Experimental infection and protection against ... - TI Pharma

Experimental infection and protection against ... - TI Pharma Experimental infection and protection against ... - TI Pharma

31.08.2013 Views

NF135.C10: a new Plasmodium falciparum clone for controlled human malaria infections and heterologous (NF54 infected/NF135.C10 stimulated, NF135.C10 infected/NF54 stimulated) in vitro re-stimulation (Figure 3D-I). IL-2 responses seemed slightly higher when stimulated with NF135.C10 but this was similar for NF135.C10 and NF54 infected volunteers. IFNγ-producing cells were found in both the innate compartment (γδ-T, NK, NK-T) and the adaptive compartment (CD4 and CD8) and mainly displayed an effector memory phenotype (Figure 4). Despite inter-individual differences in relative contribution of various subsets, the composition of responding cells was highly consistent over time for every individual (data not shown). Upon homologous restimulation of cells on C+35, the vast majority of responding lymphocytes were single positive for IFNγ (mean 71%), TNF (9.4%) or double positive for IFNγ and TNF (18%). Additional responding lymphocytes were single positive for IL-2 (0.40%), double positive IFNγ + IL-2 + (0.21%) or IL-2 + TNF + (0.61%) or triple positive (0.50%) (data not shown). Discussion We identified and characterized NF135.C10 as the first Pf clone of Asian origin for successful infection of malaria-naive human volunteers by CHMI. Clone NF135.C10 consistently produced gametocytes in culture, and was able to generate infections in laboratory-reared mosquitoes with high yields of sporozoites. NF135.C10 parasites were clearly distinct from NF54 parasites by drug sensitivity and established genetic marker profiles. Clinical presentation after CHMI and characteristics of PfRBC-specific recall (T-)lymphocyte responses in vitro were similar to NF54. Selection and identification of field strain parasites for CHMI poses technical difficulties, because of insufficient and unstable production of infectious sexual and sporogonic stages. For manufacturing purposes, cultures should ideally produce gametocytes that consistently infect at least 75% of the mosquitoes with at least ten oocysts resulting in 10-30 thousand sporozoites/mosquito. Only after extensive effort on more than seventy isolates were we able to successfully identify a parasite clone, NF135.C10, that met these criteria. Until now, the culture of NF135.C10 has only been re-started (using previous cryopreserved batches) seven times, as compared to 306 times for the NF54, and is therefore more closely related to the original clone. Also the geographical and molecular divergence from the NF54 strain makes this new clone an attractive candidate for use in CHMI trials. The vast majority of CHMI trials have been carried out 143

144 Chapter 7 with either the NF54 strain or its clone 3D7 (~1300 volunteers [4, 27]) as opposed to only 42 volunteers challenged with strain 7G8 of South American origin [7, 8, 27]. 3D7 is derived from NF54 and cannot be distinguished from NF54 by drug sensitivity testing, simple genetic markers, or microsatellite mapping (Sim et al., unpublished). Thus, clinical trials with more genetically distinct parasite strains including 7G8 or NF135.C10 will be important to complement current knowledge on heterologous Pf strains. Parasitological and clinical findings after CHMI with NF54 or 3D7 were recently compared in two meta-analyses (Roestenberg et al. PLoS One, in press)[28]. Here we show that clinical signs and symptoms induced by NF135.C10 or NF54 do not show any differences in successfully infected volunteers. We found slight differences in infectivity of the parasites; in these small groups of volunteers, NF135.C10 showed a marginally shorter prepatent period, but parasite kinetics of both NF135.C10 and NF54 were both within the limits of historical NF54 controls. Notably, not all volunteers exposed to NF54 infected mosquitoes became parasitemic, as assessed by both microscopy and qPCR in contrast to 22 previous CHMI trials infecting 128 naive volunteers with NF54 parasites (Roestenberg et al. PLoS One, in press). Unsuccessful infection after bites of five mosquitoes has been described previously for 3D7 [29, 30]. Although the exact reason is unclear, this might due to the unusual low NF135.C10 and NF54 oocyst and sporozoite counts per mosquito obtained for this trial compared to our routinely obtained counts (table 1). A technical disturbance in our cultures, leading to suboptimal culture circumstances prior to this study was most likely the reason for this relatively low mosquito infection with both strains. However, a formal relationship between sporozoite counts and mosquito infectivity has never been established [31] and only small percentages of sporozoites in salivary glands are injected during a blood meal of a mosquito [32-34]. Surprisingly, all three unsuccessfully infected volunteers reported AEs that were considered possibly, probably, or definitely related to the trial procedures. Symptoms reported by these volunteers might have been the result of over-reporting in an intense follow-up schedule, concurring with our findings from a previous study, in which volunteers reported malaria-related symptoms after exposure to bites of only uninfected mosquitoes [35]. Previously, we reported sustained IFNγ re-call responses in vitro in both αβ-T cells and γδ-T cells upon homologous PfRBC re-stimulation with NF54 asexual stage parasites after a single CHMI, suggestive of cross talk between innate and adaptive compartments with induction of memory [36, 37]. Here we show similar kinetics and composition of IFNγ responses upon homologous Pf54 and

NF135.C10: a new Plasmodium falciparum clone for controlled human malaria<br />

<strong>infection</strong>s<br />

<strong>and</strong> heterologous (NF54 infected/NF135.C10 stimulated, NF135.C10<br />

infected/NF54 stimulated) in vitro re-stimulation (Figure 3D-I). IL-2<br />

responses seemed slightly higher when stimulated with NF135.C10 but this was<br />

similar for NF135.C10 <strong>and</strong> NF54 infected volunteers. IFNγ-producing cells were<br />

found in both the innate compartment (γδ-T, NK, NK-T) <strong>and</strong> the adaptive<br />

compartment (CD4 <strong>and</strong> CD8) <strong>and</strong> mainly displayed an effector memory<br />

phenotype (Figure 4). Despite inter-individual differences in relative contribution<br />

of various subsets, the composition of responding cells was highly consistent<br />

over time for every individual (data not shown). Upon homologous restimulation<br />

of cells on C+35, the vast majority of responding lymphocytes were<br />

single positive for IFNγ (mean 71%), TNF (9.4%) or double positive for IFNγ <strong>and</strong><br />

TNF (18%). Additional responding lymphocytes were single positive for IL-2<br />

(0.40%), double positive IFNγ + IL-2 + (0.21%) or IL-2 + TNF + (0.61%) or triple<br />

positive (0.50%) (data not shown).<br />

Discussion<br />

We identified <strong>and</strong> characterized NF135.C10 as the first Pf clone of Asian origin<br />

for successful <strong>infection</strong> of malaria-naive human volunteers by CHMI. Clone<br />

NF135.C10 consistently produced gametocytes in culture, <strong>and</strong> was able to<br />

generate <strong>infection</strong>s in laboratory-reared mosquitoes with high yields of<br />

sporozoites. NF135.C10 parasites were clearly distinct from NF54 parasites by<br />

drug sensitivity <strong>and</strong> established genetic marker profiles. Clinical presentation<br />

after CHMI <strong>and</strong> characteristics of PfRBC-specific recall (T-)lymphocyte responses<br />

in vitro were similar to NF54.<br />

Selection <strong>and</strong> identification of field strain parasites for CHMI poses technical<br />

difficulties, because of insufficient <strong>and</strong> unstable production of infectious sexual<br />

<strong>and</strong> sporogonic stages. For manufacturing purposes, cultures should ideally<br />

produce gametocytes that consistently infect at least 75% of the mosquitoes<br />

with at least ten oocysts resulting in 10-30 thous<strong>and</strong> sporozoites/mosquito. Only<br />

after extensive effort on more than seventy isolates were we able to successfully<br />

identify a parasite clone, NF135.C10, that met these criteria. Until now, the<br />

culture of NF135.C10 has only been re-started (using previous cryopreserved<br />

batches) seven times, as compared to 306 times for the NF54, <strong>and</strong> is therefore<br />

more closely related to the original clone. Also the geographical <strong>and</strong> molecular<br />

divergence from the NF54 strain makes this new clone an attractive c<strong>and</strong>idate<br />

for use in CHMI trials. The vast majority of CHMI trials have been carried out<br />

143

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!