Art Criticism - The State University of New York
Art Criticism - The State University of New York Art Criticism - The State University of New York
These passages were meant to help guide the visitor through the exhibition. Along with these quotes, some pieces were accompanied by short descrip , tions, for example: This horror hung as a war memorial in the cathedral of Lubeck. An insult to German womanhood. The Ideal-cretin and whore. Deliberate sabotage of national defense. An insult to the German heroes of the Great War. Nature as seen by a sick Mind. Decadence exploited for literary and commercial 'purposes. 24 Arid over one doorway it was written "They had four years." Thi~ short statement refers to the grace period given by Hitler for those in the cultural community to adjust to the Nazi way of thinking while Hitler put ~ogether his cultural machine. From this point on, that which had not been proven as healthy would be eliminated. With the demonstration of the Degenerate Art exhibition and the Great German Art Exhibition, there was no room for an alternative view. Already, Goebbels had forbade art criticism: I granted German critics four years after our assumption of power to adapt themselves to National Socialist principles ... Since the year 1936 has passed without any satisfactory improvement in art criticism, I am herewith forbidding, from this day on, the conduct of art criticism as it has been practiced to aate ... The art critic will be replaced by the art editor .. .In the future only those art editors will be allowed to report on art who approach the task with an undefiled heart and National socialist convictions.25 To practice art criticism was to be critical of the art which was presented. And as only healthy art was to be presented, there would be no place for the art critic. What is more, to criticize the art that was presented was to be critical of the work that presented the ideals Hitler had set for·the nation; therefore, to be critical of art was, by extension, to be critical of Hitler. Goebbels would continue to justify his ban on criticism through 1944, declaring that the ancients had disregarded art critics and had judged works for themselves. 26 However, the ban on criticism can also be seen as an attempt to mask the shallowness of a heavily censored art meant for mass consumption. The Great German Art Exhibition was meant to underscore the official art's triumph over degenerate works as well as to demonstrate what the Haus der Deutschen Kunst would house. The building was to be the first of a new German artistic tradition, housing contemporary works to help further shape .18 Art Criticism
cultural policy. The exhibition opening was celebrated as a national holiday, German Art Day.27 Hitler gave a speech on the contrast between modem ideals and German ideals with such passion that even his entourage were taken aback. He forbade artists to use anything but the forms seen in nature in their paintings. "We will, from now on, lead an unrelenting war of purification, an unrelenting war of extermination, against the elements which have displaced our art."28 It was with these words that the audience made their way into the museum for the first time. The 600 works that had been chosen for the opening were organized into categories such as landscape, portraiture, nudes, and heroic military themes, with many works also focusing on German folk themes of family, peasant life, and motherhood. So-called art editors, having replaced art critics, reported in the press that "Sketchiness has been rigorously eliminated" and that the only paintings accepted were those "that are fully executed examples of their kind, and give no cause to ask what the artist might have meant to convey."29 The exhibition was straightforward, accessible to the point that it had clear messages without any room for interpretation. Such a message was conveyed by the many depictions of the well toned and forward looking Nordic nude, that, according to one report, "emanates delight in the healthy human body."30 These pieces were instructional, embodying proper morality and behavior by symbolizing a standard of beauty and utilizing a classical vocabulary to avoid seeming sexual. They offered a moral standard around which Hitler hoped to unite a nation. This morality was represented in the bodies of the larger than life nudes that were smooth, and frozen so that they could be worshipped but not desired, like the Greece formY In this way, beauty helped one maintain control of one's passions. And by depicting the nude in a static state like that of the Greek form, the works expressed unchanging values to those in search of values in post-war, modern Germany. The great statutes represented a link to Greco-Roman antiquity, echoing the tradition set forth by Rosenberg, a tradition of which the German people, hungry for national pride, could be proud. 32 The works suggested the greatness of those in the empire, while towering over the individual viewer, making him feel small and powerless against the empire." However, while the hushed whispers of the crowd generally admired the works for their realistic depiction of what was good and beautiful, the exhibition drew relatively low attendance, while the Degenerate Art exhibition drew record breaking crowds. Part of this may have been the aura of iIIicitness that the exhibition had. 34 No children were allowed and often times the doors had to be closed to prevent overcrowding. Arid by drawing on the average German's distrust of the avant-garde, the exhibition gave the people what they wanted, an enemy to voice a unified hatred towards. The fact that the avantgarde was continually equated with Judeo-Bolshevik ideas and that the Gervol. 17, no. 1 79
- Page 30 and 31: with the sleep of reason. In the Am
- Page 32 and 33: cent. Its fluidity of happy acciden
- Page 34 and 35: And yet I can imagine these atrocit
- Page 36 and 37: erature the not very evocative work
- Page 38 and 39: maiden" of Marxism (unless things g
- Page 40 and 41: ic he realize that artists suddenly
- Page 42 and 43: The little nonsense that wise men r
- Page 44 and 45: desensitized by the imitated means
- Page 46 and 47: symbolism? If the arts only exist t
- Page 48 and 49: The Femme Fatale as seen in the wor
- Page 50 and 51: Huysmans parallels the life of De R
- Page 52 and 53: ask for the unreasonable and receiv
- Page 54 and 55: ennui or physical distress leads th
- Page 56 and 57: ences cited herein, the femme fatal
- Page 58 and 59: period."2 He traced the tradition b
- Page 60 and 61: suggestion to the artist and the po
- Page 62 and 63: of Moreau's works is vague and myst
- Page 64 and 65: ing her as the femme fatale, or sub
- Page 66 and 67: The subtitle Satanic Decameron evok
- Page 68 and 69: completely mythical. Coupled with a
- Page 70 and 71: Moreau was very much a man of his t
- Page 72 and 73: themes and images are often decaden
- Page 74 and 75: p. 7-8; cited in Pierre Louis Mathi
- Page 76 and 77: Between World War I and World War I
- Page 78 and 79: shown distrust in the new styles. T
- Page 82 and 83: man public was voicing disapproval
- Page 84 and 85: y old masters that were more suitab
- Page 86 and 87: Notes 1 Alfred Barr, "Art in the Th
- Page 88 and 89: From Diagnoses to Decadence: A Brie
- Page 90 and 91: ate effort to reproduce fully an im
- Page 92 and 93: patients. Charcot was often to be f
- Page 94 and 95: Breuer attributed the presence of A
- Page 96 and 97: still is traditionally associated w
- Page 98 and 99: is not always recognized as such. H
- Page 100 and 101: generation on which the multitude o
- Page 102 and 103: 2 Elaine Showalter, The Female Mala
- Page 104 and 105: 36 Freud and Breuer, 37. 37 Su'ch a
- Page 106 and 107: Recasting the Art History Survey: E
- Page 108 and 109: mode of self-consciousness that bes
- Page 110 and 111: student-as-Other "calls" us to teac
- Page 112 and 113: thesis of such descriptions into an
- Page 114 and 115: In this final section of the essay,
- Page 116 and 117: image-world, the picture opens up a
- Page 118 and 119: history must itself be rethought in
- Page 120 and 121: 15 Two of the most prominent propon
- Page 122 and 123: power: from the premodern exercise
- Page 124: ~fJed in the Unikd Smtc, .• 9 ~]~
cultural policy. <strong>The</strong> exhibition opening was celebrated as a national holiday,<br />
German <strong>Art</strong> Day.27 Hitler gave a speech on the contrast between modem ideals<br />
and German ideals with such passion that even his entourage were taken<br />
aback. He forbade artists to use anything but the forms seen in nature in their<br />
paintings. "We will, from now on, lead an unrelenting war <strong>of</strong> purification, an<br />
unrelenting war <strong>of</strong> extermination, against the elements which have displaced<br />
our art."28 It was with these words that the audience made their way into the<br />
museum for the first time.<br />
<strong>The</strong> 600 works that had been chosen for the opening were organized<br />
into categories such as landscape, portraiture, nudes, and heroic military themes,<br />
with many works also focusing on German folk themes <strong>of</strong> family, peasant life,<br />
and motherhood. So-called art editors, having replaced art critics, reported in<br />
the press that "Sketchiness has been rigorously eliminated" and that the only<br />
paintings accepted were those "that are fully executed examples <strong>of</strong> their kind,<br />
and give no cause to ask what the artist might have meant to convey."29<br />
<strong>The</strong> exhibition was straightforward, accessible to the point that it had<br />
clear messages without any room for interpretation. Such a message was conveyed<br />
by the many depictions <strong>of</strong> the well toned and forward looking Nordic<br />
nude, that, according to one report, "emanates delight in the healthy human<br />
body."30 <strong>The</strong>se pieces were instructional, embodying proper morality and behavior<br />
by symbolizing a standard <strong>of</strong> beauty and utilizing a classical vocabulary<br />
to avoid seeming sexual. <strong>The</strong>y <strong>of</strong>fered a moral standard around which Hitler<br />
hoped to unite a nation. This morality was represented in the bodies <strong>of</strong> the<br />
larger than life nudes that were smooth, and frozen so that they could be<br />
worshipped but not desired, like the Greece formY In this way, beauty helped<br />
one maintain control <strong>of</strong> one's passions. And by depicting the nude in a static<br />
state like that <strong>of</strong> the Greek form, the works expressed unchanging values to<br />
those in search <strong>of</strong> values in post-war, modern Germany. <strong>The</strong> great statutes<br />
represented a link to Greco-Roman antiquity, echoing the tradition set forth by<br />
Rosenberg, a tradition <strong>of</strong> which the German people, hungry for national pride,<br />
could be proud. 32 <strong>The</strong> works suggested the greatness <strong>of</strong> those in the empire,<br />
while towering over the individual viewer, making him feel small and powerless<br />
against the empire."<br />
However, while the hushed whispers <strong>of</strong> the crowd generally admired<br />
the works for their realistic depiction <strong>of</strong> what was good and beautiful, the<br />
exhibition drew relatively low attendance, while the Degenerate <strong>Art</strong> exhibition<br />
drew record breaking crowds. Part <strong>of</strong> this may have been the aura <strong>of</strong> iIIicitness<br />
that the exhibition had. 34 No children were allowed and <strong>of</strong>ten times the doors<br />
had to be closed to prevent overcrowding. Arid by drawing on the average<br />
German's distrust <strong>of</strong> the avant-garde, the exhibition gave the people what they<br />
wanted, an enemy to voice a unified hatred towards. <strong>The</strong> fact that the avantgarde<br />
was continually equated with Judeo-Bolshevik ideas and that the Gervol.<br />
17, no. 1 79