Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ...

Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ... Guenter Hilmer - Phd Thesis - Glamorgan Dspace - University of ...

dspace1.isd.glam.ac.uk
from dspace1.isd.glam.ac.uk More from this publisher
25.10.2012 Views

7.4 Summary 7 PRACTICAL EVALUATION 7.4.3 Linking of TLSs The linking of the TLSs was not a problem during the practical evaluation of the HEAT. However, depending on the complexity of the educational material authored the linking structure can become increasingly complex. This complexity was especially observed during the creation of educational material that has not a book like structure. The linking mechanisms implemented in the HEAT worked as foreseen, but the actual realisation of the implementation did not work ideally. For example, the problem of indexed linking that was already identified during the interview eval- uation should be addressed in the future (cf. section 9.2). 7.4.4 EM-Layer Two major problems with the EM-layer were discovered in the practical evalua- tion. Firstly, the HEAT is can not of work with several EMs at the same time. Depend- ing on the educational material that needs to be converted, rather large EMs must be created. Furthermore, the bigger an EM gets the more difficult it is to manage the single TLSs. Secondly, the possibility of inter-EM-linking is not provided currently by the HEAT. However, both problems are a not a design problem of the EFTECS, but an imple- mentation problem of the HEAT which can be solved in future work (cf. section 9.2). 7.4.5 Presentation of the material During the practical evaluation of the HEAT it was found that the presentation of the created and produced material has potential for improvement. Several is- sues concerning the presentations were found, for example the presentation of the 178

7.4 Summary 7 PRACTICAL EVALUATION EHPs themselves or the implementation of multimedia files within the produced material. However, the basic functionality is given and is working error free. During the future work the presentation of the produced material will have to be addressed and improved (cf. section 9.2). 7.4.6 Ease of authoring The ease of authoring and the author’s expertise in the domain of the educational material seem to be directly related to one another. The proficiency of an author in the educational material seems to have an influence on the difficulty of the authoring process. In general, within the given restrictions of its prototype character, the HEAT offers an authoring environment that is expected to provide the user with an easy to use authoring tool for educational hypermedia. 7.4.7 Author’s expertise The results found during the interview evaluation already suggested that educa- tional experts are quite able to produce good educational material with the HEAT. Additionally, the insights gained through the practical evaluation of the HEAT points into the direction that educational experts in a specific domain can create good material with the HEAT. Altogether, it can be stated that the HEAT and EFTECS approach is working within its actual existing boundaries. The HEAT worked as expected during the conversion and creation of the educational material in technical respects, for ex- ample there were no system crashes and no database problems. Some problems, e.g. the conversion of existing material outside the author’s educational domain (cf. section 7.2), were discovered which had not occured in the previous evalua- tion of the framework, but this allows some deeper insights for the whole project. These problems cannot all be solved by this PhD, but possible solutions can be pointed out and described. 179

7.4 Summary 7 PRACTICAL EVALUATION<br />

7.4.3 Linking <strong>of</strong> TLSs<br />

The linking <strong>of</strong> the TLSs was not a problem during the practical evaluation <strong>of</strong><br />

the HEAT. However, depending on the complexity <strong>of</strong> the educational material<br />

authored the linking structure can become increasingly complex. This complexity<br />

was especially observed during the creation <strong>of</strong> educational material that has not a<br />

book like structure.<br />

The linking mechanisms implemented in the HEAT worked as foreseen, but the<br />

actual realisation <strong>of</strong> the implementation did not work ideally. For example, the<br />

problem <strong>of</strong> indexed linking that was already identified during the interview eval-<br />

uation should be addressed in the future (cf. section 9.2).<br />

7.4.4 EM-Layer<br />

Two major problems with the EM-layer were discovered in the practical evalua-<br />

tion.<br />

Firstly, the HEAT is can not <strong>of</strong> work with several EMs at the same time. Depend-<br />

ing on the educational material that needs to be converted, rather large EMs must<br />

be created. Furthermore, the bigger an EM gets the more difficult it is to manage<br />

the single TLSs.<br />

Secondly, the possibility <strong>of</strong> inter-EM-linking is not provided currently by the<br />

HEAT.<br />

However, both problems are a not a design problem <strong>of</strong> the EFTECS, but an imple-<br />

mentation problem <strong>of</strong> the HEAT which can be solved in future work (cf. section<br />

9.2).<br />

7.4.5 Presentation <strong>of</strong> the material<br />

During the practical evaluation <strong>of</strong> the HEAT it was found that the presentation<br />

<strong>of</strong> the created and produced material has potential for improvement. Several is-<br />

sues concerning the presentations were found, for example the presentation <strong>of</strong> the<br />

178

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!