RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

repositorio.ufsc.br
from repositorio.ufsc.br More from this publisher
29.12.2013 Views

285 'More than it has to do with you, probably,' she replied, plaintive and venomous (p.117). In this atmosphere of competition March feels as if happy because she is the motive for the battle between Henry and Banford to occur; March seemed to flourish in this atmosphere. She seemed to sit between two antagonists with a little wicked smile on her face, enjoying herself. There was even a sort of complacency in the way she crocheted this evening (p.118). It seems a good therapy for March's divided self to be between the antagonists. This explains her new mood. She is feeling somehow proud of herself. "[The girls] seemed to be losing ground, somehow losing hope as the month went by... they seemed to have to live too much off themselves. There was nothing to keep them up - and no hope" (p.88). This quotation is a way to remind us that since the beginning of the story the girls' relationship was not going to last long. When Henry arrives at the farm and 'hunts' March, he becomes the agent which dissolves the link that binds the girls. March, in her divided self, opens herself up and allows him to discover the flower of femininity hidden in her manly appearance. He makes her become a weak, defenceless woman. This means that she was not actually happy in her relationship with Banford. Banford, however, seems to be satisfied with her homosexuality. She does not need any man to fulfil herself. March fulfils her completely. As Henry's presence menaces the relationship, Banford stops being the delicate girl to be like she really is - the strongest, the dominant. Her delicacy is a mask to hide her strength. Henry has made her take this mask off and thus she starts behaving the way she really is. A way to fight Henry off is to make March aware of the kind of

286 relationship she is going to have with the man: 'No, Nellie, if you were to do such a thing as to marry him, you could never stop here... And I know, I know he's only counting what he can get out of you... He's just a good for nothing, who doesn't want to work, and who thinks he'll live on us... If you marry him he'll just make a fool of you... I know he will, if he can't get Bailey Farm out of us - and he's not going to, while I live. He'd soon think he was master of both us, as he thinks he's master of you already' (p.119). In this speech, Banford points out at least seven terrible features of Henry's personality which are enough to destroy any relation. However, two things must be considered: first, one has to think of the two people involved in the conversation - the speaker and the hearer. The speaker is extremely jealous, angry and desperate because she is losing her companion. Everything she says can be taken just as jealousy and so it cannot be taken seriously. The hearer is unable to distinguish anything because she is in a kind of trance/of dizziness and enchantment because of the discovery of her new self. Therefore, she will never accept what the other says. All March considers as being worth saying is: "'I don't think he's as bad as that"' (p.120). Besides all the defects Banford has pointed out, there is another one: Henry is an eavesdropper. Thus, he can plot perversely against Banford or whoever disturbs him. Banford says that Henry is bossy, selfish, predatory, cold and deep. March does not hear. But Banford's evaluation is right. He wants to dominate others and since now he cannot fully develop his bossy spirit he goes out after hearing the conversation. He is murderously angry with Banford who is interfering in his plot. As he cannot yet kill her he must do something to release all his repressed aggression:

286<br />

relationship she is going to have with the man:<br />

'No, Nellie, if you were to do such a thing as to<br />

marry him, you could never stop here... And I<br />

know, I know he's only counting what he can get<br />

out of you... He's just a good for nothing, who<br />

doesn't want to work, and who thinks he'll live<br />

on us... If you marry him he'll just make a fool<br />

of you... I know he will, if he can't get Bailey<br />

Farm out of us - and he's not going to, while I<br />

live. He'd soon think he was master of both us,<br />

as he thinks he's master of you already' (p.119).<br />

In this speech, Banford points out at least seven terrible<br />

features of Henry's personality which are enough to destroy any<br />

relation.<br />

However, two things must be considered: first, one<br />

has to think of the two people involved in the conversation -<br />

the speaker and the hearer.<br />

The speaker is extremely jealous,<br />

angry and desperate because she is losing her companion.<br />

Everything she says can be taken just as jealousy and so it<br />

cannot be taken seriously.<br />

The hearer is unable to distinguish<br />

anything because she is in a kind of trance/of dizziness and<br />

enchantment because of the discovery of her new self.<br />

Therefore,<br />

she will never accept what the other says.<br />

All March considers<br />

as being worth saying is: "'I don't think he's as bad as that"'<br />

(p.120).<br />

Besides all the defects Banford has pointed out, there is<br />

another one: Henry is an eavesdropper. Thus, he can plot<br />

perversely against Banford or whoever disturbs him.<br />

Banford says that Henry is bossy, selfish, predatory, cold<br />

and deep. March does not hear. But Banford's evaluation is<br />

right.<br />

He wants to dominate others and since now he cannot fully<br />

develop his bossy spirit he goes out after hearing the<br />

conversation.<br />

He is murderously angry with Banford who is<br />

interfering in his plot.<br />

As he cannot yet kill her he must do<br />

something to release all his repressed aggression:

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!