Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Your Church Choir<br />
Can Sing Mendelssohn!<br />
text, Hör, mein Bitten, Herr, neige dich zu mir.<br />
Later (1847), the composer arranged it for<br />
orchestra. Mendelssohn set a paraphrase of<br />
Psalm 55 by William Bartholomew (1793–<br />
1867), who asked him to compose the<br />
piece. Bartholomew had translated several<br />
of Mendelssohn’s works into English. It was<br />
fi rst performed with organ accompaniment<br />
in 1844. 14 Although he composed it for a<br />
concert, the composer may have hoped to<br />
make it useable to churches by arranging the<br />
accompaniment for organ. Hear My Prayer is<br />
a testimony to Mendelssohn’s ability to absorb<br />
the form of the English anthem. Though<br />
this work enjoyed tremendous popularity<br />
in England during the nineteenth century,<br />
some twentieth century British scholars have<br />
complained that Felix “accommodated his<br />
style to English tastes.” 15 George Bernard<br />
Shaw, the playwright-critic, spoke of it in<br />
reverent tones<br />
[F]or Hear My Prayer. Unless you<br />
can sing those opening lines with<br />
the rarest nobility of tone and the<br />
most touching depth of expression,<br />
your one duty to them is to let them<br />
alone…: Success in delivering them<br />
is only possible to singers who have<br />
the fi nest temperamental sympathy<br />
with their spirit; and anything short<br />
of success is utter failure. 16<br />
The work is divided into four sections—<br />
an introduction for soprano solo joined by<br />
choir in the last two measures, an Allegro<br />
moderato in two parts for solo and chorus,<br />
HELP<br />
WANTED<br />
The Choral Journal<br />
Needs Column Editors<br />
More information can be<br />
found on page 17.<br />
a recitative in which the chorus joins with<br />
brief imitation, and a fi nal section in ternary<br />
form. In the fi nal section, a soprano solo<br />
is followed by an imitative section for the<br />
chorus and then returns with the chorus<br />
underneath at one point, hinting at the imitation<br />
of the middle part.<br />
The Andante opening section consists of<br />
a thirty-three measure soprano solo that<br />
is, at fi rst, cantabile then recitative-like and<br />
returns to the cantabile before the chorus<br />
enters, singing in unison the fi rst phrase of<br />
the soprano solo. This G-major section shifts<br />
abruptly with the solo reentering to the Allegro<br />
moderato and E minor.<br />
This second section of the work also<br />
changes from common meter to 3/8. Until<br />
bar 64, there is a phrase-by-phrase echoing<br />
of the solo by unison choir. At 64, the choir<br />
breaks into parts with solo voice and soprano<br />
line the same. After the choir cadences,<br />
the soloist repeats the phrase that began<br />
this section. The unison choir again responds<br />
but this time a step lower and substituting<br />
an augmented fourth for the perfect fourth<br />
of the solo (Figure 4).<br />
The choir returns with similar parts as<br />
before and progresses to a climax on a 2 for<br />
both solo and sopranos. In block chords, the<br />
combined forces move to a cadence on the<br />
tonic. With one last outburst, “O God, hear<br />
my cry,” the soloist expands the skip in the<br />
fi rst motive of the section to a sixth. The<br />
choir then sings a phrase that ends on an E<br />
major six-fi ve chord which is the transition<br />
to the third section of the piece.<br />
A brief Recitative which becomes a Sostenuto<br />
when the choir joins the solo, the third<br />
section never reaches a point of harmonic<br />
rest until the fi nal D-major chord. One is<br />
only assured of this rest when the next<br />
section begins in the home key of G major.<br />
Melodically, all new material appears in this<br />
section. Only the fi nal unison phrase of the<br />
choir helps connect with what follows. The<br />
choir will reprise unison Ds in the middle of<br />
the fi nal section.<br />
The last section, Con un poco più di moto,<br />
begins with the soloist singing “O for the<br />
wings, for the wings of a dove,” to a poignantly<br />
fl owing melody. As in the Andante,<br />
the choir does not enter until the solo has<br />
presented her melody in its entirety (twentyeight<br />
measures). When the choir enters, they<br />
build up one part at a time from lowest to<br />
highest on the words with which the soloist<br />
began and then break into brief imitation<br />
on a descending arpeggio on the words “far<br />
away” before reaching a climax on a homophonic<br />
statement of those words. Imitation<br />
of a brief stepwise descending motive leads<br />
to a forceful declaration of “remain there for<br />
ever to rest” on unison Ds fi rst in the upper<br />
octave, then in the lower one. As the choir<br />
completes the only signifi cant portion of the<br />
work in which they sing independently of the<br />
soloist, the soloist enters and presents all<br />
but the fi nal phrase of the solo with which<br />
38 Choral Journal • April 2010