Social, Humanitarian and Cultural Committee (SOCHUM)

Social, Humanitarian and Cultural Committee (SOCHUM) Social, Humanitarian and Cultural Committee (SOCHUM)

22.08.2013 Views

Often, these general growth strategies, including privatization and trade liberalization, not only fail to help but actually adversely affect indigenous populations. Even if minority development strategies are included, they are often underfunded and ineffective. Without the participation of indigenous peoples in the development discussion, it will be difficult to prevent flawed policies from being enacted again in the future. indigenous peoples need to be included at all levels of the debate, including policy and program design, implementation, and evaluation. 149 Additionally, according to the World Bank, growth is more sustainable in countries where political power is more evenly distributed, a reason in itself to encourage indigenous participation in the development discussion. 150 An example of the harm that can come from leaving indigenous peoples out of the development discussion is the 1997 Poverty Eradication Action Plan in uganda. this plan was touted as a proposal for reducing poverty among minority populations, but in reality, it had no effect on the dire circumstances that many indigenous people in the country still endure. The Poverty Eradication Action Plan called for the liberalization of trade, privatization of industries, low inflation, and a balancing of the budget. It also cut social programs that were targeted at poverty reduction, human development, and income distribution. The indigenous population relied on many of the eliminated programs for assistance, and the reduction in government spending and lowering of inflation prevented the development of new public or private initiatives to assist the indigenous groups. Overall, the Poverty Eradication Action Plan was a complete failure and exemplifies the importance of indigenous involvement in the discussion and development of any future poverty reduction plans. 151 There are many factors that prevent indigenous populations from participating in development discussions. Their minority status may not be recognized by the national government in the first place, which makes any attempt to create special programs nearly impossible. 152 Many indigenous populations speak a small minority language instead of the official national language and thus cannot communicate with governmental officials. Further challenges include a lack of education among indigenous people, which prevents them from understanding the complex economic issues involved and from articulating their needs to others, and a lack of knowledge about government processes and their rights. 153 NGOs that represent indigenous peoples can provide a voice for these disenfranchised people, but these groups often have their own troubles, including limited funding for travel, translation, and information gathering. 154 The international community has taken a step toward indigenous involvement in the development discussion with the establishment of the Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs) by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. The PRSPs are documents that these two organizations require before they allocate any sort of development aid under the Heavily Indebted Poor Country initiative, and they force developing countries to draft proposals for using the aid to reduce poverty within their borders. 155 Thus, at a minimum the PRSPs encourage developing nations with significant indigenous communities to consider how to effectively bring economic development to the most remote regions. Many countries, however, have drafted PRSPs without considering the effects of their policies on indigenous peoples and have thereby ignored the plights of some of their poorest residents. 156Any effective solution to this problem necessitates the inclusion of indigenous peoples in developing countries’ PRSPs to support their participation in the creation of development policies. 38 Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design

Discrimination Of all of the factors that lead to extreme poverty like arson, rape, or murder. In the face of this violent discrimination, it is impossible for indigenous peoples among indigenous peoples, the most important may be the discrimination that they encounter from the ethnic majority population and the government. 157 Such discrimination is especially relevant if the indigenous population has been evicted from their tribal lands and are forced to seek new employment opportunities outside of their traditional occupations. Many indigenous peoples have trouble securing jobs because members of the majority ethnic population own and operate most businesses and are averse to hiring indigenous labor. Many employers do not value indigenous knowledge and skills and instead see indigenous peoples as uneducated and backwards. Even when they can secure employment, indigenous people are almost always underpaid in comparison to non-minorities. An analysis of these earnings differentials globally shows that between 25% and 50% of the differences in pay can be account for as a result of discrimination. this distinction is especially acute for jobs that require higher levels of education. 158 in addition to employment, discrimination also prevents indigenous peoples from accessing educational opportunities and healthcare. 159 to continue with their traditional livelihoods or with their attempts to establish new lives elsewhere. On the other hand, extreme poverty can also be the cause of violence and crime among indigenous populations. Without meaningful educational opportunities or employment, many indigenous youth commit violent acts or crimes in desperation. Thus, the problem with lawlessness is present on both sides; in order to bring indigenous people out of poverty, we must protect them from discriminatory crimes, but the poverty that discrimination causes among the same population leads them to commit their own crimes. In some circumstances, discrimination can take the form of violence and crime. Indigenous peoples sometimes find themselves subject to constant attacks from members of the majority ethnic population in the form of nonviolent harassment or more violent crimes 160 It is impossible to provide developmental aid to areas with significant violence, an issue that has rendered many governments and civil society organizations inactive in the face of indigenous poverty. It is therefore urgent that the international community finds a way to stop this cycle of violence. Discrimination is most prevalent in urban environments in which indigenous peoples live side-by-side with members of the majority ethnic group and members of other minority populations. Indigenous peoples are often driven to cities by land dispossession and eviction and the search for new employment opportunities, as shown in many of the examples described above. Once in cities, however, indigenous peoples are often unable to find adequate employment or housing. 161 Upon moving to a city in search of employment, many indigenous peoples find themselves living in slums, such as the infamous Rochina slum in Rio de Janeiro. If they are lucky enough to 39 Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design

Discrimination<br />

Of all of the factors that lead to extreme poverty<br />

like arson, rape, or murder. In the face of this violent<br />

discrimination, it is impossible for indigenous peoples<br />

among indigenous peoples, the most important may<br />

be the discrimination that they encounter from the<br />

ethnic majority population <strong>and</strong> the government. 157<br />

Such discrimination is especially relevant if the<br />

indigenous population has been evicted from<br />

their tribal l<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong><br />

are forced to seek<br />

new employment<br />

opportunities outside<br />

of their traditional<br />

occupations. Many<br />

indigenous peoples<br />

have trouble securing<br />

jobs because members<br />

of the majority ethnic<br />

population own <strong>and</strong><br />

operate most businesses<br />

<strong>and</strong> are averse to hiring<br />

indigenous labor. Many<br />

employers do not value<br />

indigenous knowledge <strong>and</strong> skills <strong>and</strong> instead see<br />

indigenous peoples as uneducated <strong>and</strong> backwards.<br />

Even when they can secure employment, indigenous<br />

people are almost always underpaid in comparison<br />

to non-minorities. An analysis of these earnings<br />

differentials globally shows that between 25% <strong>and</strong> 50%<br />

of the differences in pay can be account for as a result<br />

of discrimination. this distinction is especially acute<br />

for jobs that require higher levels of education. 158 in<br />

addition to employment, discrimination also prevents<br />

indigenous peoples from accessing educational<br />

opportunities <strong>and</strong> healthcare. 159<br />

to continue with their traditional livelihoods or with<br />

their attempts to establish new lives elsewhere. On<br />

the other h<strong>and</strong>, extreme poverty can also be the cause<br />

of violence <strong>and</strong> crime among indigenous populations.<br />

Without meaningful educational opportunities or<br />

employment, many<br />

indigenous youth<br />

commit violent acts or<br />

crimes in desperation.<br />

Thus, the problem with<br />

lawlessness is present<br />

on both sides; in order<br />

to bring indigenous<br />

people out of poverty,<br />

we must protect them<br />

from discriminatory<br />

crimes, but the poverty<br />

that discrimination<br />

causes among the same<br />

population leads them to<br />

commit their own crimes.<br />

In some circumstances, discrimination can take<br />

the form of violence <strong>and</strong> crime. Indigenous peoples<br />

sometimes find themselves subject to constant attacks<br />

from members of the majority ethnic population in the<br />

form of nonviolent harassment or more violent crimes<br />

160 It is impossible to provide<br />

developmental aid to areas with significant violence,<br />

an issue that has rendered many governments <strong>and</strong><br />

civil society organizations inactive in the face of<br />

indigenous poverty. It is therefore urgent that the<br />

international community finds a way to stop this cycle<br />

of violence.<br />

Discrimination is most prevalent in urban<br />

environments in which indigenous peoples live<br />

side-by-side with members of the majority ethnic<br />

group <strong>and</strong> members of other minority populations.<br />

Indigenous peoples are often driven to cities by l<strong>and</strong><br />

dispossession <strong>and</strong> eviction <strong>and</strong> the search for new<br />

employment opportunities, as shown in many of the<br />

examples described above. Once in cities, however,<br />

indigenous peoples are often unable to find adequate<br />

employment or housing. 161 Upon moving to a city in search of employment, many indigenous<br />

peoples find themselves living in slums, such as the infamous Rochina<br />

slum in Rio de Janeiro.<br />

If they are lucky enough to<br />

39<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media <strong>and</strong> Design

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!