Authenticity of Kartarpuri Bir - Global Sikh Studies

35
Salok is not in the Mohan Pothies, it is on the face of it absurd
to accuse the fifth Guru of fear, especially when there is nothing
to suggest that the Salok was ever placed before Guru Arjun
for inclusion in the Adi-Granfh and that he refused to do so.” 37
In one chapter of his book, Jodh Singh describes the
‘farbrications’ indulged in by the author, G.B. Singh, regarding
the Adi-Granth, and, in the second, he describes the ‘untruthful
statements’ made by the author regarding the Adi-Granth. 38
Citing a number of wrong statements by the author, Jodh Singh
writes: “Had G.B. Singh seen the Kartarpuri Bir, he would out
of sheer shame have never made such baseless statements.” 39
G.B. Singh’s Sense of interpreting things is equally ridiculous.
The words “Pothi Likh Pauhnche”, indicating that the Granth
was completed on that date’, he says, mean that Bhai Banno
had reached Lahore on that date after copying the Adi-Granth
on the way. 40 On the one hand G.B. Singh writes that the
Kartarpuri Bir could not have been copied before Samat 1733,
and, on the other hand, he states it was copied in Samat 1697. 41
Many statements of G.B. Singh are so self-contradictory that
Jodh Singh describes them to be “ridiculously absurd”. Further,
G.B. Singh asserts that in the Kartarpuri Bir all dates of demise
are in the same hand and that those were written in Samat
1717-18 by the 8th Guru. Hence the Granth was written not
earlier than 1718, he concludes. We have already seen that
this is a wrong statement and could be made only by a person
like G,B. Singh who had never seen the Kartarpuri Bir. Yet, at
many places in his book he never shirked from making
numerous wrong assertions about its contents. It is in this
context Dr. Jodh Singh cites the Persian proverb: “The liar has
no memory” and the Punjabi proverb: “The Lies have no legs
to stand firm.” 42 In the Kartarpuri Bir the word Pothi is used to
describe the Adi-Granth and not Guru Baba, but G.B. Singh