Authenticity of Kartarpuri Bir - Global Sikh Studies

36
argues that as the Guru Granth became the Guru after the
demise of the tenth Guru it shows that the Kartarpuri Bir was
written after 1708 A. D. Regarding this Jodh Singh comments,
“to make conjectures on the basis of misstatements is a sample
of the kind of research done by the author (G.B Singh).” 43
G.B. Singh writes that in the Kartarpuri Bir the will of one
Niranjan Rai, the great grandson of Dhirmal, stands recorded,
and, considering the likely year of the death of Niranjan Rai,
the Kartarpuri Bir, he suggests, was written not earlier than
Samat 1780. Now, the fact is that on a blank page of the
Kartarpuri Bir another greenish coloured paper stands pasted.
Evidently, the will of Niranjan Rai had been written on a paper,
in an ink, and in a handwriting different from the ones of the
Kartarpuri Bir. It has nothing to do with the Kartarpuri Bir except
that some one has later pasted the greenish paper containing
the will on a blank page of the Granth. In this regard Jodh
Singh observes that this is another ridiculous instance of the
senseless fabrications made by G.B. Singh. Citing more such
instances, Jodh Singh concludes that G.B. Singh on the basis
of some wrong statements of Kahan Singh mentioned in a
letter, coupled with some false facts introduced by him, has,
without verifying them by a look at the Kartarpuri Bir, made
assertions which he describes as his research. “In fact every
literate person should be ashamed of the manner in which G.B.
Singh has abused the word research.” 44
As to the Banno Bir, the reply of the custodian shows
that 12 scribes worked in preparing the same. He also writes
that some one had informed him that from Rag Kanara onwards
the entire Banno Bir was in one hand. G.B Singh tries to brush
aside this contradiction by saying that, may be, the leaves of
Banno Bir got old and someone got them replaced and rewritten
(actually the finding of the scholars, Harbhajan Singh. Harnam
Dass, is that the entire Banno Bir is in one hand). On page 271
of his book, G.B.