Experimental infection and protection against ... - TI Pharma

Experimental infection and protection against ... - TI Pharma Experimental infection and protection against ... - TI Pharma

31.08.2013 Views

General Discussion 229 to induce protection when co-administered with live sporozoites in a mouse model [111]. Interestingly, both drugs also exhibit immunoregulatory properties [112-114]. Alternatively, the passive transfer of antibodies directed against blood-stage antigens could also prevent clinical disease and modulate the immune response [115]. As an alternative to radiation, several other methods of attenuation, mainly in rodent models, have been developed. Treatment of sporozoites with the DNA alkylating agent centanamycin, a compound that particularly attenuates malaria parasites because it exploits the AT-richness of the parasite genome, impairs the infection of hepatocytes by sporozoites and arrests liver stage parasite development. Mice inoculated with centanamycin-treated sporozoites failed to produce blood stage infections and were protected against subsequent challenge with wild-type sporozoites [116]. Moreover, cross-species protection could be induced and parasite-specific antibodies and IFN-gamma-producing CD8(+) T cells were induced that were not significantly different from radiationattenuated sporozoites [116]. In fact, CPS immunisation also implies chemical attenuation, albeit in vivo. CPS as currently presented is not a widely implementable vaccine strategy, but one could envision the co-administration of a drug with a needle administered live vaccine product for a selected group of subjects. However, safety requirements for such in vivo attenuated product will likely be very stringent, e.g. full attenuation must be independent from compliance and pharmacokinetics of the drug. Moreover, in vivo attenuation precludes the ability to carry out viability checks before the vaccine is administered, necessitating extensive postvaccination follow-up. In addition to the random genetic attenuation induced by radiation or chemicals, targeted attenuation of sporozoites can be achieved by inactivation of specific genes by molecular techniques. The main advantage of Genetically Attenuated Parasites [GAP) over radiation and chemically attenuated parasites is the fact that a homogeneous parasite population with a defined phenotype is obtained. The recent availability of complete Plasmodium genome sequences permits the development of live-attenuated parasites by more precise and defined genetic manipulations [117]. Based on their expression profile and phenotype, approximately seven genes have been selected for attenuation and knock-out strains created primarily in rodent malaria parasites P. berghei and P. yoelii (p52, p36, uis3, uis4, fabb/f, fabz, sap1 [118-126]). Immunisation of mice with GAP

230 Chapter 11 results in protective immune responses that are similar to those induced by irradiated sporozoites [127, 128]. To ensure safety of the GAP vaccine, the liver arrest of a genetically attenuated parasite vaccine needs to be complete and irreversible [129]. Occasional breakthrough infections in GAP lacking genes uis4 and p52, emphasize that multiple genes will have to be removed in order to achieve complete arrest [119, 120]. Recently studies, however, show that also parasites lacking expression of both P52 and P36 are capable of developing through the liver stage into blood stage infections in vitro and in mouse models [130]. This raises concerns about the number of genes that need to be attenuated to ensure safety of a whole-sporozoite vaccine. The potency of a GAP, on the contrary, depends on development of the attenuated parasites into the late liver stage, engendering higher levels of T-cell responses and cross-stage and cross–species protection [124]. Whether or not safety and potency requirements can both be adequately met in one multiply-attenuated whole parasite product will have to be investigated. In addition, the GAP vaccines also require precautions with respect to the introduction of attenuated parasites into the environment, most likely necessitating the removal of foreign DNA sequences from the parasite clones [131]. Regardless of the method of attenuation, a live attenuated sporozoite vaccine will have to meet stringent safety regulations, as accidental parasite multiplication may induce a potentially fatal disease particularly if the vaccine is to be used in immunologically vulnerable populations: HIV-infected subjects or malnourished infants. An assay that could be reliably and repeatedly used to check the potency of sporozoites for vaccination would be an important asset. Such a potency assay could also potentially address the issue of translating the dose of mosquito-delivered inoculation into a needle-delivered vaccines. The only currently available potency assay is the in vitro hepatocyte invasion assay. This assay relies on the in vitro invasion of Pf sporozoites in the hepatoma cell line HepG2, the human transformed hepatocyte cell line HC04 or primary human hepatocytes, all of which are unfortunately limited by very low infection efficiencies (

General Discussion 229<br />

to induce <strong>protection</strong> when co-administered with live sporozoites in a mouse<br />

model [111]. Interestingly, both drugs also exhibit immunoregulatory properties<br />

[112-114]. Alternatively, the passive transfer of antibodies directed <strong>against</strong><br />

blood-stage antigens could also prevent clinical disease <strong>and</strong> modulate the<br />

immune response [115].<br />

As an alternative to radiation, several other methods of attenuation, mainly in<br />

rodent models, have been developed. Treatment of sporozoites with the DNA<br />

alkylating agent centanamycin, a compound that particularly attenuates malaria<br />

parasites because it exploits the AT-richness of the parasite genome, impairs the<br />

<strong>infection</strong> of hepatocytes by sporozoites <strong>and</strong> arrests liver stage parasite<br />

development. Mice inoculated with centanamycin-treated sporozoites failed to<br />

produce blood stage <strong>infection</strong>s <strong>and</strong> were protected <strong>against</strong> subsequent<br />

challenge with wild-type sporozoites [116]. Moreover, cross-species <strong>protection</strong><br />

could be induced <strong>and</strong> parasite-specific antibodies <strong>and</strong> IFN-gamma-producing<br />

CD8(+) T cells were induced that were not significantly different from radiationattenuated<br />

sporozoites [116].<br />

In fact, CPS immunisation also implies chemical attenuation, albeit in vivo. CPS as<br />

currently presented is not a widely implementable vaccine strategy, but one<br />

could envision the co-administration of a drug with a needle administered live<br />

vaccine product for a selected group of subjects. However, safety requirements<br />

for such in vivo attenuated product will likely be very stringent, e.g. full<br />

attenuation must be independent from compliance <strong>and</strong> pharmacokinetics of the<br />

drug. Moreover, in vivo attenuation precludes the ability to carry out viability<br />

checks before the vaccine is administered, necessitating extensive postvaccination<br />

follow-up.<br />

In addition to the r<strong>and</strong>om genetic attenuation induced by radiation or chemicals,<br />

targeted attenuation of sporozoites can be achieved by inactivation of specific<br />

genes by molecular techniques. The main advantage of Genetically Attenuated<br />

Parasites [GAP) over radiation <strong>and</strong> chemically attenuated parasites is the fact<br />

that a homogeneous parasite population with a defined phenotype is obtained.<br />

The recent availability of complete Plasmodium genome sequences permits the<br />

development of live-attenuated parasites by more precise <strong>and</strong> defined genetic<br />

manipulations [117]. Based on their expression profile <strong>and</strong> phenotype,<br />

approximately seven genes have been selected for attenuation <strong>and</strong> knock-out<br />

strains created primarily in rodent malaria parasites P. berghei <strong>and</strong> P. yoelii (p52,<br />

p36, uis3, uis4, fabb/f, fabz, sap1 [118-126]). Immunisation of mice with GAP

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!