3. Strain, Christopher Barry. “Civil Rights and ... - Freedom Archives

3. Strain, Christopher Barry. “Civil Rights and ... - Freedom Archives 3. Strain, Christopher Barry. “Civil Rights and ... - Freedom Archives

freedomarchives.org
from freedomarchives.org More from this publisher
26.10.2013 Views

grant earmarked for an urban renewal project, "Cleveland: NOW!". Bureaucrats within Stokes' administration had allocated the grant money, and Stokes became known as a benefactor of cop-killing revolutionaries . The embarrassing incident tarnished the mayor's legacy.° It is unclear why and how the shooting in Cleveland really began . No one knows who fired the first shots 9~ Because a situation existed in which any catalyst could have triggered bloodshed, it does not really matter. Both sides were primed for violence . Each expected a confrontation; each, to a certain degree, desired it . Cleveland's police officers, like those in Oakland, were white. Some had emigrated from the southern states, and brought with them all the racial assumptions associated with that region ; or, they had descended from immigrants who had worked their way out of the slums . Many were not predisposed to empathize with the plight of blacks living in the ghetto . On the other side, Ahmed Evens and his comrades-in-arms were itching for a fight . The shootout in Cleveland seemed to bear credence to the notions that merely having weapons at hand created an impetus to use them, and that those who go looking for trouble often find it . It is certainly within the realm of possibility that Ahmed Evens 9°For more on Mayor Stokes and the Ahmed Evens incident, see Estelle Zannes, Ch~kmate in Cleveland : The Rhetoric of Confrontation During th (Cleveland: Case Western University Press, 1972). 9rAn exhaustive investigation by the Civil Violence Reseat+ch Center at Case Western Reserve University, under the direction of Louis H. Maseru and Jerome R. Corsi, proved inconclusive . Maseru and Corsi's report soundly condemned police conduct in Cleveland's black neighborhoods . See Maseru and Corsi, Shootout in Cleveland: A Report Submitted to t_he National Commission_ on_~ Ca_us~s_ aid P~,wention of Violence (New York : Bantam Books, 1969) . 190

and his band waylaid the Cleveland police. If so, this incident marked the complete metamorphosis of self-defense into an offensive action, or non-defensive assault . Evens' actions represented a severe deviation from the kind of defensive measures recommended by Malcolm X, and by the Deacons for Defense and Justice a few years before. Perhaps the brand of self-defense practiced by Evens represented a necessary step toward a revolutionary consciousness . But it subsequently compromised any legitimate claim to self-defense, as understood in most legal and ethical frameworks, and marked the end of an era of relative progress in black-white relations, especially compared to what would follow . By 1968, self-defense as understood by the civil rights vanguard had come to signify something quite different than it had in 1955, and it only partially related to conventional notions of self-protection . Guns were flooding not only black communities but also white communities around the counay, which geared up on both sides of the racial divide for a race war that never came' The rhetoric of self-defense had assumed an ominous tone by 1968 . A resolution adopted at the Black Students' Conference at Central State University of Ohio dalar+ed : We assert the right of Black students who arc experiencing political and violent suppression to respond in kind. We see the Orangeburg Massacre as a lesson which teaches the necessity of self-defense . Our motto is: Avenge Orangeburg 9a Black nationalists outlined "black survival curriculums" which detailed self-defense and 9ZSee "Guns!," 17 (August 1968): 22-26 . 93Reprinted in C. Eric Lincoln, ed., Is Any~y Listening to Black America? (New York: Seabury Press, 1968), 150 .

grant earmarked for an urban renewal project, "Clevel<strong>and</strong>: NOW!". Bureaucrats within<br />

Stokes' administration had allocated the grant money, <strong>and</strong> Stokes became known as a<br />

benefactor of cop-killing revolutionaries . The embarrassing incident tarnished the<br />

mayor's legacy.°<br />

It is unclear why <strong>and</strong> how the shooting in Clevel<strong>and</strong> really began . No one knows<br />

who fired the first shots 9~ Because a situation existed in which any catalyst could have<br />

triggered bloodshed, it does not really matter. Both sides were primed for violence . Each<br />

expected a confrontation; each, to a certain degree, desired it . Clevel<strong>and</strong>'s police officers,<br />

like those in Oakl<strong>and</strong>, were white. Some had emigrated from the southern states, <strong>and</strong><br />

brought with them all the racial assumptions associated with that region ; or, they had<br />

descended from immigrants who had worked their way out of the slums . Many were not<br />

predisposed to empathize with the plight of blacks living in the ghetto .<br />

On the other side, Ahmed Evens <strong>and</strong> his comrades-in-arms were itching for a<br />

fight . The shootout in Clevel<strong>and</strong> seemed to bear credence to the notions that merely<br />

having weapons at h<strong>and</strong> created an impetus to use them, <strong>and</strong> that those who go looking<br />

for trouble often find it . It is certainly within the realm of possibility that Ahmed Evens<br />

9°For more on Mayor Stokes <strong>and</strong> the Ahmed Evens incident, see Estelle Zannes,<br />

Ch~kmate in Clevel<strong>and</strong> : The Rhetoric of Confrontation During th<br />

(Clevel<strong>and</strong>: Case Western University Press, 1972).<br />

9rAn exhaustive investigation by the Civil Violence Reseat+ch Center at Case Western<br />

Reserve University, under the direction of Louis H. Maseru <strong>and</strong> Jerome R. Corsi, proved<br />

inconclusive . Maseru <strong>and</strong> Corsi's report soundly condemned police conduct in<br />

Clevel<strong>and</strong>'s black neighborhoods . See Maseru <strong>and</strong> Corsi, Shootout in Clevel<strong>and</strong>: A<br />

Report Submitted to t_he National Commission_ on_~ Ca_us~s_ aid P~,wention of Violence<br />

(New York : Bantam Books, 1969) .<br />

190

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!