Falkirk Council Community Services
Falkirk Council Community Services
Falkirk Council Community Services
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Feb 2011 minutes (2).doc<br />
Minute of Meeting - Denny Development Group<br />
16 February 2010 in Denny <strong>Community</strong> Centre<br />
Present: <strong>Council</strong>lor Gerry Goldie(Chair)<br />
<strong>Council</strong>lor Martin Oliver<br />
<strong>Council</strong>lor John McNally<br />
<strong>Council</strong>lor Alex Waddell (from Item 4)<br />
Raymond Murray - Retailers Representative<br />
Ian Wallace - Henry Boot Developments Plc<br />
Michael Murphy – St Alexander’s Church<br />
Matt Mulligan - Denny & Dunipace <strong>Community</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Christine Bell - Denny & Dunipace <strong>Community</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Colin Belbin - Denny & Dunipace <strong>Community</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Brian McCabe - Denny & Dunipace <strong>Community</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Douglas Duff - <strong>Falkirk</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Colin Frame - <strong>Falkirk</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Jacquie McArthur - <strong>Falkirk</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Mary-Jane Armstrong - Town Centre Management<br />
Kate Kane – <strong>Falkirk</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Apologies: <strong>Council</strong>lor Joe Lemetti<br />
<strong>Council</strong>lor Jim Blackwood<br />
Sharon Tait - Denny & Dunipace <strong>Community</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
Alastair Mitchell - Town Centre Management Ltd<br />
David Reid - Central Scotland Police<br />
Pat McGrandles - St Alexander’s Church<br />
Father Boyle - St Alexander’s Church<br />
1.0 Minutes of Previous Meeting<br />
<strong>Falkirk</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
<strong>Community</strong> <strong>Services</strong><br />
1.1 <strong>Council</strong>lor Goldie welcomed those attending the meeting. He confirmed that he<br />
was attending the meeting as <strong>Council</strong>lor Waddell was attending to other <strong>Council</strong><br />
business and would be joining the meeting later. Following a short discussion on<br />
Cllr Goldie’s role as Chair it was agreed to proceed.<br />
1.2 Brian McCabe requested for the Development Group minutes to be issued earlier<br />
than the current two week prior to the meeting period. It was confirmed that this<br />
could be accommodated.<br />
1.3 The minutes were taken as a true record of the meeting.<br />
Deleted: <strong>Council</strong>lor Alex<br />
Waddell (late comer)<br />
Deleted: Ltd<br />
Deleted: <strong>Council</strong>lor Craig<br />
Martin<br />
Deleted: because<br />
Deleted: .<br />
Deleted: Douglas<br />
Deleted: The
2.0 Matters Arising<br />
2.1 Brian McCabe commented that he was disappointed that neither <strong>Council</strong>or<br />
Waddell nor Douglas Duff attended the Urban Realm exhibition of alternative<br />
designs. Douglas Duff explained why he had chosen not to attend, emphasizing<br />
his view that the best and quickest way of delivery of the project is with Henry<br />
Boot. He added that if there were any relevant design ideas picked up through<br />
this exercise, these could be fed into the Henry Boot masterplan for the town<br />
centre.<br />
2.2 Colin Frame added that he had visited the display. He confirmed that whilst the<br />
plans were of interest they did not take account of the commercial aspect of the<br />
project and therefore did not show a deliverable scheme.<br />
2.3 Ian Wallace said that he was happy to look at the Urban Realm proposals with a<br />
view to incorporating any viable design changes to those already developed and<br />
consulted on masterplan.<br />
2.4 Colin Belbin expressed a need to focus on the timescales for delivery of the<br />
project. <strong>Council</strong>lor McNally reported that he had visited the Henry Boot<br />
development in Ayr to look see how it compares to the Denny proposals. He also<br />
enquired about the prospects for an indoor market facility and it was explained<br />
that there were no plans for such a venture at this time.<br />
3.0 Regeneration Update<br />
3.1 Douglas Duff said that the <strong>Council</strong> is pressing ahead with the delivery of the<br />
scheme looking at acquisitions under compulsory purchase arrangements. He<br />
confirmed that a recent report enabling this to be pushed forward had recently<br />
been considered and passed by the <strong>Council</strong>.<br />
3.2 Colin Frame said that a PAN notice would be lodged as soon as a food operator<br />
was identified but emphasised that commitment from a food operator is vital. He<br />
confirmed that the site assembly process was underway with an initial committed<br />
budget of £500k. This had recently been increased by an additional £300,000 to<br />
negotiate the acquisition of interests and proceed with demolition at Block A<br />
(Duke Street) and Block D (Stirling Street).<br />
3.3 Colin reported that the Scottish Government appears willing to see Compulsory<br />
Purchase Orders used more widely to accelerate the site assembly process. He<br />
confirmed that <strong>Falkirk</strong> <strong>Council</strong> had approved the use of this and as a result all<br />
Church Walk interests have had notification of this approach. He stressed that<br />
negotiation is the preferred route to acquire these interests and this would<br />
Feb 2011 minutes (2).doc<br />
Deleted: said that he does<br />
Deleted: want<br />
Deleted: be diverted from the<br />
task in hand<br />
Deleted: is<br />
Deleted: he would be happy to<br />
feed them<br />
Deleted: interesting<br />
Deleted: the<br />
Deleted: <br />
Deleted: has<br />
Deleted: 3.2<br />
Deleted: critical.<br />
<br />
Deleted: a<br />
Deleted: , now extended<br />
Deleted: all<br />
Deleted: demolish the<br />
Deleted: , Block A<br />
Deleted: now<br />
Deleted: . He<br />
Deleted: is keen<br />
Deleted: properties<br />
Deleted: to say that<br />
Deleted: is being done.
continue alongside the CPO process. He added that he would be happy to<br />
speak with any occupiers to discuss and clarify the situation. Douglas Duff<br />
reinforced the <strong>Council</strong>’s desire to achieve the acquisitions through agreement.<br />
3.4 Douglas Duff said that the process was highly sensitive but reiterated the desire<br />
to acquire through consensus.<br />
3.5 <strong>Council</strong>or McNally asked if this process could delay the planned demolition.<br />
Colin Frame explained that it was proposed to have 3 CPO’s - Church Walk<br />
Block A (Duke Street), Block D (North Block) and Blocks C & B (East Blocks).<br />
This phased approach will avoid delays in early demolition of Blocks A & D<br />
caused by potential appeal delays relating to occupiers of Blocks B & C. He said<br />
that there was no guarantee when blocks would be demolished and assured the<br />
group that every possible step was being taken to negotiate successfully.<br />
3.6 Raymond Murray asked about notice to be given to town centre businesses<br />
regarding requirements to move etc. Colin said that he has been in discussion<br />
with local businesses about this and said that a phased approach will be used to<br />
move businesses.<br />
3.7 Colin Belbin asked if acquisitions are still at 15. Colin confirmed that this was<br />
correct.<br />
3.8 Brian McCabe asked Henry Boot which food operators they were in discussion<br />
with. Ian Wallace said that commercial negotiations were sensitive and highly<br />
confidential and therefore was unable to divulge this information.<br />
3.9 Brian McCabe asked which foodstore had shown interest in the scheme in 2005.<br />
It was confirmed that at this time Asda had submitted a letter of interest.<br />
3.10 <strong>Council</strong>lor McNally asked if the appointment of Henry Boot was down to them<br />
being able to bring a food operator. Colin Frame explained that there was a<br />
lengthy assessment process followed to appoint the <strong>Council</strong>s developer.<br />
Potential developers were assessed on 9 key criteria such as; expertise and<br />
technical capability, financial resources, previous developments and references.<br />
3.11 Colin Frame informed the group that the severe weather experienced had caused<br />
water ingress in the Church Walk block. He confirmed that rumours circulating<br />
that the flooding of some shops was caused by <strong>Council</strong> contractors. Technical<br />
inspections of these flat roof areas found the drains and gullies to be clogged and<br />
blocked by debris not associated with the roughcasting contract. He stressed<br />
that maintenance of these flat roofs, gullies and drains is the responsibility of the<br />
tenant per the terms of the lease.<br />
3.12 There was discussion on the perceived effectiveness of the contract in curing<br />
water ingress as well as widespread criticism of the look of the blocks following<br />
Feb 2011 minutes (2).doc<br />
Formatted: Font color: Red<br />
Deleted: visit concerned<br />
subjects in the town
this. It was noted that the primary function of the works is to stop ongoing water<br />
ingress to the retail units below.<br />
4.0 Town Centre Promotion<br />
4.1 Mary Jane provided an update on current activity in Denny town centre<br />
including:-<br />
• Denny Day/Viva Las Vegas featuring Elvis impersonator planned for<br />
September<br />
• Easter Music Event – date to be confirmed<br />
• Comedy Festival to return following the success of last years. She is<br />
currently scouting for new premises for this and asked the group for<br />
ideas.<br />
• Electronic signage is working well with many local groups using them to<br />
post information.<br />
5.0 Any Other Business<br />
5.1 There was discussion on the opening of the Denny Regeneration Office. Colin<br />
reported that repairs were being carried out following the recent water ingress.<br />
An opening date would be advertised once known.<br />
6.0 Date & Time of Next Meeting<br />
6.1 The date of the next meeting was confirmed as Thursday 28 April at 10.30am in<br />
Denny <strong>Community</strong> Education Centre.<br />
Feb 2011 minutes (2).doc