XXth century_physics

XXth century_physics XXth century_physics

25.10.2013 Views

”The fact that the variables used for describing a dynamical system do not satisfy the commutative law means, of course, that they are not numbers in the sense of the word previously used in mathematics. To distinguish the two kinds of numbers, we shall call the quantum variables q-numbers and the numbers of classical methematics which satisfy the commutative law c-numbers, while the word number alone will be used to denote either a q-number or a c-number. When xy = yx we shall say that x commutes with y. At present one can form no picture of what a q-number is like. One cannot say that one q-number is greater or less than another. All one knows about q-numbers is that if z 1 and z 2 are two q-numbers, or one q number and one c-number, there exist the numbers z 1 + z 2 , z 1 z 2 , z 2 z 1 , which will in general be q-numbers, but may be c-numbers. One knows nothing of the processes by which the numbers are formed except that they satisfy all the ordinary laws of algebra, excluding the commutative law of multiplication...” Dirac (1926) [Measurements always give c numbers]

Solvay Conference 1927

”The fact that the variables used for describing a dynamical system<br />

do not satisfy the commutative law means, of course, that they are<br />

not numbers in the sense of the word previously used in<br />

mathematics. To distinguish the two kinds of numbers, we shall call<br />

the quantum variables q-numbers and the numbers of classical<br />

methematics which satisfy the commutative law c-numbers, while<br />

the word number alone will be used to denote either a q-number or<br />

a c-number. When xy = yx we shall say that x commutes with y.<br />

At present one can form no picture of what a q-number is like. One<br />

cannot say that one q-number is greater or less than another. All<br />

one knows about q-numbers is that if z 1 and z 2 are two q-numbers,<br />

or one q number and one c-number, there exist the numbers<br />

z 1 + z 2 , z 1 z 2 , z 2 z 1 , which will in general be q-numbers, but may be<br />

c-numbers. One knows nothing of the processes by which the<br />

numbers are formed except that they satisfy all the ordinary laws of<br />

algebra, excluding the commutative law of multiplication...”<br />

Dirac (1926)<br />

[Measurements always give c numbers]

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!