Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ...

Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ... Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ...

dspace1.isd.glam.ac.uk
from dspace1.isd.glam.ac.uk More from this publisher
25.10.2012 Views

8.1 Review of the EFTECS 8 DISCUSSION This observation can be explained by their lack of educational background com- pared to the educational experts. It had been expected that they were not as fast as the educational experts at understanding the concepts of the 3-Layer-Model and the EFTECS. This was observed during the interview evaluation in section 6.2, where the technical experts stated that they had difficulties during the first steps working with the EFTECS. However, at the end of the manual markup task the technical experts said that they were able to use the EFTECS to tag the given material. All the members of the evaluation group stated that they did not have any problems using the EFTECS once they had understood the underlying principles. However, during the manual markup task some problems did occur and were pointed out by the whole evaluation group. Those problems did not regard the EFTECS but the material that had to be tagged during the manual markup task. For example, it was stated that the tagging of pre-existing material was perceived as more difficult than the creation and tagging of the test subjects’ own material. Altogether, it has been shown that the 3-Layer-Model and the EFTECS were com- prehensible and usable by both educational and technical experts. 8.1.2 Content separation The separation of the educational content from the technical content was shown in the interview and in the practical evaluation. The educational experts stated in the interview evaluation (cf. section 6.3) that they could use and apply the EFTECS without any problems. However, this could be the effect of their educational back- ground, because they are used to working with the educational paradigms used in the EFTECS. Therefore, it is also necessary to take the results of the technical experts into consideration for the evaluation of the EFTECS. The technical experts also stated that they were able to use the EFTECS without any problems after they had been given some information about the educational background of the material they had to author. 182

8.1 Review of the EFTECS 8 DISCUSSION Altogether, this means that one of the major goals of the project has been achieved, because the separation of educational and technical content was feasible within the EFTECS and the HEAT paradigm. 8.1.3 Reusability of material The reusability of the created material in other EMs was one of the requirements of this PhD. Only if existing material can be reused, will it be beneficial to educa- tional experts in their work. As it was shown in the interview evaluation and the practical evaluation, educational material has to exist in the content space before it can be reused. This is a basic principle of IT applications, which usually need work input before they can support the users. However, once the material is authored it can be stored in the content space (cf. section 4.6) and further on can be reused by other authors. This reusability of material was confirmed in the interview evaluation (cf. chapter 6) as well as in the practical evaluation (cf. chapter 7) and it was regarded as a major advantage of the EFTECS. Additionally, the search functions based on EHPs were especially useful to the members of the evaluation group (cf. section 6.5.4). After an author has searched and found some educational material, he can insert it into his EM. Altogether, it was shown that material authored with the EFTECS and the HEAT can be reused. 8.1.4 Presentation and communication The 3-Layer-Model and the EFTECS focus on the creation of educational material based on teaching and learning strategies. The EFTECS model provides the option of using different presentation technologies via the physical information layers, but leaves the actual realisation of additional functions to the HEAT or any other technical solution based on the EFTECS. For example, communication between the teacher and the students could be es- tablished by the creation of a special communication TLS and its implementation within the HEAT. This implementation of a communication TLS could also cover 183

8.1 Review <strong>of</strong> the EFTECS 8 DISCUSSION<br />

Altogether, this means that one <strong>of</strong> the major goals <strong>of</strong> the project has been achieved,<br />

because the separation <strong>of</strong> educational and technical content was feasible within the<br />

EFTECS and the HEAT paradigm.<br />

8.1.3 Reusability <strong>of</strong> material<br />

The reusability <strong>of</strong> the created material in other EMs was one <strong>of</strong> the requirements<br />

<strong>of</strong> this PhD. Only if existing material can be reused, will it be beneficial to educa-<br />

tional experts in their work. As it was shown in the interview evaluation and the<br />

practical evaluation, educational material has to exist in the content space before<br />

it can be reused. This is a basic principle <strong>of</strong> IT applications, which usually need<br />

work input before they can support the users.<br />

However, once the material is authored it can be stored in the content space (cf.<br />

section 4.6) and further on can be reused by other authors. This reusability <strong>of</strong><br />

material was confirmed in the interview evaluation (cf. chapter 6) as well as in the<br />

practical evaluation (cf. chapter 7) and it was regarded as a major advantage <strong>of</strong><br />

the EFTECS. Additionally, the search functions based on EHPs were especially<br />

useful to the members <strong>of</strong> the evaluation group (cf. section 6.5.4). After an author<br />

has searched and found some educational material, he can insert it into his EM.<br />

Altogether, it was shown that material authored with the EFTECS and the HEAT<br />

can be reused.<br />

8.1.4 Presentation and communication<br />

The 3-Layer-Model and the EFTECS focus on the creation <strong>of</strong> educational material<br />

based on teaching and learning strategies. The EFTECS model provides the option<br />

<strong>of</strong> using different presentation technologies via the physical information layers,<br />

but leaves the actual realisation <strong>of</strong> additional functions to the HEAT or any other<br />

technical solution based on the EFTECS.<br />

For example, communication between the teacher and the students could be es-<br />

tablished by the creation <strong>of</strong> a special communication TLS and its implementation<br />

within the HEAT. This implementation <strong>of</strong> a communication TLS could also cover<br />

183

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!