RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE RELATIONS OF DOMINANCE AND EQUALITY IN D. H. LAWRENCE

repositorio.ufsc.br
from repositorio.ufsc.br More from this publisher
29.12.2013 Views

On the one hand there is Will's desire to destroy the woman in Anna and be the master of the home. Anna, on the other, dreads this in her man and "wanted to desert him, to leave him a prey to the open, with the unclean dogs of the darkness setting on to devour him" (p.170). She cannot bear to depend on Will and, as she is stronger, she gradually destroys his beliefs. She cannot give in to him. I believe that the main point in their conflict refers to a deep lack of respect in both husband and wife. They do not respect each other. Furthermore, Will lets Anna disrespect him because his personality is unripe and the woman he has married has been self-sufficient since she was a little child. For her it is enough that she loves him. Hence, Anna starts to tease him. Will lets Anna destroy the man as subject, transforming him into a mere object. Will's destruction seems to start when Anna tells him that his Eve is a mere doll in the hands of his Adam and that she, Anna, will not be like the Eve. The result of this is that Will feels deceived and destroys his unfinished carving: but this only proves that Will himself is an unfinished creature. The second and crucial moment of Will's defeat happens when Anna, pregnant, dances naked in front of him as a way to assert her right to independence. She as a woman does not need to be guided by any man to reach God. She can touch God by herself. And she decides to dance before the unknown to prove to herself and to her weak husband her right to freedom: Suddenly she had realized that this was what she wanted to do. Big with child as she was, she danced there in the bedroom by herself, lifting her hands and her body to the Unseen, to the unseen Creator who had chosen her, to whom she belonged (p.183). Will, at this moment, is no master, no giant. He, in her eyes,

is like a dwarf without power. exultation beyond him" (ibid). Therefore, "she had to dance in To be more provocative she takes her clothes off and aware of her superiority (because of her pregnancy) she dances Will's nullification. It is as if he were not the father but rather the stars were the father, or Anna were both mother and father. Will sees with amazement the apex of Anna's dance and he feels that "The strangeness, the power of her in her dancing consumed him, he was burned, he could not grasp, he could not understand" (p.184). As he can do nothing to stop the destructive power of his wife, Will is forced to leave the room. From now on Anna will be the master in the relation. Husband and wife are separated. They now sleep in different rooms. Will is only to be with Anna when she orders him to. Apart from this he has no function at home. He becomes an object of decoration which Anna manipulates at her wish. Her victory over the man is complemented when Anna gives birth. The living child makes Anna's victory more real and concrete. As the pains of the birth start Anna feels she is getting closer and closer to victory. The only disappointment in Anna's success is that she wanted a boy and the baby is a girl. However, the mother soon forgets the sex of the child when it starts sucking her milk. She has become 'Anna Victrix'. As for Will, his wife "was indeed Anna Victrix. He could not combat her any more" (p.193). The enchantment of the baby soon passes and Anna feels unfulfilled. She wants more than a simple child. One may think that motherhood is not sufficient for Anna and that her wish is to go beyond this. However, it is not true. What Anna really wants is to bear more and more children. The 'beyond' she will leave to her children to find. She is satisfied where she is:

is like a dwarf without power.<br />

exultation beyond him" (ibid).<br />

Therefore, "she had to dance in<br />

To be more provocative she takes<br />

her clothes off and aware of her superiority (because of her<br />

pregnancy) she dances Will's nullification.<br />

It is as if he were<br />

not the father but rather the stars were the father, or Anna<br />

were both mother and father.<br />

Will sees with amazement the apex<br />

of Anna's dance and he feels that "The strangeness, the power<br />

of her in her dancing consumed him, he was burned, he could not<br />

grasp, he could not understand" (p.184).<br />

As he can do nothing<br />

to stop the destructive power of his wife, Will is forced to<br />

leave the room.<br />

From now on Anna will be the master in the<br />

relation. Husband and wife are separated. They now sleep in<br />

different rooms.<br />

Will is only to be with Anna when she orders<br />

him to. Apart from this he has no function at home. He becomes<br />

an object of decoration which Anna manipulates at her wish.<br />

Her victory over the man is complemented when Anna gives<br />

birth.<br />

The living child makes Anna's victory more real and<br />

concrete.<br />

As the pains of the birth start Anna feels she is<br />

getting closer and closer to victory.<br />

The only disappointment<br />

in Anna's success is that she wanted a boy and the baby is a girl.<br />

However, the mother soon forgets the sex of the child when it<br />

starts sucking her milk. She has become 'Anna Victrix'. As for<br />

Will, his wife "was indeed Anna Victrix.<br />

He could not combat her<br />

any more" (p.193).<br />

The enchantment of the baby soon passes and Anna feels<br />

unfulfilled. She wants more than a simple child. One may think<br />

that motherhood is not sufficient for Anna and that her wish is<br />

to go beyond this. However, it is not true. What Anna really<br />

wants is to bear more and more children.<br />

The 'beyond' she will<br />

leave to her children to find.<br />

She is satisfied where she is:

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!