RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

repositorio.ufsc.br
from repositorio.ufsc.br More from this publisher
29.12.2013 Views

323 nauseous to her" (ibid). Lawrence again controls the narrative and manipulates Kate like a puppet on his knee. Only thus could he force Kate to accept Cipriano's sadism. It is perhaps an extension of her sense of sin we noted when she desired Ramon sexually and longed for the men to 'save' her. Thus, Cipriano 'saves' her by punishing her in their sexual relations. What seems strange and somehow false in this marriage is that Kate's feelings about a relation of balance is completely distorted in her relation with Cipriano. Once she told Ramon that she was aware that Cipriano would never meet her: "'He would come to take something from me and I should have to let him. And I don't want merely that'" (pp.297-8). And she adds that she as a woman wants "'... a man who will come half-way, just half-way to meet me'" (p.298). be her own going to meet this man. The other 'half-way' will This idea implies the balance she wants and not Cipriano's authoritarian yet childish demands upon her. Ramon apparently agrees with Kate for he says: "'A woman who just wants to be taken, and then to cling on, is a parasite. And a man who wants just to take, without giving, is a creature of prey*" (ibid). Ramon implies in his speech a certain alliance with Kate against a relation of domination. This contradicts every single attitude taken by the Quetzalcoatl followers, including Ramon himself when he marries the submissive Teresa (a 'parasite' in his own terms) and passes Kate on to the sadistic Cipriano. Moreover, in this same conversation Lawrence again expresses through Ramon the notion that the only possibility of a meeting of 'half-way' walkers is bound to occur between men, never between man and woman: 'And I'm afraid Don Cipriano might be [a creature of prey],' said Kate. 'Possibly,' said Ramon. 'He is not so with me.

324 But perhaps he would be, if we did not meetperhaps it is our half-way - in some physical belief that is at the very middle of us, and which we recognize in one another. Don't you think there might be that between you and him?' 'I doubt if he'd feel it necessary, with a woman. A woman wouldn't be important enough.' Ramon was silent (ibid). Ramon's silence is a clear signal of his mute agreement with the lack of importance of a woman in this meeting in a balanced relation with a man. And the fact that he mentions a sort of 'physical recognition' between him and Cipriano reinforces the idea that what Kate wants with a man who is not a 'creature of prey' is only possible between men. It is the bloodbrotherhood Birkin wanted with Gerald. Lawrence speaks through Ramon again to say that '... with a woman, a man always wants to let himself go. And it is precisely with a woman that he should never let himself go, but stick to his innermost belief, and meet her just there' (ibid). To complement this idea, Lawrence, some pages earlier, interfered in the narrative to assert the only possibility of balance in relationships: Men and women should know that they cannot, absolutely, meet on earth... When men meet at the quick of all things, they are neither naked nor clothed; in the transfiguration they are just complete, they are not seen in part. The final perfect strength has also the power of innocence (pp.277-8 - My underlining). Kate's assertion that she wants balance is therefore thrown away by the author in the marriage with Cipriano. The latter will never give and take. He will only take from her and she will never be allowed to ask for anything except to accept her submission. The strange thing is that all her efforts to attain balance are suddenly replaced by an absurd desire to

324<br />

But perhaps he would be, if we did not meetperhaps<br />

it is our half-way - in some physical belief<br />

that is at the very middle of us, and which we<br />

recognize in one another. Don't you think there<br />

might be that between you and him?'<br />

'I doubt if he'd feel it necessary, with a<br />

woman. A woman wouldn't be important enough.'<br />

Ramon was silent (ibid).<br />

Ramon's silence is a clear signal of his mute agreement with the<br />

lack of importance of a woman in this meeting in a balanced<br />

relation with a man.<br />

And the fact that he mentions a sort of<br />

'physical recognition' between him and Cipriano reinforces the<br />

idea that what Kate wants with a man who is not a 'creature of<br />

prey' is only possible between men.<br />

It is the bloodbrotherhood<br />

Birkin wanted with Gerald.<br />

Lawrence speaks through Ramon again<br />

to say that<br />

'... with a woman, a man always wants to let<br />

himself go. And it is precisely with a woman<br />

that he should never let himself go, but stick<br />

to his innermost belief, and meet her just<br />

there' (ibid).<br />

To complement this idea, Lawrence, some pages earlier,<br />

interfered in the narrative to assert the only possibility of<br />

balance in relationships:<br />

Men and women should know that they cannot,<br />

absolutely, meet on earth...<br />

When men meet at the quick of all things, they<br />

are neither naked nor clothed; in the transfiguration<br />

they are just complete, they are not seen in part.<br />

The final perfect strength has also the power of<br />

innocence (pp.277-8 - My underlining).<br />

Kate's assertion that she wants balance is therefore<br />

thrown away by the author in the marriage with Cipriano.<br />

The<br />

latter will never give and take.<br />

He will only take from her and<br />

she will never be allowed to ask for anything except to accept<br />

her submission.<br />

The strange thing is that all her efforts to<br />

attain balance are suddenly replaced by an absurd desire to

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!