29.12.2013 Views

Lynne Wong's PhD thesis

Lynne Wong's PhD thesis

Lynne Wong's PhD thesis

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Rein (1975) investigated the effects of fibre and pol % cane on the extraction achieved by<br />

milling tandems, by using a statistical approach. He showed that extraction is adversely<br />

affected by high fibre levels but improves as pol % cane rises.<br />

A cost analysis done by Cargill (1976) showed the following:<br />

• Reducing tops and trash in cane by 3% would increase throughput (tons cane per hour<br />

TCH) by 9% with the same installed capacity, and reduce transport costs by 3%.<br />

• Decreasing trash in cane by 1% would increase the overall recovery of pol by 0.3%.<br />

Scott (1977) carried out full-scale tests at two milling tandems to measure the effect of<br />

fibre % cane, trash and tops in cane on throughput. Except for tops in cane, he obtained<br />

statistically significant regressions:<br />

TCH = 203.3 – 5.3 fibre % cane<br />

TCH = 134.3 – 3.0 trash % cane<br />

The overall results showed that the crushing rate is reduced by about 4% for a unit rise in<br />

fibre % cane and by 2.2 to 3.0% for a unit rise in trash % cane.<br />

Reid and Lionnet (1989) carried out full-scale processing of different types of harvested<br />

cane: clean stalk, stalk without removal of tops, trash, and tops and trash. Compared to<br />

clean stalk, the results showed that:<br />

• The mill throughput with unburnt, untopped cane was 30% less than that with burnt,<br />

topped cane, while that with unburnt, topped cane was 22% less.<br />

• Compared to burnt, topped cane, boiling house recovery was predicted to drop by 6%<br />

with unburnt, untopped cane.<br />

Similar results were obtained when Lionnet (1992b) carried out tests with a diffuser<br />

instead of the milling tandems.<br />

The effect of trash on milling has been studied by numerous workers. Most of the studies<br />

either dealt with dry trash only or a fixed pre-defined proportion of dry trash, cane tops and<br />

soil, while many others were conducted as factory trials. Using an experimental threeroller<br />

mill equipped with rollers of 10 inches diameter and 14 inches long with a hydraulic<br />

pressure of 30 tons, Arceneaux and Davidson (1944) crushed clean cane of several<br />

varieties to which were added separately green and dry trash in amounts of 2.5, 5.0 and<br />

7.5%, with maceration water applied four times at 20% on the cane. They found that green<br />

21

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!