Gosford Water Survey 1 - Gosford City Council
Gosford Water Survey 1 - Gosford City Council
Gosford Water Survey 1 - Gosford City Council
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Report<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community<br />
Consultation, Field Investigation and Sampling Design<br />
For<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>City</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
February 2000
© AWT Environment, Science & Technology ACN 003 848 860<br />
Sydney Office<br />
51 Hermitage Road West Ryde NSW Australia 2114<br />
PO Box 73 West Ryde NSW Australia 2114<br />
telephone +61 2 9334 0935 <br />
facsimile +61 2 9334 0973 <br />
Melbourne Office<br />
68 Ricketts Road Mt Waverley Vic Australia 3149<br />
Private Bag 1 Mt Waverley Vic Australia 3149<br />
telephone +61 3 9550 1000 <br />
facsimile +61 3 9543 7372 <br />
Brisbane Office<br />
Unit 1, 37 Mein St Spring Hill Brisbane Australia 4000 <br />
PO Box 673 Spring Hill Brisbane Australia 4004<br />
telephone +61 7 3832 9126 <br />
facsimile +61 7 3832 9179 <br />
Commercial-in-Confidence<br />
This report and the information, ideas, concepts, methodologies,<br />
technologies and other material it contains remain the intellectual<br />
property of AWT Pty Ltd, unless otherwise agreed.<br />
AWT Report Number: 2000/0032<br />
File Reference: G:\PROJECTS\45-<br />
46\WR004530\Reports\Report1.doc<br />
June 2002
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Executive Summary<br />
In November 1999, AWT was commissioned by <strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>City</strong> <strong>Council</strong> to<br />
carry out a water quality survey to investigate water quality problems in<br />
three creeks in the Brisbane <strong>Water</strong> catchment. The creeks Narara, Erina and<br />
Kincumber were targeted following water quality results from a monitoring<br />
program established in 1996. The survey was established to localise<br />
problem areas within these catchments.<br />
The survey is in three stages. Stage 1 comprised a community consultation<br />
process and field investigation to establish issues relating to water quality in<br />
the catchment, the values the local community holds for the creek systems<br />
and catchment ‘hot spots’ or specific problem areas. Stage 2 is a broad scale<br />
water sampling and analysis program to identify tributaries with elevated<br />
pollutant levels, and Stage 3 will further localise areas with elevated<br />
pollutant levels. The outcomes of Stage 1 are presented in this report.<br />
The consultation process carried out in December 1999 identified values that<br />
are common for all three catchments. Local residents see the value of the<br />
creek systems in terms of active and passive recreation, ecological<br />
requirements for biodiversity, commercial uses, and cultural and historical<br />
significance. A general feeling is held by the local residents that these<br />
values have been partially or completely lost as a result of numerous issues.<br />
These include degraded water quality, altered drainage patterns, sediment<br />
erosion, nuisance weed growth, increased presence of rubbish, plant debris<br />
and increased urban development.<br />
During the community consultation process, several approaches were put<br />
forward as to how the situation could be improved. These include<br />
revegetation of riparian zones, better controls on developments including<br />
application approvals and development site controls, increased community<br />
education and awareness, litter and debris removal and improved source<br />
controls.<br />
The field investigation carried out in early January 2000 confirmed many of<br />
the observations made in the community consultation process, identified<br />
issues that related to specific areas of the catchment and identified<br />
appropriate water quality sampling locations for Stage 2 of the survey.<br />
Page 3 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Contents<br />
1 Introduction 6<br />
1.1 Background 6<br />
1.2 The <strong>Survey</strong> 6<br />
Stage 1 6<br />
Stage 2 6<br />
Stage 3 6<br />
2 Stage 1 Approach 7<br />
3 Outcomes of Community Consultation 8<br />
3.1<br />
Kincumber Creek Catchment 8<br />
Catchment Values 8<br />
Catchment Issues 9<br />
Catchment ‘Hot Spots’ 10<br />
Community Vision for Kincumber Creek Catchment 11<br />
3.2<br />
Erina Creek Catchment 11<br />
Catchment Values 11<br />
Catchment Issues 12<br />
Catchment ‘Hot Spots’ 13<br />
Community Vision for Erina Creek Catchment 13<br />
3.3<br />
Narara Creek Catchment 14<br />
Catchment Values 14<br />
Catchment Issues 14<br />
Catchment ‘Hot Spots’ 15<br />
Community Vision for Narara Creek Catchment 17<br />
4 Outcomes of Field Investigation 18<br />
4.1 Kincumber Creek Catchment 18<br />
4.2 Erina Creek Catchment 19<br />
4.3 Narara Creek Catchment 19<br />
5 Community Consultation - Summary of Findings 21<br />
6 Recommendations for Stage 2 23<br />
7 Conclusions 27<br />
8 References 28<br />
Page 4 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
List of Tables<br />
Table 3.1: Values for Kincumber Creek catchment 8<br />
Table 3.2: Issues for Kincumber Creek catchment 9<br />
Table 3.3: Kincumber Catchment ‘hot spots’ location and problem 10<br />
Table 3.4: Values for Erina Creek catchment 11<br />
Table 3.5: Issues for Erina Creek catchment 12<br />
Table 3.6: Erina Catchment ‘hot spots’ location and problem 13<br />
Table 3.7: Values for Narara Creek catchment 14<br />
Table 3.8: Issues for Narara Creek catchment 15<br />
Table 3.9: Narara Creek catchment ‘hot spots’ location and problem 16<br />
Table 6.1: Stage 2 Kincumber Creek sampling locations and justifications 24<br />
Table 6.2: Stage 2 Erina Creek sampling locations and justifications 25<br />
Table 6.3: Stage 2 Narara Creek sampling locations and justifications 26<br />
List of Maps<br />
Map 6.1: Stage 2 Kincumber Creek water sampling locations 24<br />
Map 6.2: Stage 2 Erina Creek water sampling locations 25<br />
Map 6.3: Stage 2 Narara Creek water sampling locations 26<br />
Appendixes<br />
Appendix A Field Investigation Observations 29<br />
Page 5 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
1 Introduction<br />
1.1 Background<br />
Since 1996, <strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>City</strong> <strong>Council</strong> has been conducting a water quality<br />
monitoring program for Brisbane <strong>Water</strong>, its major tributaries and the coastal<br />
lagoons. Results from that program have shown degraded water quality in<br />
several of the major tributaries (Laxton 1999).<br />
In 1999, <strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>City</strong> <strong>Council</strong> commissioned AWT to carry out a water<br />
quality survey on three of those tributaries: Kincumber Creek, Erina Creek<br />
and Narara Creek. This was to aid in the identification of sources or causes<br />
of the degraded water, and to make recommendations to <strong>Council</strong> of ways of<br />
reducing the existing level of degradation.<br />
1.2 The <strong>Survey</strong><br />
The water quality survey initiated by <strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Council</strong> comprises three<br />
stages: a community consultation process and catchment investigation<br />
(Stage 1), a broad scale water sampling program (Stage 2) and a small scale<br />
sampling program (Stage 3).<br />
Stage 1<br />
Stage 1 of the survey was designed as an information gathering process to<br />
aid in the identification of the most appropriate water sampling sites for<br />
Stage 2 water quality assessment. In addition, the process was used to obtain<br />
views from local residents and stakeholder groups on catchment values and<br />
issues and to seek input into future management directions.<br />
This report details the outcomes of Stage 1 of the survey.<br />
Stage 2<br />
Stage 2 of the survey will be used to assess water quality at the base of<br />
several tributaries and drainage channels entering Kincumber, Narara and<br />
Erina creeks (sites identified in Stage 1). This stage will be used to identify<br />
those sub-catchments that contribute significantly to degraded water quality<br />
during dry and wet weather flow conditions. A report will be presented to<br />
<strong>Council</strong> with a list of sub-catchments recommended for investigation in<br />
Stage 3. Stage 3 will then assess these sub-catchments.<br />
Stage 3<br />
Stage 3 of the survey will be used to identify local sources and causes of<br />
degraded water quality within the catchments. The report prepared for this<br />
stage will also include recommendations on ways to progress the survey<br />
initiative.<br />
Page 6 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
2 Stage 1 Approach<br />
Stage 1 of the <strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> was carried out between<br />
December 1999 and January 2000. It was designed to inform the community<br />
about the study, to gauge views about the catchment held by local residents<br />
and to gain local knowledge of water quality issues and problem areas in the<br />
catchments. This information would then be used in the design of work<br />
carried out through the remainder of the survey.<br />
The first step in the process was the production of a brochure that was<br />
delivered to all residents within the three catchment areas (Kincumber, Erina<br />
and Narara creeks). In addition, the brochures were delivered to stakeholder<br />
groups including the Brisbane <strong>Water</strong> Catchment Management Committee.<br />
The brochure presented some background information on water quality<br />
issues and a map of the creek system within each of the catchments. The<br />
brochure also invited local residents to participate in the survey process by<br />
identifying problem areas on a map of their catchment area and returning<br />
them to <strong>Council</strong> or by attending a public meeting to discuss the issues.<br />
An open meeting hosted by AWT was held for each of the catchments.<br />
Dates and times for the meetings were advertised in the local newspaper. A<br />
meeting for the Kincumber Creek catchment was held at the Green Point<br />
Community Centre on 13/12/99, the Erina Creek catchment at the Erina<br />
Progress Hall on 14/12/99 and the Narara Creek catchment at Wyoming<br />
Community Centre on 16/12/99.<br />
The meetings involved an initial presentation by AWT providing<br />
background information on the survey, general information on water and<br />
stormwater quality issues and an introduction to an open discussion. The<br />
open discussions were centred around identifying the values that local<br />
residents placed on the creek system and the catchment, their issues relating<br />
to environmental qualities of the system, identification of problem areas<br />
within the catchment and determining how they would like to see the<br />
condition of their local catchment. The information gathered from this<br />
process is presented in Section 3 of this report.<br />
The above information was collated and summarised prior to a field<br />
investigation in early January 2000. The field investigation involved<br />
travelling around the catchments, viewing the problem areas and issues<br />
identified, assessing flow conditions in drainage channels within the<br />
catchments and identifying appropriate sites for the Stage 2 water quality<br />
assessment. The sites recommended and justification for the choice of these<br />
sites is presented in Section 6 of this report.<br />
Page 7 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
3 Outcomes of Community Consultation<br />
Attendances at the meetings were lower than expected, which may have<br />
been a result of the minimal lead in time from the mail out of the brochures<br />
or the timing of the meetings in relation to Christmas and school holidays.<br />
Five people attended the Kincumber meeting and 16 brochures were<br />
returned, eight people attended the Erina meeting and 15 brochures were<br />
returned, and twelve people attended the Narara meeting and 20 brochures<br />
were returned. Valuable information was obtained from those participants.<br />
To ensure an increased participation rate in any future public consultations, a<br />
longer lead in period will be required to allow notifications to be better<br />
circulated.<br />
3.1 Kincumber Creek Catchment<br />
Catchment Values<br />
Catchment values are seen by the community to give value to the catchment<br />
in terms of how the catchment is or was used and enjoyed by residents,<br />
visitors and its biota. The values identified in the Kincumber Creek<br />
community consultation have been grouped into several categories (Table<br />
3.1).<br />
Table 3.1: Values for Kincumber Creek catchment<br />
Category<br />
Cultural<br />
Passive Recreation<br />
Active Recreation<br />
Commercial<br />
Environment<br />
Description of Value<br />
• historical such as previous use of creek for<br />
boating<br />
• archaeological including aboriginal heritage<br />
sites, middens<br />
• provision of community focus and identity<br />
• educational uses (such as <strong>Water</strong> Watch and<br />
nature studies)<br />
• picnics, walking<br />
• scenic and landscape values<br />
• fishing<br />
• swimming<br />
• oyster farming<br />
• need for natural flows<br />
• water and land suitable to sustain<br />
biodiversity.<br />
Page 8 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Catchment Issues<br />
Catchment issues identified in the community consultation process included<br />
issues relating to water quality and loss of amenity. These issues are<br />
generalised problems that have lead to diminished value of the catchment<br />
and ultimately degraded quality of the waterways. The issues identified are<br />
categorised and summarised in Table 3.2.<br />
Table 3.2: Issues for Kincumber Creek catchment<br />
Category<br />
<strong>Water</strong> Quality<br />
<strong>Water</strong>ways<br />
Access<br />
Environment<br />
Description of Issue<br />
• loss of water clarity through erosion of<br />
unconsolidated particulates in the catchment<br />
• odours from sewage and other sources<br />
• slime on rocks through algal growth / excess<br />
nutrients<br />
• pathogens in the water from sewage and<br />
stormwater<br />
• gross pollutants in waterways and drainage<br />
channels including domestic and commercial<br />
litter and garden refuse. No Gross Pollutant<br />
Traps (GPTs) in catchment<br />
• stream and drainage channel flows changed<br />
through development and encroaching<br />
vegetation<br />
• erosion of unconsolidated areas in the<br />
catchment, no kerb and guttering or erosion<br />
control of areas such as unpaved driveways<br />
• build up of silt and sediment in stormwater<br />
drains, tributaries and the bay that has been<br />
washed from the catchment<br />
• closure of oyster leases following large<br />
rainfall events<br />
• loss of creek through changes in drainage<br />
patterns<br />
• loss of access through urban encroachment<br />
• closing up of creek from overgrown<br />
vegetation<br />
• depletion and loss of fish<br />
• loss of mussel beds in Kincumber<br />
Broadwater<br />
• loss of other biodiversity<br />
• health of seagrass beds in bay<br />
• clearing of vegetation by developers<br />
• large areas of impervious surfaces in medium<br />
density developments increase runoff<br />
volumes<br />
• vegetation encroachment and weeds<br />
Page 9 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Catchment ‘Hot Spots’<br />
The catchment hot spots are those areas identified by the local residents<br />
through the community meeting or returned brochures that have specific<br />
environmental problems. These are listed in Table 3.3.<br />
Table 3.3: Kincumber Catchment ‘hot spots’ location and problem<br />
Location<br />
<strong>Water</strong>front Kincumber<br />
Broadwater behind<br />
Kincumber Hotel<br />
Problem Description<br />
Loss of fish and crabs; slime and other pollution<br />
in water<br />
Entrance to creek Minimal tidal flushing resulting in mud buildup /<br />
siltation in bay, and excessive algal growth<br />
resulting in slimes on rock surfaces<br />
Southern Ocean Yachts<br />
boat ramp<br />
Creek and boat ramp<br />
opposite Kincumber boat<br />
building factories<br />
Upstream from boat ramp<br />
Lower Kincumber Creek<br />
Kincumber Creek d/s<br />
Empire Bay Drive<br />
End of Gunya Rd<br />
Kincumber Creek at<br />
Empire Bay Drive<br />
Frost Reserve<br />
Opposite industrial area<br />
(near Empire Bay Dr)<br />
Quarry<br />
Oberton St<br />
Tip<br />
Creek under footbridge<br />
between Kookaburra and<br />
Kingfisher Sts Kincumber<br />
Dundulla Rd stormwater<br />
pipes<br />
Opposite No 11 Booragal<br />
Wilky King St Sorowaga<br />
and Sun Valley Road<br />
Proposed golf course<br />
Odours noted and oily / greasy water observed<br />
Foul state, near sewerage plant, measured high<br />
faecal coliforms, dumped cars, fishkills,<br />
botulism in ducks, blames leak from sewerage<br />
plant<br />
Regular oily slick and rubbish with incoming<br />
tide especially when large boats moored<br />
Weed encroachment<br />
<strong>Water</strong> turns black<br />
Domestic litter and sediment buildup<br />
Visual pollution and domestic litter, question of<br />
culvert design in terms of fisheries regulations<br />
Previously a landfill site, possible contaminated<br />
leachate problem<br />
white film in drain water, possibly from concrete<br />
works<br />
Sediment transported from site into creek system<br />
Domestic litter and garden refuse in gutters<br />
Possible contaminated leachate<br />
Murky, dirty water, rubbish dumped<br />
Frothy scum observed<br />
Silt built up in open drain<br />
Run off from old drain<br />
Concern over effect on existing biological<br />
communities including various frog species<br />
Page 10 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Community Vision for Kincumber Creek Catchment<br />
Through the community meeting, a vision for the desired future of<br />
Kincumber Creek was developed. In essence, this vision is to halt<br />
degradation of water quality and work towards restoring the qualities of the<br />
creek system. The specific objectives leading towards realisation of this<br />
vision are:<br />
• to remove gross pollutants including domestic and commercial litter<br />
and garden refuse from drainage channels<br />
• to improve water quality to a level suitable for primary contact<br />
activities (eg swimming and wading) and to sustain a diverse range<br />
of aquatic life<br />
• to restore riparian vegetation zones to reduce erosion, sedimentation,<br />
nutrient inputs and aid in restoration of natural stream flows<br />
• to halt development proximate to the creek<br />
• to encourage and educate the community with a sense of stewardship<br />
over the creek<br />
• to better enforce existing by-laws and legislation relating to pollution<br />
of waterways<br />
• to restore creek access to the public.<br />
3.2 Erina Creek Catchment<br />
Catchment Values<br />
The values identified in the Erina Creek community consultation have been<br />
grouped into several categories shown in Table 3.4:<br />
Table 3.4: Values for Erina Creek catchment<br />
Category<br />
Cultural<br />
Passive Recreation<br />
Active Recreation<br />
Commercial<br />
Environment<br />
• historical<br />
Description of Value<br />
• knowing it’s there to be used and enjoyed<br />
• scenic and landscape values<br />
• fishing<br />
• boating<br />
• swimming<br />
• oyster farming<br />
• water extraction for irrigation, watering<br />
purposes<br />
• need for natural flows<br />
• water and land suitable to sustain<br />
biodiversity.<br />
Page 11 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Catchment Issues<br />
The catchment issues identified for the Erina Creek catchment are<br />
categorised and summarised in Table 3.5.<br />
Table 3.5: Issues for Erina Creek catchment<br />
Category<br />
<strong>Water</strong> Quality<br />
<strong>Water</strong>ways<br />
Behaviour<br />
Description of Issue<br />
• loss of water clarity through erosion of<br />
unconsolidated particulates in the catchment<br />
• contamination of water from septic overflows<br />
• pollution of waterways and drainage channels<br />
through litter including plastic bags, odours<br />
from sewage and other sources<br />
• stagnation of water & mosquito infestation<br />
• stream and drainage channel flows changed<br />
through development and encroaching<br />
vegetation<br />
• flooding<br />
• build up of silt and sediment in stormwater<br />
drains, tributaries and the bay that has been<br />
washed from the catchment<br />
• inappropriate boating, speed indication signs<br />
not obeyed, wash from boats eroding banks<br />
• lack of communication and coordination<br />
between agencies<br />
• illegal dumping in tributaries<br />
Environment<br />
Urban management<br />
• depletion and loss of fish and other aquatic<br />
species including seagrasses<br />
• excessive weed growth along river bank<br />
resulting in reduced creek access and choking<br />
the creek<br />
• loss of native aquatic plant species<br />
• litter in gutters from lack of street sweeping<br />
• over-development<br />
• impervious surfaces in medium density<br />
developments<br />
• lack of sediment control on building sites<br />
• increased traffic and resulting pollutants in<br />
street runoff<br />
• lack of controls on industry, including home<br />
industry<br />
• need for controls on properties with animals<br />
and stock<br />
• lack of kerb and guttering<br />
• insufficient maintenance of stormwater drains<br />
Page 12 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Catchment ‘Hot Spots’<br />
‘Hot spots’ identified through the community consultation process in the<br />
Erina Creek catchment are listed in Table 3.6.<br />
Table 3.6: Erina Catchment ‘hot spots’ location and problem<br />
Nunns Creek<br />
Location<br />
Worthing Creek<br />
Bank erosion<br />
Generally polluted<br />
Problem Description<br />
Sarah Rd Flow restricted through weed growth and<br />
siltation. Foul odour and murky water noted<br />
Yerin Bridge<br />
Reserve at Lingi St<br />
Matcham Valley headwaters<br />
Industrial areas<br />
Karalta Rd<br />
Erina Creek at the Entrance<br />
Rd<br />
tributary leading towards<br />
Bradys Gully Rd<br />
Vandalism and dumping of rubbish including<br />
shopping trolleys and domestic rubbish. Foul<br />
odours also noted<br />
Rubbish dumping<br />
Community Vision for Erina Creek Catchment<br />
Flooding and siltation from flow restricting<br />
culverts. Concern over water extraction for stock<br />
watering. Odour and creek choking by weed<br />
infestation also noted<br />
Quality and quantity of runoff from impervious<br />
industrial areas<br />
Concern over quality of runoff from development<br />
areas<br />
Car in creek, surrounding areas clogged with<br />
dumped refuse (cars, washing machines, asbestos<br />
waste etc)<br />
Oily film on water; rubbish; spillage from BFI<br />
bins near stormwater drains weeds and lack of<br />
environmental management, illegal agistment of<br />
horses cnr Springfield Rd<br />
The vision put forward by the Erina Creek catchment community is to see no<br />
further degradation of stream flows and water quality; to restore the creek to<br />
its pre-development depth; and to increase the width of the riparian zone. To<br />
realise this vision, the following actions were put forward by the local<br />
community:<br />
• change development controls so that development applications are<br />
required to demonstrate that no further stress will be added to the<br />
hydrology of the catchment<br />
• encourage Bushcare and other community groups to instigate projects<br />
for restoring riparian vegetation zones. Support flow-on effects of<br />
revegetation projects to initiate projects for restoring creeks to more<br />
natural systems<br />
• better communication and co-ordination between environmental and<br />
community groups to better utilise available funds and resources.<br />
Page 13 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
3.3 Narara Creek Catchment<br />
Catchment Values<br />
The values identified in the Narara Creek community consultation have been<br />
grouped into several categories (Table 3.7).<br />
Table 3.7: Values for Narara Creek catchment<br />
Category<br />
Cultural<br />
Passive Recreation<br />
Active Recreation<br />
Commercial<br />
Environment<br />
• historical<br />
Description of Value<br />
• educational potential for community and<br />
school groups<br />
• sense of ownership and community identity<br />
for the creek environment<br />
• scenic and landscape values<br />
• bird watching<br />
• peaceful quiet area<br />
• fishing<br />
• children playing<br />
• boating<br />
• water extraction for irrigation, other watering<br />
purposes<br />
• need for natural flows<br />
• major flood water drainage channel<br />
• habitat for various species<br />
• water and land suitable to sustain<br />
biodiversity.<br />
Catchment Issues<br />
The catchment issues identified for the Narara Creek catchment are<br />
categorised and summarised in Table 3.8.<br />
Page 14 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Table 3.8: Issues for Narara Creek catchment<br />
Category<br />
<strong>Water</strong> Quality<br />
Description of Issue<br />
• pollution of waterways in wet weather from<br />
runoff from industrial sites<br />
• poor quality of road runoff<br />
• loss of water clarity through erosion of<br />
unconsolidated particulates in the catchment<br />
• pollution of waterways and drainage channels<br />
through litter, including plastic bags<br />
<strong>Water</strong>ways<br />
Access<br />
Behaviour<br />
Environment<br />
• stream and drainage channel flows changed<br />
through development and encroaching<br />
vegetation<br />
• build up of silt and sediment in stormwater<br />
drains, tributaries and the bay that has been<br />
washed from the catchment<br />
– lack of<br />
sediment traps / controls<br />
• Loss of access to creek<br />
• need for further education eg signage about<br />
catchment management issues<br />
• lack of response by <strong>Council</strong> to complaints by<br />
residents<br />
• effect of poor water quality (litter, oil etc) on<br />
mangrove communities<br />
• deterioration of environment through<br />
development cycle<br />
Urban management • litter in gutters and many drainage channels /<br />
creeks – lack of street sweeping<br />
• over-development and encroachment of<br />
development on creek<br />
• lack of strategic direction in catchment<br />
development<br />
• concern over Chamberlain Rd development,<br />
Reptile Park and other developments so close<br />
to creek. Call for more stringent controls on<br />
development<br />
• concern over old garbage dumps / landfill<br />
sites and potential for new one. Question of<br />
proposed landfill at Niagara Park.<br />
• Lack of enforcement of environmental<br />
legislation<br />
Catchment ‘Hot Spots’<br />
‘Hot spots’ identified through the community consultation process in the<br />
Narara Creek catchment are listed in Table 3.9.<br />
Page 15 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Table 3.9: Narara Creek catchment ‘hot spots’ location and problem<br />
Location<br />
Minor tributary in upper catchment,<br />
adjacent to Haggerty Drive<br />
Wingello Creek – dissected oxbow<br />
bend between the Pacific Highway<br />
and the railway, “no man’s land”<br />
Taylor Road and Pacific Highway;<br />
Chamberlain Road<br />
Saw mill next to Pacific Highway,<br />
near train station, upper catchment<br />
Drainage line between Goonak and<br />
Karina Streets, middle catchment<br />
Mann Street where Brady’s Gully<br />
passes under the railway line, near<br />
Ahora Road.<br />
Between tennis courts and high<br />
school, between Faunce Street and<br />
Racecourse Road<br />
Creek between Yandina and Nell’s<br />
Road also one near Merinee Road.<br />
Old railway dam in upper, western<br />
catchment<br />
Drainage line north of Grieve Road<br />
down from Debenham Road.<br />
Wingello Creek near Turpentine Rd<br />
Small St & Darryl Rd<br />
Problem Description<br />
Reports of general pollution, weed growth,<br />
development in area – sediment, etc<br />
Potential for reserve, some remnant vegetation. Used<br />
to be a dairy, plans to extend road along edge, acts as<br />
flood basin<br />
Lisarow Wetlands threatened by sediment in runoff<br />
from new developments. No protection from pollution.<br />
Reports of discharge of large volumes of wastewater<br />
from saw mill site into adjacent creek line.<br />
Reports of Streamwatch monitoring showing low<br />
oxygen and high turbidity. Highly degraded.<br />
Fruit shop – containers, rubbish is spread around by<br />
youths.<br />
Old creosote tank that was used by Electricity<br />
Company. Surrounded with bund with drainage outlet<br />
in it – discharging to adjacent creek. Residents showed<br />
photos of site, said approximately 8 years ago last seen.<br />
Is it still there or has the site been remediated?<br />
Downstream of industrial area, cement plant.<br />
Reports of rubbish, needles especially.<br />
risk.<br />
Polluted<br />
Poses health<br />
Weeds, litter including shopping trolleys, yellow &<br />
oily in dry weather.<br />
Gutters clogged with leaf and domestic litter<br />
Creek along Chamberlain Rd General pollution, stagnant water, overgrown,<br />
mosquitoes<br />
Industrial development at Manns<br />
Rd near Dell Rd<br />
Creek along Warrawilla Rd<br />
Pecan Close Reserve<br />
Wingello Creek between Jarrett St<br />
& Maidens Brush Rd<br />
Bradys Gully into Narara creek –<br />
Cary Rd to Henry Parry Dr<br />
Around 37-39 Hanlan St<br />
Reeves St<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> High School, Showground<br />
Rd<br />
Discoloured water<br />
General pollution and noxious weed growth<br />
Noxious weeds and concern over fire hazard and poor<br />
stream flows<br />
Weeds and domestic litter<br />
Overgrown with trees<br />
Erosion of top soil and odours from animals on<br />
property<br />
Erosion of unsealed road<br />
Blocked drains with leaves and domestic litter<br />
Page 16 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Location<br />
<strong>Water</strong>way in Allan Davidson Park<br />
Day St/Allan Davidson oval<br />
Day St Wyoming<br />
Narara Creek and tributaries from<br />
Carrington St/Deanne Road area<br />
Problem Description<br />
Branches, bins and other refuse dumped near the foot<br />
crossing<br />
oily film and orange/brown slime<br />
concrete channel under Day St: west side has much<br />
rubbish; east side is overgrown impeding flows and<br />
causing stagnation<br />
dumping of rubbish and contents of clothing charity<br />
bins. Oily residue on water. Rusty coloured water.<br />
112 Newling St, Lisarow adjacent stormwater creek choked with weeds, much<br />
rubbish, rat infested<br />
Narara Creek near Manns Rd<br />
Wingello Creek, behind<br />
old<br />
Wyoming Hospital and alongside<br />
The Willows<br />
frequent sightings of debris, cardboard boxes<br />
silted up, many exotic plants growing<br />
Community Vision for Narara Creek Catchment<br />
The vision put forward by the Narara Creek catchment community is to see<br />
an increased awareness by the general community of the values of the creeks<br />
and waterways, which will lead to improved practices and improved<br />
condition of the catchment. To realise this vision, the following actions<br />
were put forward by the local community:<br />
• encourage groups such as Streamwatch and “adopt-a-creek” and other<br />
schemes for involving the community such as the environmental<br />
competitions between schools run by Wyong <strong>Council</strong>, and establishing<br />
groups such as ‘Friends of Narara Creek’<br />
• increased resourcing in <strong>Council</strong> to enforce environmental legislation<br />
• increased environmental education for school groups, general public<br />
and property developers<br />
• initiate source control measures for litter and other pollutants<br />
• use Internet to disseminate information to public. Already established<br />
for Wingello Creek<br />
Page 17 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
4 Outcomes of Field Investigation<br />
A field investigation was undertaken of the Kincumber, Erina and Narara<br />
creek catchments on 11-12/1/2000 during a period of light rainfall that<br />
resulted in a small increase in runoff from dry weather flow conditions.<br />
Observations made during the investigation are presented in Appendix A.<br />
‘Hot spots’ identified through the community consultation process were<br />
visited and an overview of the catchment was made.<br />
Although areas in the catchment were found to have specific issues (refer to<br />
Appendix A), a number of general observations were made that were<br />
pertinent to much of the catchment.<br />
4.1 Kincumber Creek Catchment<br />
The Kincumber Creek catchment has been largely developed with few<br />
potential development areas remaining. In the northern catchment area,<br />
residential and low-lying bushland areas border the estuarine section of the<br />
creek. The creek discharges into Kincumber (Cockle) Broadwater with<br />
fringing mangroves and mud banks around the bay and along the lower<br />
creek. Large amounts of rubbish were found along the bay foreshore and in<br />
the lower creek and the bushland areas were overgrown with weeds<br />
including lantana.<br />
Several small tributaries drain the north of the catchment, which includes a<br />
small shopping centre, new retirement villages and new and established<br />
housing. Bordering the developed areas is bushland that extends to the top<br />
of the catchment. The edge of the bushland was found to have extensive<br />
weed growth. Issues relating to runoff from this area include potentially<br />
elevated nutrient levels from gardens, contaminated street runoff and litter.<br />
Flow observed in the tributaries was discoloured but the appearance<br />
suggested the discolouration may have been due mostly to fine particulates<br />
possibly accumulated on impervious surfaces rather than eroded sediment<br />
from the small areas of unconsolidated surfaces.<br />
Along the south of the estuarine section of the creek, several industries may<br />
have an impact on the creek if effective on-site runoff controls are not in<br />
place. The potential impact is from a variety of chemicals used in the<br />
various industries.<br />
Where Empire Bay Dr crosses Kincumber St, the stormwater system<br />
effectively acts as a weir, halting further upstream tidal flows. Extensive<br />
weed growth was also observed throughout the area. Numerous signs are in<br />
place stating a revegetation scheme is in progress however there is little<br />
evidence of any progress in the area.<br />
Further to the south, the creek drains a low lying area that has little or no dry<br />
weather flow. The tributary to the south is below ground until immediately<br />
downstream of Empire Bay Drive. From the topography in this area, it<br />
appears that the sewage treatment plant (STP) located to the south of<br />
Kincumber Creek would have little direct impact on the tributary. The major<br />
issue with the STP would therefore be odours or any exfiltration / overflows<br />
from the sewerage system leading to the STP.<br />
Page 18 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
The great majority of the eastern catchment has been recently developed into<br />
residential areas. Some small areas are still under development but the<br />
majority of the area appears to be established with few areas of unpaved or<br />
non-vegetated areas. In the area, a large amount of plant debris was<br />
observed along with a moderate amount of litter in the drainage channels,<br />
particularly roadside drains. A small area of bushland was observed in the<br />
upper catchment containing substantial weed areas. The major runoff issues<br />
for this area would therefore be nutrient levels, the quality of road runoff and<br />
gross pollutants (rubbish, plant debris).<br />
Kincumber Rubbish Tip is located in the far east of the catchment. There is<br />
potential for leachate and sediment erosion problems associated with this<br />
area if effective on-site controls are not in place. The water downstream<br />
from the tip was observed to be discoloured although the appearance was not<br />
of eroded sandy sediments.<br />
4.2 Erina Creek Catchment<br />
Erina Creek catchment comprises a relatively small developed area in the<br />
lower catchment with large rural and semi-rural areas in the remainder of the<br />
catchment. Along the western side of the creek, new developments are<br />
under construction or have been recently completed. Small drainage<br />
channels and tributaries pass through these developments with some water<br />
quality control measures such as detention ponds evident downstream of the<br />
developments. Areas of development and unpaved or non-vegetated areas<br />
may be contributing substantial quantities of sediment to Erina Creek.<br />
In the south-east of the catchment, there is an area of new and established<br />
housing and a commercial zone along The Entrance Rd. With the exception<br />
of household gardens, this area is comprised largely of impervious surfaces<br />
that will lead to a large proportion of rainfall being converted to runoff. This<br />
increases the flow into Erina Creek substantially and has led to some bank<br />
erosion in tributaries such as Nunns Creek. The relatively high density of<br />
urban activities in the area has also resulted in a problem with domestic<br />
rubbish entering many of the drainage channels, ultimately being washed<br />
into Erina Creek and found along high tide lines.<br />
The majority of the developed area of the catchment discharges directly to<br />
the estuarine section of Erina Creek and so much of the impact made on the<br />
waterway will not be measured in the creek’s tributaries.<br />
In the upper catchment, rural and semi-rural properties cover the great<br />
majority of the area. Along the creek, weeds including lantana were found<br />
although generally not as dense as they were in the Narara Creek catchment.<br />
Reeds and grasses were found in many sections of the tributaries. The<br />
vegetation appeared to have a restricting effect on the flow. Ponded sections<br />
in rural areas were often densely vegetated.<br />
4.3 Narara Creek Catchment<br />
The catchment area to the west of Narara Creek, extending into the bushland<br />
areas to the plateau, was found to contain large amounts of domestic rubbish.<br />
Cleared areas away from main roads were found to be prime dumping<br />
grounds for large domestic goods including cars, white goods and furniture.<br />
Smaller rubbish (plastic bags, bottles, wrappers, plant debris etc) was found<br />
in the great majority of drainage channels, particularly roadside drains<br />
Page 19 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
throughout the western catchment and into the estuarine section of Narara<br />
Creek.<br />
Large areas of unconsolidated surfaces were also found in the western<br />
catchment area, particularly unsealed roads, driveways and cleared, nonvegetated<br />
areas resulting in large amounts of sediments being eroded from<br />
the catchment. These sediments were found deposited in numerous points<br />
along the drainage channels causing flow restriction and ponding during low<br />
flow conditions. These conditions can lead to mosquito infestation and the<br />
creation of an anaerobic environment with unpleasant odours. During high<br />
flow conditions, these sediments are removed from the drainage channels to<br />
be deposited in the estuarine section of Narara Creek or in Brisbane <strong>Water</strong><br />
leading to a shallowing of the waterway.<br />
Another major issue in the western Narara Creek catchment and the upper<br />
catchment tributaries was the presence of large numbers of weeds in the<br />
riparian zone. At the majority of creek access points, the creek was<br />
overgrown with various weeds including lantana and vines. These weeds, in<br />
conjunction with the sediment deposited in the creek, have led to a choking<br />
of the creek system with restricted flows in many drainage lines through the<br />
western catchment. The weed growth has also resulted in restricted access to<br />
the creek in those areas that have not been used for residential or commercial<br />
developments.<br />
In the lower western catchment, numerous industries are located along<br />
Manns Rd, adjacent to the estuarine section of Narara Creek. The area<br />
contains industries such as motor repairs, garden supplies and scrap metal.<br />
There is the potential for contaminated runoff from these sites discharging<br />
directly into the estuarine section of Narara Creek if effective on-site runoff<br />
controls are not in place.<br />
The eastern Narara Creek catchment is largely a residential / light<br />
commercial area with fringing bushland in the steeper sloping areas of the<br />
catchment. In the upper catchment there are some industries along the<br />
railway line, including scrap metal industries, which may again lead to<br />
contaminated runoff without effective on-site controls. A major issue for<br />
this part of the catchment is runoff from the developed areas including<br />
nutrient runoff from properties, zinc from old roofs and hydrocarbons / lead<br />
from road runoff.<br />
Wingello and Wyoming creeks also have flow restriction issues through<br />
vegetation in the creeks although there is generally less weed growth along<br />
the creek banks than other parts of the catchment. This has allowed creek<br />
access in some areas. Litter is also less of a problem in the eastern<br />
catchment.<br />
Page 20 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
5 Community Consultation - Summary of Findings<br />
The community consultation process has shown that the local residents from<br />
the three different catchments share many common views about their local<br />
environment. Residents see the value of the creek systems as recreational<br />
areas to be enjoyed both actively and passively. They see value in a<br />
commercial sense through provision of water from the creeks to rural<br />
properties and as the basis of aquaculture industries such as oyster farming<br />
and fishing. They see the value to the environment as providing a habitat for<br />
a diverse range of terrestrial and aquatic species of plants and animals.<br />
Finally, there is a sense of community around the creek systems with the<br />
value of knowing the creeks are there and knowing how the creeks have<br />
been used in the past, before European settlement and in more recent times.<br />
There is however a great sense of loss over the current condition of the<br />
creeks and their catchments. The general perception is held that, with<br />
increasing urbanisation, the quality of the catchment environment has<br />
steadily declined and the creek system has become degraded. There are<br />
common concerns over issues including:<br />
• erosion of the catchment, in particular development sites, with the<br />
eroded sediments reducing the clarity of the waterways, clogging the<br />
drainage channels and ultimately filling in the receiving bays,<br />
• urban developments encroaching on the creek resulting in reduced<br />
access and less opportunity to enjoy the creek,<br />
• contamination of water through leaking, overflowing sewage or septic<br />
systems and contaminated runoff from home and industrial sites,<br />
• choking of the creek system through uncontrolled growth of noxious<br />
weeds,<br />
• poor litter controls with the creeks and drainage channels often<br />
becoming a dumping ground from domestic and commercial litter,<br />
garden refuse and other gross pollutants. This also has the effect of<br />
reducing the aesthetic qualities of the catchment,<br />
• disturbances to the natural flow regime of the catchment by weirs,<br />
inadequate culverts, weed infestation and siltation<br />
• perceived inadequate controls of new developments,<br />
• insufficient resources to enforce existing environmental legislation<br />
• the negative effects of all of these factors on biodiversity and the<br />
ecosystem.<br />
Numerous suggestions were put forward by residents as to means of<br />
combating these problems, however, they can generally be reduced to<br />
several actions. They are:<br />
• to better educate landholders (industrial and residential) about<br />
environmental issues. In particular, the processes and effects involved<br />
with rainfall, runoff and other discharges from there properties into the<br />
drainage / creek system. This in turn should lead to processes of<br />
encouraging on-site control of potential pollution sources;<br />
Page 21 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
• to encourage and fund Bushcare and other community groups to actively<br />
promote removal of noxious weeds and revegetation of the catchment, in<br />
particular riparian zones, with appropriate native species. Also to<br />
encourage a sense of stewardship by the community over the creeks;<br />
• to have and enforce strict controls on new developments, halting any<br />
further encroachment of buildings on creeks, and begin to restore public<br />
access to the creek;<br />
• to improve the level of resources available to enforce existing<br />
environmental legislation eg controlling sediment runoff from<br />
construction sites, prosecuting polluters;<br />
• to improve communications between environmental groups to ensure<br />
effective use of resources and also to better communicate information to<br />
the general public; and<br />
• to generally work towards improving the environmental condition of the<br />
catchment.<br />
Finally, there is a feeling among those who participated in the meetings that<br />
there is a need to communicate the results of these studies back to the public<br />
to increase awareness. This may be done in the form of further consultations<br />
or presentations, mail outs or public displays.<br />
Page 22 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
6 Recommendations for Stage 2<br />
This water quality survey was initiated to identify potential sources of poor<br />
water quality in three catchments in the <strong>Gosford</strong> area. The community<br />
consultation and field investigation process has shown that in these<br />
catchments, perception of the quality of the creek environment is not limited<br />
to bacteria and nutrient contents in the water. There are many issues that<br />
affect the quality of the catchment including the presence of domestic litter,<br />
dumped rubbish throughout the catchment, restricted creek access, excess<br />
weed growth in and around the drainage channels, sediment erosion and<br />
chemical quality of the water.<br />
During Stage 2 of the survey, water samples will be collected to identify<br />
major tributaries and catchments that have water quality issues relating to the<br />
parameters measured (nutrients, bacteria and physical parameters). In<br />
designing the sampling program for Stage 2 of the survey, consideration<br />
must be made of whether the data can aid in dealing with the issues<br />
identified during Stage 1. For example, monitoring nutrients or bacteria in<br />
the catchment to the west of the estuarine section of Narara Creek may not<br />
identify any problems associated with chemical discharges from industries<br />
along Manns Rd, nor will it provide further information on the rubbish or<br />
weed issues in the area. However, in the residential areas of the Erina and<br />
Kincumber creek catchments, assessment of nutrient and bacteria levels may<br />
provide an indication of areas with sewerage system exfiltration or active<br />
overflows.<br />
The following recommendations for Stage 2 sampling locations are therefore<br />
limited to areas where the data collected may be used effectively in any<br />
future approaches to improving water quality. Recommended Stage 2<br />
sampling locations and justifications for their choices are presented in Table<br />
6.1, Table 6.2 and Table 6.3 and Map 6.1, Map 6.2 and Map 6.3.<br />
For the remaining areas of the catchment, and for issues not necessarily<br />
related to water quality, it is recommended that a strategy incorporating a<br />
total catchment management approach be initiated. This would address<br />
issues on a broader basis than only those issues relating to water quality.<br />
The first step in such an initiative would be a comprehensive audit to<br />
produce an inventory of environmental issues or problems in the catchments.<br />
This would be followed by an integrated series of responses to the issues<br />
identified in the audit and in the current survey. In order for responses to<br />
make a difference to environmental qualities, a well communicated and<br />
holistic approach will be required with sufficient enthusiasm and funding<br />
needed to see the initiative through.<br />
Page 23 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Table 6.1: Stage 2 Kincumber Creek sampling locations and justifications<br />
Kincumber Creek Catchment<br />
Sampling Location<br />
Corner of Wallen and <strong>Water</strong> St<br />
(KC1)<br />
Corner of Wallen and <strong>Water</strong> St<br />
(KC2)<br />
Tributary crossing Empire Bay Dr<br />
south of Bridge St (near bus depot)<br />
(KC3)<br />
Tributary entering Kincumber Creek<br />
at end of Davies St (KC4)<br />
Justification<br />
Asses water quality in upper Kincumber Creek<br />
catchment – drains residential areas and Kincumber<br />
tip<br />
Assess water quality in tributary draining residential<br />
areas in eastern catchment<br />
Assess water quality in tributary draining low-lying<br />
areas in southern catchment.<br />
Assess water quality in established and newly<br />
developed residential areas (sampling upstream of<br />
tidal influence)<br />
D Derby St<br />
KINCUMBER<br />
Avoca Dr<br />
Avoca Dr<br />
O Oberton St<br />
Kincumber<br />
Broadwater<br />
KC4<br />
K Kincumber C Creek<br />
Cullens Rd<br />
KC2<br />
KC1<br />
0 0.25<br />
Kilometres<br />
0.5<br />
Empire Bay Dr<br />
KC3<br />
Swamp St<br />
Melville M St<br />
Boundary Rd<br />
∗<br />
Abundance St<br />
The Scenic Rd<br />
BENSVILLE<br />
• KC1<br />
Sampling locations<br />
Map 6.1: Stage 2 Kincumber Creek water sampling locations<br />
Page 24 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Table 6.2: Stage 2 Erina Creek sampling locations and justifications<br />
Erina Creek Catchment Sampling<br />
Location<br />
Tributary crossing Chetwynd Rd<br />
(EC1)<br />
Tributary crossing Carlton Rd at<br />
entrance to Gooriwa Rd (EC2)<br />
Tributary crossing Wattle Tree Rd at<br />
“Girraween” (EC3)<br />
Tributary crossing Milina Rd east of<br />
Wattle Tree St (EC4)<br />
Tributary crossing Oak Rd 100 m<br />
north of Coachwood Rd (EC5)<br />
Tributary crossing Oak Rd at Max’s<br />
Lane (EC6)<br />
Nunns Creek at The Entrance Rd<br />
(EC7)<br />
Justification<br />
Assess water quality in Worthing Creek catchment –<br />
garden industries, unsealed road areas, undeveloped<br />
areas<br />
Assess water quality in small tributary leading into<br />
western catchment – semi rural area with ponding<br />
upstream and bushland at the top of the catchment<br />
Assess water quality in rural and bushland areas in<br />
Fires Creek catchment<br />
Assess water quality at base of rural areas<br />
Assess water quality of rural areas in upper Erina<br />
Creek catchment<br />
Assess water quality in rural and bushland areas<br />
along Oak Rd<br />
Assess water quality in residential and commercial<br />
areas of Nunns Creek catchment<br />
The Ridgeway<br />
HOLGATE<br />
EC3<br />
Wattle Wattle Tree Tree Rd<br />
∗<br />
Toomeys Toomeys Toomeys Toomeys Toomeys Toomeys Toomeys Toomeys ToomeysRd<br />
Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd<br />
Bandalong Rd<br />
Fire Creek<br />
EC6<br />
Oak Rd<br />
Matcham Rd<br />
Erina Erina Erina Erina Creek<br />
Creek Creek<br />
Creek<br />
EC5<br />
Coachwood Rd<br />
MATCHAM<br />
Bradys Gully Rd<br />
Gooriwa Rd<br />
EC2<br />
EC4<br />
Erina Erina Erina Erina Erina Erina Erina Erina ErinaCreek<br />
Creek Creek Creek Creek Creek Creek Creek Creek<br />
The Entrance Rd<br />
Milina Rd<br />
WAMBERAL<br />
Lakala Ave<br />
EC1<br />
ERINA<br />
EC7<br />
Terrigal Dr<br />
TERRIGAL<br />
0 0.5 1<br />
Nunns Creek<br />
Kilometres<br />
• EC1<br />
Sampling locations<br />
Map 6.2: Stage 2 Erina Creek water sampling locations<br />
Page 25 of 33
Rd d<br />
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Table 6.3: Stage 2 Narara Creek sampling locations and justifications<br />
Narara Creek Catchment<br />
Sampling Location<br />
Tributary crossing Carrington St,<br />
100 m west of Hanlon St (NC1)<br />
Tributary crossing Hanlon Rd,<br />
approximately 50 m north of<br />
Fountains Rd (NC2)<br />
Tributary adjacent to Konaderie Pde<br />
opposite Yarunga Ave (NC3)<br />
Tributary at end of Glencoe Ave<br />
(NC4)<br />
Tributary opposite Wyoming<br />
shopping centre (Kinarra Ave)<br />
(NC5)<br />
Tributary at corner of Mann St and<br />
Laycock St (NC6)<br />
Justification<br />
Assess water quality in Fountain Creek catchment –<br />
residential and bushland area<br />
Assess water quality in upper Narara<br />
catchment - residential and bushland area<br />
Creek<br />
Assess water quality in upper catchment – residential<br />
and bushland area. Limited flows upstream of this<br />
point in dry weather<br />
Assess water quality in Wyoming Creek catchment –<br />
residential and bushland area<br />
Assess water quality in Wingello Creek catchment –<br />
residential and bushland area<br />
Assess water quality in Bradys Gully catchment –<br />
residential and bushland area<br />
Man Mangrove Mangrove Rd Rd Rd Rd<br />
NIAGARA<br />
PARK<br />
angrove Rd<br />
ngrove Rd<br />
ve Rd<br />
Pacific Hwy<br />
Deanne Rd<br />
NC2<br />
NC3<br />
NARARA<br />
Wyoming Wyoming Wyoming Wyoming Wyoming Wyoming Wyoming Wyoming WyomingCreek<br />
Creek Creek Creek Creek Creek Creek Creek Creek<br />
Cham berlain Rd<br />
0 0.5 1<br />
Kilometres<br />
∗<br />
Narara Creek<br />
Carrington St<br />
Manns Rd<br />
NC1<br />
NC4<br />
NC5<br />
NC6<br />
Jarrett St<br />
Day St<br />
WYOMING<br />
Maidens Brush Rd<br />
Coulter Rd<br />
Bradys Gully Rd<br />
W Wingello Creek<br />
Toomeys Toomeys Toom Toomeys Toomeys Toomeys Rd Rd<br />
GOSFORD<br />
Debenham Debenham Debenham Debenham Debenham Debenham Debenham Debenham Debenham Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd Rd<br />
Pacific Hwy<br />
• NC1<br />
Sampling locations<br />
Map 6.3: Stage 2 Narara Creek water sampling locations<br />
Page 26 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
7 Conclusions<br />
The community consultation process and field investigations have shown<br />
that there are numerous issues affecting the quality of the three catchments<br />
investigated, and numerous values held by the residents for their local<br />
catchment. A general feeling was found to be held by the community that<br />
the catchments are degraded although the nature of the degradation varies<br />
from area to area.<br />
Weed growth and rubbish dumping were major issues in many parts of the<br />
three catchments. Excessive weed growth has also resulted in poor access to<br />
the creek in areas that have not been developed. Urban development and<br />
encroachment were found to concern many people with development<br />
resulting in reduced creek access, domestic litter in drainage channels,<br />
degraded water quality, bank erosion and sediment deposition. Alterations<br />
to natural drainage were also a concern in terms of increased stormwater<br />
runoff from highly developed areas, restrictions in creek flows through weed<br />
infestation and sediment deposition, and increased potential for flooding in<br />
some areas.<br />
The effect of development and the general degradation of the catchment<br />
were also of concern in terms of the effects on ecological health both within<br />
the creek system and in downstream water bodies.<br />
The general feeling is held that many of the creek systems’ values have been<br />
lost with increased development. There has been a general drop in<br />
opportunities to enjoy activities such as fishing, swimming, walking and<br />
boating with the increased level of development in recent years.<br />
A desire to see improvements in the quality of the creeks and their<br />
catchments was seen throughout the community consultation process. The<br />
approaches put forward to achieve these improvements were generally<br />
consistent through the three catchments. In general terms, the desired<br />
approach includes revegetation of riparian vegetation zones, improved<br />
controls on developments, increased community education and awareness,<br />
litter and debris removal and improved source controls. From local<br />
advertising and the State of the Environment Report (<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>City</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
1998), it is understood that policies are in place for such issues as sediment<br />
removal from development sites, and programs for riparian revegetation are<br />
also in place. However, little evidence exists throughout the catchment to<br />
show that these programs and policies are being carried out.<br />
The design for the Stage 2 sampling program addresses some of the issues<br />
raised in Stage 1, principally issues relating to water quality in urban and<br />
rural catchments. The program will identify those catchments that have<br />
elevated levels of a range of pollutants, however, a number of issues remain<br />
which need to be addressed in the development of any catchment<br />
management and improvement program<br />
Page 27 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
8 References<br />
Laxton, J.H. (1999) <strong>Water</strong> Quality of <strong>Gosford</strong> Lagoons and Brisbane <strong>Water</strong><br />
(1996-1998). J.H. & E.S. Laxton – Environmental Consultants P/L<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>City</strong> <strong>Council</strong> (1998) State of the Environment Report 1998.<br />
Page 28 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Appendix A<br />
Field Investigation Observations<br />
Page 29 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Table A1: Kincumber Creek Field Observations<br />
Location<br />
Kincumber Creek at Empire<br />
Bay Dr<br />
Entrance to Kincumber Creek<br />
• Creek very turbid<br />
Observation<br />
• Clear of vegetation in channel but very muddy<br />
downstream of road<br />
• Riparian zone and adjacent reserve overgrown with<br />
weeds (blackberry / lantana etc)<br />
• Signs in place for revegetation project however no signs<br />
of progress<br />
• Similar weed problems along creek bank upstream of<br />
road<br />
• Shallow muddy bay fringed by mangrove system<br />
• Lots of domestic litter along high tide line and in<br />
adjacent bushland area<br />
• Low lying area with limited drainage capability<br />
• Small tributary to north and adjacent bush area<br />
overgrown with lantana and other weeds. Trash rack and<br />
boom net in need of maintenance.<br />
Davies Rd • Small quarry at end of street largely vegetated –<br />
minimal potential for erosion problem<br />
Hawk St<br />
Catchment south of Kincumber<br />
Creek<br />
Cullens Rd<br />
Eastern Catchment<br />
• Residential area adjacent to bushland lined with weeds<br />
• Industrial area with potential for contaminated runoff<br />
issue of effective on-site controls not in place<br />
• Low flow area, generally low lying – low gradient area.<br />
• Drainage line to south below ground level almost to<br />
Empire Bay Dr<br />
• Weeds in upper catchment bushland<br />
• STP unlikely to have direct impact on Kincumber Creek<br />
water quality<br />
• Rubbish tip in upper catchment, potential leachate<br />
quality and sediment issues<br />
• Creek downstream of tip choked with weeds (lantana<br />
etc)<br />
• Turbid / grey water observed in creek<br />
• Almost entire eastern catchment now developed<br />
• Few areas of unconsolidated surfaces, mostly vegetated<br />
or paved<br />
• Small bushland area at top of eastern catchment has<br />
weed problem<br />
• New development along Elmitta St – potential sediment<br />
erosion problem<br />
Page 30 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Table A2: Erina Creek Field Observations<br />
Location<br />
Wells St and western side of<br />
Erina Creek<br />
Well St at Sherwood Dr<br />
Clarence Rd<br />
Chetwynd Rd<br />
Observation<br />
• Mostly residential with some reserves<br />
• Small tributaries branch west through residential areas<br />
into bushland. Generally less developed than eastern<br />
catchment<br />
• Creek turbid, possibly an overgrown detention pond full<br />
of reeds, macrophytes, grasses.<br />
• No flow, stagnant<br />
• Domestic litter along street drainage channels<br />
• Little or no flow in small creek<br />
• Wetland downstream of recently developed area<br />
appears generally healthy<br />
• Some areas not vegetated, possible soil erosion problem<br />
in wet weather<br />
• Road works with unsealed surfaces a potential soil<br />
erosion problem<br />
• Garden supplies shop at top of catchment, potential<br />
nutrient issue<br />
Portsmouth and Serpentine Rds • Semi rural properties with ponded areas in top of gully<br />
Carlton Rd near Gooriwa Rd<br />
Fires Creek at Wattle Tree Rd<br />
Carlton St at Wattle Tree St<br />
Oak Rd<br />
Coachwood Rd<br />
Elaine Rd<br />
The Entrance Rd and Karalta<br />
Rd<br />
• Vegetation (reeds / rushes) in channel<br />
• Garden supplies shops in catchment<br />
• Large open grassed areas with few houses<br />
• Detention ponds upstream slow water flow<br />
• Rural areas upstream<br />
• Rural / bushland catchment<br />
• Several ponded areas along creek<br />
• Relatively few weeds along riparian zone and little<br />
evidence of litter<br />
• Rural / bushland catchment.<br />
• Lantana growing in riparian zone<br />
• Riparian vegetation with some weed infestation<br />
• Low flows in dry weather conditions<br />
• Zone on either side of creek cleared for properties<br />
bordered by bushland to the top of the catchment<br />
• Some unconsolidated areas – unsealed roads etc may<br />
have sediment erosion problems<br />
• Dam and irrigation channel observed alongside small<br />
orchard<br />
• Stream choked with sediment and weeds<br />
• Weed growth in creek appears continuous to top of<br />
catchment<br />
• Several ponds for properties along creek<br />
• Commercial area drains direct to estuarine section of<br />
Erina Creek<br />
• Domestic litter observed in many channels<br />
Nunns Creek at The Entrance • Domestic litter in creek<br />
Page 31 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Rd<br />
Henzel Rd<br />
Location<br />
Observation<br />
• Some bank erosion observed<br />
• Recently developed residential area. Most areas appear<br />
vegetated or paved – few unconsolidated surfaces<br />
Table A3: Narara Creek Field Observations<br />
Location<br />
Debenham Rd / Kowara Rd<br />
Dyer Cr / Grieve Cl<br />
Manns Rd<br />
Nells Rd<br />
Dell Rd / Manns Rd<br />
Upper Reeves Rd<br />
Research Rd<br />
Carrington Rd<br />
Deanne Rd<br />
Brancourt Cl<br />
Willow Tree Cl<br />
Top of Mangrove Rd<br />
Louis Cl<br />
Konaderie Pde at Yarunga Ave<br />
Observation<br />
• Sediments eroded from unsealed roads<br />
• Domestic rubbish in all drainage channels<br />
• Rubbish dump near top of Debenham Rd<br />
• Clear water and low flows upstream of Debenham Rd<br />
• Potential erosion / sediment removal from quarry<br />
• Numerous industries (motor repair, garden supplies,<br />
scrap metal etc) with potential for toxic discharges during<br />
wet weather if on-site controls not in place<br />
• Continuation of industrial areas, bushland upstream of<br />
industries<br />
• Many unconsolidated surfaces in area<br />
• Disused quarry, largely revegetated now<br />
• Industrial area with bushland in upper catchment.<br />
• Sediment and vegetation problem in drainage channel<br />
near Manns Rd. Flow restricted.<br />
• Domestic rubbish<br />
• Unconsolidated road with lots of sediment deposited in<br />
adjacent and downstream drainage channels<br />
• Stream choked with bracken and lantana<br />
• Horticulture Research Centre – possible fertiliser issues<br />
• Increased proportion of residential housing from other<br />
areas off Manns Rd<br />
• Bank erosion<br />
• Residential catchment<br />
• Flood prone area<br />
• Bushland upstream<br />
• Small wetland with stagnant oily water<br />
• Mosquito problem<br />
• No creek access in vacant blocks due to weed growth<br />
• Slow, restricted flow in creek, orange slick, choked<br />
with weed/mud<br />
• Herbicides used on lantana<br />
• Old quarry / landing strip largely revegetated<br />
• Dumping ground for cars, rubbish in drainage channels<br />
• No flow in dry weather – choked with weed and<br />
sediment<br />
• Slow flow through vegetation<br />
Page 32 of 33
Australian <strong>Water</strong> Technologies<br />
<strong>Gosford</strong> <strong>Water</strong> Quality <strong>Survey</strong> Stage 1 Report – Community Consultation, Field Investigation and Stage 2 Sampling Design<br />
Location<br />
North eastern catchment<br />
Chamberlain Rd<br />
Glencoe Ave<br />
Rainforest St<br />
Creek opposite<br />
Shopping Centre<br />
Wyoming<br />
Maidens Brush Rd / Dalton St<br />
Creek at Laycock and Mann St<br />
Observation<br />
• Industries along railway line including scrap metal<br />
industry. Potential runoff problem if runoff not<br />
contained / controlled<br />
• Narrow strip of residential and industrial properties<br />
bounded by fringing bushland to the top of the catchment<br />
• Creek flow restricted by vines / weeds.<br />
• Wetland at end of road in poor condition – discoloured<br />
and thick with algae<br />
• Weeds found in creek<br />
• Horse training paddock<br />
• Machinery dumped on roadside<br />
• Large areas of unconsolidated surfaces<br />
• Wide open channel, good flow with rock flow<br />
retardants<br />
• Residential catchment upstream<br />
• Low flow, overgrown with vegetation / vines<br />
• Large stormwater drains enter main channel<br />
• Dense vegetation in channel<br />
• Litter from shopping centre<br />
• Open reserve areas, limited access due to weeds.<br />
• Mainly houses with streets kerb and guttered<br />
• Herbicides used on lantana higher in catchment<br />
• Rubbish dumping higher in catchment<br />
• Residential catchment with bushland at top of<br />
catchment<br />
• Open channel with dense vegetation and flow retardants<br />
Page 33 of 33