Stony Brook University - SUNY Digital Repository

Stony Brook University - SUNY Digital Repository Stony Brook University - SUNY Digital Repository

dspace.sunyconnect.suny.edu
from dspace.sunyconnect.suny.edu More from this publisher
25.12.2013 Views

associated set of colonies in history was as large, none so totally dominated, none so unequal in power to the Western metropolis” (7). Because of this, then, that perspective was most explicitly exhibited during the nineteenth century. And according to Said, this imperialist perspective of the world and those who live in it had particular criteria that defined it as “imperialist”: [Imperialism and colonialism] are supported and perhaps even impelled by impressive ideological formations that include notions that certain territories and people require and beseech domination, as well as forms of knowledge affiliated with domination: the vocabulary of classic nineteenth-century imperial culture is plentiful with words and concepts like 'inferior' or 'subject races,' 'subordinate peoples,' 'dependency,' 'expansion,' and 'authority.' Out of the imperial experiences, notions about culture were clarified, reinforced, criticized, or rejected. (9) Said’s explanation of that perspective continues: [T]here is more than [profit] to imperialism and colonialism. There was a commitment to them over and above profit, a commitment in constant circulation and recirculation, which, on the one hand, allowed decent men and women to accept the notion that distant territories and their native peoples should be subjugated, and, on the other, replenished metropolitan energies so that these decent people could think of the imperium as a protracted, almost metaphysical obligation to rule subordinate, inferior, or less advanced peoples. (10) In short, "[T]he enterprise of empire depends upon the idea of having an empire” (11). It is in the third chapter of Culture and Imperialism that Said offers his most vivid example of imperialism’s legacy in literature with his discussion of Joseph Conrad’s Heart of 74

Darkness. For Said, it was in the pages of Conrad’s novel that you could not only observe the workings of that ideology but its inadequacies as well. And these inadequacies are rooted in imperialism's ignorance of that "heart of darkness," the chaotic and dissonant unknown – very well that dreaded uncertainty – which poses a palpable threat to its claim to order, control, and authority. [N]either Conrad nor Marlow gives us a full view of what is outside the world-conquering attitudes embodied by Kurtz, Marlow, the circle of listeners on the deck of the Nellie, and Conrad. By that I mean that Heart of Darkness works so effectively because its politics and aesthetics are, so to speak, imperialist […]. For if we cannot truly understand someone else's experience and if we must therefore depend upon the assertive authority of the sort of power that Kurtz wields as a white man in the jungle or that Marlow, another white man, wields as narrator, there is no use looking for other, nonimperialist alternatives; the system has simply eliminated them and made them unthinkable. (24) To Said, Conrad was able to present a dualistic presentation of an imperialistic "truth" about reality. Of this, he writes: By accentuating the official “idea" of empire and the remarkably disorienting actuality of Africa, Marlow unsettles the reader's sense not only of the very idea of empire, but of something more basic, reality itself. For if Conrad can show that all human activity depends on controlling a radically unstable reality to which words approximate only by will or convention, the same is true of empire, of venerating the idea, and so forth. […] What appears stable and secure […] is only slightly more secure than the white men in the jungle, and requires the same continuous (but precarious) triumph over an allpervading darkness. (29) This “epistemology inevitable and unavoidable” of imperialism that Said puts on display here is, I believe, the same perspective upon knowledge, upon “reality” and “truth,” at the 75

associated set of colonies in history was as large, none so<br />

totally dominated, none so unequal in power to the Western<br />

metropolis” (7). Because of this, then, that perspective was<br />

most explicitly exhibited during the nineteenth century. And<br />

according to Said, this imperialist perspective of the world and<br />

those who live in it had particular criteria that defined it as<br />

“imperialist”:<br />

[Imperialism and colonialism] are supported and<br />

perhaps even impelled by impressive ideological<br />

formations that include notions that certain<br />

territories and people require and beseech<br />

domination, as well as forms of knowledge affiliated<br />

with domination: the vocabulary of classic<br />

nineteenth-century imperial culture is plentiful with<br />

words and concepts like 'inferior' or 'subject<br />

races,' 'subordinate peoples,' 'dependency,'<br />

'expansion,' and 'authority.' Out of the imperial<br />

experiences, notions about culture were clarified,<br />

reinforced, criticized, or rejected. (9)<br />

Said’s explanation of that perspective continues:<br />

[T]here is more than [profit] to imperialism and<br />

colonialism. There was a commitment to them over and<br />

above profit, a commitment in constant circulation<br />

and recirculation, which, on the one hand, allowed<br />

decent men and women to accept the notion that<br />

distant territories and their native peoples should<br />

be subjugated, and, on the other, replenished<br />

metropolitan energies so that these decent people<br />

could think of the imperium as a protracted, almost<br />

metaphysical obligation to rule subordinate,<br />

inferior, or less advanced peoples. (10)<br />

In short, "[T]he enterprise of empire depends upon the idea of<br />

having an empire” (11).<br />

It is in the third chapter of Culture and Imperialism that<br />

Said offers his most vivid example of imperialism’s legacy in<br />

literature with his discussion of Joseph Conrad’s Heart of<br />

74

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!