29.12.2013 Views

Download your concert programme here - Barbican

Download your concert programme here - Barbican

Download your concert programme here - Barbican

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Wednesday 3 February<br />

attitude to musical motion. This is at its most striking in the<br />

moderately paced first movement, which poses all sorts of<br />

questions and t<strong>here</strong>fore offers conductors considerable<br />

latitude in interpretation. Is the very opening an<br />

accompaniment or a theme, for example? Is its basic pulse<br />

defined by the steadily throbbing crotchets or by their<br />

broader melodic ascent? As the music unfolds, w<strong>here</strong> are the<br />

main points of structural articulation, apart from the<br />

extremely characteristic theme (first heard on declamatory<br />

woodwind) beginning with a long held note and ending in<br />

a flurry of short ones? Leaving all these issues undecided,<br />

the music evolves in an improvisatory succession of moods,<br />

rarely emotional or dramatic on the surface, but all in a<br />

state of becoming and carried along as though by forces<br />

of nature.<br />

The two central movements are again remarkable for their<br />

economy of means and concealed structural energy. The<br />

dark-hued slow movement is built around an introspective<br />

melody for bassoons (marked ‘lugubriously’) and quiet,<br />

chorale-like phrases in the strings, those ideas being spaced<br />

by more of the accelerations that have already marked the<br />

first movement.<br />

The scherzo then contrasts a whirlwind of agitated stringwriting<br />

with a heartfelt trio section led off by the oboe;<br />

displaying a fine instinct for symphonic proportion, Sibelius<br />

curtails this trio, so that its recurrence after the repeat of the<br />

scherzo will not sound jaded. Even more effectively, this<br />

recurrence leads straight on to the finale rather than back to<br />

a final statement of the scherzo – in broad terms following<br />

the model of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony. Now the<br />

redemptive tone promised by the quasi-religious ideas of the<br />

slow movement at last comes out into the open. And while the<br />

finale itself may be open to criticism for its relatively<br />

conventional imagery and structure, it is nothing if not bold in<br />

its attempt to measure up to Beethovenian (and other)<br />

precedents.<br />

Programme note © David Fanning<br />

7

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!