The Big MAC - Aon

The Big MAC - Aon The Big MAC - Aon

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Big</strong> <strong>MAC</strong><br />

Multi Asset Credit -<br />

<strong>The</strong> simple way to<br />

access credit markets


1 Global Investment Consulting<br />

Summary<br />

Has the long-awaited secular rise in interest rates finally<br />

started? How should investors reposition their corporate<br />

bond portfolios to avoid capital losses and achieve a decent<br />

return over cash?<br />

<strong>The</strong>re is a myriad of choices, which we detailed in our<br />

previous papers*:<br />

• Investment Grade Corporate Bonds.<br />

• High Yield Corporate Bonds<br />

• Loans<br />

• Asset Backed Bonds<br />

• Emerging Market Bonds<br />

Pick one, pick two, or pick them all!<br />

Just as a visit to the Golden Arches can leave a hungry diner<br />

confused by the multitude of burger based meal choices,<br />

the same can be said for yield hungry credit investors. But<br />

with careful attention to the menu, investors should find<br />

something to satisfy.<br />

(*) Give Me Credit! (October 2012) and Derisking when yields are low<br />

(November 2012).<br />

A Clear and Present Danger<br />

A survey of managers at our annual <strong>Aon</strong> Hewitt manager<br />

conference highlighted Investment Grade Corporate Bond Funds<br />

as the asset class most likely to perform poorly this year (apart<br />

from gilts).<br />

Why is this?<br />

• If gilt yields rise back to their 10 year average, corporate<br />

bond portfolios could fall around 15%.<br />

• Even if the rise in yields is mitigated by credit spreads<br />

narrowing to 10 year record levels, the loss would still be<br />

over 10%<br />

<strong>The</strong> recent rise in government bond yields has brought this<br />

simple maths to the attention of investors and current Lipper data<br />

shows that outflows from corporate bond funds are now close to<br />

record levels.<br />

What to do?<br />

<strong>The</strong> answer is to invest in funds which focus primarily on credit<br />

risk, rather than funds which mix credit risk and interest rate<br />

risk together.<br />

But which one?<br />

<strong>The</strong> table (overleaf) shows that no one credit asset class has<br />

consistently outperformed the others. Performance has been<br />

adjusted to show excess returns over LIBOR cash rates (thereby<br />

stripping out the impact of duration).<br />

<strong>The</strong> answer is an active fund that can tactically shift allocation<br />

between various credit classes. This could include funds that<br />

allocate between just a few asset classes or funds that can invest<br />

across the whole credit universe.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Big</strong> <strong>MAC</strong><br />

Credit Asset Class 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013<br />

Investment Grade<br />

Corporates<br />

-0.65 2.32 1.31 0.19 0.48 -2.14 -13.92 10.38 0.67 -4.18 7.13 2.05<br />

High Yield -15.33 22.45 9.39 3.61 8.12 -4.55 -42.91 61.59 10.34 -7.10 18.02 5.11<br />

Sub Financials -0.52% 3.42% 2.03% 0.72% 0.85% -4.21% -28.74% 19.16% 1.35% 14.53% 23.78% 5.01%<br />

ABS n/a n/a 0.40 0.56 0.52 -7.49 -46.68 8.82 21.82 -5.69 15.76 5.19<br />

Loans n/a 1.45 3.29 3.69 3.34 -4.81 -34.44 42.51 9.27 -0.48 9.40 6.06<br />

Emerging Market<br />

Corporates<br />

-14.14 11.76 5.48 3.83 2.54 -4.69 -31.75 39.27 6.36 -4.15 12.31 -0.45<br />

Key Best Performing Worst Performing<br />

Source: ML Lynch Data (EN00, HEAD EBSU) 30/06/2013, Credit Suisse Loan (Credit Suisse Western Europe)<br />

and Barclays ABS (ABS Bond Index ex AAA) 31/12/2012. Merrill Lynch returns are excess returns over swaps<br />

(no duration). Floating Rate Loans and ABS are total returns excluding Euribor


Global Investment Consulting<br />

2<br />

<strong>The</strong>re are many funds that fall under the <strong>MAC</strong> moniker. <strong>The</strong>y can<br />

range from simple combinations of a few closely related asset<br />

classes, such as High Yield and Loans as outlined below, through<br />

to funds that invest across the whole spectrum of credit asset<br />

classes - outlined later in this paper.<br />

Manager approaches can vary from a focus on delivering credit<br />

beta, through to ambitious LIBOR- plus targeted funds.<br />

What is common to them all is a keen focus on credit spreads and<br />

a low, if any, reliance on duration and currency to achieve the<br />

target return.<br />

Combined High Yield and Loan Funds:<br />

Both High Yield and Loans can be attractive asset classes:<br />

But Which one?<br />

• Loans are generally more senior and have better recovery<br />

rates should they default; but they can be illiquid, particularly<br />

in Europe.<br />

• High Yield bonds are usually the next step down in the<br />

seniority of the capital structure and offer greater liquidity,<br />

but the recovery in default is lower and they are sensitive to<br />

changes in bond yields.<br />

However, the similarities are greater than the differences:<br />

• Both are driven by bottom up credit analysis and<br />

default avoidance.<br />

• Often the issuers are similar, or even the same, since much<br />

of the universe is the result of leveraged buy-outs<br />

Global High Yield and Loans Market ($2.6 Tr)<br />

Full Spectrum Multi Asset Credit<br />

As one credit asset class cannot provide the best returns all of<br />

the time, active allocation <strong>MAC</strong> strategies are needed. <strong>The</strong>se<br />

portfolios allow managers access to more tools with a wider<br />

freedom to seek best in class returns throughout the credit cycle.<br />

Rather than focus primarily on bottom-up stock selection the<br />

manger is challenged to combine these skills with a top-down<br />

macro view to ensure effective sector rotation within the credit<br />

universe of developed, and increasingly, of emerging economies.<br />

In times of economic expansion, when corporate earnings are<br />

strongest, a manager could choose to allocate to higher credit<br />

beta sectors such as High Yield and Loans, and in times of<br />

economic downturn seek the protection of the stronger balance<br />

sheets offered by Investment Grade companies.<br />

Neither Filet o’ Fish nor Fowl McNuggets<br />

Investors need to know where <strong>MAC</strong> should be on their menu.<br />

As a new style of investing, albeit using established sub-asset<br />

classes of credit, it can be confusing as many features will be<br />

used in other strategies. So having outlined what <strong>MAC</strong> strategies<br />

should do it’s worth clarifying what they are not, and what they<br />

should not do.<br />

• <strong>The</strong>y are not Absolute Return Bond Funds, they do not focus<br />

on seeking alpha from duration or currency positioning.<br />

• <strong>The</strong>y do not cling to the yield curve and riding the fair-wind<br />

of a positively sloped yield curve and, until recently at least,<br />

falling bond yields.<br />

• Although they may be active users of derivatives such as<br />

credit indices and Exchange Traded Funds to control sector<br />

exposures,they are not Hedge Funds. <strong>The</strong>y do not use<br />

leverage or go short.<br />

US Loan Market<br />

Global Credit Market ($9.0 Tr)<br />

US High<br />

Yield Bond<br />

Market<br />

European<br />

Loan Market<br />

High Yield<br />

European High<br />

Yield Bond Market<br />

Loans<br />

Investment<br />

Grade<br />

In Europe especially, markets are becoming increasingly<br />

integrated as issuers switch between loans and high yield<br />

depending on market conditions. Much of the new High-Yield<br />

issuance seen recently in Europe has been ‘senior secured’,<br />

ranking it pari-passu with loans.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Big</strong> <strong>MAC</strong><br />

So what are the advantages of combining the two asset classes in<br />

a single fund?<br />

• A bigger market which maximises diversification and provides<br />

a bigger opportunity set from which managers can select<br />

their best investment ideas.<br />

• Pricing inefficiency caused by individual asset class flows can<br />

create over, or under valuations between loans and high-yield<br />

that the manager of a combined portfolio can exploit. Often<br />

these opportunities occur within the same company.<br />

Emerging<br />

Market Corporates<br />

Conclusion<br />

Source: Barclays, S&P and Credit Suisse<br />

<strong>MAC</strong> funds primarily seek to receive income from managing<br />

credit beta. Either from a simple combination of a few credit<br />

classes, or from more complex combinations of global credit beta.<br />

Where possible, they should also seek opportunities to invest<br />

both up, and down, company capital structures.<br />

Longer term, credit markets are likely to become a bigger part of<br />

the investable universe. <strong>The</strong> effects of banking disintermediation<br />

are already starting to be seen and the on-going deleveraging by<br />

the banking sector will accelerate this.<br />

This dynamic at a time when investors are rightly questioning the<br />

risks that passive duration exposure in growth portfolios pose<br />

should focus more attention on credit asset classes and seek ways<br />

to combine them to meet their investment goals.


Contacts<br />

Birmingham<br />

Mike Johnson<br />

0121 262 5076<br />

michael.johnson@aonhewitt.com<br />

St Albans<br />

Darren Kidd<br />

01727 888 670<br />

darren.kidd@aonhewitt.com<br />

Bristol<br />

Kate Charsley<br />

0117 900 4414<br />

kate.charsley@aonhewitt.com<br />

Asset Allocation<br />

Lucinda Downing<br />

020 7086 9440<br />

lucinda.downing@aonhewitt.com<br />

Edinburgh<br />

Kenneth Ettles<br />

0131 456 6426<br />

kenneth.ettles@aonhewitt.com<br />

Delegated Consulting<br />

Paul Carne<br />

020 7086 9042<br />

paul.carne@aonhewitt.com<br />

Farnborough<br />

Peter Jackson<br />

01252 768 035<br />

peter.jackson@aonhewitt.com<br />

Manager Research<br />

Steve Sawyer<br />

020 7086 9286<br />

steve.sawyer@aonhewitt.com<br />

Leeds<br />

Tim Manuel<br />

0113 291 5038<br />

timothy.manuel@aonhewitt.com<br />

Risk & Modelling<br />

Yves Josseaume<br />

020 7086 9157<br />

yves.josseaume@aonhewitt.com<br />

London<br />

Sophie Moore<br />

020 7086 9209<br />

sophie.moore.3@aonhewitt.com<br />

Disclaimer<br />

Nothing in this document should be treated as an authoritative statement of the law on any particular<br />

aspect or in any specific case. It should not be taken as financial advice and action should not be taken as a<br />

result of this document alone.<br />

Unless we provide express prior written consent, no part of this document should be reproduced,<br />

distributed or communicated. This document is based upon information available to us at the date of this<br />

document and takes no account of subsequent developments. In preparing this document we may have<br />

relied upon data supplied to us by third parties and therefore no warranty or guarantee of accuracy or<br />

completeness is provided. We cannot be held accountable for any error, omission or misrepresentation<br />

of any data provided to us by any third party. This document is not intended by us to form a basis of any<br />

decision by any third party to do or omit to do anything. Any opinion or assumption in this document is<br />

not intended to imply, nor should be interpreted as conveying, any form of guarantee or assurance by us<br />

of any future performance or compliance with legal, regulatory, administrative or accounting procedures<br />

or regulations and accordingly we make no warranty and accept no responsibility for consequences arising<br />

from relying on this document.<br />

Copyright © 2013 <strong>Aon</strong> Hewitt Limited<br />

<strong>Aon</strong> Hewitt Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England<br />

& Wales. Registered No: 4396810.<br />

Registered Office: 8 Devonshire Square, London EC2M 4PL<br />

About <strong>Aon</strong> Hewitt<br />

<strong>Aon</strong> Hewitt is the global leader in human resource consulting and outsourcing solutions. <strong>The</strong> company<br />

partners with organizations to solve their most complex benefits, talent and related financial challenges,<br />

and improve business performance. <strong>Aon</strong> Hewitt designs, implements, communicates and administers a<br />

wide range of human capital, retirement, investment management, health care, compensation and talent<br />

management strategies. With more than 29,000 professionals in 90 countries, <strong>Aon</strong> Hewitt makes the<br />

world a better place to work for clients and their employees.<br />

For more information on <strong>Aon</strong> Hewitt, please visit www.aonhewitt.com<br />

This document has been produced<br />

using a minimum of 50% recycled<br />

material from a sustainable forest.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!