Conducting Educational Research
Caroll
Caroll
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
WRITING A RESEARCH QUESTION<br />
The category is determined by the degree to which the study will involve and<br />
impact the subjects. Those projects that have greater risks, stress or discomfort to<br />
the subjects require greater scrutiny. We encourage our students to design their<br />
studies so they will be deemed exempt. This does not mean the proposal is not<br />
required to be reviewed and approved by the IRB, but the number of members that<br />
must review the proposal is reduced. In our institution, examples of types of<br />
proposals generally determined to be exempt can be found in Table 2.1. A<br />
complete listing of exempt categories is available in the Code of Federal Regulations<br />
(45 CFR 46.101); the URL is located in the reference section of this chapter. You<br />
will need to check with your institution to get the specific guidelines to follow to<br />
get your research proposal approved.<br />
Table 2.1. Samples of an exempt proposal<br />
− Investigations of commonly accepted educational practices in established or<br />
commonly accepted settings (e.g., a faculty member or teacher is examining a new<br />
method of teaching instruction to determine educational effectiveness)<br />
− Analysis of information from educational tests that will be recorded in such<br />
a manner that subjects cannot be identified<br />
− Surveys or interviews in which responses will be recorded in such a manner that<br />
a subject cannot be identified directly or through identifiers linked to a subject. To<br />
qualify for exempt status, the surveys would not involve vulnerable populations<br />
(e.g., juveniles) or ask questions about sensitive aspects of a subject’s behavior<br />
(e.g., criminal behavior)<br />
− Observations of public behavior (participant observation)<br />
− Collection or study of publicly available existing data, documents, records or<br />
specimens<br />
− Collection or study of existing data, documents, records or specimens in which<br />
information will be recorded or reported in such a manner that a subject cannot<br />
be identified directly or through identifiers linked to a subject<br />
Source: University of Portland, 2008. Reprinted with permission.<br />
In expedited and full review studies, there are two important criteria that<br />
must be met concerning the use of human subjects: their privacy must be<br />
maintained and you must have informed consent. Privacy of individuals is<br />
maintained through the use of anonymous data collection or confidential means<br />
such as coding. Although this is not always possible, participants must be<br />
assured that they cannot—even through their responses—be identified by a third<br />
party.<br />
Subjects must also be willing participants in the research project after being<br />
briefed about the purpose of the study and any risks. This consent is written. If the<br />
subjects are under 18 years of ago, consent must be obtained by the parent/legal<br />
guardian of the minor.<br />
29