Authenticity of Kartarpuri Bir - Global Sikh Studies

12
the left is 15 and not 15/1. Secondly, after making a rough
guess about the Bani likely to be available for each section or
Rag, one or more clusters or bunches of eight leaves each,
numbered in advance, were allotted for each Rag or section of
the Bani. And, as and when the Bani, or part of it, of a particular
Rag, section, Guru, or Bhagat was available, it was sorted out
and copied out at the appropriate places in the concerned
packets or sections, in a particular, or proper sequence.
Though, as we have seen, the numbering of the pages had
been given inside of a leaf, for the convenience of identifying
the concerned packets (which had, evidently to be kept loose
or unbound), without the need of opening them, the outside
of the first leaf of the cluster or packet had been marked by
the page number borne by its inside, i.e. a packed starting with
page 33 on the inside of its first leaf would also bear number
33 on the outside of it, though in the bound book it would be
the right-half page of page 32 or 32/2. All the same, the
adoption of this method of marking was essential in readily
picking up and identifying packets for the purpose of recording
any Sabad, Shalok or Var in the assigned packet or packets at
the appropriate place, or section. We shall see later that while
the adoption of this method was convenient and necessary
for the day to day working, it led to some mistakes. As indicated
already, totals of Padas, Sabads, or Shaloks of each Guru or
author, or the totals of the Sabads of each Rag are also serially
given.
We shall hereafter record internal pieces of evidence
into two parts: (i) those that are individually conclusive in their
evidentiary value, and, (ii) those that are, coupled with other
evidence, conclusive in showing the authenticity of the Bir.
4. Individually conclusive facts
1. G. B. Singh who suspected the originality of the