Negro Digest - Freedom Archives
Negro Digest - Freedom Archives Negro Digest - Freedom Archives
complete without dealing in a large way with students . If a summary of the arguments can be attempted, the authors seem to be saying that somewhere near the heart of the problems confronting the black community is what Carter G. Woodson called "the mis-education of the Negro." This "mis-education" consists principally in the education of black scholars to feel contempt for themselves and for the black community . By failing to confront them with adequate knowledge about themselves, both to counter white stereotypes and to bolster their self-confidence, the Negro colleges have also failed to develop meaningful helping relationships between black scholars and the balck community . Accustomed to facile imitations of white middle class life styles, Negro colleges have failed to plumb the depths of the black experience : Thus, Stephen Henderson underlines the contention that in the search for identity, "the black experience is not only relevant . . . it is fundamental and crucial" .a A strengthened sense of identity will produce not only a black university which serves the Black American community ; it will create the indispensable pre-condition for new linkages with the entire Third World . A unique internationalism will be created in which, according to Vincent Handing, "the uniqueness of our approach to the world would be found in our vision through an unashamedly black- 76 oriented prism . In the academic program and in a hundred other less structured ways, the black university would seek to explore, celebrate and record the experience of the non-western world." 4 Similarly, Gerald McWarter views as a key component of the very meaning of Blackness the "affirmation of an identity independent of the historical human evils of modern nation states ." 5 The significant problem encountered here is not adequately stated in terms of the simply dichotemy of integration versus separatism . The real question is whether this statement of mission and strategy does justice to the facts and the logic of the very black experience it claims to celebrate . This writer has no quarrel with the objectives of a Black University which seeks to serve the needs of the black community, nor with the concern for more adequate study and dramatization of events in the black experience, nor with the desire to create unquestionably intelligent and competent centers of learning for black people . Nonetheless, as is well known, agreement on specific objectives and even on particular tactical points does not necessarily mean agreement on underlying issues embedded in the strategy itself. This writer wishes to focus on but one of such issues with the hope of clarifying some of the strategic questions raised . The issue can be introduced by March 1969 NEGRO DIGEST
aising a question regarding in exactly what ways does the black experience address the problem of racism encountered by the black community in the areas of housing and employment, for example . What curricular expression of the black experience would relate the black university more effectively to the black community? Is the creation of a black consciousness in the minds and hearts of black people more important than assisting them with their daily struggle for survival? Are the two problems the same thing? Anyone familiar with the long and often bitter struggle in our colleges and universities not only to get "Black Studies," but a particular ideological brand of Black Studies, will know that these are not trivial questions . ' In a footnote to a widely talked about but seldom read volume, Frantz Fanon makes an important observation about the decision of the president of Senegal "to include the study of the idea of Negro-ism in the curriculum . If this decision was due to an anxiety to study historical causes, no one can criticize it. But if on the other hand it was taken in order to create black selfconsciousness, it is simply a turning of his back upon history" .° The point Fanon is making is that the people are helped not by excessive investments in the study of the people's culture but by addressing current problems felt by the people . Of the four authors who discuss ,the curriculum of the black uni- NEGRO DIGEST March 1969 versity, three of them (McWorter, Henderson, and Harding) seem to give clear priority to the humanistic sciences . Henderson is quite explicit that "such a university would almost by definition involve chiefly those disciplines which are humancentered, i.e., the social sciences, the behavioral sciences, literature, art and the like ."g Moreover, "the faculty of the University (would) be staffed with Black Humanists and Specialists in Blackness" .s And although he says that the non-humanistic sciences "should have . . . an honored place in the curriculum",1° it is obvious where the resources of such a university would be invested . I want to state the strongest possible disagreement with this bifurcation of the black experience . It is the logical outcome of a narrow conception of black identity which, if actually pursued, would isolate the black university even further than some of these same authors say it is today from the black community . If, as Stokely Carmichael and Charles Hamilton persuasively argue, "the process of, political modernization must take place"~l in both the black and white communities in order to treat adequately the problems of racism, then a Black University which invests a preponderance of its resources in black humanistic studies is seriously dis advantaged in its intentions to help (Coruinued on page 96) 77
- Page 125 and 126: else suggests that the group is bac
- Page 127 and 128: e established far Black students th
- Page 129 and 130: A Dual Responsibility The White Uni
- Page 131 and 132: a situation in a different manner w
- Page 133 and 134: Black Perspective A cU~TU~~L, ~~~I~
- Page 135 and 136: life-style, yet they persist in the
- Page 137 and 138: plex (a viable institution in that
- Page 139 and 140: The Positiveness of Separation BL~C
- Page 141 and 142: white students are, except that wha
- Page 143 and 144: did) to thesis students who then gr
- Page 145 and 146: Roach, Harold Cruse, Rhody Mc- Coy,
- Page 147 and 148: conferees attempted to eject white
- Page 149 and 150: ~. iii1~i-i Black Life, White "Expe
- Page 151 and 152: BOOKS Black Writing : this is u, th
- Page 153 and 154: Grow old? Maan! I ain't never Gonna
- Page 155 and 156: answering ; "Monday. That is if tha
- Page 157 and 158: at a time when the ratio of Negro d
- Page 159 and 160: A Special Experience xox .a~, xi .:
- Page 161 and 162: to comment that I was a typical cre
- Page 163 and 164: students said, "Didn't Malcolm prea
- Page 165 and 166: What I did object to was the effort
- Page 167 and 168: with American education, period. Ho
- Page 169 and 170: President Emeritus, Morehouse Colle
- Page 171 and 172: them, there just aren't enough blac
- Page 173 and 174: I cannot see the sponsorship for su
- Page 175: economic changes now occurring with
- Page 179 and 180: to say that "yet an irreverent revi
- Page 181 and 182: Fire ; steal it, borrow it or wait
- Page 183 and 184: lures and yet, in a most interestin
- Page 185 and 186: and what is the right procedure for
- Page 187 and 188: mentioned earlier, the whole black
- Page 189 and 190: (C) Consistency of Thought and Acti
- Page 191 and 192: J. .JICLCfj ._Jd .L'~ .FU~~e ; one
- Page 193 and 194: must carry a greater sexual burden
- Page 195 and 196: C.~e~or 3 l /ot~e3-- (Continued fro
- Page 197 and 198: and that prepares them to deal effe
- Page 199 and 200: THE DUKE NATURAL S ET EASY COMB let
- Page 202 and 203: BLACK HISTORY BLACK POWER U .S .A .
- Page 204 and 205: ~re~atorc~ ~o~e~- THE BLACK UNIVERS
- Page 206 and 207: "1lTew Creation or Familiar Deatla"
- Page 208 and 209: contradictions they entail . Furthe
- Page 210 and 211: As northern universities continue t
- Page 212 and 213: Response to Vincent Harding 12 BY R
- Page 214 and 215: was then running for the state asse
- Page 216 and 217: e done without some base of support
- Page 218 and 219: amount of emphasis-both in Bro . Mo
- Page 220 and 221: m~,irofir_- ~r- ir;r_ rr_~,~r; v;~~
- Page 222 and 223: Institute of the Black World : Basi
- Page 224 and 225: In Chicago, movement toward the Bla
aising a question regarding in exactly<br />
what ways does the black experience<br />
address the problem of<br />
racism encountered by the black<br />
community in the areas of housing<br />
and employment, for example .<br />
What curricular expression of the<br />
black experience would relate the<br />
black university more effectively to<br />
the black community? Is the creation<br />
of a black consciousness in the<br />
minds and hearts of black people<br />
more important than assisting them<br />
with their daily struggle for survival?<br />
Are the two problems the<br />
same thing? Anyone familiar with<br />
the long and often bitter struggle<br />
in our colleges and universities not<br />
only to get "Black Studies," but a<br />
particular ideological brand of<br />
Black Studies, will know that these<br />
are not trivial questions .<br />
' In a footnote to a widely talked<br />
about but seldom read volume,<br />
Frantz Fanon makes an important<br />
observation about the decision of<br />
the president of Senegal "to include<br />
the study of the idea of <strong>Negro</strong>-ism<br />
in the curriculum . If this decision<br />
was due to an anxiety to study historical<br />
causes, no one can criticize<br />
it. But if on the other hand it was<br />
taken in order to create black selfconsciousness,<br />
it is simply a turning<br />
of his back upon history" .° The<br />
point Fanon is making is that the<br />
people are helped not by excessive<br />
investments in the study of the people's<br />
culture but by addressing current<br />
problems felt by the people .<br />
Of the four authors who discuss<br />
,the curriculum of the black uni-<br />
NEGRO DIGEST March 1969<br />
versity, three of them (McWorter,<br />
Henderson, and Harding) seem to<br />
give clear priority to the humanistic<br />
sciences . Henderson is quite explicit<br />
that "such a university would<br />
almost by definition involve chiefly<br />
those disciplines which are humancentered,<br />
i.e., the social sciences,<br />
the behavioral sciences, literature,<br />
art and the like ."g Moreover, "the<br />
faculty of the University (would)<br />
be staffed with Black Humanists<br />
and Specialists in Blackness" .s And<br />
although he says that the non-humanistic<br />
sciences "should have . . .<br />
an honored place in the curriculum",1°<br />
it is obvious where the resources<br />
of such a university would<br />
be invested .<br />
I want to state the strongest possible<br />
disagreement with this bifurcation<br />
of the black experience . It<br />
is the logical outcome of a narrow<br />
conception of black identity which,<br />
if actually pursued, would isolate<br />
the black university even further<br />
than some of these same authors<br />
say it is today from the black community<br />
.<br />
If, as Stokely Carmichael and<br />
Charles Hamilton persuasively argue,<br />
"the process of, political modernization<br />
must take place"~l in<br />
both the black and white communities<br />
in order to treat adequately the<br />
problems of racism, then a Black<br />
University which invests a preponderance<br />
of its resources in black<br />
humanistic studies is seriously dis<br />
advantaged in its intentions to help<br />
(Coruinued on page 96)<br />
77