23.10.2012 Views

"Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!" - unam.

"Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!" - unam.

"Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!" - unam.

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Somebody had gotten tired of this, no doubt, and had taken the door off. Now this<br />

room, it so happened, had two doors, the way it was built, so I got an idea: I took the<br />

other door off its hinges, carried it downstairs, and hid it in the basement behind the oil<br />

tank. Then I quietly went back upstairs and went to bed.<br />

Later in the morning I made believe I woke up and came downstairs a little late.<br />

The other guys were milling around, and Pete and his friends were all upset: The doors to<br />

their room were missing, and they had to study, blah, blah, blah, blah. I was coming<br />

down the stairs and they said, "<strong>Feynman</strong>! Did you take the doors?"<br />

"Oh, yeah!" I said. "I took the door. You can see the scratches on my knuckles<br />

here, that I got when my hands scraped against the wall as I was carrying it down into the<br />

basement."<br />

They weren't satisfied with my answer; in fact, they didn't believe me.<br />

The guys who took the first door had left so many clues ­­ the handwriting on the<br />

signs, for instance ­­ that they were soon found out. My idea was that when it was found<br />

out who stole the first door, everybody would think they also stole the other door. It<br />

worked perfectly: The guys who took the first door were pummeled and tortured and<br />

worked on by everybody, until finally, with much pain and difficulty, they convinced<br />

their tormentors that they had only taken one door, unbelievable as it might be.<br />

I listened to all this, and I was happy.<br />

The other door stayed missing for a whole week, and it became more and more<br />

important to the guys who were trying to study in that room that the other door be found.<br />

Finally, in order to solve the problem, the president of the fraternity says at the<br />

dinner table, "We have to solve this problem of the other door. I haven't been able to<br />

solve the problem myself, so I would like suggestions from the rest of you as to how to<br />

straighten this out, because Pete and the others are trying to study."<br />

Somebody makes a suggestion, then someone else.<br />

After a little while, I get up and make a suggestion. "All right," I say in a sarcastic<br />

voice, "whoever you are who stole the door, we know you're wonderful. <strong>You're</strong> so clever!<br />

We can't figure out who you are, so you must be some sort of super­genius. You don't<br />

have to tell us who you are; all we want to know is where the door is. So if you will leave<br />

a note somewhere, telling us where the door is, we will honor you and admit forever that<br />

you are a super­marvel, that you are so smart that you could take the other door without<br />

our being able to figure out who you are. But for God's sake, just leave the note<br />

somewhere, and we will be forever grateful to you for it."<br />

The next guy makes his suggestion: "I have another idea," he says. "I think that<br />

you, as president, should ask each man on his word of honor towards the fraternity to say<br />

whether he took the door or not."<br />

The president says, "That's a very good idea. On the fraternity word of honor!" So<br />

he goes around the table, and asks each guy, one by one: "Jack, did you take the door?"<br />

"No, sir, I did not take the door."<br />

"Tim: Did you take the door?"<br />

"No, sir! I did not take the door!"<br />

"Maurice. Did you take the door?"<br />

"No, I did not take the door, sir."<br />

"<strong>Feynman</strong>, did you take the door?"<br />

"Yeah, I took the door."

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!