Woodland on the south-west side of the viaduct would minimise views towards the proposed wind farm. The listed building is of high importance. There would be no physical effect on the listed building. The effect on its setting would be detectable but would not fundamentally or materially compromise the ability to understand the setting. The level of effect is therefore assessed as small. The effect of the proposed wind farm on the listed building is slight adverse. 10.5.54 There are a number of listed buildings within the built area of West Calder. These include HB numbers 14210, West Calder 13-19 (Odd Nos) Main Street, Former West Calder Co-Op, 14211 West Calder East End, Library, 14212 Old West Calder Kirk is (also a SM, number 7254) and 19677 West Calder Station, including Cast-Iron Footbridge to E. These buildings are all listed at Category B, while HB number 51118 43 Main Street, Railway Inn is listed at Category C. 10.5.55 The listed buildings are grouped around Main Street, with Old West Calder Kirk just to the south on Kirkgate and the Library at its junction with Harburn Road. Although the listed buildings lie within the ZTV, the built development around Main Street is inward looking with few views outwards towards the proposed wind farm. Landscape viewpoint 8 (Figure 9.14/8ac)shows the view from the B7008 road at the southern extremity of West Calder towards the proposed wind farm. From this viewpoint, the proposed wind farm would be difficult to discern even in winter. The settings of the listed buildings primarily comprise each other and the remainder of the built development of central West Calder. The assets are of medium and high importance. There would be no physical effect on the assets, nor any effect on their setting. The level of effect is therefore assessed as no change. The effect of the proposed wind farm on the assets is none. 10.5.56 Hermand House (HB number 14219) and Hermand Coachhouse and Stables (HB number 14220) are listed at Category B are located to the east of the built development at West Calder. The front of the house looks to the south-east, away from the proposed wind farm. Both the main house and the coach house are located in an area which is shown on the OS twenty-five inch edition of 1894 as being parkland, with a wooded drive (now removed) leaving to the east from the main house. A considerable amount of mature woodland remains, which would provide screening. March 2013 10-23 ES Chapter 10 Cultural Heritage and Archaeology Copyright Partnerships for Renewables Development Co. Ltd 2013 ©

<strong>Camilty</strong> <strong>Wind</strong> <strong>Farm</strong><br />

turbines would be located between the existing pylons and would appear lower against the<br />

skyline. There would be little screening of the turbines from this viewpoint.<br />

10.5.51 Linhouse mansion is of high importance. There would be no physical effect on the listed<br />

building. Much of the buildings setting would remain unchanged. The effect on its setting<br />

would result from a change to the view towards the proposed wind farm in which turbines<br />

would become visible. The change in this view would affect the setting of the listed building<br />

materially but not fundamentally, in that turbines would be visible but would not screen any<br />

currently available views. On this basis the ability of the setting of the listed building to be<br />

understood would be moderately compromised. The level of effect is there<strong>for</strong>e assessed as<br />

medium, but towards the lower end of that range. The effect of the proposed wind farm on the<br />

listed building is moderate adverse.<br />

Other Listed Buildings<br />

10.5.52 The Railway Viaduct, Linhouse Water was built in 1842 and comprises six segmental arches<br />

with dressed stones. The structure is listed at Category A (HB number 7365).<br />

10.5.53 The setting of the listed railway viaduct primarily comprises the valley of the Linhouse Water<br />

over which it passes and the corridor of the railway of which it is a part. Woodland on the<br />

south-west side of the viaduct would minimise views towards the proposed wind farm. The<br />

listed building is of high importance. There would be no physical effect on the listed building.<br />

The effect on its setting would be detectable but would not fundamentally or materially<br />

compromise the ability to understand the setting. The level of effect is there<strong>for</strong>e assessed as<br />

small. The effect of the proposed wind farm on the listed building is slight adverse.<br />

10.5.54 There are a number of listed buildings within the built area of West Calder. These include HB<br />

numbers 14210, West Calder 13-19 (Odd Nos) Main Street, Former West Calder Co-Op,<br />

14211 West Calder East End, Library, 14212 Old West Calder Kirk is (also a SM, number<br />

7254) and 19677 West Calder Station, including Cast-Iron Footbridge to E. These buildings<br />

are all listed at Category B, while HB number 51118 43 Main Street, Railway Inn is listed at<br />

Category C.<br />

10.5.55 The listed buildings are grouped around Main Street, with Old West Calder Kirk just to the<br />

south on Kirkgate and the Library at its junction with Harburn Road. Although the listed<br />

buildings lie within the ZTV, the built development around Main Street is inward looking with<br />

few views outwards towards the proposed wind farm. Landscape viewpoint 8 (Figure 9.14/8ac)shows<br />

the view from the B7008 road at the southern extremity of West Calder towards the<br />

proposed wind farm. From this viewpoint, the proposed wind farm would be difficult to discern<br />

even in winter. The settings of the listed buildings primarily comprise each other and the<br />

remainder of the built development of central West Calder. The assets are of medium and<br />

high importance. There would be no physical effect on the assets, nor any effect on their<br />

setting. The level of effect is there<strong>for</strong>e assessed as no change. The effect of the proposed<br />

wind farm on the assets is none.<br />

10.5.56 Hermand House (HB number 14219) and Hermand Coachhouse and Stables (HB number<br />

14220) are listed at Category B are located to the east of the built development at West<br />

Calder. The front of the house looks to the south-east, away from the proposed wind farm.<br />

Both the main house and the coach house are located in an area which is shown on the OS<br />

twenty-five inch edition of 1894 as being parkland, with a wooded drive (now removed)<br />

leaving to the east from the main house. A considerable amount of mature woodland<br />

remains, which would provide screening.<br />

March 2013 10-23 ES Chapter 10<br />

Cultural Heritage and Archaeology<br />

Copyright <strong>Partnerships</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Renewables</strong> Development Co. Ltd 2013 ©

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!