Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables

Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables

07.02.2014 Views

Camilty Wind Farm hills, although the majority of the Pentland ridge would remain unhindered by views of wind farms. The overall views of this distinctive landscape feature would not be unacceptably compromised. The sensitivity of occupiers of vehicles on this road is medium and the change in view would be of a small magnitude. The level of effect would be Slight. 9.5.132 At night, the warning lights on turbines would be seen in the context of existing lights at properties and settlements in the landscape and the Pates Hill Wind Farm to the right of the view. The level of effect on night time views would be Slight. Sequential Effects 9.5.133 Sequential receptors are illustrated in Figure 9.20. Windygreen to Camilty Plantation Travelling north on the A70 9.5.134 Potential views of the proposed wind farm would be gained from approximately 7 km of this road which lies within the ZTV. 9.5.135 Sporadic views through gaps in roadside vegetation and dips in the landform from the road towards the proposed wind farm would be gained between 11 km and 4 km from the site. The turbines would form a distant to mid-distance new element in these views, often in combination with the Pates Hill Wind Farm to the left of the view. Within 4 km of the site, the views are more open and would enable the proposed wind farm to be seen rising out of conifer plantations beyond the fringes of the Pentland Hills Regional Park. Over a 2 km stretch of this road the view is alternately revealed and then concealed by mature roadside planting. Views of the proposed wind farm would be glimpsed through vegetation and not immediately apparent in the landscape. The sensitivity of the receptor is medium and the magnitude of change in view would be small, resulting in a Slight effect, which is not significant. 9.5.136 Within 2 km of the site, the views open out again and would allow the turbines to be seen in close proximity, as dominant new additions to the largely rural view. As the road follows the southern boundary of the site, fragmented views through boundary vegetation across blocks of varying ages of commercial forestry extend over a relatively flat landscape to the horizon. The proposed wind farm would form a dominant feature in the view, whilst allowing views through to the landscape beyond. To the right of the road, dense blocks of conifers obscure views to the Pentland Hills. The magnitude of change in view from this section of the road would be large resulting in a Major to Moderate effect, which would be significant. Auchinoon to Camilty Plantation Travelling South on the A70 9.5.137 Potential views of the proposed wind farm would be gained from approximately a 4 km long section of this route. 9.5.138 As the road travels south west around the base of Auchinoon Hill, beside Harperrig Reservoir, the proposed wind farm would become visible ahead in the middle distance above intervening groups of trees. Turbines at the Pates Hill Wind Farm would be visible to the right of this group and the Pentland Hills would form the focus of the view to the left. The magnitude of change would be medium resulting in a Moderate effect on receptors, which is not significant. 9.5.139 Where the road doglegs to the south at Wester Causwayend, roadside trees, properties and the orientation of the road would prevent most views of the proposed wind farm. The view opens up again approximately 0.5 km to the south west, where it is directly aligned on the March 2013 9-73 ES Chapter 9 Landscape and Visual Copyright Partnerships for Renewables Development Co. Ltd 2013 ©

Camilty Wind Farm site. Mid-distance views towards the proposed wind farm as a prominent new element within a landscape of grazing land and large expanses of coniferous plantation define the scene. The Pates Hill Wind Farm is visible emerging from forestry to the right of the view. The turbines at the Camilty Wind Farm would become more dominant in the view as the road approaches the site boundary. The magnitude of change would be large resulting in a Major effect on views, which is significant 9.5.140 As the road passes by the southern edge of the site near views of the turbines would continue to provide the focus in the landscape of commercial forestry. Views to the left are screened by mature stands of conifers. The tops of turbines at Pates Hill are visible above the tree tops to the right of the view. The change in view would result in a Major, and thus significant, effect for occupiers of vehicles on this stretch of road. The B7008 Travelling South from West Calder to the A70 9.5.141 Roadside trees and woodland would limit views out from this road to a length of approximately 2 km. For a distance of approximately 2 km from West Calder to the site boundary, views are restricted to occasional glimpses of turbines between blocks of woodland and roadside trees and hedgerows to the Pentland Hills in the distance. The magnitude of change would be small leading to a Slight effect, which is not significant. 9.5.142 As the road approaches the site boundary, the conifer plantation at Camilty is set back from the road around the Roman Fortlet site. The tops of turbines would form a prominent addition to the view, with a backdrop of the distant Pentland Hills. The magnitude of change would be medium, resulting in a Moderate significance of effect, which is not significant. The B7008 Travelling North from the A70 to the Roman Fortlet 9.5.143 Views of the proposed wind farm would be possible from less than 0.5 km of this route beside the site. At the junction with the A70, the proposed wind farm would be partially visible through deciduous roadside vegetation, mainly in the winter. Where the road passes open land in which the Roman Fortlet is located, open, oblique views of turbines rising out of the forestry beyond would be gained. The magnitude of change would be medium, resulting in a Moderate effect, which is not significant. The Lockerbie to Livingston Railway Travelling North from Auchengray to Harburn 9.5.144 In the limited locations where the railway is at grade or on embankment lengthy views would be gained over the landscape towards the proposed wind farm. These limited locations occur north of the road bridge at Auchengray, south of Woolfords cottages, Cobbinshaw Reservoir and south west of Harburn. The turbines would be visible in a landscape of commercial forestry beyond a foreground of open grazing land and a backdrop of the Pentland Hills ridge. The total length of line from which views of the proposed wind farm would be gained, is approximately 1.25 km. Receptors would be of medium sensitivity to a medium magnitude of change in view, resulting in a Moderate effect. The accumulation of a series of Moderate effects over the length of the journey would result in a significant effect overall for receptors. The Lockerbie to Livingston Railway Travelling South West from Livingston to Harburn 9.5.145 The total length of line from which views towards the site can be gained is approximately 1 km. On the edge of Livingston, where the line drops down to the Linhouse Water and west of Linhouse and north east of Harburn, where the railway lies on embankment, distant views over grazed farmland conifer plantations towards the proposed turbines at Camilty would be March 2013 9-74 ES Chapter 9 Landscape and Visual Copyright Partnerships for Renewables Development Co. Ltd 2013 ©

<strong>Camilty</strong> <strong>Wind</strong> <strong>Farm</strong><br />

hills, although the majority of the Pentland ridge would remain unhindered by views of wind<br />

farms. The overall views of this distinctive landscape feature would not be unacceptably<br />

compromised. The sensitivity of occupiers of vehicles on this road is medium and the change<br />

in view would be of a small magnitude. The level of effect would be Slight.<br />

9.5.132 At night, the warning lights on turbines would be seen in the context of existing lights at<br />

properties and settlements in the landscape and the Pates Hill <strong>Wind</strong> <strong>Farm</strong> to the right of the<br />

view. The level of effect on night time views would be Slight.<br />

Sequential Effects<br />

9.5.133 Sequential receptors are illustrated in Figure 9.20.<br />

<strong>Wind</strong>ygreen to <strong>Camilty</strong> Plantation Travelling north on the A70<br />

9.5.134 Potential views of the proposed wind farm would be gained from approximately 7 km of this<br />

road which lies within the ZTV.<br />

9.5.135 Sporadic views through gaps in roadside vegetation and dips in the land<strong>for</strong>m from the road<br />

towards the proposed wind farm would be gained between 11 km and 4 km from the site. The<br />

turbines would <strong>for</strong>m a distant to mid-distance new element in these views, often in<br />

combination with the Pates Hill <strong>Wind</strong> <strong>Farm</strong> to the left of the view. Within 4 km of the site, the<br />

views are more open and would enable the proposed wind farm to be seen rising out of<br />

conifer plantations beyond the fringes of the Pentland Hills Regional Park. Over a 2 km<br />

stretch of this road the view is alternately revealed and then concealed by mature roadside<br />

planting. Views of the proposed wind farm would be glimpsed through vegetation and not<br />

immediately apparent in the landscape. The sensitivity of the receptor is medium and the<br />

magnitude of change in view would be small, resulting in a Slight effect, which is not<br />

significant.<br />

9.5.136 Within 2 km of the site, the views open out again and would allow the turbines to be seen in<br />

close proximity, as dominant new additions to the largely rural view. As the road follows the<br />

southern boundary of the site, fragmented views through boundary vegetation across blocks<br />

of varying ages of commercial <strong>for</strong>estry extend over a relatively flat landscape to the horizon.<br />

The proposed wind farm would <strong>for</strong>m a dominant feature in the view, whilst allowing views<br />

through to the landscape beyond. To the right of the road, dense blocks of conifers obscure<br />

views to the Pentland Hills. The magnitude of change in view from this section of the road<br />

would be large resulting in a Major to Moderate effect, which would be significant.<br />

Auchinoon to <strong>Camilty</strong> Plantation Travelling South on the A70<br />

9.5.137 Potential views of the proposed wind farm would be gained from approximately a 4 km long<br />

section of this route.<br />

9.5.138 As the road travels south west around the base of Auchinoon Hill, beside Harperrig<br />

Reservoir, the proposed wind farm would become visible ahead in the middle distance above<br />

intervening groups of trees. Turbines at the Pates Hill <strong>Wind</strong> <strong>Farm</strong> would be visible to the right<br />

of this group and the Pentland Hills would <strong>for</strong>m the focus of the view to the left. The<br />

magnitude of change would be medium resulting in a Moderate effect on receptors, which is<br />

not significant.<br />

9.5.139 Where the road doglegs to the south at Wester Causwayend, roadside trees, properties and<br />

the orientation of the road would prevent most views of the proposed wind farm. The view<br />

opens up again approximately 0.5 km to the south west, where it is directly aligned on the<br />

March 2013 9-73 ES Chapter 9<br />

Landscape and Visual<br />

Copyright <strong>Partnerships</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Renewables</strong> Development Co. Ltd 2013 ©

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!