Chapter 2: Proposed Bus Modifications - Metro Gold Line Foothill ...
Chapter 2: Proposed Bus Modifications - Metro Gold Line Foothill ...
Chapter 2: Proposed Bus Modifications - Metro Gold Line Foothill ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
OVERVIEW<br />
This chapter presents the recommended bus interface plan to coincide with the opening of the <strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong><br />
Extension Pasadena to Azusa project in 2015. This project will extend rail service from the existing Sierra Madre Villa<br />
Station in Pasadena 11.4 miles east to the proposed Azusa-Citrus Station, adding six new stations to the regional rail<br />
network. The proposed plan outlined in this chapter reshapes the existing fi xed route bus network around the <strong>Gold</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong> light rail and recommends service levels commensurate with prevailing and projected future land use conditions,<br />
community development objectives, the needs and expectations of transit users as well as short-range fi scal constraints.<br />
The proposed bus network is displayed in Figure 2-1. Individual route recommendations by station are summarized in<br />
Table 2-1 and described in the following pages.<br />
Service proposals are based on analysis of existing services using ridership data as available from <strong>Metro</strong>, <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit,<br />
and municipal providers, supplemented by observations in the fi eld. Additionally, the results of separate bus and rail<br />
passenger surveys, a random sample telephone survey of residents in the service area, meetings with the cities along the<br />
corridor, and focused discussions with bus operators were synthesized into the recommendations.<br />
The six new stations will be served by a combination of <strong>Metro</strong>, <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit, City of Duarte, and City of Glendora<br />
fi xed route bus services, as well as by paratransit services operated by each of the cities and the regional operators.<br />
Conceptually, the plan assumes that longer bus trips currently occurring in the San Gabriel Valley will be converted<br />
into shorter feeder trips to the most proximate <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> stations. These and other short distance trips will become the<br />
primary focus of the bus system. Duplicative express services to downtown Los Angeles and the Westlake District are<br />
proposed to be curtailed or discontinued. Similarly, bus routes currently serving cities between Glendora and Montclair<br />
are proposed to be selectively truncated or diverted to the Azusa-Citrus Station.<br />
The proposed service plan is shaped by several key design elements:<br />
• Establish new sub-regional transit hubs at the Arcadia and Azusa-Citrus Stations. Transit customers would benefi t<br />
from physical enhancements such as covered passenger waiting areas, real-time schedule information and enhanced<br />
customer information. Transit operations would benefi t from the availability of secure restrooms for bus operators at<br />
these locations. Ancillary transportation facilities such as taxi stands, auto pick up zones, and parking also should be<br />
considered within space constraints.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
• Provide pass-by service at the Monrovia, Duarte, Irwindale, and Alameda Stations with primarily on-street bus stops and<br />
minor restructuring of nearby routes to minimize walking distances and physical barriers between station platforms and<br />
bus stops. Ideally customers should have a line-of-sight visual connection between buses and the boarding platform.<br />
Transit operations would benefi t from physical enhancements such as bus turnouts, wide sidewalks, and designated bus<br />
stops. Customers would benefi t from shelters, street furniture, real-time schedule information, and passive route and<br />
timetable displays.<br />
• Restructure bus routes running parallel to the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension to operate one-way trips within a range of 38 to 52<br />
minutes and optimized schedule cycles of either 90 or 120 minutes. This will facilitate reliable operating schedules and<br />
coordinated bus-train arrival and departure times at a primary transfer point. <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Routes 187, 494, and 690<br />
are examples of existing parallel routes for which signifi cant changes are proposed.<br />
• Adjust bus routes intersecting the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> as necessary to minimize on board bus travel times required for transit<br />
riders to access the nearest rail station that is geographically consistent with prevailing travel directions. Provide direct<br />
linkages between the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>, the <strong>Metro</strong>link San Bernardino <strong>Line</strong>, and the El Monte <strong>Bus</strong>way when feasible with these<br />
routes.<br />
• Improve service frequencies on top performing routes within fi scal limitations. Ideally buses should meet every peak<br />
direction train contingent on funding availability. For cost estimation purposes, target bus service frequencies of 15<br />
minutes on weekdays and 30 minutes on weeknights and weekends are assumed when the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension opens<br />
in 2014.<br />
• Coordinate peak direction bus and train arrivals and departures to minimize transfer wait times.<br />
23
CHAPTER 2 | | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
TABLE 2-1- BUS SERVICE FREQUENCY BY STATION: Pasadena to Azusa<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Arcadia Station<br />
24<br />
<strong>Bus</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong><br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
<strong>Bus</strong>es Per Hour<br />
Arcadia Station Monrovia Station Duarte Station Irwindale Station Azusa-Alameda Station Azusa-Citrus Station<br />
a.m. Peak p.m. Peak a.m. Peak p.m. Peak a.m. Peak p.m. Peak a.m. Peak p.m. Peak a.m. Peak p.m. Peak a.m. Peak p.m. Peak<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit<br />
1861 3 1 3 1<br />
187 3 1 3 1 6 6 3 1 3 1<br />
1881 3 1 3 1<br />
185 4 4 2 1 2 1<br />
272 2 2 1 2 2 1<br />
280 3 1 3 1<br />
498 4 0 9 0<br />
488 2 1 2 1<br />
281<br />
494<br />
<strong>Metro</strong><br />
2 1 2 1<br />
79 3 1 3 1<br />
264 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1<br />
270 1 1 1 2<br />
487 2 2<br />
Municipal Operators<br />
Duarte Green 1 0 1 0<br />
Duarte Blue 0 1 0 1<br />
Duarte<br />
Commuter<br />
1 1 0 0<br />
Total Hourly<br />
<strong>Bus</strong> Arrivals<br />
8 3 3 8 3 3 2 2 1 2 3 1 5 5 2 4 4 2 - 4 - - 4 - 11 0 2 11 0 2 8 6 4 8 11 4<br />
1 New proposed bus route<br />
2 <strong>Bus</strong> space determined considering:<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 186/187 layover at Arcadia Station<br />
a.m. Peak is defi ned as the period between 6am and 9am<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route185 stops at Irwindale Station and lays-over at Azusa-Alameda Station<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 270 stops at Monrovia Station<br />
p.m. peak is defi ned as the period between 3pm and 7pm<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions<br />
Northbound/<br />
Eastbound<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
Southbound/<br />
Westbound<br />
Lay-over<br />
Positions
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Figure 2-1: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing – Pasadena to Azusa<br />
LEGEND<br />
M<br />
F<br />
PA<br />
North<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
0 0.2 0.4 miles<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
Pasadena ARTS Route<br />
25
26<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
Figure 2-1: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing – Pasadena to Azusa<br />
Azusa – Montclair<br />
LEGEND<br />
M<br />
F<br />
PA<br />
North<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
0 0.2 0.4 miles<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
Pasadena ARTS Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan
RECOMMENDATIONS BY STATION<br />
ARCADIA STATION<br />
The Arcadia Station will be located in the downtown area on the north side of Santa Clara Street between North 1st<br />
Avenue and Santa Anita Avenue. Three bus routes currently operate in the vicinity as shown in Figure 2-2.<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 79<br />
This local bus route extends from downtown Los Angeles to Arcadia and currently terminates near the proposed <strong>Gold</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong> station site. Eastbound buses approach the station area via Huntington Drive, turn north on 2nd Avenue and west<br />
on St. Joseph Street to an on-street layover point facing west. Departing westbound trips turn south on 1st Avenue and<br />
west on Huntington returning to Los Angeles.<br />
Weekday ridership information compiled from <strong>Metro</strong> automatic passenger count (APC) data indicates that Arcadia is a<br />
signifi cant trip generator on Route 79. An average 272 riders board at six bus stops east of and including Santa Anita<br />
Avenue, which represents 6.7 percent of approximately 4,100 total average weekday daily boardings on the route.<br />
Alightings (227) represent 5.5 percent of total alightings. Minor realignment is recommended to bring Route 79 nearer to<br />
the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> station entrance on Santa Clara Street and to provide a new layover point. As proposed, eastbound buses<br />
would approach via Huntington Drive, turn north on 1st Avenue and west on Santa Clara Street to a new terminal point<br />
located in a bus pullout on Santa Clara Street. Westbound departures would turn south on Santa Anita Avenue and west<br />
on Huntington Drive, returning to Los Angeles.<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 487<br />
This express bus route operates<br />
between the Westlake District in Los<br />
Angeles and the El Monte <strong>Bus</strong>way<br />
Station via downtown Los Angeles<br />
and a “U”-shaped alignment passing<br />
through San Gabriel, Pasadena and<br />
Arcadia. The existing alignment<br />
serves both the existing Sierra<br />
Madre Villa Station and the planned<br />
Arcadia Station. Route 487 travels<br />
north-south on Santa Anita Avenue<br />
and passes one-half block west<br />
of the proposed Arcadia Station<br />
site. Existing northbound and<br />
southbound bus stops are located<br />
at the intersection of Santa Anita<br />
Avenue and Santa Clara Street.<br />
Ridership information compiled<br />
from <strong>Metro</strong> Automatic Passenger<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
Passengers<br />
300<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 487<br />
Weekday Eastbound Ridership<br />
Boardings<br />
Alightings<br />
Left on Board<br />
Figure 2-3<br />
Passengers on Board<br />
Station Vicinty<br />
SMV<br />
Arcadia<br />
1,000<br />
900<br />
800<br />
700<br />
600<br />
500<br />
400<br />
300<br />
200<br />
100<br />
0<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
Counter (APC) data is displayed in Figure 2-3 for weekday eastbound trips. The profi le refl ects a radial orientation with<br />
distinctly higher ridership on the western portion of the route. The highest number of accumulated passengers aboard all<br />
weekday trips (i.e., maximum load) occurs at the USC Medical Center <strong>Bus</strong>way Station (863 passengers) per day. Passenger<br />
volumes are signifi cantly lower in Pasadena and Arcadia, where the cumulative daily passenger load drops below 200<br />
passengers per day in San Gabriel and reaches a minimum load point of 103 passengers per day approaching the Sierra<br />
Madre Villa Station.<br />
A similar pattern is seen in Figure<br />
2-4 for westbound trips. <strong>Bus</strong>es<br />
depart from the El Monte <strong>Bus</strong>way<br />
Station with approximately 200<br />
passengers per day on board and<br />
the accumulated passenger load<br />
rises to 295 passengers per day as<br />
buses proceed north on Santa Anita<br />
toward Live Oak Avenue. The load<br />
declines approaching Arcadia from<br />
the south with 170 passengers per<br />
day on board at Santa Clara Avenue.<br />
It declines further along Sierra Madre<br />
Villa Avenue with 71 passengers per<br />
day alighting at the existing <strong>Gold</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong> station. Thirty-seven passengers<br />
per day also board at the station<br />
for continuing service through<br />
San Gabriel and downtown Los<br />
Passengers<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 487<br />
Weekday Westbound Ridership<br />
Figure 2-4<br />
Angeles via I-10. The maximum load point for westbound trips occurs at the Cal State Los Angeles <strong>Bus</strong>way Station (1,057<br />
passengers per day).<br />
These data suggest that the Sierra Madre Villa Station is an appropriate point at which to terminate Route 487 when the<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension from Pasadena to Azusa opens in 2014. The results of a recent survey of bus riders conducted for this<br />
study reported that 72 percent of existing Route 487 riders are likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that Arcadia is the<br />
most likely point of access identifi ed by 29 percent of survey respondents, followed by Sierra Madre Villa Station preferred<br />
by 25 percent of respondents. Similarly, results from the concurrent survey of current <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> riders suggests that<br />
Arcadia Station will attract up to 8 percent of total a.m. peak boardings on the extended <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>. Many of these patrons<br />
currently transfer at Sierra Madre Villa.<br />
Station Vicinty<br />
SMV<br />
Arcadia<br />
Passengers on Board<br />
Truncation of Route 487 at the Sierra Madre Villa Station and introduction of a new local route between Sierra Madre<br />
Villa and El Monte via Arcadia is proposed as a means of enhancing intermodal access for most Arcadia as well as some<br />
Pasadena passengers. Operationally, Route 487 is a very long route requiring nearly two hours to complete a one-way<br />
trip, which is signifi cantly longer than most customers are willing to ride a bus. The proposed local route would operate<br />
within a 120-minute schedule cycle allow one-way running times of up to 52 minutes. This includes rerouting to serve<br />
the Arcadia Station directly by diverting buses from Santa Anita Avenue via Huntington Drive, 1st Avenue, and Colorado<br />
Boulevard in both directions. Schedule coordination would focus on peak direction connections at both stations.<br />
Boardings<br />
Alightings<br />
Left on Board<br />
1,200<br />
1,000<br />
800<br />
600<br />
400<br />
200<br />
0<br />
27
28<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
E Colorado Blvd<br />
Santa Anita<br />
M 487<br />
Arcadia<br />
Station<br />
California St<br />
Figure 2-2: Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Arcadia Station<br />
N 1st Ave<br />
M 79<br />
E Santa Clara St<br />
N 2nd Ave<br />
E Huntington Dr<br />
F 690<br />
F 187<br />
N 5th Ave<br />
LEGEND<br />
North<br />
0 400<br />
800 Feet<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 187<br />
This is <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit’s most heavily utilized route, carrying over 6,000 passengers per average weekday, 3,100 per<br />
Saturday, and 2,900 per Sunday. Structurally similar to the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>, Route 187 operates between downtown Pasadena<br />
and the Montclair Transit Center primarily on Huntington Drive and <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard, and often in close proximity to the<br />
rail corridor. A one-way trip end-to-end<br />
takes up to two hours and 15 minutes,<br />
which is substantially longer than most<br />
one-way bus transit trips taken in the<br />
region, and nearly three times longer<br />
than the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> is expected to take<br />
once the line is extended to Montclair.<br />
Ridership data compiled from <strong>Foothill</strong><br />
Transit APC information and shown in<br />
Figure 2-5 indicate a pattern of steadily<br />
rising weekday passenger volumes<br />
aboard westbound trips to a maximum<br />
load point of 985 passengers per day<br />
on Huntington Drive approaching 2nd<br />
Street near the Arcadia Station site.<br />
Passenger volumes fl uctuate within<br />
a relatively narrow range through<br />
Pasadena, with 890 passengers per day<br />
on board at the Sierra Madre Villa <strong>Gold</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong> Station and 937 passengers per day<br />
on Colorado Boulevard at Sierra Madre<br />
Villa Boulevard. Passenger volumes<br />
fall sharply from that point west to<br />
the end of the line at Colorado and<br />
Raymond as passengers alight in large<br />
numbers in the downtown Pasadena<br />
area. A similar pattern is exhibited on<br />
eastbound trips shown in Figure 2-6,<br />
with heavy boardings in downtown<br />
Pasadena resulting in a maximum load<br />
of 991 passengers per day on board at<br />
Huntington Drive and 1st Street near<br />
the Arcadia Station site. The passenger<br />
volume drops to 570 passengers per<br />
day on board at <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and<br />
Citrus Avenue near the Azusa-Citrus<br />
Station.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey<br />
conducted for this study reported<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
Passengers<br />
Passengers<br />
180<br />
160<br />
140<br />
120<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
0<br />
180<br />
160<br />
140<br />
120<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
0<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 187<br />
Weekday Westbound Ridership<br />
Ons<br />
Offs<br />
Left on Board<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 187<br />
Weekday Eastbound Ridership<br />
Figure 2-5<br />
Station Vicinty<br />
SMV<br />
Arcadia<br />
Citrus<br />
Figure 2-6<br />
Station Vicinty<br />
SMV<br />
Arcadia<br />
Citrus<br />
Passengers on Board<br />
Passengers on Board<br />
Boardings<br />
Alightings<br />
Left on Board<br />
1,200<br />
1,000<br />
800<br />
600<br />
400<br />
200<br />
0<br />
1,200<br />
1,000<br />
800<br />
600<br />
400<br />
200<br />
0<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
that 88 percent of existing Route 187 riders are likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension, the highest of any route surveyed.<br />
Arcadia is not necessarily the preferred point of access for existing bus riders, however, with the Azusa-Citrus (21<br />
percent), Monrovia (15 percent), Duarte (14 percent), Sierra Madre Villa (10 percent) and Azusa-Alameda (9 percent)<br />
Stations potentially attracting more transferring passengers than Arcadia (7 percent). These ridership patterns support<br />
reconfi guration of Route 187 to better complement the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> when the Pasadena to Azusa extension is completed.<br />
It is recommended that Route 187 be divided into three shorter routes to shift longer passenger trips to the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> and<br />
refocus bus service on providing feeder trips into multiple stations along the Pasadena to Azusa segment. Two of the<br />
three new routes would terminate at the Arcadia Station:<br />
• Route 186 Pasadena/Arcadia would operate between downtown Pasadena and Arcadia Station on an alignment<br />
similar to the current Route 187, which includes Sierra Madre Villa Station. The route should operate within a<br />
90-minute schedule cycle requiring six peak buses to provide peak period 15-minute headways designed to meet<br />
every other peak direction <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> train at Sierra Madre Villa Station. Route 186 would approach the Arcadia Station<br />
from the west via Huntington Drive eastbound, turn north on 1st Street and west on Santa Clara Street to a terminal<br />
stop located on the street adjacent to the station entrance. Westbound departures would turn south on Santa Anita<br />
Avenue and west on Huntington Drive returning to Pasadena.<br />
• Route 187 Arcadia/Azusa would operate between the Arcadia Station and the Azusa-Citrus Station on its current<br />
alignment, with minor changes to serve the Azusa-Alameda Station better. The route should operate within a<br />
90-minute schedule cycle, requiring six peak buses to provide peak period 15-minute headways designed to meet<br />
every other peak direction <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> train at the Arcadia Station. Route 187 would approach the Arcadia Station<br />
proceeding west on Huntington Drive, north on 1st Street and west on Santa Clara Street to the bus turnout adjacent<br />
to the station entrance. Eastbound departures would turn south on Santa Anita Avenue and east on Huntington<br />
Drive returning to Azusa. Although Monrovia and Duarte Stations reportedly are attractive to survey respondents,<br />
diversion of Route 187 to serve these stations directly is not recommended.<br />
The major benefi t anticipated from splitting the existing route into three routes is the opportunity to coordinate bus<br />
and train arrivals and departures at the Sierra Madre Villa, Arcadia and Azusa-Citrus Stations better. With Route 187<br />
terminating at the Arcadia Station, transfer dwell times needed to align bus and train arrivals would coincide with layover<br />
time required for operational purposes. This should result in an increased number of “line-of-sight” transfers available to<br />
customers. Operationally, the shorter routes scheduled with recovery time equivalent to 15 percent of round trip running<br />
time presumably would reduce pressure on <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit dispatchers and service supervisors attempting to maintain<br />
schedule reliability on the existing cross-valley bus line and localize the impacts of any service disruptions.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit is currently working with several San Gabriel Valley cities to install a traffi c signal priority system for Route<br />
187. It is anticipated that the route modifi cations in this report would not preclude use of this system as the current route<br />
alignments and frequency is proposed to be maintained, all be it with three separate routes instead of a single route.<br />
Station Interface<br />
The proposed layover location on Santa Clara Street should minimize the distance that customers need to walk when<br />
transferring between modes. The bus stop location also helps to emphasize the pedestrian plaza proposed for the station<br />
area by the City of Arcadia. This plaza would serve as the primary pedestrian route between the bus stops and the light<br />
rail station platform. <strong>Proposed</strong> bus route modifi cations are shown in Figure 2-7.<br />
29
30<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
E Colorado Blvd<br />
Santa Anita<br />
M 487*<br />
Arcadia<br />
Station<br />
F 186<br />
California St<br />
Figure 2-7: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Arcadia Station<br />
N 1st Ave<br />
M 79<br />
E Santa Clara St<br />
N 2nd Ave<br />
E Huntington Dr<br />
F 690<br />
F 187<br />
N 5th Ave<br />
LEGEND<br />
* New Local <strong>Metro</strong> Route Based on 487<br />
North<br />
0 400<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route
MONROVIA STATION<br />
The Monrovia Station will be located at the south periphery of the downtown area near the northwest corner of West<br />
Duarte Road and South Myrtle Avenue. Three bus routes currently operate in the vicinity as shown in Figure 2-8.<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 264<br />
This local bus route carries approximately 750 passengers per weekday between Pasadena and Duarte on an alignment<br />
that includes the Sierra Madre Villa Station as well as the proposed Monrovia and Duarte Stations. It passes the Monrovia<br />
Station site on Duarte Road west of South Myrtle Avenue. Existing bus stops are located on both sides of Duarte Road at<br />
Myrtle Avenue.<br />
Ridership data compiled<br />
from <strong>Metro</strong> APC<br />
information indicate a<br />
radial orientation focused<br />
on downtown Pasadena<br />
with a major intermediate<br />
stop at the Sierra Madre<br />
Villa <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Station.<br />
As shown in Figure 2-9,<br />
westbound trips departing<br />
from the City of Hope<br />
Medical Center opposite<br />
the proposed Duarte<br />
Station site accumulate<br />
riders along Duarte Road<br />
with 143 total passengers<br />
per day on board at<br />
South Myrtle Avenue<br />
approaching the Monrovia<br />
Station site.<br />
Passengers<br />
100<br />
90<br />
80<br />
70<br />
60<br />
50<br />
40<br />
30<br />
20<br />
10<br />
0<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 264<br />
Weekday Westbound Ridership<br />
Station Vicinty<br />
Duarte<br />
Monrovia<br />
SMV<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported that 85 percent of existing Route 264 riders are<br />
likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that the Monrovia Station is the preferred point of access for 28 percent of<br />
existing bus riders, followed by Sierra Madre Villa (17 percent), Arcadia (15 percent), Lake (15 percent) and Duarte (10<br />
percent). Similarly, the survey of existing <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> users suggests that Monrovia Station will attract up to nine percent<br />
of total a.m. peak boardings on the extended <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>. Many of the 92 riders currently transferring at Sierra Madre Villa<br />
Station will change at Monrovia instead for faster travel time and increased likelihood of getting a seat on the train. The<br />
maximum load point (185 passengers per day) currently occurs at Duarte and 1st Avenue in Arcadia; however, it is not<br />
recommended that Route 264 be diverted north to the proposed Arcadia Station. Thus Sierra Madre Villa Station will<br />
remain a signifi cant access point for Route 264 passengers originating east of Pasadena. Existing ridership west of Sierra<br />
Madre Villa Station is low, suggesting that further restructuring of Route 264 may be warranted in Pasadena and Altadena.<br />
A similar pattern is seen in Figure 2-10 showing eastbound trips. Passenger volumes rise sharply at Sierra Madre<br />
Villa Station and reach a maximum load point of 141 passengers per day on Duarte Road at Holly Avenue in Arcadia.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
Figure 2-9<br />
Boardings<br />
Aligthitngs<br />
Left on Board<br />
200<br />
180<br />
160<br />
140<br />
120<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
0<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
Approximately 100<br />
passengers per day<br />
currently travel east of<br />
Myrtle Avenue.<br />
No signifi cant change to<br />
Route 264 is proposed at<br />
Monrovia Station.<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 270<br />
Passengers<br />
40<br />
35<br />
30<br />
25<br />
20<br />
15<br />
10<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 264<br />
Weekday Eastbound Ridership<br />
Boardings<br />
Alightings<br />
Left on Board<br />
Figure 2-10<br />
Station Vicinty<br />
Duarte<br />
Monrovia<br />
SMV<br />
This local bus route carries<br />
approximately 2,500<br />
passengers per weekday<br />
between Norwalk and<br />
Monrovia, intersecting the<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> corridor on Myrtle<br />
5<br />
0<br />
20<br />
0<br />
Avenue and Duarte Road and passing immediately east of the Monrovia Station site. Southbound service would off er a<br />
20-minute connection between the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> and the El Monte <strong>Bus</strong>way Station via Myrtle Avenue. Northbound service<br />
continues a relatively short distance into Old Town Monrovia and runs a one-way loop comprised of Primrose Street, Palm<br />
Street and, Magnolia Avenue to <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and returning south via Primrose.<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> ridership data indicates that 12 percent of total weekday southbound boardings occur north of the station site<br />
with 154 passengers per day aboard all buses approaching Duarte Road from the north. Similarly, 158 passengers per<br />
day on northbound trips travel north of Duarte Road on Route 270. Although this number is signifi cant, the present route<br />
structure would limit opportunities for schedule coordination at Monrovia Station. The results of the bus rider survey<br />
conducted for this study reported that 68 percent of existing Route 270 riders are likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension<br />
and that Monrovia Station is the preferred point of access for 44 percent of existing bus riders, followed by Duarte (14<br />
percent) and Arcadia (13 percent). These data suggest potentially signifi cant interest in reverse direction transfers; i.e.,<br />
northbound Route 270 to eastbound <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> trains toward Azusa.<br />
Ideally, Route 270 would be truncated at the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> to facilitate timed transfers. With the City’s proposed off -street bus<br />
facility, the route divert from Myrtle Avenue into the facility; truncation or other alternatives should be considered, only<br />
if the City of Monrovia implements its proposed downtown shuttle to and from the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Station that is capable of<br />
providing an equivalent or better frequency of service than the existing Route 270. In the absence of this shuttle service,<br />
the existing alignment of Route 270 should be maintained.<br />
160<br />
140<br />
120<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
31
32<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
W Huntington Dr<br />
M 264<br />
Monrovia<br />
Station<br />
M 270<br />
Figure 2-8: Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Monrovia Station<br />
S Myrtle Ave<br />
F 494<br />
F 187<br />
E Pomona Ave<br />
E Duarte Rd<br />
S California Ave<br />
F 690<br />
Mountain Ave<br />
LEGEND<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route<br />
North<br />
0 400<br />
800 Feet
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 494<br />
This relatively low-volume express route provides weekday peak direction-only service between the San Dimas Parkand-Ride<br />
lot (site of a proposed future <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> station) and the El Monte <strong>Bus</strong>way Station, on an alignment that includes<br />
three proposed <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> stations: Azusa-Citrus; Azusa-Alameda, and Monrovia. It runs primarily east-west on <strong>Foothill</strong><br />
Boulevard, Baseline Road, and Huntington Drive east of Myrtle Avenue; and north-south on Myrtle to El Monte. Route<br />
494 partially overlaps several other routes, including Route 492 on Arrow Highway; Route 284 on Lone Hill Avenue and<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Drive east of Glendora Avenue; Route 187 and shorter segments of several other routes on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and<br />
Huntington Drive, as well as <strong>Metro</strong> Route 270 on Myrtle Avenue to El Monte.<br />
Route 494 carries an average of 133 weekday boardings on seven one-way trips, or 19 passengers per trip. The results<br />
of the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported that 72 percent of existing Route 494 riders are likely to use<br />
the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that the two Azusa stations are the preferred point of access for 48 percent of all riders,<br />
followed by Monrovia (19 percent) and Duarte (15 percent). Detailed passenger boarding and alighting information<br />
was not available for analysis, making defi nitive systemic recommendations more diffi cult. However, either truncation<br />
at the proposed Azusa-Citrus Station or outright discontinuation of Route 494 should be considered in conjunction with<br />
restructuring local services to feed passengers into the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>. <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit staff did note that existing riders of this<br />
route value the connection it provides between Duarte and the El Monte transit center. A replacement connection should<br />
be considered if this route is discontinuted. From a policy perspective, <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit and <strong>Metro</strong> should avoid providing<br />
parallel express bus services to downtown Los Angeles when feeder services to the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> are available providing<br />
comparable service.<br />
Station Interface<br />
The interface plan assumes on-street bus stops on Duarte Road near the station for <strong>Metro</strong> Route 264, and potential off -<br />
street layover position for <strong>Metro</strong> Route 270. Stops should be located to minimize the distance to the boarding platform.<br />
Figure 2-11 illustrates the proposed bus route modifi cations.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
33
34<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
W Huntington Dr<br />
M 264<br />
Monrovia<br />
Station<br />
M 270<br />
Figure 2-11: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Monrovia Station<br />
S Myrtle Ave<br />
F 494<br />
F 187<br />
E Pomona Ave<br />
E Duarte Rd<br />
S California Ave<br />
F 690<br />
Mountain Ave<br />
LEGEND<br />
North<br />
0 400<br />
800 Feet<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route
DUARTE STATION<br />
The Duarte Station will be located on the north side of Duarte Road, west of the intersection with Highland Avenue and<br />
near to the City of Hope Medical Campus. There are fi ve existing bus routes that operate in the vicinity of the Duarte<br />
Station, as seen in Figure 2-12.<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Route 264<br />
This local bus route carries approximately 750 passengers per weekday between Pasadena and Duarte on an alignment<br />
that includes the Sierra Madre Villa Station as well as the proposed Monrovia and Duarte Stations. Currently it passes the<br />
Duarte Station site on Duarte Road. The route terminates on the south side of Durate Road. Westbound trips return via<br />
a clockwise loop heading west on <strong>Bus</strong>iness Center Drive, north on Denning Avenue, east on Evergreen Street, and south<br />
on Highland Avenue. An existing eastbound stop is located across Duarte Road from the station site at the City of Hope<br />
exit roadway; however, the nearest westbound stop to the Duarte Station site is located far to the west at the near side of<br />
Buena Vista Avenue.<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> ridership data (shown earlier in Figures 2-9 and 2-10) indicates signifi cant ridership activity in the vicinity of the<br />
station site generated primarily by the City of Hope Medical Center and nearby businesses along Duarte Road. These<br />
conditions suggest that the Duarte Station location will strengthen an already strong eastern terminus for Route 264.<br />
Consequently, no immediate changes are proposed for this route.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 272<br />
This local route carries approximately 415 passengers per weekday between West Covina and Duarte via Baldwin Park and<br />
Irwindale. Northbound buses approach the proposed <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Duarte Station from the south via Buena Vista Avenue,<br />
turn east Duarte Road and run parallel the corridor past the station site to Highland Avenue. The route continues north<br />
on Highland Avenue and terminates at an on-street bus stop on Huntington Drive at Highland Avenue, approximately<br />
one mile north of the station. Southbound buses depart west on Huntington Drive and turn south on Buena Vista Avenue<br />
for the return trip to West Covina, bypassing Duarte Station.<br />
Detailed ridership data for Route 272 were not available at the time of this analysis, making it more diffi cult to provide<br />
defi nitive recommendations concerning this route. The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported<br />
that 66 percent of existing Route 272 riders are likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that Duarte (29 percent),<br />
Irwindale (27 percent) and Monrovia (24 percent) are most preferred as access points. Structurally, the one-way<br />
loop utilized to turn buses at the northern end of the route weakens the interface with the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> at Duarte and is<br />
particularly inconvenient for passengers transferring from rail to bus and heading south.<br />
Northbound Route 272 service should be truncated at Duarte Station. Southbound buses would use Highland Avenue,<br />
<strong>Bus</strong>iness Center Drive , Denning Road, and Evergreen Street to loop around and return to Duarte Road westbound, similar<br />
to <strong>Metro</strong> 264. Alternative local coverage on Highland Avenue could be provided with restructured City of Duarte shuttle<br />
services or by diverting Route 187 to Duarte Station. Possible restructuring coinciding with the planned 2014 opening of<br />
the Phase 2A extension also should be considered once detailed boarding and alighting data are available. The objective<br />
of short-term restructuring would be to equalize bus travel times to and from the Duarte Station.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
Duarte City Routes<br />
The City of Duarte operates three local circulator routes utilizing small buses to supplement <strong>Metro</strong> and <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit<br />
routes in the city. Shown in Figure 2-12, they are briefl y described as follows:<br />
• Duarte Blue <strong>Line</strong> operates a clockwise loop direction around the City generally northwest of the station area along<br />
Huntington Drive and Buena Vista Street. Currently the Blue <strong>Line</strong> does not stop in the immediate vicinity of the Duarte<br />
Station site.<br />
• Duarte Green <strong>Line</strong> operates a counter-clockwise loop around the City that includes Duarte Road in the eastbound<br />
direction passing the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> station site, and in the westbound direction via Evergreen Street. Eastbound service<br />
stops about 300 feet west of the station.<br />
• Duarte Commuter <strong>Line</strong> is a morning peak service that transports residents to locations where they can transfer to a<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> or <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit bus line. It currently runs on Evergreen Street, north of the station.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported that 81 percent of existing Duarte circulator riders<br />
are likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension, and that 47 percent consider Duarte Station as the preferred point of access,<br />
followed by Monrovia (13 percent), Azusa-Citrus (9 percent), Azusa-Alameda (8 percent) and Irwindale (7 percent).<br />
Detailed ridership data for these routes were not available for this analysis, making defi nitive systemic recommendations<br />
more diffi cult. Generally these routes should be evaluated in context of an integrated transit plan where <strong>Metro</strong>, <strong>Foothill</strong>,<br />
and municipal routes provide complementary services that are perceived by customers as a single network.<br />
Station Interface<br />
On-street bus stops suffi cient to accommodate fi ve fi xed-route bus routes and one paratransit or specialized<br />
transportation vehicle should be provided at the Duarte Station. Physical improvements are recommended with a new<br />
westbound stop located on the west curb of Highland Avenue near the east station portal. The eastbound stop will<br />
remain at the existing bus turnout serving the City of Hope Medical Center. A new pedestrian crossing across Duarte<br />
Road near the City of Hope driveway is planned.<br />
Figure 2-13 shows the proposed bus route modifi cations. The objective of these proposed route modifi cations is to<br />
continue to provide convenient bus connections to City of Hope Medical Center and to improve connections from this<br />
facility and the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Station to the South and West. The proposed loop for <strong>Metro</strong> Route 264 and <strong>Foothill</strong> Route 272<br />
on <strong>Bus</strong>iness Center Drive, Denning Avenue, and Evergreen Street allows both routes to serve Duarte Road, the City of<br />
Hope, and the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> station in both directions.<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> modifi cations to local Duarte bus routes will be further coordinated with the city as the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension<br />
Project advances.<br />
35
36<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
Buena Vista St<br />
F 272<br />
E Huntington Dr<br />
Duarte Green <strong>Line</strong><br />
<strong>Bus</strong>iness Center Drive<br />
M 264<br />
Duarte<br />
Station<br />
F 187<br />
Duarte Rd<br />
Figure 2-12: Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Duarte Station<br />
Duarte Commuter <strong>Line</strong><br />
Highland Ave<br />
F 494<br />
Duarte Blue <strong>Line</strong><br />
F 690<br />
LEGEND<br />
North<br />
0 300 600 Feet<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route
Buena Vista St<br />
F 272<br />
E Huntington Dr<br />
Duarte Green <strong>Line</strong><br />
<strong>Bus</strong>iness Center Drive<br />
M 264<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
Duarte<br />
Station<br />
Duarte Commuter <strong>Line</strong><br />
Highland Ave<br />
F 187<br />
Duarte Rd<br />
F 494<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
Duarte Blue <strong>Line</strong><br />
F 690<br />
LEGEND<br />
North<br />
0 300 600 Feet<br />
Figure 2-13: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Duarte Station<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route<br />
37
38<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
IRWINDALE STATION<br />
The Irwindale station will be located north of Avenida Padilla, and east of Irwindale Avenue. One existing bus route operates<br />
in the immediate vicinity of the station, as shown in Figure 2-14.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 185<br />
This local bus route carries nearly 2,000 passengers per weekday on a predominantly north-south alignment between<br />
Hacienda Heights and Azusa via West Covina and Irwindale. It passes one block west of the Irwindale Station site along<br />
Irwindale Avenue at Montoya Street and the I-210 Freeway. To the south, Route 185 provides a 20-minute connection to the<br />
Plaza at West Covina Transit Center and continues through West Covina, La Puente and Industry to Puente Hills Mall via Sunset<br />
Avenue, Glendora Avenue and Hacienda Boulevard. To the north, Route 185 continues to <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and turns east<br />
toward downtown Azusa, overlaying Route 187 between Irwindale Avenue and Alameda Avenue.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study indicate that 68 percent of existing Route 185 riders are likely<br />
to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension, and that 30 percent consider Irwindale Station as the preferred point of access, followed by<br />
Azusa-Alameda (21 percent), Azusa-Citrus (18 percent), Monrovia (11 percent), and Duarte (9 percent). The concurrent survey<br />
of current <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> riders indicated that Irwindale Station is the least preferred among the six new stations as the initial<br />
point of access to the rail line. Detailed ridership data for Route 185 were not available for this analysis, making defi nitive<br />
recommendations more diffi cult. Truncation at Irwindale Station could be considered when ridership data become available,<br />
given service redundancy with Route 187 on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard east of Irwindale Avenue and to improve opportunity for<br />
schedule coordination with <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> trains.<br />
In the immediate term, it is recommended that Route 185 divert from Irwindale Avenue to Irwindale Station in both directions<br />
when the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension opens. Northbound buses would turn right from Irwindale Avenue onto Adelante Street,<br />
where a new traffi c signal is planned, and continue north on Avenida Padilla to a new bus stop located on the north side of<br />
Montoya Street, southwest of the station. Ideally customers should have a line-of-sight visual connection to buses from the<br />
rail platform. Departing buses would continue west on Avenida Padilla, pass under the Irwindale Avenue bridge and turn left,<br />
running parallel to Irwindale Avenue until the traffi c light at Adelante Street and Irwindale Avenue, where the existing routing<br />
would be resumed. <strong>Bus</strong>es running in the southbound direction would turn left at the intersection of Irwindale Avenue and<br />
Adelante Street, follow the same itinerary as described for northbound service and then continue south after the traffi c light at<br />
Adelante Street/Irwindale Avenue. <strong>Proposed</strong> changes are shown in Figure 2-15.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan
E 1st St<br />
F185<br />
N Irwindale Ave<br />
Irwindale<br />
Station<br />
F 187<br />
F 690<br />
F 494<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
W <strong>Foothill</strong> Blvd<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Figure 2-14: Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Irwindale Station<br />
LEGEND<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route<br />
North<br />
0 300 600 Feet<br />
39
40<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
E 1st St<br />
Figure 2-15: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Irwindale Station<br />
F185<br />
N Irwindale Ave<br />
Irwindale<br />
Station<br />
F 187<br />
F 690<br />
F 494<br />
W <strong>Foothill</strong> Blvd<br />
LEGEND<br />
North<br />
0 300 600 Feet<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route
AZUSA-ALAMEDA STATION<br />
The Azusa-Alameda <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Station will be located on the north side of Santa Fe Avenue between Azusa Avenue and<br />
Alameda Avenue in the downtown area. Four existing bus routes that operate in the vicinity of Azusa-Alameda Station<br />
and are in the vicinity of the station are shown in Figure 2-16.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 185<br />
This local bus route carries nearly 2,000 passengers per weekday between Hacienda Heights and Azusa via West Covina<br />
and downtown Azusa on an alignment that includes the proposed Irwindale and Azusa-Alameda Stations. It approaches<br />
the station vicinity from the west via <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and terminates at San Gabriel Avenue two blocks west of the<br />
station.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study indicate that 68 percent of existing Route 185 riders are<br />
likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that 21 percent consider Azusa-Alameda Station as the preferred point of<br />
access, which is second to Irwindale Station (30 percent). Detailed ridership data for Route 185 were not available for<br />
this analysis, making defi nitive recommendations more diffi cult. At a minimum it is recommended that Route 185 be<br />
extended to a new terminal and layover point located adjacent to the new station entrance when the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension<br />
opens. <strong>Bus</strong>es would continue from San Gabriel Avenue on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard, turn north on Azusa Avenue and east on<br />
Santa Fe Avenue to the bus stop. Departing buses would turn south on Alameda Avenue and west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard<br />
returning to Irwindale.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 187<br />
This local bus route currently travels east-west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and passes one block south of the Azusa-Alameda<br />
Station site. Existing bus stops are located on both sides of <strong>Foothill</strong> at the Azusa Avenue intersection. As described<br />
earlier, Route 187 would be truncated at both ends and serve the Arcadia and Azusa-Citrus Stations. Ridership data<br />
indicates that downtown Azusa is a signifi cant transit trip generator and diversion of Route 187 to the station entrance<br />
on Santa Fe Avenue is recommended. Both Alameda and Azusa Avenues may be used for signal-protected access to and<br />
from <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 280<br />
This local route is <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit’s second highest volume line carrying over 3,400 passengers per average weekday<br />
between Puente Hills Mall and downtown Azusa via Azusa Avenue. It currently terminates one block south of the Azusa-<br />
Alameda Station via a one-way loop consisting of north on Azusa Avenue, west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and south on San<br />
Gabriel Avenue. Existing bus stops are located on Azusa Avenue northbound and on San Gabriel Avenue southbound,<br />
both south of <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported that 62 percent of existing Route 280 riders are<br />
likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that the Azusa-Alameda Station is the preferred point of access for 16 percent<br />
of those who expect to use the train. In comparison, Azusa-Citrus Station is preferred by 48 percent of riders, and Duarte<br />
is preferred by 10 percent of riders. Detailed ridership data for Route 280 were unavailable at the time of this analysis,<br />
making it more diffi cult to off er recommendations concerning this route. At a minimum, extension one block north on<br />
Azusa Avenue and east on Santa Fe Avenue to a new on-street bus stop and layover point located across the street from<br />
the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> station entrance is recommended. Ideally customers should have a line-of-sight visual connection to buses<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
from the rail platform. Departing southbound buses would turn south on Alameda Avenue, west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard<br />
and south on San Gabriel Avenue returning to Puente Hills Mall. This alignment would allow Route 280 use the existing<br />
bus stop located on the north side of <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard at the far side of Alameda Avenue.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 494<br />
This relatively low-volume express route provides weekday peak direction-only service between the San Dimas Park-and-<br />
Ride lot (site of a future <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> station) and the El Monte <strong>Bus</strong>way Station on an alignment that includes three proposed<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> LIne stations: Azusa-Citrus; Azusa-Alameda, and Monrovia. It runs primarily east-west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard,<br />
Baseline Road, and Huntington Drive east of Myrtle Avenue; and north-south on Myrtle to El Monte. Route 494 partially<br />
overlaps several other routes, including Route 492 on Arrow Highway; Route 284 on Lone Hill Avenue and <strong>Foothill</strong><br />
Drive east of Glendora Avenue; and Route 187 and shorter segments of several other routes on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and<br />
Huntington Drive, as well as <strong>Metro</strong> Route 270 on Myrtle Avenue to El Monte.<br />
Route 494 carries an average of 133 weekday boardings on seven one-way trips, or 19 passengers per trip. The results<br />
of the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported that 72 percent of existing Route 494 riders are likely to use<br />
the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that the Azusa-Alameda Station is the preferred point of access for 25 percent of all riders,<br />
followed by Azusa-Citrus (23 percent), Monrovia (19 percent) and Duarte (15 percent). Detailed passenger boarding<br />
and alighting information was not available for analysis, making defi nitive recommendations more diffi cult. However,<br />
either truncation at the proposed Azusa-Citrus Station or outright discontinuation of Route 494 should be considered in<br />
conjunction with restructuring local services to feed passengers into the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>.<br />
Station Interface<br />
It is proposed that Santa Fe Avenue be converted to have an on-street bus facility adjacent to the Azusa-Alameda Station,<br />
between Azusa Avenue and Alameda Avenue. This proposal will improve customer convenience and help to meet<br />
operational requirements. <strong>Bus</strong> stops suffi cient to accommodate three fi xed-route bus routes and one paratransit or<br />
specialized transportation vehicle at Azusa-Alameda Station should be provided. <strong>Bus</strong> route modifi cations are shown in<br />
Figure 2-17.<br />
41
42<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
E 11th St<br />
F 185<br />
N San Gabriel Ave<br />
Figure 2-16: Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Azusa-Alameda Station<br />
N Azusa Ave<br />
F 280<br />
N Alameda Ave<br />
E 9th St<br />
Azusa-Alameda<br />
Station<br />
F 494<br />
W 5th St<br />
E <strong>Foothill</strong> Blvd<br />
F 187<br />
N Citrus Ave<br />
F 281<br />
LEGEND<br />
North<br />
0 400<br />
800 Feet<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route
E 11th St<br />
N San Gabriel Ave<br />
F 280<br />
N Azusa Ave<br />
F 185<br />
N Alameda Ave<br />
E 9th St<br />
Azusa-Alameda<br />
Station<br />
F 494<br />
W 5th St<br />
E <strong>Foothill</strong> Blvd<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Figure 2-17: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Azusa-Alameda Station<br />
F 187<br />
N Citrus Ave<br />
F 281<br />
LEGEND<br />
M<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route<br />
North<br />
0 400<br />
800 Feet<br />
43
44<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
AZUSA-CITRUS STATION<br />
The Azusa-Citrus Station will be located northwest of the intersection of Citrus Avenue and <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard near the<br />
Citrus Community College and Azusa Pacifi c University campuses. There are fi ve existing bus routes that operate in the<br />
vicinity of the proposed station site, as shown in Figure 2-18.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 187<br />
This is <strong>Foothill</strong>’s most heavily utilized route, carrying over 6,000 passengers per average weekday, 3,100 per Saturday, and<br />
2,900 per Sunday. A detailed discussion of boarding and alighting patterns is provided earlier in this report in the Arcadia<br />
Station section. Route 187 travels east-west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and north-south on Citrus Avenue in the vicinity of<br />
the Azusa-Citrus Station site, passing several hundred feet to the south. Existing bus stops are located on the east side of<br />
Citrus Avenue south of the curve to <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard, and on the north side of <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard immediately east of<br />
the curve to Citrus Avenue.<br />
Ridership data shown earlier in Figures 2-5 and 2-6 indicate that the Azusa-Citrus station vicinity is a signifi cant transit<br />
trip generator in both directions. Passenger volumes are higher to the west and lower to the east of the station site, with<br />
accumulated loads of approximately 600 passengers aboard weekday service in each direction at <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and<br />
Citrus Avenue.<br />
These ridership patterns support reconfi guration of Route 187 better to complement the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> when the line is<br />
extended. It is recommended that Route 187 be divided into three shorter routes to shift longer passenger trips to the<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>, and refocus bus service on providing feeder trips into both Azusa-Citrus and Arcadia Stations from the east<br />
with continuing direct service provided by the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>. Two of the three new routes would terminate at Azusa-Citrus<br />
Station:<br />
• Route 187 Arcadia/Azusa would operate between Arcadia Station and Azusa-Citrus Station on its current alignment<br />
with minor changes to serve the Azusa-Alameda Station better. The route should operate within a 90-minute<br />
schedule cycle, requiring six peak buses to provide peak period 15-minute headways designed to meet every other<br />
peak direction <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> train at Arcadia Station.<br />
• Route 188 Azusa/Montclair would operate between Azusa-Citrus Station and the Montclair Transit Center on an<br />
alignment similar to the current Route 187, which includes intermediate stops at the Glendora and Claremont<br />
Stations as planned in the Azusa to Montclair Extension. The route should operate within a 120-minute schedule<br />
cycle, requiring eight peak buses to provide peak period 15-minute headways designed to meet every other peak<br />
direction <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> train at Azusa-Citrus Station.<br />
The Azusa-Citrus Station does have substantial needs for bus layover space. At project opening, the necessary layover<br />
space is proposed to be provided along the curbs on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and Citrus Avenue. Long-term need would be<br />
met by the bus facility on the north side of the light rail alignment where all fi ve bus routes would have layover space.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 281<br />
This local bus route carries nearly 2,100 passengers per weekday between Puente Hills Mall and Azusa via Industry, West<br />
Covina and Covina. It approaches Azusa from the south via Citrus Avenue and terminates one-quarter mile south of the<br />
station site at the intersection of <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard at Citrus Avenue.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study indicate that 74 percent of existing Route 281 riders are likely<br />
to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension, and that half of these consider the Azusa-Citrus Station as the preferred point of access,<br />
followed by Azusa-Alameda (12 percent) and Irwindale (11 percent). The concurrent survey of current <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> riders<br />
indicated that Azusa-Citrus Station is the most preferred among the six new stations as the initial point of access to the<br />
rail line. Detailed ridership data for Route 281 were not available for this analysis, making defi nitive recommendations<br />
more diffi cult. However, extension of the route to the Azusa –Citrus Station is strongly suggested to provide new<br />
connectivity with the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 488<br />
This local bus route carries nearly 1,600 passengers per weekday between El Monte and Glendora via Baldwin Park, West<br />
Covina and Covina. It approaches the Azusa-Citrus Station site from the south and east via South Grand Avenue and<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and currently terminates 0.5 mile east at the intersection of <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and Barranca Avenue.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study indicate that 54 percent of existing Route 488 riders are<br />
likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension, and that 56 percent of these consider the Azusa-Citrus Station as the preferred<br />
point of access, followed by Azusa-Alameda (9 percent) and Irwindale (7 percent). Detailed ridership data for Route<br />
488 were not available for this analysis, making defi nitive recommendations more diffi cult. However, extension of the<br />
route to the Azusa-Citrus Station is strongly suggested to provide an eff ective feeder connection from the South Grand<br />
Avenue corridor to the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>, as well as an additional bus connection between the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> and the San Bernardino<br />
<strong>Metro</strong>link <strong>Line</strong> in Covina.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 494<br />
This relatively low-volume express route provides weekday peak direction-only service between the San Dimas Park-and-<br />
Ride lot (site of a future <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> station) and the El Monte <strong>Bus</strong>way Station on an alignment that includes three stations<br />
in this phase: Azusa-Citrus, Azusa-Alameda, and Monrovia. It runs primarily east-west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard, Baseline<br />
Road and Huntington Drive east of Myrtle Avenue, and north-south on Myrtle to El Monte. Route 494 partially overlaps<br />
several other routes, including Route 492 on Arrow Highway; Route 284 on Lone Hill Avenue and <strong>Foothill</strong> Drive east of<br />
Glendora Avenue; Route 187 and shorter segments of several other routes on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and Huntington Drive;<br />
and <strong>Metro</strong> Route 270 on Myrtle Avenue to El Monte.<br />
Route 494 carries an average of 133 weekday boardings on seven one-way trips, or 19 passengers per trip. The results of<br />
the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported that 72 percent of existing Route 494 riders are likely to use the<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that the Azusa-Citrus Station is the preferred point of access for 23 percent of all riders, second to<br />
Azusa-Alameda (25 percent), but ahead of Monrovia (19 percent) and Duarte (15 percent). Detailed passenger boarding<br />
and alighting information was not available for analysis, making defi nitive recommendations more diffi cult. Either<br />
truncation at Azusa-Citrus Station or outright discontinuation should be considered in conjunction with restructuring<br />
local services to feed passengers into the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 498<br />
This express route provides weekday peak direction-only service between the Citrus College Park-And-Ride Lot in Azusa<br />
and downtown Los Angeles via Covina and West Covina. It carries 866 passengers per average weekday on 23 westbound<br />
trips to Los Angeles in the morning and 25 return trips to Azusa in the afternoon. Average ridership per one-way trip is 18<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan
F 494<br />
E Alosta Ave<br />
F 187<br />
Azusa-Citrus<br />
Station<br />
N Citrus Ave<br />
F 281<br />
F 187<br />
W <strong>Foothill</strong> Blvd<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
N Barranca Ave<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Figure 2-18: Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Azusa-Citrus Station<br />
F 498<br />
Alosta Ave<br />
W Bennett Ave<br />
F 488<br />
F 851<br />
S Grand Ave<br />
LEGEND<br />
M<br />
F<br />
North<br />
0 300 600 Feet<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route<br />
45
46<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
passengers.<br />
Morning trips currently depart from the intersection of Barranca Avenue at <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard, which is 0.5 mile east of the<br />
Azusa-Citrus Station site. <strong>Bus</strong>es turn east on Alosta Avenue and south onto Grand Avenue to the I-10 Freeway. Afternoon<br />
trips return via north on Grand and west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard to Barranca Avenue.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported that 54 percent of existing Route 498 riders are<br />
likely to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that the Azusa-Citrus Station is overwhelmingly preferred as the point of access,<br />
by 69 percent of those who expect to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>. Detailed passenger boarding and alighting information was<br />
not available for analysis, making defi nitive recommendations more diffi cult. Discontinuation should be considered in<br />
conjunction with restructuring local services to feed passengers into the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>. From a policy perspective, <strong>Foothill</strong><br />
Transit and <strong>Metro</strong> should consider truncating or discontinuing parallel express bus services to downtown Los Angeles<br />
when feeder services to the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> off er comparable service.<br />
Station Interface<br />
This station is particularly important as an intermodal transfer point due to its dual function as a major generator of walkon<br />
passenger traffi c and as the eastern terminus of the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> once the Azusa to Pasadena Extension is completed.<br />
Survey results conducted for this analysis suggest that this location will attract nine percent of total <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> a.m.<br />
and p.m. peak boardings, the most among the six new stations, and six percent of midday and night-time boardings.<br />
Projected utilization of Azusa-Citrus Station is even higher as an alighting point, with 12 percent of total anticipated <strong>Gold</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong> passengers alighting there during midday and p.m. peak periods 10 percent at night and six percent during the<br />
morning peak. The survey also indicated that 79 percent of respondents are interested in the extension from Azusa-Citrus<br />
to Montclair, suggesting that interim demand for access to Azusa-Citrus among residents of eastern San Gabriel Valley<br />
cities will be high. <strong>Proposed</strong> bus route modifi cations are shown in Figure 2-19.<br />
In view of its interim signifi cance as the Pasadena to Azusa Extension eastern terminus, timely construction of an off -<br />
street bus facility adjacent to Azusa-Citrus Station is recommended. The bus interface plan acknowledges that location<br />
and confi guration of a permanent facility is contingent on development of the adjacent Rosemont Master Planned<br />
Community. This may require the use of on-street bus stops and a nearby off -site location where terminating buses can<br />
spend scheduled recovery time and turn around. Initially buses will board and discharge passengers at on-street bus<br />
stops located on both sides of <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard at the Citrus Avenue curve. Terminating buses would then deadhead<br />
to an off -site recovery time point. Lacking restroom facilities, this location is not suggested for extended layovers until a<br />
permanent off -street facility is constructed.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan
F 494<br />
E Alosta Ave<br />
F 187<br />
Azusa-Citrus<br />
Station<br />
F 281<br />
N Citrus Ave<br />
W <strong>Foothill</strong> Blvd<br />
F 188<br />
N Barranca Ave<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Figure 2-19: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing at Azusa-Citrus Station<br />
F 498<br />
Alosta Ave<br />
W Bennett Ave<br />
F 488<br />
F 851<br />
S Grand Ave<br />
LEGEND<br />
F<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> New Layover Location<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route<br />
North<br />
0 300 600 Feet<br />
47
48<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
INTERIM RESTRUCTURING OF BUS ROUTES: AZUSA TO MONTCLAIR<br />
Completion of the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension from Pasadena to Azusa will warrant consideration of interim service changes to<br />
routes that primarily serve communities east of Azusa that later will be served directly by light rail service in the Azusa<br />
to Montclair Extension. This section provides a limited plan that diverts and truncates selected bus routes at the Azusa-<br />
Citrus Station, and proposes others for discontinuation.<br />
Results from the random telephone survey of San Gabriel residents conducted for this study indicate that Azusa-Citrus<br />
Station will become an attractive access point for central and eastern San Gabriel Valley residents who indicated likely use<br />
of the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> upon completion of the Pasadena to Azusa Extension. Similarly, the onboard survey of current bus riders<br />
indicate that the Azusa-Citrus Station will be the most likely point of access preferred by 23 percent of those who expect<br />
to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> when this extension opens, followed by Monrovia (15 percent), Duarte (14 percent), Azusa-Alameda<br />
(11 percent), Arcadia (8 percent) and Irwindale (7 percent).<br />
Changes to four existing bus routes as shown in Figure 2-20 are proposed:<br />
Glendora Mini <strong>Bus</strong> <strong>Metro</strong>link Shuttle<br />
This commuter shuttle service operated by the City of Glendora runs between the Glendora Transportation Center on<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard at Dalton Avenue and the Covina <strong>Metro</strong>link Station, primarily via Barranca Avenue. Southbound<br />
service to <strong>Metro</strong>link comprises six trips departing between at 5:18 a.m. and 7:14 a.m. on weekdays only. Return service<br />
comprises six northbound trips departing between 4:00 p.m. and 6:40 p.m. Neither passenger boarding and alighting<br />
information nor specifi c survey results relative to this route were available for analysis. Generally the route should be<br />
integrated into the larger bus interface plan that would feed Glendora passengers primarily to the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> throughout<br />
the service day and provide north-south connecting service to the <strong>Metro</strong>link San Bernardino <strong>Line</strong>.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 284<br />
This local bus route carries 410 passengers per weekday between West Covina and Glendora via Covina and San Dimas.<br />
It approaches the planned <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Glendora Station site from the east via <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and south on Glendora<br />
Avenue to an on-street terminal point at Ada Avenue.<br />
The results of the bus rider survey conducted for this study reported that 42 percent of existing Route 284 riders are likely<br />
to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension and that the Azusa-Citrus Station is preferred as the point of access by 36 percent of those<br />
who expect to use the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>, followed by Azusa-Alameda (26 percent) and Irwindale (14 percent). Detailed passenger<br />
boarding and alighting information was not available for analysis, making defi nitive recommendations more diffi cult.<br />
However, extension of Route 284 two miles west via <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard to the Azusa-Citrus Station should be considered.<br />
The bus connection presumably would be maintained until <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> service is extended to Glendora Station.<br />
One possible routing would be to extend the route from the existing terminus at Glendora Avenue and Alosta Avenue by<br />
routing busses west on Alosta, north on Grand Avenue and west on <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard to the Azusa-Citrus Station. This<br />
would minimize duplication with Route 187 on Alosta Avenue and maintain coverage on most of the segment of <strong>Foothill</strong><br />
Boulevard to be vacated by the proposed discontinuation of Route 494.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 690<br />
This express route operates peak direction-only weekday service between the Montclair Transit Center and downtown<br />
Pasadena on an alignment comprised primarily of <strong>Foothill</strong> Boulevard and Baseline Road east of Azusa, and the I-210<br />
Freeway west of Azusa Avenue to downtown Pasadena. It overlays local Route 187 east of Glendora. It carries an average<br />
of 274 weekday boardings on nine westbound trips in the morning and eight eastbound trips in the afternoon. Average<br />
ridership is 16 passengers per one-way trip.<br />
Detailed passenger boarding and alighting information was not available for analysis, making defi nitive<br />
recommendations more diffi cult. At a minimum, Route 690 should be diverted via Citrus Avenue to the Azusa-Citrus<br />
Station when the Pasadena to Azusa extension opens, to avoid redundancy with the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong>. Discontinuation should<br />
be considered as part of future planning.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 851<br />
This commuter-oriented local route operates weekday peak period service between Glendora and the Covina <strong>Metro</strong>link<br />
Station on a meandering north-south alignment comprised primarily of Glendora Avenue and Sunfl ower Avenue. It<br />
crosses the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> corridor at Glendora Avenue north of Alosta Avenue. Route 851 carries an average of 165 weekday<br />
boardings on eight morning trips and seven afternoon trips. Average ridership is 11 passengers per one-way trip.<br />
Detailed passenger boarding and alighting information was not available for analysis, making defi nitive<br />
recommendations more diffi cult. Consideration should be given to extending selected trips on Route 851 via <strong>Foothill</strong><br />
Boulevard to the Azusa-Citrus Station. Alternatively, local feeder service to Azusa-Citrus Station could replace the existing<br />
segment on Sierra Madre Boulevard and between Grand Avenue and Valley Center Avenue. It is recognized that this<br />
route serves a signifi cant number of school trips on weekdays. No modifi cations to school peak service are proposed.<br />
Systemic restructuring within cities east of Azusa should be considered in context of future service changes contemplated<br />
by <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit either prior to or concurrently with the opening of the extension to Montclair.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
LEGEND<br />
M<br />
F<br />
North<br />
Existing <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong> Discontinued <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Station<br />
<strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Alignment<br />
<strong>Metro</strong>link<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
0 0.2 0.4 miles<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Route<br />
Figure 2-20: <strong>Proposed</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Routing – Azusa to Montclair<br />
49
50<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
NET COST OF BUS INTERFACE RECOMMENDATIONS: PASADENA TO AZUSA PROJECT<br />
This section presents a preliminary estimate of operating cost associated with the preceding recommendations. <strong>Gold</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong> service span and frequency are key variables that will aff ect both the total operating cost of the Pasadena to Azusa<br />
feeder bus network as well as the extent to which schedule coordination between buses and trains may be achieved at<br />
the new rail stations. As actual 2015 rail schedules have yet to be fi nalized, the following assumptions have been drawn<br />
for purposes of plan costing.<br />
• Service Span – It is assumed that the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> will operate seven days per week generally between the hours of 4:30<br />
a.m. and 1:00 a.m., a daily span of 20.5 hours. This is comparable to the existing service span operated on the <strong>Gold</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong> between Pasadena and Los Angeles.<br />
• Service Frequency – Design headways recommended during the engineering phase diff er from the current level of<br />
service operated between Pasadena and Los Angeles. Planned Pasadena to Azusa service frequencies by service day<br />
and time period are summarized in Table 2-2.<br />
TABLE 2-2 <strong>Metro</strong> <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Service Span and Frequency<br />
February 2011<br />
SERVICE FREQUENCY<br />
Service Day Operating Hours Early AM a.m. Peak Base p.m. Peak Night<br />
Weekday 4:30am - 1:00 am 15 10 15 10 20<br />
Saturday 4:30am - 1:00 am 20 20 15 15 20<br />
Sunday 4:30am - 1:00 am 20 20 15 15 20<br />
Two bus service scenarios are included in this section to provide a range of probable operating cost for the Pasadena to<br />
Azusa bus network:<br />
• Base Case – includes all intersecting routes operating on modifi ed alignments as proposed at or near prevailing (2011)<br />
service levels in terms of service span and frequency;<br />
• Enhanced Service Levels – includes all intersecting routes operating on modifi ed alignments as proposed at<br />
enhanced service levels including service span equivalent to that of the <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> and bus frequencies suffi cient to<br />
meet every other train on a directional basis.<br />
Ideally, buses and trains should operate on an even multiple of the same headway to ensure schedule coordination on a<br />
directional basis. However, in consideration of both the suburban character of the Pasadena to Azusa service area and<br />
current 30 to 60 minute headways on many of the existing routes, it is assumed that meeting every train on a directional<br />
basis may be unattainable within the current transit funding environment in California. Therefore it is recommended that<br />
for planning purposes target headways for intersecting bus routes be based on an objective of meeting every other <strong>Gold</strong><br />
<strong>Line</strong> train on a bi-directional basis.<br />
BASE CASE<br />
As indicated in Table 2-3, cumulative annual revenue vehicle hours for all intersecting routes would increase by 0.8<br />
percent, from 394,734 to 398,054 assuming the base case scenario. Key changes include the proposed discontinuation of<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit Route 494. Additional savings would come from the truncation of <strong>Foothill</strong> Route 690 at the Azusa-Citrus<br />
Station, and truncation of <strong>Foothill</strong> Route 272 at Monrovia Station. These operating cost reductions would be off set by the<br />
extension of <strong>Foothill</strong> Routes 284 to Azusa-Citrus Station, division of <strong>Foothill</strong> Route 187 and <strong>Metro</strong> Route 487 into multiple<br />
routes, and various minor route extensions and span improvements as necessary to support the proposed bus interface<br />
plan.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan
TABLE 2-3 <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Extension: Pasadena to Azusa <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Change in Level of Service - Base Case<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
Existing Revenue Hours <strong>Proposed</strong> Revenue Hours<br />
Route Operator Stations Aff ected Weekday Saturday Sunday Annual Weekday Saturday Sunday Annual Percent Change<br />
79 (78) 1 <strong>Metro</strong> Arcadia 181.2 131.9 112.1 59,559 185.5 131.3 114.3 60,759 2.0%<br />
185 <strong>Foothill</strong> Irwindale, Alameda 73.9 55.0 55.0 24,896 73.5 61.5 61.5 25,508 2.5%<br />
186 <strong>Foothill</strong> Arcadia 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 81.8 47.3 64.5 26,000 1.3%<br />
187 <strong>Foothill</strong> Arcadia, Alameda, Citrus 269.5 154.8 154.8 85,748 109.0 65.3 62.0 34,788 1.3%<br />
188 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 81.8 49.0 46.5 26,091 1.3%<br />
264 (267) 2 <strong>Metro</strong> Monrovia, Duarte 55.3 33.7 33.6 17,800 56.0 33.0 33.0 17,910 0.6%<br />
270 <strong>Metro</strong> Monrovia 68.5 52.6 0.0 20,203 70.0 52.0 0.0 20,554 1.7%<br />
272 <strong>Foothill</strong> Duarte 27.3 19.6 19.6 9,107 22.5 18.8 18.8 7,800 -14.4%<br />
280 <strong>Foothill</strong> Alameda 94.7 59.0 59.0 30,622 95.0 61.0 59.5 30,848 0.7%<br />
281 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 93.1 36.7 36.7 27,764 95.0 39.0 39.0 28,515 2.7%<br />
284 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 16.4 14.8 14.8 5,802 22.0 18.0 18.0 7,590 30.8%<br />
487 <strong>Metro</strong> Arcadia 138.4 58.7 58.7 41,749 88.5 39.0 39.0 26,858 7.2%<br />
487A <strong>Metro</strong> Arcadia 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 59.0 26.0 26.0 17,905 7.2%<br />
488 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 75.1 43.1 43.1 23,875 76.5 43.5 43.5 24,293 1.7%<br />
494 <strong>Foothill</strong> Monrovia, Alameda, Citrus 9.1 0.0 0.0 2,315 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 -100.0%<br />
498 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 64.4 0.0 0.0 16,430 64.4 0.0 0.0 16,430 0.0%<br />
690 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 25.4 0.0 0.0 6,482 13.9 0.0 0.0 3,538 -45.4%<br />
851 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 13.5 0.0 0.0 3,450 13.5 0.0 0.0 3,450 0.01%<br />
Blue City of Duarte Duarte 12.0 10.0 0.0 3,580 13.0 11.0 0.0 3,887 8.6%<br />
Green City of Duarte Duarte 12.0 0.0 0.0 3,060 13.0 0.0 0.0 3,315 8.3%<br />
Commuter City of Duarte Duarte 1.5 0.0 0.0 383 1.5 0.0 0.0 383 0.01%<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Link Shuttle Glendora Minibus Citrus 3.7 0.0 0.0 944 4.0 0.0 0.0 1,020 8.1%<br />
Campus Trolley APU Citrus 43.0 0.0 0.0 10,965 43.0 0.0 0.0 10,965 0.0%<br />
Notes: 1 Estimated 67% of existing revenue hours attributable to Route 79<br />
2 Estimated 50% of existing revenue hours attributable to Route 264<br />
Total 1,277.9 669.6 587.1 394,734 1,280.8 695.6 607.6 398,054 0.8%<br />
51
52<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
The estimated net eff ect on bus transit operating budgets associated with the Base Case scenario is summarized in Table<br />
2-4. The plan generates net savings of slightly over $100,000 for <strong>Foothill</strong> Transit, and net cost of $0.57 million for <strong>Metro</strong>, as<br />
well as nominally increased cost for Duarte Transit and Glendora Minibus.<br />
TABLE 2-4 <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Base Case Operating Expenses<br />
Operator / Service Cost per RVH<br />
Existing<br />
Revenue<br />
Hours<br />
Existing<br />
Operating<br />
Expense<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Revenue Hours<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Operating<br />
Expense<br />
Change Revenue<br />
Hours<br />
Net Change<br />
Expense<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> directly operated $130.84 119,108 $15,584,119 123,431 $16,149,756 4,323 $565,637<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> contract 84.07 20,203 $1,698,441 20,203 $1,698,441 0 $0<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit - except<br />
488 & 498<br />
61.43 196,187 $12,051,755 196,288 $12,058,000 -2,058 -$126,435<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 488 60.44 23,875 $1,443,032 24,293 $1,468,239 417 $25,207<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 498 103.55 16,430 $1,701,290 16,430 $1,701,290 0 $0<br />
Duarte 60.00 7,023 $421,350 7,202 $432,120 562 $33,720<br />
Glendora 60.00 944 $56,610 1,020 $61,200 77 $4,590<br />
Azusa Pacifi c University 60.00 10,965 $657,900 10,965 $657,900 0 $0<br />
Total -- 394,734 $33,614,497 398,054 $34,117,216 3,320 $502,719<br />
Notes: * <strong>Metro</strong> unit costs per LAMTA Planning Department (S. Chesler). <strong>Foothill</strong> unit costs per <strong>Foothill</strong> Planning Department (L. Gillespie). Duarte, Glendora, and APU<br />
unit cost estimates by IBI Group.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
ENHANCED SERVICED LEVEL SCENARIO – BUS RESTRUCTURING WITH ENHANCED SERVICE LEVELS<br />
As indicated in Table 2-5, cumulative annual revenue vehicle hours for all intersecting routes would increase by 52 percent, from 394,734 to 601,161 annually, assuming the Enhanced Service Level scenario. The enhanced scenario assumes all<br />
proposed route changes operating on schedules designed to meet every other <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> train on a directional basis. Most routes would operate every 20 minutes during the a.m. and p.m. peak hours; every 30 minutes during the weekday base<br />
period and on weekends, and every 40 minutes at night.<br />
TABLE 2-5 <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> Pasadena to Azusa <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Change in Level of Service - Enhanced Service Levels<br />
Existing Revenue Hours Enhanced Revenue Hours<br />
Route Operator Stations Aff ected Weekday Saturday Sunday Annual Weekday Saturday Sunday Annual Percent Change<br />
79 (78) 1 <strong>Metro</strong> Arcadia 181.2 131.9 112.1 59,559 181.1 133.9 133.9 60,913 2.3%<br />
185 <strong>Foothill</strong> Irwindale, Alameda 73.9 55.0 55.0 24,896 132.8 114.8 114.8 46,474 86.7%<br />
186 <strong>Foothill</strong> Arcadia 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 66.4 57.4 57.4 23,237 -9.7%<br />
187 <strong>Foothill</strong> Arcadia, Alameda, Citrus 269.5 154.8 154.8 85,748 88.5 76.5 76.5 30,983 -9.7%<br />
188 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 66.4 57.4 57.4 23,237 -9.7%<br />
264 (267) 2 <strong>Metro</strong> Monrovia, Duarte 55.3 33.7 33.6 17,800 88.5 76.5 76.5 30,983 74.1%<br />
270 <strong>Metro</strong> Monrovia 68.5 52.6 0.0 20,203 177.0 153.0 0.0 53,091 162.8%<br />
272 <strong>Foothill</strong> Duarte 27.3 19.6 19.6 9,107 66.4 57.4 57.4 23,237 155.2%<br />
280 <strong>Foothill</strong> Alameda 94.7 59.0 59.0 30,622 88.5 76.5 76.5 30,983 1.2%<br />
281 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 93.1 36.7 36.7 27,764 132.8 114.8 114.8 46,474 67.4%<br />
284 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 16.4 14.8 14.8 5,802 66.4 57.4 57.4 23,237 300.5%<br />
487 <strong>Metro</strong> Arcadia 138.4 58.7 58.7 41,749 132.8 114.8 114.8 46,474 11.3%<br />
487A <strong>Metro</strong> Arcadia 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 88.5 76.5 76.5 30,983 NA<br />
488 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 75.1 43.1 43.1 23,875 132.8 114.8 114.8 46,474 94.7%<br />
494 <strong>Foothill</strong> Monrovia, Alameda, Citrus 9.1 0.0 0.0 2,315 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 -100.0%<br />
498 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 64.4 0.0 0.0 16,430 64.4 0.0 0.0 16,430 0.0%<br />
690 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 25.4 0.0 0.0 6,482 33.2 0.0 0.0 8,463 30.6%<br />
851 <strong>Foothill</strong> Citrus 13.5 0.0 0.0 3,450 88.5 0.0 0.0 22,568 554.1%<br />
Blue City of Duarte Duarte 12.0 10.0 0.0 3,580 44.3 38.3 0.0 13,273 270.7%<br />
Green City of Duarte Duarte 12.0 0.0 0.0 3,060 44.3 0.0 0.0 11,284 268.8%<br />
Commuter City of Duarte Duarte 1.5 0.0 0.0 383 1.5 0.0 0.0 383 0.0%<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> Link Shuttle Glendora Minibus Citrus 3.7 0.0 0.0 944 4.0 0.0 0.0 1,020 8.1%<br />
Campus Trolley APU Citrus 43.0 0.0 0.0 10,965 43.0 0.0 0.0 10,965 0.0%<br />
Notes: 1 Estimated 67% of existing revenue hours attributable to Route 79<br />
2 Estimated 50% of existing revenue hours attributable to Route 264<br />
Total 1,277.9 669.6 587.1 394,734 1,831.7 1,319.6 1,128.4 601,161 52.3%<br />
53
54<br />
CHAPTER 2 | PROPOSED BUS ROUTE MODIFICATIONS<br />
The estimated net eff ect on bus transit operating budgets is summarized in Table 2-6. Full implementation of the<br />
Enhanced Service Level scenario would increase bus system operating expenses by $16.9 million (current dollars).<br />
TABLE 2-6 <strong>Gold</strong> <strong>Line</strong> <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan Enhanced Service Level Operating Expenses<br />
Operator / Service Cost per RVH<br />
Existing<br />
Revenue<br />
Hours<br />
Existing<br />
Operating<br />
Expense<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Revenue Hours<br />
<strong>Proposed</strong><br />
Operating<br />
Expense<br />
Change Revenue<br />
Hours<br />
Net Change<br />
Expense<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> directly operated $130.84 119,108 $15,584,119 169,352 $22,157,999 50,244 $6,573,881<br />
<strong>Metro</strong> contract 84.07 20,203 $1,698,441 53,091 $4,463,360 32,888 $2,764,919<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Transit - except<br />
488 & 498<br />
61.43 196,187 $12,051,755 278,890 $17,132,232 82,704 $5,080,477<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 488 60.44 23,875 $1,443,032 46,474 $2,808,873 22,598 $1,365,841<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Route 498 103.55 16,430 $1,701,290 16,430 $1,701,290 0 $0<br />
Duarte 60.00 7,023 $421,350 24,939 $1,496,340 17,917 $1,074,990<br />
Glendora 60.00 944 $56,610 1,020 $61,200 77 $4,590<br />
Azusa Pacifi c University 60.00 10,965 $657,900 10,965 $657,900 0 $0<br />
Total -- 394,734 $33,614,497 601,161 $50,479,195 206,427 $16,864,698<br />
Notes: * <strong>Metro</strong> unit costs per LAMTA Planning Department (S. Chesler). <strong>Foothill</strong> unit costs per <strong>Foothill</strong> Planning Department (L. Gillespie). Duarte, Glendora and APU<br />
unit cost estimates by IBI Group.<br />
<strong>Foothill</strong> Extension <strong>Bus</strong> Interface Plan