Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ...

Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ... Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ...

dspace1.isd.glam.ac.uk
from dspace1.isd.glam.ac.uk More from this publisher
25.10.2012 Views

8.3 Critique of the study 8 DISCUSSION uation. The size of the evaluation group should have been bigger for data on a more quantitative basis. However, the insights gained from the selected evalua- tion group can be regarded as significant on a qualitative basis. It would be ideal in future work to fully implement the HEAT and to use it in a broad field study in a real educational environment, for example a school or a university. 194

9 Conclusions 9 CONCLUSIONS In this chapter the evaluation of each of the objectives of this study will be ad- dressed in turn. The problems and issues that were discussed in chapter 8 are reconsidered in the light of the evaluation of the objectives of the study. The chapter will conclude with suggestions for further work and research. 9.1 Research objectives The three main objectives of this research project, as they have been identified in the literature review in section 2.13 and as they have been addressed during the evaluation and discussion chapters, have been accomplished as stated below. 9.1.1 Creation of a suitable framework for content separation The creation of a framework for the separation of educational from technical con- tent in educational hypermedia was suggested after the literature review and was accomplished at the beginning of this PhD project. The created 3-Layer-Model based on EHPs, TLSs and EMs resulted in the EFTECS framework and addresses the separation of educational and technical content in educational hypermedia. One of the most important issues of this work was the creation of the fine-grained EHPs of teaching and learning strategies within the EHP-layer of the framework. This framework was developed as described in chapter 3. Further on, the EFTECS formed the basis for the XEML and the HEAT and was designed for further ex- tensibility in the future. This extensibility allows the introduction of new EHPs and TLSs as long as the basic EHPs, e.g. HELP-EHP, are included. The results of the interview evaluation in chapter 6, the practical evaluation in chapter 7 and the discussion in chapter 8 show that the EFTECS can be success- fully and effectively used for the separation of the educational and the technical content in educational hypermedia. However, some specific limitations of the framework were discovered especially during the interview evaluation. For example, the complexity of the framework 195

9 Conclusions<br />

9 CONCLUSIONS<br />

In this chapter the evaluation <strong>of</strong> each <strong>of</strong> the objectives <strong>of</strong> this study will be ad-<br />

dressed in turn. The problems and issues that were discussed in chapter 8 are<br />

reconsidered in the light <strong>of</strong> the evaluation <strong>of</strong> the objectives <strong>of</strong> the study.<br />

The chapter will conclude with suggestions for further work and research.<br />

9.1 Research objectives<br />

The three main objectives <strong>of</strong> this research project, as they have been identified in<br />

the literature review in section 2.13 and as they have been addressed during the<br />

evaluation and discussion chapters, have been accomplished as stated below.<br />

9.1.1 Creation <strong>of</strong> a suitable framework for content separation<br />

The creation <strong>of</strong> a framework for the separation <strong>of</strong> educational from technical con-<br />

tent in educational hypermedia was suggested after the literature review and was<br />

accomplished at the beginning <strong>of</strong> this PhD project. The created 3-Layer-Model<br />

based on EHPs, TLSs and EMs resulted in the EFTECS framework and addresses<br />

the separation <strong>of</strong> educational and technical content in educational hypermedia.<br />

One <strong>of</strong> the most important issues <strong>of</strong> this work was the creation <strong>of</strong> the fine-grained<br />

EHPs <strong>of</strong> teaching and learning strategies within the EHP-layer <strong>of</strong> the framework.<br />

This framework was developed as described in chapter 3. Further on, the EFTECS<br />

formed the basis for the XEML and the HEAT and was designed for further ex-<br />

tensibility in the future. This extensibility allows the introduction <strong>of</strong> new EHPs<br />

and TLSs as long as the basic EHPs, e.g. HELP-EHP, are included.<br />

The results <strong>of</strong> the interview evaluation in chapter 6, the practical evaluation in<br />

chapter 7 and the discussion in chapter 8 show that the EFTECS can be success-<br />

fully and effectively used for the separation <strong>of</strong> the educational and the technical<br />

content in educational hypermedia.<br />

However, some specific limitations <strong>of</strong> the framework were discovered especially<br />

during the interview evaluation. For example, the complexity <strong>of</strong> the framework<br />

195

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!