Art Criticism - The State University of New York

Art Criticism - The State University of New York Art Criticism - The State University of New York

dspace.sunyconnect.suny.edu
from dspace.sunyconnect.suny.edu More from this publisher
25.12.2013 Views

completely mythical. Coupled with a veneration of the past, is the elevation of the world of the imagination over real life, a turning inward to a realm of fantasy and refined sensation. Moreau's own life became increasingly solitary, as he grew older and more disenchanted with the increasing anomie of urban life. These aspects of Moreau's art mirror des Esseintes' denial of the modem world and his efforts to assert his own self, his uniqueness, in the ever-growing modern metropolis. Moreau was, Proust wrote, "one of those who have an inner soul into which they can sometimes penetrate. The rest of their life is a kind of exile, often voluntary, not sad, but tedious."34 This escape to an inner realm is evident on a more subtle level in Moreau's work through the use of the arabesque, a form which fascinated Moreau. The arabesque as plastic equivalent to the soul in all its mystery was discussed by many artists and poets. 35 With its Greek and Oriental connotations it also embodied the "ideal and the universal" for Moreau. 36 Its labyrinth form suggests unreason and irregularity, and the proliferation of the arabesque form in much of Moreau's work implies the mysterious or the enigmatic. Moreau was drawn to mysticism, and wished to explore the arcane realms of thought and spirit, realms that were untouchable and divineY The arabesque is associated with mystery, the world of the unconscious. Wonderful arabesques of line and color are evident in the unfinished The Unicorns (1887-88) or in The Apparition (1874-76). The arabesque in painting adds to the mystery. The clear lines of heroic Renaissance art are in sharp cont~ast to the mysteriousness deliberately fostered by Moreau. The swirling motion of the arabesque is perhaps most evident in some of Moreau's abstract sketches of pure color, which contain little or no figurative detail, but beautiful swathes of paint with the evocative power of the most compelling of the modern abstract expressionists. Moreau was extremely preoccupied with the mystery and idealism of Christianity. Like 1. K. Huysmans, who finally converted to Catholicism following his dabbles in decadence and Satan ism, Christianity appealed to many artists of the fin-de-siecle, who were disenchanted by the materialism of their peers. III. THECOUN1ER-ARGUMENT: DECADENCE AS NEITHER A BLACK NORVflllTEPROPOSrnON Viewed on a superficial level, the artificiality, gender confusion, the unnatural treatment of the female subject, and general rejection of reality would quickly condemn Moreau's art to the dungeons of decadence. If decadence in art is characterized by extreme maturity, a proliferation of detail, an extremely complicated style, a profusion of color and the tendency to translate the passions in a depraved or obsessive manner, then Moreau's art must be judged as high decadence. Along with the considerable popularity of his work among 66 Art Criticism

the decadent literati, the evidence appears conclusive. However I would suggest that, unlike the cultivated decadence of many of these writers, the decadence of Moreau's art was an unconscious side effect of his effort to imbue his art with a generalized expression of "universal appeal." This was not decadence for the sake of decadence. Moreau believed that he had a divine duty to illuminate through his art the souls and minds of his audience. His religious beliefs are evident in his following profession of faith: "Do you believe in God? I believe in him alone. I believe neither in what I touch nor what I see. I believe only in what I do not see and only in what I feel. My brain and reason seem to me ephemeral and of a doubtful reality; my inner feeling alone seems to me eternal and indubltably certain."38 His painting mirrors this tendency, in its rejection of external reality and in its attempt to convey an atmosphere or idea, instead of exact historical narrative. Moreau rarely painted historical scenes, preferring the realm of myth . or the imagination. One of his primary intentions was "to render visible, as it were, the inner flashes of insight, which one cannot connect with anything, which have something divine in their apparent meaninglessness and which, as conveyed by the wonderful effects of pure painting, open up really magical, I may say, even sublime horizons."39 His dreamlike visions appealed tremendously to Andre Breton, who considered him a forerunner of the Surrealists. While Moreau's debt to past masters is evident in his work, this is not the result of a lack of personal painting direction, but out of reverence, as a means of invoking the timeless, the universal. And apart from such lofty motives, it was indeed quite common for artists at the time to emulate the art of the Renaissance, especially as this tradition was both taught and favored by the French Academy and the Ecole des Beaux-Arts. Such imitation, far from being interpreted as a sign of decadence, was actively encouraged. In fact, innovation or stark individualism most often met with rejection; critics openly scoffed at the initial Impressionist exhibitions. As previously intoned however, Moreau only looked to those elements of High Renaissance art, that would further his artistic aims, and not for popular appeal. He eschewed traditional Romantic heroism and narrative in favor of a depiction of the mysterious and the private experience of the individual.40 Moreau's mystical images were worlds away from the growing urbanization and industrial progress of the latter half of the 19th century. He deplored the materialism and the increasing reliance upon and belief in the magical powers of science, which were becoming so commonplace. He felt that these new values threatened the very foundations of great art and abhorred the decay in standards of behavior and art he perceived in his surroundings: "but when proud materiality, when the low soul of the greedy and sensual wants to take precedence in this new civilization over the soul and thought, I feel only contempt and hatred in my heart."41 Kaplan writes that: "Because vol. 17, no. 1 67

completely mythical. Coupled with a veneration <strong>of</strong> the past, is the elevation <strong>of</strong><br />

the world <strong>of</strong> the imagination over real life, a turning inward to a realm <strong>of</strong> fantasy<br />

and refined sensation. Moreau's own life became increasingly solitary, as he<br />

grew older and more disenchanted with the increasing anomie <strong>of</strong> urban life.<br />

<strong>The</strong>se aspects <strong>of</strong> Moreau's art mirror des Esseintes' denial <strong>of</strong> the modem<br />

world and his efforts to assert his own self, his uniqueness, in the ever-growing<br />

modern metropolis. Moreau was, Proust wrote, "one <strong>of</strong> those who have an<br />

inner soul into which they can sometimes penetrate. <strong>The</strong> rest <strong>of</strong> their life is a<br />

kind <strong>of</strong> exile, <strong>of</strong>ten voluntary, not sad, but tedious."34<br />

This escape to an inner realm is evident on a more subtle level in<br />

Moreau's work through the use <strong>of</strong> the arabesque, a form which fascinated<br />

Moreau. <strong>The</strong> arabesque as plastic equivalent to the soul in all its mystery was<br />

discussed by many artists and poets. 35 With its Greek and Oriental connotations<br />

it also embodied the "ideal and the universal" for Moreau. 36 Its labyrinth<br />

form suggests unreason and irregularity, and the proliferation <strong>of</strong> the arabesque<br />

form in much <strong>of</strong> Moreau's work implies the mysterious or the enigmatic. Moreau<br />

was drawn to mysticism, and wished to explore the arcane realms <strong>of</strong> thought<br />

and spirit, realms that were untouchable and divineY <strong>The</strong> arabesque is associated<br />

with mystery, the world <strong>of</strong> the unconscious. Wonderful arabesques <strong>of</strong><br />

line and color are evident in the unfinished <strong>The</strong> Unicorns (1887-88) or in <strong>The</strong><br />

Apparition (1874-76). <strong>The</strong> arabesque in painting adds to the mystery. <strong>The</strong> clear<br />

lines <strong>of</strong> heroic Renaissance art are in sharp cont~ast to the mysteriousness<br />

deliberately fostered by Moreau. <strong>The</strong> swirling motion <strong>of</strong> the arabesque is<br />

perhaps most evident in some <strong>of</strong> Moreau's abstract sketches <strong>of</strong> pure color,<br />

which contain little or no figurative detail, but beautiful swathes <strong>of</strong> paint with<br />

the evocative power <strong>of</strong> the most compelling <strong>of</strong> the modern abstract expressionists.<br />

Moreau was extremely preoccupied with the mystery and idealism <strong>of</strong><br />

Christianity. Like 1. K. Huysmans, who finally converted to Catholicism following<br />

his dabbles in decadence and Satan ism, Christianity appealed to many<br />

artists <strong>of</strong> the fin-de-siecle, who were disenchanted by the materialism <strong>of</strong> their<br />

peers.<br />

III. THECOUN1ER-ARGUMENT: DECADENCE AS NEITHER A BLACK<br />

NORVflllTEPROPOSrnON<br />

Viewed on a superficial level, the artificiality, gender confusion, the<br />

unnatural treatment <strong>of</strong> the female subject, and general rejection <strong>of</strong> reality would<br />

quickly condemn Moreau's art to the dungeons <strong>of</strong> decadence. If decadence in<br />

art is characterized by extreme maturity, a proliferation <strong>of</strong> detail, an extremely<br />

complicated style, a pr<strong>of</strong>usion <strong>of</strong> color and the tendency to translate the passions<br />

in a depraved or obsessive manner, then Moreau's art must be judged as<br />

high decadence. Along with the considerable popularity <strong>of</strong> his work among<br />

66<br />

<strong>Art</strong> <strong>Criticism</strong>

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!