TITLE PAGE - acumen - The University of Alabama

TITLE PAGE - acumen - The University of Alabama TITLE PAGE - acumen - The University of Alabama

acumen.lib.ua.edu
from acumen.lib.ua.edu More from this publisher
17.11.2013 Views

etween reaches. All multivariate analyses were conducted in PRIMER (Version 6, Plymouth Marine Labs, Plymouth UK; Clarke & Warwick, 2001). The results from this study were combined with studies from three other cave streams in northeastern Alabama (Huntsman et al. 2011, Chapter 5) and long-term data from forested headwater streams at Coweeta Hydrologic Laboratory Southern Research Station (C53, C54, C55) with- and without-litter exclusion experiment (Wallace et al. 1999, Cross et al. 2006, Meyer et al., 1998) to examine for correlations between organic matter storage and macroinvertebrate biomass. The results from the surface and cave stream studies are comparable because of their similarities in: i) key environmental characteristics (e.g., low amount of primary production in the forested headwater streams Webster et al. 1983, Lowe et al. 1986, Mulholland et al. 1997; Wallace et al. 1999), ii) sampling regimes, and iii) biogeographic regions, which indicates that the the pool of surface species that colonized the streams come from a similar species-pools. This data set was analyzed in Data Desk version 6.1 (Data Description Inc., 1996) using simple linear regression. Data were transformed as needed. Results Water temperature and nutrients Average daily water temperature during the study was 13.5 ° C and varied ±2 ° C. Soluble reactive phosphorus (8-10 µg L -1 ) and NH + 4 -N (4-5 µg L -1 ) were similar and low in both study reaches pre- and post-litter amendment (Table 1). Average NO 3¯-N was similar between reaches pre-litter amendment (258-268 µg L -1 ), but was lower in the manipulation reach following the litter amendment (193 µg L -1 ). Organic matter Mean monthly standing crop organic matter was low in both study reaches prior to the litter amendment, ranging from 9 to 136 g AFDM m -2 . Following the litter amendment, standing 47

crop organic matter significantly increased in the manipulation reach (159-866 g AFDM m -2 ), while levels in the control reach remained low (9-75 g AFDM m -2 ; t-test: df = 8, t = -4.3, P = 0.003; Fig. 1a). Macroinvertebrates Forty-five different invertebrate taxa were identified from the core samples (Table 2). Three taxa were identified as obligate cave species: Crangonyx, Stygobromus, and Caecidotea. Six taxa could not be placed with confidence into either category: Cyclopoida, Harpacticoida, Ostracoda, Oligochaeta, Chydoridae, and Nematoda. The remaining taxa were classified as facultative cave species. Prior to the litter amendment, 23 and 22 taxa were documented from the control and manipulation reaches, respectively. Richness increased in both reaches following the litter amendment, with 31 taxa documented in the control reach and 37 taxa documented in the manipulation reach. The increases in species richness following the litter amendment was driven by increases in Diptera, especially of Chironomidae, and by Plecoptera taxa (Table 2). Total macroinvertebrate biomass from core samples mirrored the patterns in standing crop organic matter (Fig. 1b). Before the litter amendment, total macroinvertebrate biomass in both study reaches was low but increased significantly (~5 times) in the manipulation reach following the litter amendment (Wilcoxon signed rank test: n = 20, W = 44, P = 0.008). Facultative species, rather than obligates, generally dominated total macroinvertebrate biomass in both study reaches before and after the litter amendment. Facultative species accounted for 14- 77% of total macroinvertebrate biomass by date, while obligate cave species accounted for 0- 52% of total macroinvertebrate biomass. The lack of a significant biomass response to detritus amendment by obligate cave taxa (t-test: df = 8, t = 1.1, P = 0.31) contrasted with the strong, 48

etween reaches. All multivariate analyses were conducted in PRIMER (Version 6, Plymouth<br />

Marine Labs, Plymouth UK; Clarke & Warwick, 2001).<br />

<strong>The</strong> results from this study were combined with studies from three other cave streams in<br />

northeastern <strong>Alabama</strong> (Huntsman et al. 2011, Chapter 5) and long-term data from forested<br />

headwater streams at Coweeta Hydrologic Laboratory Southern Research Station (C53, C54, C55)<br />

with- and without-litter exclusion experiment (Wallace et al. 1999, Cross et al. 2006, Meyer et al.,<br />

1998) to examine for correlations between organic matter storage and macroinvertebrate biomass.<br />

<strong>The</strong> results from the surface and cave stream studies are comparable because <strong>of</strong> their similarities in:<br />

i) key environmental characteristics (e.g., low amount <strong>of</strong> primary production in the forested<br />

headwater streams Webster et al. 1983, Lowe et al. 1986, Mulholland et al. 1997; Wallace et al.<br />

1999), ii) sampling regimes, and iii) biogeographic regions, which indicates that the the pool <strong>of</strong><br />

surface species that colonized the streams come from a similar species-pools. This data set was<br />

analyzed in Data Desk version 6.1 (Data Description Inc., 1996) using simple linear regression. Data<br />

were transformed as needed.<br />

Results<br />

Water temperature and nutrients<br />

Average daily water temperature during the study was 13.5 ° C and varied ±2 ° C. Soluble<br />

reactive phosphorus (8-10 µg L -1 ) and NH + 4 -N (4-5 µg L -1 ) were similar and low in both study<br />

reaches pre- and post-litter amendment (Table 1). Average NO 3¯-N was similar between reaches<br />

pre-litter amendment (258-268 µg L -1 ), but was lower in the manipulation reach following the<br />

litter amendment (193 µg L -1 ).<br />

Organic matter<br />

Mean monthly standing crop organic matter was low in both study reaches prior to the<br />

litter amendment, ranging from 9 to 136 g AFDM m -2 . Following the litter amendment, standing<br />

47

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!