21.01.2014 Views

... Empowerment - International Diabetes Federation

... Empowerment - International Diabetes Federation

... Empowerment - International Diabetes Federation

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

G30956<br />

Strength in Knowledge ...<br />

DIABETES<br />

VOICE<br />

Bulletin of the <strong>International</strong> <strong>Diabetes</strong> <strong>Federation</strong><br />

... <strong>Empowerment</strong><br />

Understanding ...<br />

Special Edition 2001<br />

Spread the Word ...


© <strong>International</strong> <strong>Diabetes</strong> <strong>Federation</strong> 2001<br />

The mission of the <strong>International</strong> <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

<strong>Federation</strong> is to work with our member<br />

associations to enhance the lives of people<br />

with diabetes.<br />

www.diabetesvoice.com<br />

Editorial Board<br />

Editor-in-Chief<br />

Ms Leena Etu-Seppälä<br />

Finnish <strong>Diabetes</strong> Association<br />

Kirjoniementie 15<br />

FIN-33680 Tampere<br />

Finland<br />

tel: +358 3 286 0220 or +358 50 561 1105<br />

fax:+358 3 360 0462<br />

leena.etuseppala@diabetes.fi<br />

Managing Editor<br />

Ms Kristina Hawthorne<br />

Kirchheim Publishers & Co<br />

Kaiserstrasse 41<br />

D-55116 Mainz<br />

Germany<br />

tel: +49 6131 960 7031<br />

khawtho277@aol.com<br />

IDF Editor<br />

Ms Delice Gan, Belgium<br />

delice.gan@idf.org<br />

<strong>International</strong> Editor<br />

Dr Frank Vinicor, USA<br />

fxv1@cdc.gov<br />

Scientific Editor<br />

Prof Robert Heine, The Netherlands<br />

French/Spanish Subeditor<br />

Ms Stefania Sella, Belgium<br />

stefania.sella@idf.org<br />

Advisory Board<br />

Prof Sir George Alberti, UK<br />

Prof Pierre Lefèbvre, Belgium<br />

Dr Abdulrahman Salim Alkuwari, Qatar<br />

Dr Warren Lee, Singapore<br />

Prof Hajera Mahtab, Bangladesh<br />

Prof Massimo Massi-Benedetti, Italy<br />

Prof Adolfo Pérez-Comas, Puerto Rico<br />

Dr Kaushik Ramaiya, Tanzania<br />

Mr Brian Wentzell, Canada<br />

Publisher<br />

Mr Manuel Ickrath<br />

Kirchheim Publishers & Co<br />

Layout and Advertising<br />

Ms Kristina Hawthorne<br />

Since 1736<br />

This publication<br />

is also available<br />

in French<br />

and Spanish<br />

PRESIDENT’S VIEW<br />

3 An Individual Decision<br />

Sir George Alberti<br />

EDITORIAL<br />

5 Successful Self-Care: The<br />

Best Sign of <strong>Empowerment</strong><br />

Leena Etu-Seppälä<br />

FEATURE<br />

6 <strong>Empowerment</strong>:<br />

A Matter of Choice<br />

Axel Hirsch and Susan Woods-Büggeln<br />

HEALTH POLICY<br />

11 New Roles in <strong>Diabetes</strong> Care<br />

Martha Funnell<br />

CARE AND MANAGEMENT<br />

14 Becoming Experts<br />

Alice Jørgensen, Inge Kristiansen and<br />

Grete Kirketerp<br />

19 Helping People with<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong>: A Rewarding Task<br />

The PUMCH <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Education Centre in China<br />

Li Wenhui<br />

ECONOMICS<br />

25 Self-Care: An Important and<br />

Cost-Effective Investment<br />

Tero Kangas<br />

RESEARCH<br />

30 Combined Study Reveals<br />

Gaps in <strong>Diabetes</strong> Therapy<br />

Kristina Hawthorne<br />

LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

32 Children Reaching Children:<br />

The Diabetic Counsellors<br />

in Training<br />

Nana Masike, Siobhan Kotze<br />

and Sue Leuner<br />

38 Listen to a Voice<br />

Bibi Hølge-Hazelton<br />

DIABETES ON THE WEB<br />

43 Canadian <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Association’s Best<br />

Information Provider<br />

Michael Lund<br />

45 German Website:<br />

A Stamp of Quality<br />

Thomas Baehring,<br />

Melanie Steppenfeld and<br />

Werner Scherbaum<br />

IDF UPDATE<br />

48 <strong>Empowerment</strong> and How It<br />

Can be Implemented: The<br />

Role of <strong>Diabetes</strong> Associations<br />

Bjørnar Allgot<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 1


PRESIDENT’S VIEW<br />

An Individual<br />

Sir George Alberti<br />

Decision<br />

This issue of <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice focuses on the very<br />

important issue of empowerment. In some ways<br />

this has become a buzzword, but does of course<br />

focus on a very important aspect of diabetes care.<br />

When I first started working in diabetes (nearly 40 years<br />

ago!), it was unthinkable by both patients and<br />

professionals that patients would modify their own<br />

treatment. Indeed if they did, this led to a gentle but firm<br />

reprimand!<br />

The big breakthrough came at the end of the 1970s when<br />

it was shown that patients could use blood test strips to<br />

measure their own blood glucose. This revolutionized<br />

diabetes care – together with the introduction of diabetes<br />

nurse educators.<br />

One finding that made an enormous impression on me<br />

was in a study where we compared the effect of using<br />

regular urine testing, blood testing with a meter, and<br />

blood testing with visual reading of the strips on blood<br />

glucose control. There was a three-month initial period<br />

when all patients received education whilst still using<br />

urine tests. The biggest improvement in control came<br />

in this first phase and only minor changes later. The<br />

conclusion, of course, was that paying real attention to<br />

patients and giving them education about diabetes was<br />

vital, and more important than the method used to<br />

check control of their diabetes.<br />

The world has moved on in the last two decades. We now<br />

accept that diabetes education is a key component of<br />

good management of chronic diseases. But this is still not<br />

real empowerment. In many cases, the professional<br />

remains dominant. We are now undergoing the next<br />

stage – putting real power in the hands of the person with<br />

diabetes. The more the people know about diabetes, the<br />

greater their ability to manage it in a flexible way,<br />

allowing more freedom on a day-to-day basis. While the<br />

person with diabetes may not be able to lead an entirely<br />

normal life, it is now a lot better than it was in the past<br />

when there were no tools to achieve self-control.<br />

So what is the role of the doctor and the specialist nurse?<br />

It is to guide, to encourage and to advise – not to dictate.<br />

This requires time and in many parts of the world<br />

professionals do not have time as there are too few of<br />

them. It is easier then to dish out pills and instructions<br />

rather than to explain and to hand power to the person<br />

who is consulting you. In such cases, patient groups can<br />

help each other. In the UK, the concept of the ‘expert<br />

patient’ has been developed and will undoubtedly help.<br />

One should also remember that not every person with<br />

diabetes wishes to be ‘empowered’– but whether he or she<br />

wants to or not should be the individual’s choice.<br />

My final comment is to point out strongly the truism that<br />

not all parts of the world are the same. What is<br />

appropriate in northern Europe may not be appropriate<br />

in South America; not all cultures necessarily welcome or<br />

encourage empowerment. It does, however, seem a<br />

sensible and obvious route to follow and IDF, through its<br />

member associations and Regions, will certainly promote<br />

the concept and assist those who wish to follow this route.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 3


EDITORIAL<br />

Successful Self-Care:<br />

The Best Sign of <strong>Empowerment</strong><br />

Leena Etu-Seppälä<br />

There are many ways to describe empowerment.<br />

No matter what words are used, the final result<br />

is the same: improved quality of life and<br />

successful self-care, whereby the person with diabetes has<br />

the main responsibility, with full support provided by the<br />

healthcare team.<br />

What sounds simple in theory is not always as easy in<br />

practice. The key elements for empowerment – diabetes<br />

awareness, education and training, equipment and<br />

supplies and the support of healthcare providers – are<br />

partly or totally lacking in many developing and even in<br />

developed countries. We still have a long way to go but<br />

the process has clearly started and will reach both people<br />

with diabetes and healthcare providers.<br />

How can the empowerment process be measured and<br />

evaluated? There are many concrete factors which show<br />

the success of self-care; HbA1c, complications and body<br />

mass index, for example. However, one of the most<br />

essential tools to measure empowerment are surveys<br />

evaluating patient satisfaction. These surveys have<br />

become recently popular for assessing changes in<br />

treatment and their outcomes and measuring the<br />

effectiveness of education. An expert in this area is Dr<br />

Claire Bradley, UK, who has developed a highly-effective<br />

method for evaluating patient satisfaction which has been<br />

used already in many countries.<br />

The National <strong>Diabetes</strong> Programme in Finland recently<br />

implemented a study on patient satisfaction covering over<br />

2000 people, the answers of which will be analyzed by the<br />

end of this year. In addition to the questionnaires, 100<br />

people with diabetes in all age groups have also<br />

undergone a personal interview. The preliminary<br />

outcomes of the interviews show that most of these<br />

people are satisfied with their diabetes care in general, but<br />

not nearly as satisfied with their self-care. They recognize<br />

their own role in diabetes care and the need of more selfdiscipline<br />

and effort, especially in terms of diet, selfmonitoring<br />

and foot care. The people interviewed also<br />

emphasized that their quality of life improved with<br />

good glycaemic control and support from their<br />

families and healthcare providers.<br />

The factors that produced most satisfaction in the<br />

relationship between people with diabetes and healthcare<br />

providers were friendly, professional support and<br />

cooperation, continuous patient-doctor relationships,<br />

time for discussion, interest shown by the professionals in<br />

care as a whole (not only HbA1c and blood glucose<br />

monitoring) and the possibility for on-the-spot telephone<br />

consultation. In self-care the biggest problems faced were<br />

inadequate glycaemic control, lack of motivation both in<br />

healthy eating and in self-monitoring, overweight and a<br />

general lack of knowledge and skills in diabetes care.<br />

These outcomes confirm that the barriers for real<br />

empowerment still lie in basic factors, even in developed<br />

countries. This special issue, however, shows that there is<br />

a strong willingness among both healthcare providers and<br />

people with diabetes to change the world of traditional<br />

diabetes care.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 5


A Matter of C<br />

Empowerme<br />

6 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


FEATURE<br />

nt<br />

hoice<br />

Axel Hirsch<br />

Susan Woods-Büggeln<br />

There has been an<br />

enormous change over<br />

the last 30 years in<br />

diabetes care and<br />

education in Germany<br />

and most of western<br />

Europe. Nowdays,<br />

feelings of frustration<br />

have decreased for<br />

both healthcare<br />

professionals and<br />

people with diabetes,<br />

as it is finally<br />

becoming recognized<br />

just who is responsible<br />

for what.<br />

In the 1970s, diabetes<br />

treatment in western<br />

Europe was ‘law’. The<br />

lifestyles of the people<br />

affected were not considered,<br />

nor were they given the<br />

knowledge and skills<br />

necessary to adapt their<br />

therapy to the changing<br />

needs in their life.<br />

Unpopular lectures in<br />

diabetes clinics were given to<br />

large groups, instructing the<br />

participants on how to live<br />

healthily and abstain from<br />

things they liked. When<br />

outside the hospital, many of<br />

these people could be found<br />

sitting in cafés, talking and<br />

enjoying cakes they had just<br />

been told not to eat.<br />

Human Element<br />

Brought into Modern<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Care<br />

In the eighties, new forms<br />

of education developed. In<br />

Germany, for example,<br />

physicians, recognizing that<br />

lectures did not tend to<br />

work, began teaching<br />

diabetes therapy to smaller<br />

groups of 10 to 12 people.<br />

The German <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Society established a oneyear<br />

training course for<br />

nurses and dietitians to<br />

become diabetes educators,<br />

previously the sole duty of<br />

physicians. They were<br />

taught a lot more about the<br />

lives of people with diabetes<br />

and their problems with<br />

self-care. They also learnt<br />

how to listen.<br />

A growing number of<br />

hospitals started to employ<br />

these educators and<br />

developed a form of<br />

structured education<br />

programmes in which inpatients<br />

could learn<br />

everything they needed<br />

towards good diabetes selfcare<br />

within one to two<br />

weeks. For the first time<br />

there was a specialized<br />

diabetes team treating,<br />

educating and working in<br />

close contact with their<br />

patients. It was these<br />

particular programmes<br />

which initiated and<br />

developed the modern and<br />

patient-oriented diabetes<br />

education and therapy we<br />

know today in Germany.<br />

Lifestyle Considered<br />

for First Time<br />

Still, in most of these<br />

programmes only standard<br />

therapies were<br />

recommended, with little<br />

control being given to the<br />

participants after leaving the<br />

clinic. Some more openly<br />

refused to do what was<br />

recommended. However, by<br />

talking about their<br />

experiences in groups, some<br />

began finding out how to<br />

adapt the strict therapeutic<br />

rules to their life without<br />

compromising their therapy.<br />

They met in self-help<br />

groups, started asking<br />

questions and looked for<br />

educational settings which<br />

offered them more freedom<br />

and flexibility. They insisted<br />

on their wishes being taken<br />

into consideration.<br />

There had always been,<br />

however, some doctors who<br />

knew that therapy should<br />

be matched with the lives<br />

of people with diabetes.<br />

Discussion had grown<br />

about the quality of life of<br />

people with diabetes,<br />

especially with the new<br />

kinds of treatments and<br />

options being made<br />

available, for example,<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 7


FEATURE<br />

intensified insulin therapy<br />

and pump treatment.<br />

The 1989 St Vincent<br />

Declaration set quality of<br />

life as one of the desirable<br />

goals in diabetes therapy<br />

and that people should<br />

have a similar quality as<br />

those not affected by<br />

diabetes. <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

educators began talking<br />

about finding a therapy for<br />

the individual person by<br />

collaborating with patients.<br />

A Common<br />

Misunderstanding<br />

When the empowerment<br />

approach made its way from<br />

the United States to Europe,<br />

however, there was still a lot<br />

of scepticism, especially on<br />

the part of the physicians.<br />

Could healthcare<br />

professionals trust people<br />

with diabetes to decide for<br />

themselves as to how they<br />

wanted to live with their<br />

condition? Could physicians<br />

let go of their former<br />

responsibilities? What would<br />

happen if they stopped<br />

giving orders and checking<br />

for levels of compliance?<br />

Furthermore, physicians<br />

then questioned whether<br />

people with diabetes really<br />

did want to make their own<br />

decisions and take charge of<br />

their diabetes therapy<br />

themselves, at all. This was<br />

In today’s model of care, the professional listens, offers information, skills and expertise.<br />

The person with diabetes leads the diabetes team to find a self-therapy compatible with<br />

his or her personal needs.<br />

a common<br />

misunderstanding about the<br />

notion of empowerment<br />

which still holds today.<br />

The empowerment<br />

approach starts from the<br />

premise that people, by<br />

their very nature, want to<br />

manage their own affairs.<br />

However, the extent of this<br />

drive obviously depends on<br />

the individual’s knowledge<br />

8 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


FEATURE<br />

and previous experience. A<br />

slave, for example, would<br />

not normally be expected<br />

to be empowered, just as<br />

people who were never<br />

given control cannot be<br />

forced to take charge.<br />

<strong>Empowerment</strong> is an offer –<br />

an invitation to participate<br />

and manage one’s own<br />

affairs. If a person tells the<br />

healthcare professional that<br />

he or she cannot make a<br />

decision about his or her<br />

therapy and doesn’t want<br />

to, then this too is a<br />

decision and a right. The<br />

healthcare professional can<br />

then go ahead and make<br />

the decisions and show the<br />

person with diabetes how<br />

to implement them step by<br />

step.<br />

Roles Clearer between<br />

Healthcare Professionals<br />

and Patients<br />

As greater attention is<br />

focused on quality of life and<br />

the role of empowerment,<br />

professionals are increasingly<br />

questioning their right to<br />

interfere with the life of<br />

people with diabetes by<br />

giving orders and<br />

recommendations. They<br />

have begun to request<br />

training in communication<br />

skills.<br />

<strong>Empowerment</strong> and selfmanagement<br />

have become<br />

an intrinsic part of all<br />

professional training<br />

programmes for diabetes<br />

educators and physicians.<br />

Feelings of frustration<br />

have decreased as the role<br />

of the healthcare<br />

professional and patient<br />

have become more clear.<br />

The professional listens,<br />

offers information,<br />

training skills and<br />

expertise. The person with<br />

diabetes leads the diabetes<br />

team to find a self-therapy<br />

compatible with his or her<br />

personal needs.<br />

People with <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Now Individualizing<br />

Their Therapy<br />

In Germany today, a<br />

growing number of people<br />

with type 2 diabetes,<br />

especially those on<br />

insulin, are practising<br />

intensified therapy while<br />

finding ways to reduce the<br />

rigidity of their therapies<br />

and to individualize<br />

regimes. Intensified<br />

therapy also now attracts a<br />

large proportion (over 80<br />

percent) of those with<br />

type 1 diabetes.<br />

People with diabetes are<br />

now finally getting the<br />

same respect as others for<br />

their way of life, which<br />

they have so long<br />

deserved. They are no<br />

longer only forced to<br />

change their lifestyle (lose<br />

weight, be more physically<br />

active), but are given help<br />

to find their own ways of<br />

managing their condition.<br />

Multi-Disciplinary<br />

Care Leads to Better<br />

Understanding<br />

Today’s setting of German<br />

clinical diabetes care<br />

usually includes a team of<br />

doctors, diabetes educators<br />

and sometimes a<br />

psychologist. This is, in<br />

fact, an ideal combination<br />

because people with<br />

diabetes then have access<br />

to a professional for every<br />

aspect of his experience. It<br />

works best, however, if<br />

they work in close<br />

cooperation and do not<br />

divide the patient’s<br />

experience up into their<br />

own single disciplines.<br />

If organizational<br />

structures allow time<br />

for team meetings,<br />

preferably daily during<br />

the education programme,<br />

information from the<br />

various viewpoints can<br />

be pooled in order to<br />

come to a better<br />

understanding of the<br />

patients. This can, in turn,<br />

help them to cope with<br />

what can sometimes seem<br />

an overwhelming<br />

experience.<br />

This unique setting also<br />

provides the team with<br />

the opportunity to get to<br />

know and understand<br />

patients as whole people.<br />

Team members can listen<br />

to what the patients<br />

think about diabetes and<br />

its therapy, where they<br />

have problems and what<br />

they wish to change.<br />

They can see what the<br />

patients do and how they<br />

handle decisions about<br />

therapy. They can<br />

register how the patient’s<br />

blood glucose behaves<br />

under reasonably<br />

standardized conditions,<br />

even during the night.<br />

Therapy No Longer<br />

Just a Matter of<br />

Measurements<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> education no<br />

longer consists of just<br />

blood glucose values or<br />

units of insulin, but of<br />

the people themselves<br />

and their experience of<br />

diabetes and therapy in<br />

the context of their own<br />

lives.<br />

In-patient diabetes<br />

education provides the<br />

person with diabetes with<br />

the ability to make<br />

choices. The aim is to<br />

increase the breadth of<br />

these choices and the<br />

flexibility in making<br />

them.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 9


FEATURE<br />

Today’s setting of diabetes care usually includes a team of<br />

doctors, diabetes educators and a psychologist.<br />

Although such structures<br />

of healthcare are<br />

resource-intensive,<br />

recent follow-ups of<br />

people with diabetes<br />

who have participated in<br />

these programmes show<br />

very good metabolic<br />

outcomes and an<br />

improved quality of life.<br />

This reflects the<br />

programmes’ effectiveness.<br />

Years of Development<br />

Threatened by<br />

Legislation<br />

Many years of effort<br />

through practical<br />

experience and clinical<br />

application has been put<br />

into establishing today’s inpatient<br />

diabetes education<br />

system in Germany. We<br />

now enjoy a wellestablished<br />

and dynamic<br />

structure of education,<br />

satisfactory to both<br />

healthcare professional and<br />

patient.<br />

However, this very<br />

process, which has taken<br />

over 30 years to develop,<br />

is now under serious<br />

threat due to changes in<br />

the national<br />

reiumbursement system<br />

for people with diabetes.<br />

Structured education<br />

programmes, such as the<br />

one illustrated in this<br />

article, will no longer be<br />

supported by public<br />

medical insurance, forcing<br />

newly-diagnosed people<br />

with diabetes out of the<br />

hospitals as quickly as<br />

possible to seek their<br />

education elsewhere.<br />

Although the majority of<br />

people with type 1<br />

diabetes have participated<br />

and benefitted from the<br />

education programmes,<br />

surveys have shown that<br />

only 20 percent of people<br />

with type 2 diabetes have<br />

done so. Those who have,<br />

however, have yielded<br />

positive results.<br />

In light of the true status<br />

of people with diabetes in<br />

Germany, clearly shown<br />

on page 30 in the<br />

Research section of this<br />

issue, the planned<br />

restructuring could have<br />

disastrous effects on<br />

outcomes.<br />

People with diabetes will<br />

be hospitalized, not for<br />

education and<br />

consultation on<br />

preventative therapy, but<br />

for the treatment of endstage<br />

complications. This,<br />

in turn, will do nothing<br />

for the cost of healthcare<br />

– already a serious strain<br />

on the national budget.<br />

Dr Axel Hirsch is Clinical<br />

Psychologist in the<br />

Department of <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

and Metabolic Disorders<br />

at the Bethanien Hospital,<br />

Hamburg, Germany.<br />

Ms Susan Woods-Büggeln<br />

is Clinical Psychologist in<br />

the <strong>Diabetes</strong> Centre at the<br />

Medical Clinic in the<br />

Christian Albrechts<br />

University, Kiel,<br />

Germany.<br />

10 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


HEALTH POLICY<br />

New Roles in<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Care<br />

Martha Funnell<br />

<strong>Empowerment</strong> is a philosophy that<br />

recognizes the fundamental right of<br />

people with diabetes to be the primary<br />

decision makers in the management of<br />

their condition. It represents a more<br />

compatible model of care and<br />

education needed for a self-managed<br />

illness such as diabetes.<br />

© Roche Diagnostics<br />

As a philosophy,<br />

empowerment<br />

guides interaction<br />

between healthcare<br />

professionals and people<br />

with diabetes, be it for<br />

care, education<br />

or both. Embracing the<br />

empowerment philosophy<br />

requires healthcare<br />

professionals to practise<br />

in ways that are consistent<br />

with this approach.<br />

<strong>Empowerment</strong> is not a<br />

technique or a strategy,<br />

but a view of how care<br />

is provided. This often<br />

requires a shift in the<br />

relationship between the<br />

healthcare professional and<br />

the person with diabetes,<br />

whereby new roles are<br />

formed.<br />

The traditional relationship<br />

between patients and<br />

healthcare professionals was<br />

based on models taken<br />

from the care of acute<br />

conditions. The role of the<br />

hospitalized patient was to<br />

be cared for and the<br />

healthcare professional was<br />

to make the decisions and<br />

be responsible for the<br />

outcomes. However,<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 11


HEALTH POLICY<br />

attempts to function<br />

within these old roles are<br />

problematic in terms of<br />

diabetes care and<br />

education. Chronic<br />

illnesses, like diabetes,<br />

are primarily cared for<br />

by the people who<br />

experience them, not by<br />

the healthcare<br />

professionals. When roles<br />

more suitable for self-care<br />

illnesses requiring a high<br />

level of self-care are not<br />

created, both patients and<br />

healthcare professionals can<br />

often become frustrated<br />

and disappointed with the<br />

resulting negative<br />

relationships and poor<br />

outcomes.<br />

More Appropriate<br />

Roles for Patients and<br />

Healthcare<br />

Professionals<br />

Both healthcare<br />

professionals and patients<br />

often bring role<br />

expectations to their<br />

interactions based on<br />

traditional views of<br />

healthcare – the<br />

paternalistic/maternalistic<br />

doctor giving care to the<br />

powerless and helpless<br />

patient. However, when<br />

expectations reflect the<br />

philosophy of<br />

empowerment, a shift<br />

occurs so that both<br />

patients and their carers<br />

assume new roles.<br />

People with diabetes are in charge of their own lives. They are<br />

responsible for the outcomes of their treatment. They can only<br />

achieve this goal, however, if equipped with the right tools!<br />

These roles are based on<br />

collaborative relationships<br />

where the person with<br />

diabetes and the<br />

healthcare professional<br />

cooperate as a team.<br />

Healthcare professionals<br />

are unable, however, to<br />

change their roles unless<br />

the person with diabetes<br />

does so as well. Both must<br />

be prepared to assume<br />

new roles.<br />

The Healthcare<br />

Professional’s Role as<br />

Coach and Supporter<br />

For healthcare<br />

professionals, the first step<br />

is to clarify the<br />

relationship with the<br />

patient. What do<br />

healthcare professionals<br />

believe their role to be?<br />

What does the healthcare<br />

professional expect of the<br />

patients? What do the<br />

patients expect of the<br />

healthcare professionals?<br />

Collaborative care is<br />

established by a patientcentred<br />

environment,<br />

where the patients’<br />

concerns and goals are the<br />

focus of care and<br />

education. The<br />

collaborative relationship<br />

begins with a discussion<br />

about the importance of<br />

the patient’s role in the<br />

care of their diabetes and<br />

12 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


HEALTH POLICY<br />

their beliefs about their<br />

role. Healthcare<br />

professionals need to<br />

explain their role as a<br />

coach, facilitator and<br />

supporter.<br />

Healthcare professionals<br />

must relinquish their<br />

traditional beliefs in<br />

concepts such as<br />

compliance and adherence<br />

and learn to respect the<br />

patients’ right to make<br />

their own choices. By<br />

providing expert care,<br />

education and the benefit<br />

of experience, healthcare<br />

professionals meet their<br />

responsibility.<br />

Education in Self-<br />

Management Key to<br />

Establishing New Roles<br />

Self-management<br />

education is the key to<br />

establishing new roles<br />

and collaborative<br />

relationships. Education<br />

provides people with<br />

diabetes with problemsolving<br />

skills. This assists<br />

them in assuming an<br />

active role in their own<br />

care.<br />

People with<br />

diabetes need to<br />

understand that their<br />

condition is serious, that<br />

it must be self-managed<br />

and that it is a personal<br />

responsibility. Informed<br />

decisions and wise choices<br />

must be made on a daily<br />

basis.<br />

The educational process<br />

includes information<br />

about diabetes<br />

management, options for<br />

treatment and their costs<br />

and benefits, how to set<br />

goals, obtain needed<br />

support and overcome<br />

barriers. Although the<br />

content for much of this<br />

education is the same as in<br />

traditional care and<br />

education, the purpose<br />

differs. The goal is to help<br />

people with diabetes make<br />

informed choices, not to<br />

force behavioural changes.<br />

People with <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Assume Responsibility<br />

for Outcomes<br />

It needs to be emphasized<br />

that healthcare<br />

professionals cannot<br />

change their roles unless<br />

people with diabetes do so<br />

as well. People with<br />

diabetes must<br />

communicate about their<br />

feelings, and provide<br />

information on their<br />

values, needs and abilities,<br />

and actively work with<br />

their healthcare<br />

professionals.<br />

This sort of collaboration<br />

requires that all members<br />

of the team actively<br />

participate and are equally<br />

valued. Instead of the<br />

healthcare professional<br />

taking sole responsibility<br />

for decisions and<br />

outcomes, as in the<br />

traditional acute-care<br />

model, the person with<br />

diabetes should assume<br />

this role.<br />

Working towards<br />

important goals,<br />

recognizing their role in<br />

the team and becoming an<br />

informed decision-maker<br />

are all things that people<br />

with diabetes can do to<br />

become an effective<br />

collaborator.<br />

Old Habits Die Hard<br />

People with diabetes and<br />

healthcare professionals<br />

will encounter barriers<br />

and challenges as they<br />

attempt to make changes<br />

in their roles. Healthcare<br />

professionals are used to<br />

setting goals and solving<br />

problems. People with<br />

diabetes will often expect<br />

precise answers or may<br />

not understand the need<br />

for their involvement in<br />

the daily care of their<br />

condition.<br />

The complexity of the<br />

physical and psychosocial<br />

issues people with diabetes<br />

experience may cause<br />

healthcare professionals to<br />

feel overwhelmed. Some<br />

may not want not change<br />

their current roles at all,<br />

or may feel that this new<br />

approach would take up<br />

too much in the way of<br />

additional time or<br />

resources.<br />

Patient-Centred Care<br />

More Satisfying<br />

Patients are more satisfied<br />

because the empowerment<br />

approach to care meets<br />

their needs. This, in turn,<br />

is more rewarding for the<br />

healthcare professional.<br />

When people with<br />

diabetes work to achieve<br />

self-selected goals,<br />

healthcare professionals<br />

no longer have to try to<br />

motivate them to achieve<br />

provider-selected goals. As<br />

patients are better able to<br />

achieve self-selected goals,<br />

which address their own<br />

needs and concerns,<br />

outcomes improve.<br />

Ms Martha Funnell<br />

is Director for<br />

Administration at the<br />

Michigan <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Research and Training<br />

Center in the Division of<br />

Endocrinology and<br />

Metabolism, Department<br />

of Internal Medicine,<br />

Ann Arbor, USA.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 13


EDITORIAL<br />

CARE AND MANAGEMENT<br />

Becoming<br />

Experts<br />

Alice Jørgensen, Inge Kristiansen and Grete Kirketerp<br />

Increasing the knowledge<br />

of people with diabetes<br />

gives them motivation<br />

and promotes better<br />

diabetes control. This, in<br />

turn, enhances quality of<br />

life and delays, if not<br />

totally prevents, the onset<br />

of complications. The<br />

Danish <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Education Centre, opened<br />

in Odense, 1993, does just<br />

that, by providing<br />

teaching and assistance to<br />

people with diabetes and<br />

their friends and families.<br />

The centre educates over<br />

500 people in total<br />

each year.<br />

14 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


CARE AND MANAGEMENT<br />

EDITORIAL<br />

The Danish<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Education Centre<br />

is part of a leading<br />

diabetes research unit at<br />

the Odense University<br />

Hospital, providing<br />

courses that give people<br />

with diabetes a working<br />

knowledge of their<br />

condition with practical<br />

tips, as well as enough<br />

theory to know what is<br />

the right thing to do in<br />

various situations. The<br />

diabetes educators strive<br />

to transform themselves<br />

from the role of expert to<br />

the role of consultant.<br />

The role of the expert<br />

should be taken over by<br />

the participants<br />

themselves.<br />

The concept is simple and<br />

effective: the best way of<br />

coping with diabetes is to<br />

master the condition<br />

yourself. Those who<br />

become diabetes experts<br />

and achieve a high level of<br />

practical and theoretical<br />

knowledge of the condition<br />

will be able to maintain a<br />

higher quality of life.<br />

Peer Groups Provide<br />

Atmosphere of Trust<br />

Each course consists of 11<br />

units and runs for around<br />

five full days. Each class<br />

consists of 10 to 12<br />

participants of similar age.<br />

It has been found that the<br />

majority of participants<br />

enjoy the group experience<br />

with people they can relate<br />

to. They are all allowed to<br />

have a friend, parent or<br />

spouse sit in. However, in<br />

groups with adolescents,<br />

the ‘extras’ are girl- or<br />

boyfriends and not parents.<br />

The young teenagers must<br />

learn to stand on their own<br />

feet, so their parents are<br />

offered tuition in another<br />

course.<br />

Learning by Combining<br />

Theory and Practice<br />

The curriculum covers all<br />

the main themes and gives<br />

people, newly-diagnosed<br />

with diabetes, all the<br />

necessary knowledge and<br />

skills to cope with most<br />

aspects of their condition.<br />

The participants learn how<br />

to administer insulin, test<br />

blood sugar levels and<br />

attain control, choose<br />

proper exercise, plan<br />

appropriate meals, read<br />

food labels and how to<br />

generally live with diabetes.<br />

The curriculum also<br />

includes practical tuition<br />

on topics such as<br />

exercising, good cooking<br />

and shopping. These<br />

activities form a very<br />

important and popular<br />

part of the classes.<br />

The participants walk to the nearby shops as part of the unit<br />

on nutrition and learn about buying the right food.<br />

Each course is run by two<br />

nurses who teach the group<br />

as a whole as well as give<br />

individual tuition. The<br />

nurses then become the<br />

contact persons for the<br />

participants, responsible for<br />

their supervision during<br />

and after the course. Apart<br />

from diabetes nurses,<br />

dietitians, physicians and<br />

podiatrists are also involved<br />

in the education<br />

programme.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 15


EDITORIAL<br />

CARE AND MANAGEMENT<br />

the affect of exercise on<br />

insulin and oral medication,<br />

losing weight and<br />

low blood sugar levels<br />

during sport. During<br />

the course we do<br />

exercises and measure blood<br />

glucose levels<br />

before and afterwards. The<br />

young groups even<br />

go to a fitness centre in<br />

town to do their exercise.<br />

Once at the shops, the groups learn about reading the food labels, for example, all the different<br />

names given to sugar, the fat content, number of calories, etc.<br />

This is very popular, and<br />

during the following<br />

session the participants’<br />

own experience and<br />

suggestions form the<br />

backbone of the<br />

discussion.<br />

The Curriculum<br />

The following is a brief<br />

glimpse of how a typical<br />

course is set out. The courses<br />

are divided up into units.<br />

1: Introduction<br />

This includes the<br />

presentation of the course<br />

and the education team, a<br />

brief rundown of the<br />

condition itself and an<br />

overview of all the different<br />

treatment possibilities.<br />

2: Attaining Blood<br />

Sugar Control<br />

After basic theory, the<br />

participants learn how to test<br />

their own blood glucose<br />

levels. All the participants<br />

make at least four daily tests<br />

– before the three main<br />

meals and at bedtime. They<br />

also learn how to get the<br />

most out of using a daily<br />

personal diary, keeping track<br />

of blood sugar readings,<br />

insulin administration,<br />

weight, exercise, food intake<br />

and incidents of<br />

hypoglycaemia and<br />

hyperglycaemia. It is<br />

emphasized how the diary<br />

can be useful for interaction<br />

between the person with<br />

diabetes, the hospital and the<br />

general practitioner.<br />

3: Treating <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

This unit deals in more<br />

detail with the alternatives<br />

in treatment, especially<br />

concerning insulin and<br />

oral anti-diabetic agents.<br />

4: Nutrition<br />

The nutrition unit is taken<br />

by the dietitians. The<br />

group is usually divided up<br />

into two. One part of the<br />

group learns about<br />

shopping for the right<br />

foods, and the other part of<br />

the group learns about food<br />

preparation. Then they<br />

swap around. How to read<br />

food labels is also a major<br />

part of this unit.<br />

5: Physical Exercise<br />

Thisk unit covers insulin<br />

uptake during exercise,<br />

The participants learn how to keep a person<br />

insulin administration, weight, exercise, food<br />

hyperglycaemia.<br />

16 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


CARE AND MANAGEMENT<br />

6: Alcohol and Parties<br />

Here the participants<br />

learn the tricks about<br />

going out with diabetes.<br />

7: Hypoglycaemia<br />

This includes the<br />

symptoms and signs of<br />

hypoglycaemia, its<br />

prevention and treatment.<br />

8: Hyperglycaemia<br />

As in the seventh unit,<br />

the participants learn<br />

about the symptoms and<br />

signs, prevention and<br />

treatment.<br />

l diary, recording blood sugar readings,<br />

intake and incidents of hypo- and<br />

9: Complications<br />

This unit is taught by a<br />

physician. The prevention<br />

of complications and<br />

relevant treatment options<br />

are discussed here.<br />

10: Foot Care<br />

Foot care is an essential<br />

factor in the prevention of<br />

complications. This unit is<br />

taken up by a podiatrist.<br />

11: Living with <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Living with diabetes is<br />

where the participants can<br />

share their stories, feelings,<br />

and the parts of their lives<br />

they do not feel others,<br />

without diabetes, can<br />

understand.<br />

The diary is a useful tool for interaction between the person<br />

with diabetes, the hospital and the general physician.<br />

Evaluation<br />

Finally, a questionnaire is<br />

given out with questions<br />

regarding achieved<br />

knowledge. This is used as<br />

a general evaluation.<br />

Detailed feedback from<br />

participants is constantly<br />

called upon in order to<br />

improve the courses.<br />

Many participants continue<br />

as out-patients at the<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Education Centre.<br />

They keep in touch with<br />

their contact nurse and the<br />

hospital ward. Most<br />

participants, however, are<br />

referred back to their<br />

general practitioner.<br />

More Specialization in<br />

the Future<br />

The future of the <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Education Centre will<br />

move more in the direction<br />

of courses on specific<br />

topics.<br />

Having been quite<br />

successful in creating<br />

courses for the newlydiagnosed,<br />

we now feel that<br />

the time has come to take<br />

one more step.<br />

We have already started<br />

offering special courses on,<br />

for example, how to use<br />

insulin pumps from the<br />

user’s perspective. Ethnic<br />

groups using an interpreter<br />

will also soon be<br />

introduced.<br />

Ms Alice Jørgensen, Ms Inge<br />

Kristiansen and Ms Grete<br />

Kirketerp are diabetes<br />

nurses and educators at the<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Education Centre<br />

at Odense University<br />

Hospital, Odense,<br />

Denmark.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 17


CARE AND MANAGEMENT<br />

Helping People with <strong>Diabetes</strong>:<br />

A Rewarding Task<br />

The PUMCH <strong>Diabetes</strong> Education Centre in China<br />

Li Wenhui<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> has ‘arrived’<br />

in China. This<br />

condition was<br />

relatively rare among<br />

the Chinese population<br />

until 20 years ago. As<br />

life has become more<br />

and more westernized<br />

and industrial, the<br />

prevalence of diabetes<br />

has increased rapidly.<br />

The average prevalence<br />

rate has increased from<br />

just under 1 percent in<br />

1980 to as high as<br />

nearly 7 percent in<br />

some areas in 1996.<br />

Chinese health<br />

resources are struggling<br />

to keep up with this<br />

explosion. However,<br />

the Peking Union<br />

Medical College<br />

Hospital (PUMCH)<br />

have an education<br />

programme which is<br />

producing positive<br />

outcomes.<br />

The rise in standard<br />

of living has not<br />

only brought with<br />

it an explosion in chronic<br />

conditions such as diabetes,<br />

it has also raised people’s<br />

health awareness. Although<br />

the health market for<br />

consumers has become<br />

more prolific, medical<br />

services and education have<br />

remained quite stagnant.<br />

One exception has been the<br />

PUMCH which was<br />

established in 1921 with<br />

help of the Rockefeller<br />

Foundation and modelled<br />

on the Johns Hopkins and<br />

Health System in<br />

Maryland, USA. During<br />

these 70 years it has<br />

provided China with a<br />

highly-trained pool of<br />

medical personnel and<br />

researchers. In the 1960s,<br />

doctors had already started<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 19


CARE AND MANAGEMENT<br />

to recognize the importance<br />

of widespread education<br />

concerning diabetes, hence<br />

the special treatment unit<br />

for diabetes was established<br />

in the 1970s to facilitate<br />

discussion and lectures<br />

upon the subject. In the<br />

last 30 years, people<br />

diagnosed with diabetes at<br />

the centre have received<br />

treatment, follow-up and<br />

assistance.<br />

In 1996, an electronic<br />

register was created to keep<br />

a detailed record of the<br />

personal data and medical<br />

history of each patient.<br />

Presently, 20 percent of the<br />

people with type 2 diabetes<br />

treated by the centre are on<br />

insulin.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Education<br />

Facility Formally<br />

Established in 1996<br />

Also in 1996, the PUMCH<br />

established the Centre of<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Education, under<br />

the supervision of Dr Wang<br />

Heng, a well-known<br />

diabetologist in China.<br />

People with diabetes from<br />

all facets of society have<br />

come forward to the<br />

education centre to attend<br />

its bi-monthly round of<br />

lectures and discussions.<br />

For reasons of efficiency<br />

and convenience,<br />

subgroups are formed<br />

consisting of participants<br />

A six-year old at PUMCH is practicing drawing insulin from the bottle. His mother is beside<br />

him, delighted with his skill.<br />

from similar geographical<br />

locations. Each group elects<br />

its own supervisor and<br />

includes a physician and<br />

nurse. The activities<br />

within these groups are<br />

mainly centred around<br />

general discussion and<br />

question-and-answer<br />

sessions.<br />

Centre Offers Large<br />

Variety of Additional<br />

Activities<br />

Since four years ago, an<br />

annual round of lectures<br />

consisting of eight sessions<br />

have been held at the<br />

centre. This will be<br />

continued. The subject<br />

matter ranges from the<br />

latest in diabetes<br />

treatment to the<br />

prevention of<br />

complications, from<br />

practical care and selfmanagement<br />

to highly<br />

sophisticated scientific<br />

theory.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> nursing and<br />

psychotherapy is also<br />

covered. In other words,<br />

there are fresh topics of<br />

interest for everyone.<br />

Extracurricular activities<br />

such as general knowledge<br />

competitions and lucky<br />

draws are often<br />

conducted, especially<br />

during holidays and on<br />

World <strong>Diabetes</strong> Day.<br />

In addition to the abovementioned<br />

activities, the<br />

centre provides seasonal<br />

outings for people with<br />

diabetes.<br />

Demonstrations of bloodglucose<br />

monitoring are<br />

often conducted to show<br />

the importance of diet<br />

regulation and physical<br />

exercise. This wide range of<br />

activities helps people with<br />

their day-to-day experience<br />

in living with diabetes.<br />

The large selection of<br />

colourful and interesting<br />

20 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


CARE AND MANAGEMENT<br />

131±27.0 mg/dl<br />

(7.3±1.5 mmol/l). The<br />

2-hour prandial blood<br />

glucose decreased from<br />

191±66.3 mg/dl<br />

(10.7±3.7 mmol/l) to<br />

172±41.6 mg/dl<br />

(9.6±2.3 mmol/l), and<br />

HbA1c fell from 7.43<br />

±1.32 percent to 6.95<br />

±1.10 percent (p


ECONOMICS<br />

Self-Care:<br />

An Important and<br />

Cost-Effective Investment<br />

Tero Kangas<br />

The elevated cost of<br />

diabetes can be seen as<br />

the result of all<br />

previous failures of<br />

treatment. As<br />

illustrated in this<br />

article, treating<br />

diabetes complications<br />

is far more expensive<br />

than taking<br />

preventative measures.<br />

Future cost cutting,<br />

therefore, can only be<br />

achieved by improving<br />

the level of care,<br />

especially in the field of<br />

self-management.<br />

People with diabetes<br />

must be given the<br />

means to do this, which<br />

can only be attained by<br />

future investment.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> differs<br />

from the majority<br />

of other illnesses<br />

in one very important<br />

respect: the outcome<br />

depends almost solely on<br />

the ability of those affected<br />

to take care of themselves.<br />

The traditional model in<br />

which the doctor prescribes<br />

particular medication<br />

applies to diabetes only in<br />

part. All the other essential<br />

aspects of effective<br />

treatment (diet, exercise,<br />

etc) are the responsibility of<br />

the person with diabetes.<br />

A Way of Living<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> is a disorder of<br />

sugar metabolism. It is also<br />

a way of living, or a<br />

vocation, which has to be<br />

learnt. People with diabetes<br />

need to know what effect<br />

eating, exercising and even<br />

stress has on their blood<br />

sugar. Everything they do,<br />

or not do, affects their<br />

metabolic outcomes.<br />

Therefore, it is of utmost<br />

importance that people<br />

with diabetes understand<br />

their condition so that they<br />

are able to treat themselves<br />

properly.<br />

Healthcare professionals,<br />

no matter how<br />

knowledgeable in the field<br />

of diabetes, can only give<br />

advice. People with<br />

diabetes, after being<br />

properly informed, must<br />

then be in the position to<br />

continue to carry out those<br />

instructions through selfcare.<br />

Therefore, they must<br />

know how to self-monitor.<br />

Self-Monitoring Central<br />

to Effective Treatment<br />

The measure of<br />

haemoglobin A1c (HbA1c),<br />

has been one of the major<br />

breakthroughs in diabetes<br />

treatment since the<br />

invention of insulin. The<br />

other is the self-monitoring<br />

of blood glucose. HbA1c<br />

and self-monitoring go<br />

hand in hand. Although<br />

the measurement of HbA1c<br />

indicates how well the<br />

achieved control meets the<br />

set targets of the treatment,<br />

it does not show where the<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 25


ECONOMICS<br />

possible mistakes lie, or how<br />

to correct them. This can<br />

only be detected by selfmonitoring.<br />

Figure 1 shows<br />

the positive effect of selfmonitoring<br />

on HbA1c.<br />

Figure 1<br />

Prevention of<br />

Complications: Main<br />

Aim in <strong>Diabetes</strong> Care<br />

What is effective self-care<br />

good for? What is it that<br />

must be achieved? The aim<br />

of diabetes treatment is to<br />

achieve blood glucose<br />

concentrations as close as<br />

possible to the levels of<br />

people without diabetes<br />

(between 4 to 8 mmol/dl or<br />

70-140 mg/dl). This is done<br />

in order to avoid late<br />

complications. <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

complications threaten the<br />

very lives of people with<br />

diabetes and their treatment<br />

account for the highest<br />

costs. Complications come<br />

about due to long-term<br />

inadequate control of blood<br />

glucose. These<br />

complications, however, can<br />

be prevented with proper<br />

control of diabetes, which is<br />

frequently called ‘intensive<br />

treatment’.<br />

The Proven Effect of<br />

Intensive Treatment<br />

As just mentioned, the major<br />

reason for the high cost of<br />

diabetes is its complications.<br />

Over 90 percent of the true<br />

excess costs of diabetes are<br />

due to the treatment of its<br />

complications, and just<br />

under one third of people<br />

with diabetes have them. In<br />

other words, the other 70<br />

percent, who have not<br />

developed them, need only<br />

less than 10 percent of the<br />

excess costs of treatment of<br />

diabetes 1 . (‘Excess’ means the<br />

additional cost of diabetes<br />

above that of the<br />

corresponding gender and<br />

age-group without diabetes.<br />

Also known as<br />

‘incremental’.)<br />

The results of well-known<br />

studies have indicated that<br />

intensive treatment reduces<br />

complications as well as<br />

excess costs. The <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Control and Complications<br />

Trial (DCCT) showed a 27<br />

to 76 percent reduction of<br />

complications in people<br />

with type 1 diabetes 2 and<br />

the United Kingdom<br />

Prospective <strong>Diabetes</strong> Study<br />

(UKPDS) showed a 25<br />

percent reduction of<br />

diabetes-related<br />

microvascular<br />

complications among<br />

people with type 2<br />

diabetes 3 – for which the<br />

Kumamoto Study showed<br />

a 64 to 77 percent<br />

reduction.<br />

All these studies have proven<br />

the cost-effectiveness of<br />

preventing complications 4 .<br />

The costs of type 2<br />

complications are, on<br />

average, 24 times higher<br />

and, in the case of type 1<br />

diabetes, 12 times higher,<br />

than that of their peers<br />

without complications 1<br />

(figure 2).<br />

Cost of Equipping<br />

People with <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

In order to carry out proper<br />

self-care, the person with<br />

diabetes needs equipment<br />

such as meters and strips for<br />

26 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


ECONOMICS<br />

blood glucose monitoring,<br />

and syringes, needles and<br />

pens to administer insulin<br />

when and if required. This<br />

does sound expensive, but<br />

when the cost of treatment<br />

for people with established<br />

diabetes complications is<br />

compared to the cost of<br />

prevention by intensive<br />

treatment (ie, at least four<br />

blood glucose tests per day<br />

as in the DCCT), the selfcare<br />

group is always shown<br />

to be the most costeffective.<br />

In Finland, for example, the<br />

cost of self-care equipment<br />

(including blood-glucose<br />

strips) was recently found to<br />

Figure 2<br />

be only 2.8 percent of the<br />

total incremental costs of<br />

diabetes care 1 .<br />

It can be speculated that<br />

there is a real possibility of<br />

saving up to some 40<br />

percent per year of the<br />

present incremental costs of<br />

diabetes care. To achieve<br />

such a result, it is also<br />

necessary to treat the other<br />

cardiovascular risk factors<br />

of type 2 diabetes, not only<br />

to control glucose<br />

metabolism.<br />

Much future investment in<br />

diabetes education and<br />

equipment will be needed<br />

towards improving diabetes<br />

care. The visible results of<br />

such investment, however,<br />

would manifest itself only<br />

after a period of about five<br />

years 4 .<br />

The major worry<br />

concerning diabetes at the<br />

moment is the predicted<br />

explosion of its prevalence,<br />

especially of type 2<br />

diabetes 5 . This makes total<br />

prevention of diabetes on a<br />

global scale an unrealistic<br />

goal, indeed. It is, therefore,<br />

of utmost importance, at<br />

least in economic terms, to<br />

prevent the complications<br />

of diabetes by every possible<br />

means. <strong>Empowerment</strong> and<br />

self-care have been shown<br />

to be among the most<br />

effective approaches to<br />

achieve this aim.<br />

References:<br />

1. Kangas T, Sivonen K: Analysis of<br />

incremental and total direct costs of<br />

health care for persons with diabetes<br />

by type of diabetes with age and sex<br />

matched controls. Abstracts for the<br />

17th IDF Congress Mexico. <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Res Clin Pract 2000:50 (Suppl):8.<br />

2. The <strong>Diabetes</strong> Control and<br />

Complications Trial Research<br />

Group: The effect of intensive<br />

treatment of diabetes on<br />

development and progression of<br />

long-term complications in insulindependent<br />

diabetes mellitus. N Engl<br />

J Med 1993:329:977-986.<br />

3. UKPDS, Intensive blood-glucose<br />

control with sulphonylureas or<br />

insulin compared with conventional<br />

treatment and the risk of<br />

complications in patients with type 2<br />

diabetes (UKPDS 33). Lancet<br />

1998:352:837-853.<br />

4. Wake N, Hisashige A, Katayama<br />

T et al: Cost-effectiveness of<br />

intensive insulin therapy for type 2<br />

diabetes: a 10-year follow-up of the<br />

Kumamoto study. <strong>Diabetes</strong> Res Clin<br />

Pract 2000:48:201-210.<br />

5. King H, Aubert RE, Herman<br />

WH: Global burden of diabetes,<br />

1995-2025: prevalence, numerical<br />

estimates, and projections. <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Care 1998:21:1414-1431.<br />

Professor Tero Kangas,<br />

Vantaa, Finland,<br />

diabetologist and internist,<br />

is former Chief Physician at<br />

the Eastern Health Centre,<br />

Helsinki, and was IDF Vice<br />

President between 1982<br />

and 1988. He is Honorary<br />

President of the Finnish<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Association and<br />

was President between<br />

1991 and 1994.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 27


RESEARCH<br />

Combined Study<br />

in <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Care of people with<br />

diabetes is in need of<br />

improvement. Patients<br />

are often left in the<br />

dark about their<br />

condition and many<br />

receive false or<br />

unnecessary<br />

medication. It has been<br />

shown in a recent<br />

German study,<br />

performed by the<br />

Centre for Sociopolitics<br />

at the University of<br />

Bremen, together with<br />

the medical insurance<br />

company, Gmünder<br />

Ersatzkasse (GEK),<br />

that too few people<br />

with diabetes are being<br />

subscribed much<br />

needed medication, too<br />

many are taking the<br />

wrong type of<br />

medication and many<br />

are inadequately<br />

informed about<br />

sensible diet and selfmanagement<br />

techniques.<br />

Inadequate treatment<br />

and lack of information<br />

from doctors mean<br />

one thing. People with<br />

diabetes will suffer from<br />

complications such as foot<br />

amputations, blindness and<br />

serious circulatory<br />

problems.<br />

According to Mr Dieter<br />

Hebel, Head of the GEK,<br />

“Negligent medical care<br />

accounts for two thirds of<br />

all amputations in<br />

Germany. This means we<br />

have to truly enable people<br />

with diabetes to take over<br />

more responsibility for<br />

their condition<br />

themselves.”<br />

The study also revealed that<br />

only 50 percent of people<br />

with type 2 diabetes in<br />

Germany adhere to a<br />

specific nutritional plan<br />

Kristina Hawthorne<br />

and only 20 to 30 percent<br />

have received any<br />

structured education on the<br />

concomitant conditions of<br />

diabetes and their<br />

consequences such as<br />

hyper- and hypoglycaemia,<br />

high blood pressure,<br />

diabetic foot and<br />

arteriosclerosis, or on oral<br />

medication or injecting<br />

techniques.<br />

Too Many Doctors<br />

Lack Knowledge<br />

Mr Hebel directs criticism<br />

towards the medical scene.<br />

“People with diabetes not<br />

only have to worry about<br />

whether they receive<br />

appropriate treatment, but<br />

also lack of information.<br />

Even the most open of<br />

patients cannot cope<br />

properly with a<br />

misinformed doctor. Too<br />

many doctors fail to keep<br />

themselves educated and<br />

up-to-date.”<br />

According to the Bremen<br />

study, many people with<br />

diabetes are not receiving<br />

suitable medication and<br />

treatment.<br />

Dr Bernhard Braun, the<br />

leader of the study, states,<br />

“Too few young people<br />

with diabetes are on an<br />

appropriate nutritional<br />

plan. A reason for this<br />

could be that doctors are<br />

still in the dark ages in<br />

terms of diabetic nutrition<br />

and are recommending the<br />

old carbohydrate-exchange<br />

30 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


RESEARCH<br />

Reveals Gaps<br />

Therapy<br />

diets that are nearly<br />

impossible to adhere to<br />

over a long term and have<br />

become obselete.”<br />

The study also showed that<br />

more than 60 percent of<br />

people with diabetes in<br />

Germany are probably<br />

using their meters<br />

improperly and not<br />

keeping them adequately<br />

maintained. This can lead<br />

to false readings, dosages<br />

and, above all, places the<br />

user in danger of missing<br />

important indications.<br />

“This kind of inaccuracy is<br />

even more dangerous than<br />

no self-management at all,”<br />

states Dr Braun.<br />

The lives of many people<br />

with diabetes would be<br />

made much easier with a<br />

competent and modern<br />

nutritional therapy. By<br />

raising the standard of care<br />

in such a way, almost 80<br />

percent of people with type<br />

2 diabetes could be treated<br />

without anti-diabetic drugs<br />

or insulin. According to the<br />

Bremen study, 30.3 percent<br />

of such subscribed drugs<br />

are superfluous.<br />

A Passport to Health<br />

In response to the results of<br />

the study, Mr Hebel<br />

decided to send every GEK<br />

member with diabetes a<br />

‘<strong>Diabetes</strong> Gesundheitspass’.<br />

The Gesundheitspass is a<br />

health ‘passport’ used by<br />

people with diabetes and<br />

their physicians to keep a<br />

record of treatment. Only<br />

47 percent of the 2700<br />

people with diabetes<br />

involved in the study were<br />

found to possess one.<br />

Dr Braun points out, “We<br />

could provide much needed<br />

and helpful education and<br />

provide free ‘diabetes<br />

passports’ to people with<br />

diabetes in this country<br />

with the money that could<br />

be saved by cutting down<br />

on unnecessary<br />

prescriptions.”<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 31


LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

Children Reac<br />

The Diabetic Coun<br />

The success of the Diabetic Counsellors in Training (CiTs)<br />

programme has not only been recognized locally but<br />

also internationally. The counsellors presented their<br />

programme at last year’s Pan Africa Congress<br />

held in Johannesburg and again at the<br />

17th IDF Congress in Mexico City.<br />

At both congresses, their presentation<br />

received standing ovation. What is this<br />

revolutionary and dynamic movement<br />

out of Johannesburg,<br />

South Africa?<br />

Nana Masike, Siobhan Kotze and Sue Leuner<br />

32 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

hing Children<br />

sellors in Training<br />

The initial shock and<br />

fear felt by people<br />

newly diagnosed<br />

with diabetes is very real. “...<br />

Injections? Every day? What<br />

do you mean? Where? Blood<br />

glucose tests? How? What do<br />

they mean? Hypo- what?<br />

What can people with<br />

diabetes eat?<br />

Oh, no! ...”<br />

Your world has come to a<br />

sudden stop. Your child has<br />

just been diagnosed with<br />

diabetes. You’re in the<br />

hospital but not really aware<br />

of what is happening<br />

around you. A needle is<br />

presented to you; it is time<br />

to administer your first<br />

injection. The very thought<br />

of injecting your little one<br />

terrifies you. You had always<br />

thought that that was<br />

something doctors and<br />

nurses did, not you. You<br />

think your ‘normal life’ is<br />

over.<br />

This initial reaction is a<br />

normal part of the process<br />

of adapting to a life that will<br />

be different in many ways.<br />

A new life of injections,<br />

testing and balancing.<br />

But how do children, newly<br />

diagnosed with diabetes, feel<br />

in this situation? A scary life<br />

of constant battles, with<br />

every moment filled with<br />

terrifying choices that could<br />

spell disaster if the wrong<br />

decisions are made.<br />

Help Arrives in<br />

Moment of Need<br />

Meanwhile, in walks a<br />

friendly and vibrant young<br />

teenager who greets you<br />

with the words, “Hi! My<br />

name is Jenna. I have<br />

diabetes and I have come to<br />

share with you how I live<br />

with diabetes.” Your<br />

immediate reaction is one<br />

of amazement. How can<br />

such a healthy, confident<br />

youngster such as this<br />

possibly have diabetes? She<br />

speaks to you and your<br />

child about her experiences.<br />

She explains how she copes<br />

with diabetes. She shows<br />

you how she does her<br />

insulin injections, how she<br />

copes at school, what she<br />

does when she goes on<br />

school outings, and when<br />

she travels or sleeps out at<br />

friends. In other words, she<br />

assures you that there is life<br />

after diagnosis. Questions<br />

are answered, stories shared<br />

and phone numbers<br />

exchanged. From now on,<br />

this person has become a<br />

part of the circle of diabetes<br />

care – a counsellor and,<br />

more importantly, a friend.<br />

This young person is not<br />

just anyone – she is one<br />

member of a team of young<br />

people known as the ‘The<br />

Diabetic Counsellors in<br />

Training’ or ‘CiTs’.<br />

The Seeds of Hope<br />

are Sown<br />

The programme was started<br />

in Johannesburg about six<br />

years ago when <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Nurse Educator, Ms Karen<br />

Denton, noticed a common<br />

pattern of behaviour among<br />

her own patients. Karen,<br />

the mother of a diabetic<br />

child herself, Siobhan,<br />

would often take her<br />

daughter with her when she<br />

visited her patients. While<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 33


LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

speaking to the parents,<br />

Siobhan and the child<br />

would start swapping<br />

stories and ideas. Siobhan<br />

would tell the child about<br />

her own experiences with<br />

diabetes and would explain<br />

how she lived with her<br />

condition at school, while<br />

visiting friends, on tours,<br />

when travelling, or at<br />

home. The idea of the CiTs<br />

was born. Karen then went<br />

ahead and selected a group<br />

of 10 teenagers and trained<br />

them in various aspects of<br />

diabetes and child care.<br />

From here, the programme<br />

has grown extensively.<br />

Counselling from Peers<br />

Easier to Grasp<br />

One of the problems with<br />

diabetes is that the<br />

condition is relentless. It is<br />

there every moment of<br />

everyday, and affects every<br />

aspect of life. Imagine how<br />

this must feel to a child.<br />

Children cannot understand<br />

the seemingly senseless<br />

strictures imposed upon<br />

them by what appears to be<br />

unfeeling adults. “No cake!<br />

No candy! Not too much of<br />

this! Be careful when you<br />

exercise! No, you may not<br />

sleep over at your friend’s<br />

house!”<br />

Having to deal with<br />

fingerpricks, injections, the<br />

curtailment of many<br />

A Counsellor in Training (CiT), Monika Fiandeiro, visiting a newly diagnosed child with<br />

diabetes in hospital.<br />

activities and dietary<br />

restrictions become tedious,<br />

indeed. Added to this,<br />

children cannot<br />

comprehend the fact that<br />

they will become adults<br />

and, eventually, elderly.<br />

That life belongs to<br />

someone else. The threat of<br />

long-term complications is<br />

nothing more than that –<br />

an empty threat. The<br />

counsellors, however, are<br />

able to teach and lead by<br />

example, and are successful<br />

at gaining trust and<br />

compliance.<br />

Counsellors are there to<br />

help out at any time.<br />

Sometimes it is something<br />

as simple as discussing the<br />

latest movie, other times it<br />

can involve the child<br />

expressing his feelings about<br />

diabetes and possible<br />

conflicts and frustrations<br />

with friends, at home or at<br />

school. This contact is very<br />

important in maintaining<br />

the relationship and trust<br />

that bonds them.<br />

Ongoing Training for<br />

the Ten Counsellors<br />

Over the past six years, the<br />

counsellors have not only<br />

learnt from their own<br />

experience, but have also<br />

been through extensive<br />

training. During the<br />

weekends, Karen would<br />

teach them about various<br />

aspects of diabetes and the<br />

psychology of children, and<br />

they would learn at the<br />

programmes in which they<br />

participated. The training is<br />

always ongoing and updated<br />

as new information,<br />

techniques and ideas are<br />

brought forward in the<br />

diabetes world. The original<br />

five years of learning<br />

culminated in a recent<br />

learning trip to the Joslin<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Camp and a visit<br />

to the Joslin Institute, USA.<br />

CiT Group Activities<br />

Create Trust<br />

The counsellors work at<br />

diabetes camps (averaging<br />

10 weekend camps a year),<br />

34 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

absent. Counsellors are<br />

never negative towards a<br />

child. They use positive<br />

reinforcement techniques<br />

to encourage appropriate<br />

behaviour. At the same<br />

time, all conversations are<br />

totally confidential and a<br />

counsellor will only break<br />

the confidence if it is<br />

essential to the child’s<br />

well-being, and even then,<br />

the child’s permission is<br />

first sought.<br />

A new junior CiT discussing diet with her young charges at a diabetes camp.<br />

hold fun days, visit newlydiagnosed<br />

children in<br />

hospital and help those<br />

who find life with diabetes<br />

challenging. “We never,<br />

ever tell a child what to do,<br />

we only explain to them<br />

what we do,” says one<br />

counsellor. “Who best to<br />

understand how a child<br />

feels than another child?”<br />

says another.<br />

Camps for diabetic children<br />

are not uncommon around<br />

the world, and counsellors<br />

at camps are not a new<br />

idea. However, they are<br />

simply one aspect of our<br />

counsellors’ numerous<br />

functions. Campers and<br />

counsellors share phone<br />

numbers to keep in<br />

contact. This means that a<br />

counsellor may call a<br />

camper to invite him or<br />

her to a ‘fun day’ or a<br />

camper may call a<br />

counsellor for any number<br />

of reasons.<br />

Fun days can differ in all<br />

aspects. Most common are<br />

those that are held at the<br />

local mall where a small<br />

meal or snack is provided<br />

and then the fun and<br />

games begin. Bowling,<br />

mini-golf and movies are<br />

some of the more popular<br />

activities. These are great<br />

ways to allow children<br />

who may be worried<br />

about leaving home to go<br />

on camp to experience<br />

some of the fun and get a<br />

taste of camp life and the<br />

diabetic community they<br />

have become a part of.<br />

They also give ‘old<br />

campers’ a chance to catch<br />

up with their counsellors<br />

and friends, and give<br />

others a chance to meet<br />

other people with diabetes<br />

so that they know that<br />

they are not alone.<br />

Positive Reinforcement<br />

and Individual Support<br />

Given by Counsellors<br />

Group activities, however,<br />

do not fulfill all the needs<br />

of a child. Counsellors can<br />

arrange to meet a child<br />

with diabetes either at his<br />

home or at a favourite<br />

place to discuss anything<br />

that may be on the child’s<br />

mind. Children find it<br />

easier to speak to a peer or<br />

a slightly older person<br />

about problems because<br />

the fear of reprimand is<br />

Dynamic Presentation<br />

Brings High Profile<br />

In addition to working<br />

with children with<br />

diabetes and their<br />

families, the counsellors<br />

try to spread diabetes<br />

awareness. They have<br />

appeared in magazines,<br />

and on the radio and<br />

television. They are often<br />

to be seen giving talks at<br />

schools, social groups,<br />

clubs – wherever they are<br />

invited to speak.<br />

As one counsellor says, “It<br />

is not the big awards that<br />

make us feel good, it is<br />

the thank you from a<br />

mother who says that her<br />

child is managing better<br />

after we saw them.”<br />

Another says, “Even more<br />

than that, it is the genuine<br />

smile a child gives you<br />

when you leave after<br />

seeing them.”<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 35


LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

Newcomers to the Scene<br />

The CiT initiative has now<br />

moved on to a new stage.<br />

The original 10<br />

‘Counsellors in Training’<br />

are now called ‘<strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Counsellors’ and a new<br />

team of Junior CiTs are in<br />

training. Forty children<br />

aged 12 to 17 from all<br />

around South Africa were<br />

selected last year to<br />

undergo the challenging<br />

training. Over a period of<br />

three years they will attend<br />

an annual three-day<br />

workshop. They are<br />

required to complete four<br />

written assignments on<br />

various aspects of diabetes<br />

per year and attend camps<br />

as leaders in their own area.<br />

They also visit hospitals<br />

and attend the South<br />

African <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Association events.<br />

Karen hopes that one day,<br />

every person with diabetes<br />

will have someone like<br />

these counsellors to help<br />

out and be a friend. A<br />

friend with a common<br />

bond – diabetes.<br />

Ms Nana Masike is a<br />

diabetes nurse, Ms Siobhan<br />

Kotze, a diabetes<br />

counsellor, and Ms Sue<br />

Leuner is Editor of<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Focus,<br />

Johannesburg, South<br />

Africa.<br />

A Uniquely Effective Social Support System<br />

As a clinical psychologist working extensively with children and a<br />

student at the Department of Psychology at Rhodes University<br />

(Grahamstown, South Africa), my field of research is on the<br />

psycho-educational aspects of social support systems and their<br />

impact on children with chronic diseases.<br />

The <strong>Diabetes</strong> Counsellors in Training initiative, supported by<br />

Roche Diagnostics and Eli Lilly, is a unique programme for diabetic<br />

children based on the psycho-educational concept of peer<br />

mentoring. The process of peer mentoring and learning through<br />

role models teaches children to integrate the diabetic condition,<br />

with all its demands, into their lifestyles.<br />

I had the privilege to participate in a diabetes camp and observe<br />

the process of peer mentoring, that is, of children teaching other<br />

children. In interviews with the counsellors, it was made apparent<br />

that the impact of this programme is twofold. It builds up their<br />

knowledge about diabetes through the teaching of the necessary<br />

skills for monitoring and controlling blood glucose levels and it<br />

engenders a sense of well-being, confidence, self control and<br />

compassion.<br />

In interviews with counsellors’ parents and with parents of children<br />

who had attended these camps, the results were also positive.<br />

Most of the latter had established ongoing post-camp<br />

relationships with the counsellors. The parents were all impressed<br />

with the positive impact the modelling of peers had had on the<br />

lives of their children. Their children now had the ability to selfmonitor<br />

their diabetes and social improvements were seen within<br />

the family sphere.<br />

Ms Jo Kanfer<br />

36 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

Listen ...<br />

to a Voice<br />

Bibi Hølge-Hazelton<br />

Listen to the voice of<br />

a young girl Lonnie,<br />

who was diagnosed<br />

with type 1 diabetes<br />

at 16. Imagine that<br />

she is deeply involved<br />

in the social security<br />

system. She lives with<br />

her mother and two<br />

siblings in a working<br />

class part of a small<br />

town. She is at a<br />

special school for<br />

problematic youth,<br />

and her carers are<br />

seriously concerned<br />

about how she is<br />

going to manage her<br />

diabetes.<br />

38 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

Lonnie, at the age of 16<br />

Iwent from 56 to 43<br />

kilos within a few days.<br />

I felt really bad.<br />

It was very scary.<br />

My counsellor looked at<br />

me and asked if I had been<br />

smoking dope again.<br />

Then we went to the<br />

doctor who said, “There is<br />

something else wrong with<br />

her, we must call an<br />

ambulance.” He did not say<br />

why, or how, or anything.<br />

I was just sitting there,<br />

totally in the dark. Help!<br />

What is happening to me?<br />

What is the meaning of all<br />

this?<br />

At the moment my blood<br />

sugar goes up and down<br />

whether I eat or not.<br />

But I need to look nice<br />

because there is always that<br />

fear that I will be sent to<br />

the hospital.<br />

When I am in hospital, I<br />

can do absolutely nothing<br />

but just lie there.<br />

I am being observed all the<br />

time, and am allowed<br />

almost nothing.<br />

Lying there, I am thinking,<br />

“Tell me, am I more ill<br />

than they really let on?”<br />

I just take one day at a<br />

time. I am used to this,<br />

because I have had to<br />

endure enough things<br />

already.<br />

Scientists and all those clever<br />

people. It is easy for them to<br />

just sit there and say so and<br />

so and so. But they don’t<br />

know how I feel.<br />

How should they know,<br />

when I have not been asked?<br />

And even if they ask one<br />

person one question, it isn’t<br />

so that all other people also<br />

feel that way.<br />

In general, we can live a<br />

normal life. But there is,<br />

however, a great deal of<br />

difference.<br />

A year has passed. She<br />

has been admitted to the<br />

hospital countless times.<br />

She has stopped coming<br />

to the appointments. She<br />

has been thrown out of<br />

school. She spends her<br />

days in front of the<br />

television, waiting for<br />

her friends to come<br />

home. She is confused,<br />

angry, trapped.<br />

Nevertheless, if you<br />

listen carefully, you will<br />

hear how diabetes gives<br />

meaning to her life<br />

history, and if you really<br />

concentrate, you will<br />

also hear her own<br />

suggestion as to what<br />

kind of help she would<br />

find relevant. But she is<br />

not heard. Her carers<br />

have given up on her.<br />

Lonnie, at the age of 17<br />

I can’t cope with all this<br />

pressure. I don’t want any<br />

more pressure. I do not<br />

even want to think about it<br />

and only want to get away.<br />

I don’t have very much to<br />

do with my father. It is four<br />

years since I last saw him.<br />

I do not want to receive<br />

help.<br />

I want to take care of<br />

myself. I have always been<br />

like that.<br />

I simply believe that I<br />

need somebody I can cling<br />

to and talk to about<br />

everything to help<br />

stabilize myself.<br />

Without having really<br />

thought about it, I am, in a<br />

way, tired of living. I don’t<br />

care about anything. I<br />

couldn’t care less about my<br />

family.<br />

I feel that I am attached<br />

to something that I do not<br />

want to be attached to. I<br />

have no use for these<br />

people at the hospital,<br />

because one day I will be<br />

standing there, and will<br />

have to be able to manage<br />

alone someday without<br />

them, too.<br />

I am unable to express<br />

myself.<br />

I was only 10 or 11 years<br />

old when I had this<br />

thought that maybe I<br />

should jump into the river,<br />

nobody would miss me<br />

anyway. I thought about<br />

how they would look when<br />

they stood there looking<br />

down into my grave. But<br />

then there was this little<br />

voice up there that said,<br />

“What about daddy? What<br />

would daddy say?”<br />

And I ran home again.<br />

You are a coward if you<br />

take your own life. That’s<br />

for sure.<br />

Listen to the voice of<br />

Lonnie. She has had<br />

diabetes for two years.<br />

She has not been in<br />

contact with her carers<br />

for a long time. To<br />

them she is probably<br />

lost. But what is it she<br />

is telling? <strong>Diabetes</strong> has<br />

become an integral<br />

part of her life, gives<br />

meaning to her<br />

personality and her<br />

painful story, and now<br />

she sees it as a lifeline,<br />

drawing her out of the<br />

haze and the endless,<br />

unstructured days.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 39


LIVING WITH DIABETES<br />

They do not realize that this<br />

leaves a stamp on your life.<br />

Lonnie, at the age of 18<br />

I have not been inside a<br />

hospital for the last 18<br />

months. I have been<br />

indifferent and have ignored<br />

the whole thing. This is<br />

probably because I have<br />

experienced a lot of bad<br />

things. Hospital only gives<br />

you a framework of rules,<br />

which you couldn’t care less<br />

about anyway.<br />

I have always been very<br />

stubborn. I just feel like<br />

straightening my back and<br />

saying, “You know what? I<br />

can manage by myself! I have<br />

told you so many times.<br />

What about believing in me<br />

instead?”<br />

I have seen it from my<br />

mother’s side a lot, because I<br />

could easily see that I was so<br />

blind. In the end it was too<br />

humiliating for my her.<br />

When I was 12, I was told<br />

how my father had treated<br />

my mother. He tried to hit<br />

her and made a hole in the<br />

wall. That was at the time<br />

when my mother had<br />

become pregnant with me<br />

and he did not believe that<br />

he was the father.<br />

I have found my own<br />

explanation for the diabetes.<br />

It is the soul that has finally<br />

been used so much that the<br />

pancreas simply has stopped<br />

functioning.<br />

I believe it has been a good<br />

thing that I got diabetes,<br />

because if I had not got<br />

diabetes, I would never have<br />

stopped taking hash.<br />

Due to diabetes, I mustn’t<br />

lose myself so much that I<br />

forget my injections. If I did<br />

not have diabetes and did<br />

not have to inject myself,<br />

then I would have nothing<br />

to be responsible for.<br />

I might as well say it. I<br />

believe in fate. It has been<br />

my fate to get diabetes.<br />

If not, I would have been lost<br />

by now.<br />

Who can judge what life<br />

is like for a person with<br />

diabetes? Who has got<br />

the recipe for the<br />

wonder tool that can<br />

make people with<br />

diabetes ‘comply’? The<br />

answer is hidden in the<br />

voices of the people who<br />

live with diabetes. We<br />

need to listen more<br />

carefully.<br />

This piece was extracted<br />

from qualitative interviews<br />

with Lonnie, conducted as<br />

a part of Ms Bibi Hølge-<br />

Hazelton’s thesis entitled<br />

‘<strong>Diabetes</strong> – A School for<br />

Life’. Ms Hølge-Hazelton is<br />

doing her doctorate at the<br />

Graduate School of<br />

Lifelong Learning in the<br />

University Centre of<br />

Roskilde, Denmark.<br />

40 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


The Internet:<br />

Empowering People with <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

There are numerous benefits to<br />

accessing diabetes information on<br />

the internet. It provides the latest<br />

scientific information and<br />

guidelines, allowing users to<br />

overcome geographic barriers. The<br />

information is relatively<br />

inexpensive and easy to find and<br />

is available seven days a week, 24<br />

hours a day. Here are two<br />

examples of websites from<br />

different corners of the globe.<br />

42 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


Canadian <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Association’s<br />

Best Information<br />

Provider<br />

Michael Lund<br />

Imagine having<br />

millions of pages of<br />

diabetes information<br />

at your fingertips<br />

whenever you need it, at<br />

any time, day or night.<br />

This was only a dream<br />

less than 10 years ago,<br />

but today the internet<br />

can deliver this in<br />

seconds. For example,<br />

searching the term<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 43


DIABETES ON THE WEB<br />

‘diabetes’ on the<br />

Google.com search<br />

engine results in<br />

2,780,000 page links.<br />

The number one benefit<br />

of having access to this<br />

information is that it<br />

enables people to take<br />

charge of their own<br />

health by helping them<br />

stay informed and learn<br />

more about the disease<br />

and ways to manage it.<br />

Some may question the<br />

importance of looking for<br />

information on diabetes<br />

if they regularly see their<br />

doctor. Your doctor is<br />

expected to know a great<br />

deal about hundreds of<br />

different health problems<br />

and he or she can’t<br />

always stay on top of the<br />

latest research or<br />

developments. Your<br />

health is at stake, so<br />

taking responsibility for<br />

your own health is<br />

important.<br />

This does not, in any<br />

way, suggest that the<br />

internet or any other<br />

information source be<br />

used as a substitute, but<br />

rather as a complement<br />

to regular visits to a<br />

healthcare professional. A<br />

good doctor will be<br />

pleased that you are<br />

informed and taking an<br />

interest in your health.<br />

Being Selective<br />

When reviewing material<br />

online, however, caution<br />

is required. Some<br />

websites may have a bias<br />

for their material or, in<br />

some cases, may provide<br />

incorrect information.<br />

Non-profit associations,<br />

government agencies or<br />

universities typically run<br />

the most reliable online<br />

resources.<br />

Internet Provides<br />

Great Opportunity<br />

for Interaction<br />

In addition to being an<br />

invaluable resource for<br />

information on diabetes,<br />

the internet is also an<br />

excellent way to find<br />

support and advice from<br />

other people with<br />

diabetes. Many sites<br />

provide discussion groups<br />

or electronic bulletin<br />

board systems where you<br />

can post a question or a<br />

problem and receive<br />

responses from others<br />

who have been through<br />

similar situations. You<br />

can also learn from the<br />

questions and responses<br />

others have posted.<br />

The internet doesn’t only<br />

empower the person with<br />

diabetes, but it can also<br />

be an invaluable tool for<br />

diabetes organizations.<br />

Website Best Method<br />

for Giving Information<br />

Each month, the<br />

Canadian <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Association site,<br />

www.diabetes.ca, serves<br />

over 55,000 visitors who<br />

view more than 300,000<br />

pages. There simply isn’t<br />

an easier way of serving<br />

that many people with<br />

any other method of<br />

communication.<br />

At the Canadian <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Association, the website is<br />

becoming the primary<br />

means of providing<br />

diabetes-related<br />

information.<br />

In addition to the many<br />

pages of information<br />

already online, we are<br />

converting many of our<br />

paper-based articles and<br />

brochures and<br />

reformatting them for<br />

display on the web.<br />

More than 150 Canadian<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Association<br />

branches across the<br />

country list information<br />

on branch news, support<br />

groups and local events<br />

online.<br />

Taking this one step<br />

further, we are<br />

implementing a<br />

discussion group area to<br />

establish a virtual<br />

community for those<br />

people who are not close<br />

to a branch or who prefer<br />

to get their information<br />

from the internet.<br />

The World Wide Web is<br />

already an incredible tool<br />

and a great resource for<br />

people with diabetes,<br />

despite it being around<br />

for less than a decade.<br />

It will continue to grow,<br />

offer new and exciting<br />

opportunities for people<br />

with diabetes to help<br />

them manage their<br />

disease.<br />

Mr Michael Lund is<br />

Manager of the Website<br />

and Online Initiatives in<br />

the Marketing and<br />

Communications<br />

Department of the<br />

Canadian <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Association, Toronto,<br />

Canada.<br />

44 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


DIABETES ON THE WEB<br />

German Website:<br />

A Stamp of Quality<br />

Thomas Baehring, Melanie Steppenfeld and Werner Scherbaum<br />

In the face of rising<br />

diabetes prevalence in<br />

Germany,<br />

empowerment of people<br />

with diabetes and access<br />

to information is<br />

especially needed for the<br />

prevention of the<br />

condition itself, as well<br />

as its complications. To<br />

this end, a cooperative<br />

effort between the<br />

National Ministry of<br />

Health, the German<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Research<br />

Institute and the two<br />

national diabetes<br />

organizations,<br />

Deutsche <strong>Diabetes</strong>-<br />

Gesellschaft (DDG)<br />

and the Deutsche<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Union<br />

(DDU), has created a<br />

new website offering upto-date<br />

and qualityassured<br />

information for<br />

people with diabetes<br />

and healthcare<br />

professionals alike.<br />

Access to expert<br />

information has<br />

proven to be one<br />

of the most essential tools<br />

in the prevention of<br />

diabetes and its<br />

complications,<br />

particularly in enabling<br />

empowerment. The<br />

internet is playing an<br />

increasingly important<br />

role in this process. It<br />

provides the basis for<br />

making information and<br />

electronic communication<br />

accessible to its users.<br />

The internet also offers<br />

further opportunities by<br />

providing people with<br />

diabetes with interactive<br />

designs consisting of<br />

discussion forums for<br />

those affected,<br />

appointment calendars for<br />

The internet can be an incredibly powerful teaching tool because it can provide the most<br />

up-to-date knowledge.<br />

© Roche Diagnostics<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 45


DIABETES ON THE WEB<br />

regional activities, online<br />

classification of diabetes<br />

risk, and possibly, in the<br />

future, personal medical<br />

files for use in diabetes<br />

therapy.<br />

Need for Quality<br />

Assurance<br />

However, this process<br />

demands the highest<br />

standards in terms of<br />

technology and data<br />

protection. Experts<br />

working in clinical and<br />

research fields of diabetes<br />

must, therefore, play a<br />

key role in the<br />

contribution, control, and<br />

quality assurance.<br />

Currently, there is a<br />

plethora of information<br />

on the internet<br />

concerning diabetes. The<br />

information offered is of<br />

varying quality and is<br />

often difficult to navigate.<br />

Understandable and<br />

Easy to Navigate<br />

In the negative case, users<br />

can find it difficult to<br />

obtain objective and<br />

balanced health<br />

information. In this<br />

context, a new website<br />

under www.diabetesdeutschland.de,<br />

created<br />

in June this year, has been<br />

implemented, offering<br />

information controlled by<br />

experts in a style that the<br />

non-expert can easily and<br />

readily understand.<br />

The information provided<br />

by the portal is prepared<br />

by an expert team from<br />

the German <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Research Institute,<br />

Düsseldorf, with a council<br />

of 40 diabetes specialists<br />

from all over the country.<br />

It is published by the<br />

DDG, the body of<br />

healthcare professionals,<br />

and financially supported<br />

by the German Ministry<br />

of Health. Another very<br />

important contributor<br />

and patron of the website<br />

is the DDU, the national<br />

combined diabetes<br />

association. The DDU<br />

ensures that the interests<br />

and opinions of people<br />

with diabetes are included<br />

in the information<br />

provided.<br />

diabetes-deutschland.de<br />

is not only aimed at<br />

people with diabetes, but<br />

also their families, friends<br />

and those others involved<br />

in the prevention of<br />

complications. It provides<br />

information about topics<br />

relevant to everyday life,<br />

integrating them more<br />

into the individual’s<br />

diabetes management.<br />

The website presents a<br />

trustworthy source of<br />

information presented in<br />

a clear way and includes<br />

daily breaking news,<br />

regular newsletters sent to<br />

the users by e-mail, and a<br />

question-and-answer area<br />

serviced by diabetes<br />

experts. A diabetes<br />

appointment calendar,<br />

updated daily, provides<br />

information on talks,<br />

seminars, workshops, TV<br />

shows and regional events<br />

held by self-help groups,<br />

and an address list of<br />

contacts.<br />

The website also includes<br />

an online discussion<br />

forum for people with<br />

diabetes and other<br />

interested parties to<br />

interact either through<br />

normal discussion,<br />

interactive games, and<br />

tests to assess risk,<br />

diabetes knowledge, etc.<br />

The contents, structure<br />

and organization of<br />

diabetes-deutschland.de<br />

has become a model for<br />

providing information<br />

controlled by experts for<br />

people with diabetes both<br />

within and beyond<br />

Germany’s boundaries.<br />

Thus, the main direction<br />

in the future will be on<br />

developing a European<br />

and, eventually, a<br />

worldwide network of<br />

diabetes information, each<br />

with its own national<br />

emphasis. The<br />

experiences of<br />

the website may be drawn<br />

upon in creating defined<br />

strategies towards this<br />

goal.<br />

Dr Thomas Baehring,<br />

Dr Melanie Steppenfeld<br />

and Professor Werner<br />

Scherbaum, German<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Research<br />

Institute, Heinrich Heine<br />

University Clinic,<br />

Düsseldorf, Germany, are<br />

all part of the diabetesdeutschland.de<br />

team, for<br />

which Dr Baehring is<br />

responsible for technical<br />

and academic input and<br />

Professor Scherbaum is<br />

consulting director and<br />

publisher.<br />

46 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


IDF UPDATE<br />

<strong>Empowerment</strong> and<br />

How It Can be<br />

Implemented<br />

The Role of <strong>Diabetes</strong> Associations<br />

Bjørnar Allgot<br />

48 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


IDF UPDATE<br />

The definitions of<br />

empowerment are<br />

many but less varied.<br />

They all tend to refer<br />

to a ‘process’. In this<br />

article, Mr Bjørnar<br />

Allgot, Norway, briefly<br />

analyses the concept of<br />

empowerment and<br />

gives guidelines as to<br />

how this process can be<br />

achieved. Finally, as<br />

IDF Vice President,<br />

Mr Allgot sees the need<br />

for the <strong>International</strong><br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> <strong>Federation</strong> to<br />

create an effective tool<br />

for evaluating<br />

empowerment which<br />

can be used by member<br />

associations around the<br />

world.<br />

There are many<br />

definitions of<br />

empowerment<br />

and all are quite similar in<br />

essence. <strong>Empowerment</strong><br />

can be understood as a<br />

process whereby a person<br />

attains the authority to<br />

make decisions for<br />

managing his or her own<br />

life.<br />

Education:<br />

Key to Management<br />

of Chronic Illnesses<br />

Chronic conditions<br />

require optimal treatment<br />

facilities, combined with<br />

an appropriately adapted<br />

and continual prospect of<br />

education. Learning about<br />

one’s own condition is a<br />

basic necessity for<br />

managing life with<br />

diabetes. People with<br />

diabetes must make their<br />

own decisions concerning<br />

their diabetes and be<br />

responsible for difficult<br />

and demanding choices in<br />

their daily lives.<br />

Education in selfmanagement<br />

provides the<br />

best possible foundation<br />

for making such personal<br />

decisions. Seen in this<br />

context, a lack of<br />

education is as serious as a<br />

lack of medicine.<br />

People with diabetes need<br />

the opportunity to make<br />

decisions about their own<br />

treatment, as they are the<br />

ones who have to live with<br />

the consequences.<br />

Health service personnel<br />

have medical knowledge<br />

about diabetes, but that is<br />

not necessarily the same as<br />

knowing what is best for a<br />

particular person. Giving<br />

people with diabetes the<br />

tools for making<br />

appropriate decisions in<br />

self-management is the<br />

best possible foundation<br />

for treatment.<br />

Different Ways of<br />

Communication<br />

Communication between<br />

healthcare professionals<br />

and their ‘patients’ can<br />

take place in different<br />

forms. The healthcare<br />

professional can give<br />

instructions and the<br />

person with diabetes<br />

listens and is expected to<br />

obey. This process is<br />

categorized as one-way<br />

communication. On the<br />

other hand, there can be a<br />

balanced, mutual<br />

relationship between the<br />

healthcare professional<br />

and the person with<br />

diabetes. This process is<br />

categorized as two-way<br />

communication, whereby<br />

each of the parties is an<br />

expert in his own right,<br />

but together form a solid<br />

foundation for managing<br />

diabetes. This model<br />

represents the basic<br />

foundation for the<br />

development of<br />

empowerment.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Associations<br />

Essential in Delivery of<br />

Information<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> associations play<br />

a central role in<br />

influencing the<br />

development of<br />

empowerment for people<br />

with diabetes. First and<br />

foremost, diabetes<br />

associations play a major<br />

role in education and the<br />

dissemination of<br />

information.<br />

It is often said that<br />

knowledge is power.<br />

Important to this is access<br />

to information. Having<br />

access to valid, updated<br />

information will put an<br />

individual in quite a<br />

different position than<br />

those who are<br />

uninformed. Most<br />

diabetes associations<br />

publish journals and<br />

leaflets to disseminate<br />

information to their<br />

members. This is an<br />

essential contribution in<br />

empowering those with<br />

diabetes.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 49


IDF UPDATE<br />

© Martha Funnell<br />

Education provides the best possible foundation for making personal decisions in managing diabetes.<br />

During the last few<br />

decades huge changes<br />

have taken place in the<br />

treatment and<br />

understanding of<br />

diabetes. This new<br />

knowledge will, without<br />

doubt, lead to changes and<br />

improvements. Journals<br />

about diabetes contribute<br />

to this new knowledge and<br />

are available to individuals<br />

for the rest of their lives.<br />

Instruction versus<br />

Interaction<br />

It is also important to look<br />

at how information is<br />

given. If information has<br />

the character of being<br />

instructive and only<br />

medically oriented, it will<br />

not have an especially<br />

positive influence on the<br />

development of<br />

empowerment. If<br />

information is interactive<br />

and user-receiver oriented<br />

it will have a stronger<br />

positive effect.<br />

Most diabetes associations<br />

organize their own<br />

educational activities<br />

towards care and<br />

management, which<br />

contributes greatly to<br />

the development of<br />

empowerment. However,<br />

it is also important that<br />

organizations influence the<br />

health service and<br />

authorities so that<br />

educational activities<br />

provided by the health<br />

service is done in such a<br />

way that learning to<br />

manage becomes an<br />

integrated element in the<br />

treatment of diabetes.<br />

The Methods of<br />

Learning<br />

Not only is it important<br />

that learning actually takes<br />

place, it is also important<br />

how the learning takes<br />

place. There is a vast<br />

difference between<br />

teaching and learning.<br />

While teaching can be<br />

carried out by a single<br />

person with a lot of<br />

knowledge, learning is<br />

something that, by its very<br />

nature, must take place<br />

within the individual. A<br />

passive form of teaching<br />

frequently leads to<br />

individuals learning<br />

passivity. An active form of<br />

teaching, centred around<br />

the ‘pupil’, will promote<br />

activity, independence and<br />

responsibility for one’s<br />

own learning. These<br />

interactive forms of<br />

education are central to<br />

50 <strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong>


IDF UPDATE<br />

the promotion of<br />

empowerment.<br />

<strong>Empowerment</strong> is Not a<br />

Power Game<br />

The diabetes association<br />

can also promote<br />

empowerment by its<br />

philosophy. There are<br />

different forms of<br />

knowledge about diabetes:<br />

scientific medical<br />

knowledge and everyday<br />

medical knowledge. In<br />

order to manage diabetes<br />

we must have both.<br />

To avoid the pitfall<br />

whereby empowerment is<br />

reduced to a question of<br />

who has power over<br />

whom, it is important that<br />

a mutual respect exist<br />

between healthcare<br />

personnel and people with<br />

diabetes. When<br />

empowerment takes place,<br />

both the healthcare<br />

personnel and people with<br />

diabetes benefit. It is a<br />

question of cooperation to<br />

gain and maintain control<br />

over the condition, and a<br />

question of how people<br />

with diabetes can keep<br />

their independence,<br />

freedom and integrity.<br />

Effective Evaluation<br />

How can we measure<br />

empowerment? Until<br />

now, there have been no<br />

effective tools to measure<br />

empowerment, but the<br />

time is ripe for such<br />

development.<br />

When measuring<br />

empowerment, we must<br />

differentiate between<br />

activities that promote<br />

empowerment and to<br />

what degree people with<br />

diabetes themselves think<br />

they manage their own<br />

diabetes.<br />

It is easy to ascertain the<br />

former (if a person with<br />

diabetes receives<br />

education or not). We<br />

know whether or not the<br />

associations themselves<br />

provide this education<br />

through magazines,<br />

journals and leaflets. It<br />

can be assessed, for<br />

example, whether their<br />

members have access to<br />

this information<br />

regardless of their<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> associations all around the world are busy educating their members. This is happening<br />

in over 150 countries.<br />

geographical location or<br />

socio-economic situation.<br />

To assess the latter is<br />

more difficult.<br />

Nevertheless, a few years<br />

ago in Europe, a<br />

questionnaire was<br />

designed with indicators<br />

for the development of<br />

empowerment. There is<br />

now a need to further<br />

develop this work.<br />

I believe this task should<br />

be one of the most<br />

important priorities for<br />

the <strong>International</strong> <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

<strong>Federation</strong>, and should be<br />

carried out in<br />

collaboration with<br />

diabetes associations<br />

around the world.<br />

Having defined<br />

purposeful indicators, we<br />

can regularly measure the<br />

development of<br />

empowerment. This is an<br />

important tool for<br />

diabetes associations for<br />

evaluating the results of<br />

their work.<br />

Mr Bjørnar Allgot is<br />

General Secretary of the<br />

Norwegian <strong>Diabetes</strong><br />

Association and IDF Vice<br />

President.<br />

<strong>Diabetes</strong> Voice • Volume 46 • September 2001 • <strong>Empowerment</strong> 51

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!