Witness to Abuse - Human Rights Watch
Witness to Abuse - Human Rights Watch
Witness to Abuse - Human Rights Watch
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Recommendations<br />
The recommendations below are intended <strong>to</strong> address the violations of international<br />
human rights law and U.S. constitutional law identified in this report. They are directed<br />
primarily <strong>to</strong> the Department of Justice, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation<br />
(FBI). We also urge Congress <strong>to</strong> exercise its legislative and oversight authority <strong>to</strong> ensure<br />
that the necessary changes in current policies and practices are made. If detention of<br />
witnesses is permissible at all, the U.S. government must ensure that investigations and<br />
arrests of persons suspected of having information material <strong>to</strong> a terrorism investigation<br />
are conducted with regard for the rights of all persons in the United States <strong>to</strong> be free of<br />
arbitrary, pretextual, or unnecessarily prolonged detention; mistreatment in confinement,<br />
and discrimination.<br />
To the Justice Department<br />
To the FBI and U.S. At<strong>to</strong>rneys<br />
• The Justice Department should use the material witness law only for the<br />
purpose of obtaining testimony and not for the purpose of detaining criminal<br />
suspects without charges.<br />
• National origin, race, religion, or gender should not be the basis for suspicion of<br />
unlawful conduct, possession of material information, or flight risk.<br />
• Federal law enforcement officials should strictly limit the detention of a material<br />
witness <strong>to</strong> the shortest time necessary <strong>to</strong> secure his testimony by appearance<br />
before a court or grand jury or by deposition. The government’s interest in<br />
further investigation of the witness should not delay the witness’s testimony and<br />
release.<br />
• The Department of Justice should seek the cooperation of potential witnesses<br />
before arresting them as material witnesses. The Justice Department should<br />
apply for a material witness warrant only when the witness has explicitly refused<br />
<strong>to</strong> testify or done something affirmative <strong>to</strong> show that he would not comply with<br />
a subpoena.<br />
• U.S. At<strong>to</strong>rneys should provide material witnesses and their lawyers with full<br />
access <strong>to</strong> the application, affidavits, and any other materials necessary for the<br />
witness and lawyer <strong>to</strong> adequately respond <strong>to</strong> the government’s contentions.<br />
• On arresting material witnesses, federal law enforcement officers should<br />
promptly inform them, in a language they can understand, of the basis for their<br />
arrest, provide them with a copy of the warrant, and inform them that they have<br />
7 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH VOL. 17, NO. 2(G)