Witness to Abuse - Human Rights Watch
Witness to Abuse - Human Rights Watch
Witness to Abuse - Human Rights Watch
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
y subletting their apartment. Although the federal agents announced he was a suspect,<br />
they arrested him as a material witness and jailed him in solitary confinement in New<br />
York for three months, while continuing <strong>to</strong> threaten terrorism charges against him.<br />
According <strong>to</strong> his lawyer:<br />
Bakarbashat leased an apartment that [the two hijackers] once resided in.<br />
He <strong>to</strong>ok over the rest of the lease from the guys. He had no social<br />
interactions with al-Hazmi and al-Midhar. Initially the government was<br />
going <strong>to</strong> charge him with providing material support for renting an<br />
apartment from them. Really, he was pretty poor—a student, getting his<br />
degree in computers. He would be living in his car if he didn’t rent a<br />
cheap apartment. 291<br />
Bakarbashat was eventually criminally charged and deported for doing work while on a<br />
student visa. 292<br />
XI. Consequences of Arrest for Material <strong>Witness</strong> Detainees and their Families<br />
I prayed <strong>to</strong> God not <strong>to</strong> hate, but I thought this was a setup and that I would spend my life in prison. I<br />
was depressed. I hated myself, my family, the officers, everyone. I did nothing, but I thought that if they<br />
asked me if I did something that would give me a death sentence, I was ready <strong>to</strong> [confess].<br />
—Omer Bakarbashat 293<br />
For the material witnesses profiled in this report, the experience of arrest and<br />
incarceration has been devastating—in many cases a nightmare which continues <strong>to</strong><br />
darken their lives. The misuse of the material witness law has not just been a violation of<br />
abstract rights. Being treated as potential suspects would be bad enough, but innocent<br />
men have found themselves without the reassuring safeguards and protections afforded<br />
<strong>to</strong> criminal suspects; they have been hauled off <strong>to</strong> jail by armed agents for no reason they<br />
could discern and with none provided, held for weeks and months in solitary<br />
confinement, and handcuffed and shackled, as though they were dangerous terrorist<br />
suspects. It is difficult <strong>to</strong> imagine the fear, confusion, despair, and devastation these men<br />
and their families have experienced in these circumstances. It is not supposed <strong>to</strong> be an<br />
experience one would ever endure in the United States.<br />
291<br />
HRW/ACLU telephone interview with Randy Hamud, at<strong>to</strong>rney for Omer Bakarbashat, August 16, 2004.<br />
292<br />
Ibid.<br />
293<br />
James Sterngold, “The Wrong Place, at the Wrong Time,” San Francisco Chronicle, September 9, 2002.<br />
91 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH VOL. 17, NO. 2(G)