18.08.2013 Views

Dr. Holger Schmidt - EEWeb

Dr. Holger Schmidt - EEWeb

Dr. Holger Schmidt - EEWeb

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

<strong>EEWeb</strong><br />

PULSE<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong>.com<br />

Issue 21<br />

November 22, 2011<br />

<strong>Dr</strong>. <strong>Holger</strong> <strong>Schmidt</strong><br />

Nanoscale Optofluidics<br />

Electrical Engineering Community


It’s all about<br />

connections. <strong>EEWeb</strong><br />

Electrical Engineering Community<br />

engineers<br />

hobbyists<br />

discussions<br />

power<br />

microcontroller<br />

Digi-Key is an authorized distributor for all supplier partners. New products added daily.<br />

© 2011 Digi-Key Corporation, 701 Brooks Ave. South, Thief River Falls, MN 56701, USA<br />

Contact Us For Advertising Opportunities<br />

The user-to-user forum is for everyone, from<br />

design engineers to hobbyists, to discuss<br />

technology, products, designs and more.<br />

Join the discussions that match your interest<br />

or offer your expertise to others.<br />

Join the discussion now at:<br />

students<br />

industry experts<br />

1.800.574.2791<br />

advertising@eeweb.com<br />

www.eeweb.com/advertising<br />

community<br />

wireless<br />

www.digikey.com/techxchange<br />

technical documents<br />

lighting<br />

sensor<br />

resources<br />

application notes<br />

white papers<br />

links<br />

reference designs


TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

<strong>Dr</strong>. <strong>Holger</strong> <strong>Schmidt</strong> 4<br />

DIRECTOR, W.M. KECK CENTER FOR NANOSCALE OPTOFLUIDICS<br />

Interview with <strong>Dr</strong>. <strong>Holger</strong> <strong>Schmidt</strong> - Professor of Electrical Engineering, UC Santa Cruz.<br />

Single Molecules on a Chip 7<br />

BY HOLGER SCHMIDT<br />

Exploring chip-scale integration of nanotechnology and integrated optics for biomolecular<br />

science.<br />

Featured Products 10<br />

Tradeoffs in New Generation ADCs 12<br />

BY ED KOHLER AND JASON MESSIER WITH INTERSIL<br />

Analog-to-Digital Converters are becoming increasingly pervasive, and Kohler and Messier<br />

offer critical tradeoffs for product design success.<br />

Hey You, Get Into My Cloud 19<br />

BY ROB IRWIN WITH ALTIUM<br />

How web-based services will change the future of the electronic design process.<br />

RTZ - Return to Zero Comic 24<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 3<br />

TABLE OF CONTENTS


INTERVIEW<br />

<strong>Dr</strong>. <strong>Holger</strong> <strong>Schmidt</strong><br />

W.M. Keck Center for Nanoscale Optofluidics<br />

How did you get into<br />

engineering and when did you<br />

start?<br />

My original degree is in physics.<br />

My M.S. thesis project dealt with<br />

semiconductor devices with<br />

direct applications in fiber-optic<br />

communications. After my PhD<br />

work in Electrical Engineering on a<br />

similar topic, I decided to develop<br />

new optical devices and methods<br />

with real-world applications.<br />

What are your favorite<br />

hardware tools that you use?<br />

I enjoy working with a variety of<br />

lasers, in particular ultrafast lasers<br />

that produce short optical pulses<br />

only about 100 femtoseconds long.<br />

With these lasers, we can study<br />

materials on time scales that cannot<br />

be reached electronically. We also<br />

have recently set up a dual beam<br />

electron/ion beam microscope in<br />

our W.M. Keck Center for Nanoscale<br />

Optofluidics. An optofluidic device<br />

combines integrated optics with<br />

microfluidics. This can be a<br />

fluidically tuneable optical device,<br />

for example a fluidic dye laser, in<br />

which the active laser dye solution<br />

is contained in a microchannel on<br />

a chip. It can also be a device that<br />

uses integrated optical elements<br />

(waveguides, filters, splitters) to<br />

investigate or manipulate particles<br />

in a microfluidic channel, for<br />

example an integrated biosensor.<br />

<strong>Dr</strong>. <strong>Holger</strong> <strong>Schmidt</strong> - Professor of Electrical Engineering; UC Santa Cruz<br />

This is an extremely versatile nanofabrication<br />

and nanocharacterization<br />

tool that is a lot of fun to work<br />

with and allows us to both sculpt and<br />

image objects on the nanoscale.<br />

What are your favorite<br />

software tools that you use?<br />

I mostly work with MATLAB,<br />

do some programming in C,<br />

and design optical waveguide<br />

structures using simulation<br />

packages from Photon Design.<br />

What is on your bookshelf?<br />

I have recently read The Master<br />

Switch: The Rise and Fall of<br />

Information Empires by Tim Wu<br />

which deals with the fascinating<br />

story of the people and companies<br />

that invented new communication<br />

technologies and how they deal<br />

with issues of information control.<br />

The Elegant Universe by Brian<br />

Greene also tells a great story<br />

on the cosmic scale, presenting<br />

an introduction to string theory<br />

and its implications. I also read<br />

contemporary and classic fiction,<br />

plus a lot of children’s books with<br />

my family. Most recently, I read<br />

Aaron Hawkins’ The Year Money<br />

Grew on Trees which tells a great<br />

coming-of-age story that shows<br />

how hard work, persistence,<br />

and a great group of friends can<br />

accomplish almost anything.<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 4<br />

FEATURED INTERVIEW


INTERVIEW<br />

Do you have any tricks up<br />

your sleeve?<br />

In my view, the keys to achieving<br />

breakthroughs in the lab are a<br />

combination of good planning<br />

ahead of time, persistence, the<br />

ability to recognize problems or<br />

new directions, and a bit of luck at<br />

the right time.<br />

We need to stay<br />

one step ahead by<br />

providing cuttingedge<br />

training to<br />

our bright and<br />

motivated students.<br />

What has been your favorite<br />

project?<br />

For a number of years, I have had the<br />

vision of realizing optical quantum<br />

interference effects on a chip.<br />

Quantum coherence produces<br />

strange effects such as making<br />

opaque materials transparent,<br />

slowing light down, or making<br />

single photons “talk to each other.”<br />

Possible applications for quantum<br />

coherence devices include alloptical<br />

nonlinear devices (e.g.,<br />

switches) that work on the few to<br />

single photon level, optical storage<br />

and memory, extremely sensitive<br />

metrology devices (magnetometers,<br />

interferometer), or single photon<br />

light sources and detectors.<br />

In collaboration with our colleagues<br />

at BYU, we have recently succeeded<br />

in slowing light down over a 1,000<br />

times on a tiny silicon chip. Viewed<br />

differently, we have taken a 20 foot<br />

long optical pulse and compressed<br />

it to a fraction of an inch on a chip.<br />

Do you have any note-worthy<br />

engineering experiences?<br />

Being exposed to a one million<br />

volt spark from a Tesla coil (http://<br />

photon.soe.ucsc.edu/classes.htm )<br />

while standing in a metal suit that<br />

acted as a Faraday cage and NOT<br />

getting shocked was one of the<br />

most exhilarating experiences of my<br />

teaching career.<br />

What are you currently<br />

working on?<br />

We’re using laser optics in a<br />

number of ways. We are studying<br />

nanomagnets for next-generation<br />

data storage media, will attempt<br />

to stop light on a chip to create<br />

optical memory devices, and are<br />

developing optofluidic chips for<br />

biomolecular diagnostics such as<br />

virus detection at the point of care.<br />

We use different methods to make<br />

the magnets. We make our own<br />

magnets using electron beam<br />

lithography. A photoresist is<br />

patterned with nanoscale holes;<br />

magnetic material (e.g., nickel)<br />

is deposited, followed by a liftoff<br />

process. We also get samples<br />

from Western Digital, San Jose,<br />

formerly Hitachi Global Storage<br />

Technologies. These are metallic<br />

multilayers deposited on nanosize<br />

islands that were etched into a<br />

substrate wafer. Finally, we work<br />

with a group at the University of<br />

Chemnitz, Germany, which deposits<br />

magnetic layers on top of selfassembled<br />

silica nanospheres. The<br />

spheres produce ordered patterns<br />

as they are spread on a wafer which<br />

can make for a very quick and<br />

inexpensive patterning step. The<br />

main application we are interested<br />

in at the moment is bit-patterned<br />

magnetic storage media for nextgeneration<br />

hard drives. However,<br />

nanomagnets are also relevant for<br />

memory devices (MRAM) or other<br />

emerging spintronic applications.<br />

What direction do you see<br />

your business heading in the<br />

next few years?<br />

I see a lot of potential in optofluidic<br />

technology—the combination of<br />

microfluidics and integrated optics.<br />

It allows us to look at devices that<br />

have been used for optoelectronic<br />

and communication applications<br />

in a new light. Their combination<br />

with non-solid media such as gases<br />

and liquids poses new research<br />

questions, but also has a lot of<br />

applications in the life sciences,<br />

biomedicine, toxicology, pollution<br />

monitoring, and other fields.<br />

What challenges do you<br />

foresee in our industry?<br />

We need to stay one step ahead,<br />

which will provide cutting-edge<br />

training to our bright and motivated<br />

students. ■<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 5<br />

FEATURED INTERVIEW


New Encoder for the<br />

Worst Case Environments<br />

Avago Technologies new AEAT-6600<br />

Hall E ect Magnetic Encoder delivers optimal<br />

solutions for Robotic, Industrial and Medical<br />

systems designers.<br />

• World’s highest resolution<br />

• 16-bit absolute positiion through SSI<br />

• Programmable Magnetic Rotary Encoder IC<br />

• 16-pin TSSOP package<br />

• Power down mode<br />

Avago Technologies Motion Control Products<br />

For more information and to request<br />

a free sample go to:<br />

www.avagotech.com/motioncontrol


PROJECT<br />

S ingle<br />

Molecules<br />

on a Chip<br />

The history of integrated photonics dates back to the<br />

late 1960s when researchers at Bell Labs proposed<br />

the use of thin film technology to create planar optical<br />

structures that would mimic the successful integration<br />

paradigm of integrated electronic circuits. The field<br />

grew rapidly along with the burgeoning area of fiberoptic<br />

communications. Even though early approaches<br />

to long-haul fiber links considered liquid-filled fibers,<br />

integrated optics was implemented almost exclusively<br />

in solid-state materials due to the challenges of guiding<br />

light through substances with low refractive indices<br />

such as gases and liquids. Unfortunately, this has<br />

prevented the creation of integrated optical devices<br />

and systems for a large class of areas, in particular the<br />

life sciences for which fluids (air, water) are the natural<br />

environment. It has only been over the past few years<br />

that rapid advances in microfluidics, silicon photonics,<br />

and integrated optics have converged into the new,<br />

burgeoning field of optofluidics, the combination of<br />

integrated optics and fluidics in a single system.<br />

The groups of <strong>Holger</strong> <strong>Schmidt</strong> at UC Santa Cruz<br />

and Aaron Hawkins at Brigham Young University<br />

have developed a unique approach to optofluidics<br />

that is based on creating micron-scale channels that<br />

simultaneously guide light and liquids on a silicon chip.<br />

By <strong>Dr</strong>. <strong>Holger</strong> <strong>Schmidt</strong><br />

The combination of these “liquid-core waveguides”<br />

with more conventional solid-state structures creates<br />

fully self-contained, planar chips that allow for the study<br />

and manipulation of fluids and particles therein with<br />

the convenience of off-the-shelf fiber optics equipment.<br />

Much of the early work focused on exploration of basic<br />

photonic properties such as low-loss light propagation,<br />

optical mode structure, and implementation of optical<br />

signal processing such as spectral filtering in the<br />

liquid-core waveguides. The greatest potential of the<br />

technology, however, lies in the application of these<br />

devices to fields that historically were off limits for<br />

integrated optics, for example molecular biology,<br />

medical diagnostics, toxicology, or gas spectroscopy. In<br />

particular, the demonstration of optical detection of single<br />

fluorescent molecules showed a sensitivity normally<br />

seen in expensive and bulky microscopy equipment,<br />

and provided much stimulation for new research and<br />

applications dealing with single particles on a chip.<br />

To this end, the W.M. Keck Foundation supported the<br />

creation of the Center for Nanoscale Optofluidics at<br />

UC Santa Cruz. Directed by Professor <strong>Holger</strong> <strong>Schmidt</strong>,<br />

the Center brings together faculty from five different<br />

departments (H. Noller, Molecular Biology; M. Akeson<br />

and D. Deamer, Biomolecular Engineering; J. Zhang,<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 7<br />

FEATURED PROJECT


PROJECT<br />

single-mode fiber<br />

Figure 1: Cartoon of optofluidic chip; photograph of chip during experiment; scanning electron images of<br />

Waveguide cross sections with hollow and solid cores along with guided light mode.<br />

Chemistry; and W. Dunbar, Computer Engineering).<br />

In this Center, the researchers are able to take an<br />

interdisciplinary approach to exploring the use of<br />

nanoscale elements in conjunction with optofluidic<br />

waveguides to address problems in molecular biology,<br />

biophysics, and medical diagnostics.<br />

One focus area of research within the Center is the<br />

incorporation of nanopores into optofluidic devices.<br />

The concept of nanopore biophysics was proposed by<br />

D. Deamer who recognized that a molecule passing<br />

through a nanoscale hole in a membrane could partially<br />

block the opening, and therefore reduce the amount<br />

of electric (ionic) current flowing through that hole.<br />

Effectively, such a structure functions as an electric,<br />

single molecule detector that can distinguish molecular<br />

signatures on the picoampere level. Recently, the groups<br />

of Professors <strong>Schmidt</strong> and Noller have demonstrated the<br />

first detection of single ribosomes using nanopores that<br />

were incorporated into a dielectric layer that comprises<br />

the liquid-core optofluidic waveguide. Moreover, they<br />

multi-mode fiber<br />

were able to control the amount of nanoparticles that<br />

entered the fluidic channel by changing the applied<br />

electrical voltage. This opens up the possibility to use<br />

the nanopores as “smart gates” to introduce individual<br />

fluorescent particles into the liquid-core waveguides<br />

where they can then be investigated “on demand.”<br />

Additional collaborations are under way to apply this<br />

principle to quantum dot labeled DNA for genetic<br />

analysis and controlled nanopore translocation for DNA<br />

sequencing.<br />

Another focus area of the Center expands on the theme<br />

of particle control. Professor <strong>Schmidt</strong>’s group has<br />

recently developed new implementations of optical<br />

particle trapping (i.e., the control over a particle’s motion<br />

and position using optical forces). Using the intrinsic<br />

optical properties of the liquid-core waveguides, they<br />

were able to hold particles in place at any position along<br />

the fluidic channel. In addition, they used light beams<br />

to accumulate over 100 particles at a single spot within<br />

the waveguide, effectively creating the equivalent of an<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 8<br />

FEATURED PROJECT


PROJECT<br />

Figure 2: Cut-open views of waveguide intersection<br />

with fluorescent particles (green) in light beam (red).<br />

optical leaf blower. Current efforts are directed at using<br />

optical forces to create optofluidic devices for particle<br />

sorting as well as to examine new trapping paradigms<br />

and the potential of moving particles between welldefined<br />

chemical microenvironments.<br />

A third thrust area deals with single molecule<br />

Figure 3: Optofludic waveguide chip with nanopore. Applied voltage is used<br />

to drive nanoparticles through Nanopore into fludic channel.<br />

spectroscopy for biomedical applications. The<br />

demonstrated ability to detect fluorescent signatures<br />

from single molecules opens up the possibility to<br />

observe and count individual, labeled bioparticles<br />

such as nucleic acids (DNA, RNA) and proteins. These<br />

play a central role in molecular diagnostics applied to<br />

infectious disease detection, genetic screening, and<br />

genomics-based personalized medicine. The ability<br />

to identify single molecules on an integrated platform<br />

has the potential to break with the current diagnostic<br />

paradigm of amplifying the genomic material to create<br />

detectable signals. <strong>Schmidt</strong>’s group is working with a<br />

number of clinical researchers to explore the potential of<br />

optofluidics as a diagnostic platform.<br />

This snapshot of the research pursued at the Keck<br />

Center at UCSC provides a glimpse at the potential<br />

of optofluidics. It opens new windows for optical and<br />

device engineers to use traditional engineering skills<br />

in new contexts that interface electrical engineering<br />

with chemists, biologists, toxicologists, and medical<br />

researchers. Thus, this emerging area provides an<br />

extremely stimulating environment for the development<br />

of new optical technology in the years to come. ■<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 9<br />

FEATURED PROJECT


FEATURED PRODUCTS<br />

Stellaris® Robotic Evaluation Board<br />

The Stellaris® Robotic Evaluation Board (EVALBOT) is a robotic<br />

evaluation platform for the Stellaris LM3S9B92 microcontroller. The<br />

board also uses a range of Texas Instruments’ analog components<br />

for motor drive, power supply, and communications functions. After a<br />

few minutes of assembly, the EVALBOT’s electronics are ready-torun.<br />

When roaming, three AA batteries supply power to the EVALBOT.<br />

The EVALBOT automatically selects USB power when tethered to a<br />

PC as a USB device or when debugging. Test points are provided to<br />

all key EVALBOT signals. Two 20-pin headers enable future wireless<br />

communications using standardized Texas Instruments’ low-power embedded radio modules (EM boards).<br />

Additional microcontroller signals are available on break-out pads arranged in rows adjacent to the microcontroller.<br />

The EVALBOT has factory-installed quickstart software resident in on-chip Flash memory. For software debugging<br />

and Flash programming, an integrated In-Circuit Debug Interface (ICDI) requires only a single USB cable for debug<br />

and serial port functions.For more information, please click here.<br />

Capacitors for High Pulse Current Applications<br />

Vishay Intertechnology, Inc. introduced a new multilayer ceramic<br />

chip capacitor (MLCC) featuring an integrated resistor and low<br />

electrostrictive ceramic formulation. For high-pulse-current applications,<br />

the VJ controlled discharge capacitor (CDC) offers excellent reliability,<br />

high voltage ratings from 1,000 VDC to 1,500 VDC, and a capacitance<br />

range from 33 nF to 560 nF. The integration of a high-capacitance MLCC<br />

with a bleed resistor on its surface allows the VJ CDC to discharge<br />

more rapidly, while also reducing board space requirements and<br />

assembly costs. Typical applications for the device include detonation devices (munitions, pyrotechnics, blasting)<br />

and electronic fuzing. The capacitor released today is manufactured in Noble Metal Electrode (NME) technology<br />

with a wet build process. The VJ CDC features a low electrostrictive ceramic formulation for repeated charge and<br />

discharge cycles, allowing the device to achieve very high field reliability. For more information, please click here.<br />

RF Multi-Measurement Signal Analyzer<br />

Agilent Technologies Inc. announced that an innovative, new multimeasurement<br />

capability is being added to its 89600 VSA software,<br />

enabling simultaneous signal analysis of multiple carriers and signal<br />

formats for more efficient testing and deeper signal insight in wireless<br />

test. With wireless R&D and manufacturing engineers increasingly<br />

working with more than one signal at a time?whether for multi-format/<br />

multi-carrier devices or for viewing both uplink and downlink signals<br />

at the same time?analyzing one signal at a time is no longer efficient.<br />

Moreover, it fails to provide intelligence about the subtle interactions<br />

among dissimilar signals within a device. The 89600 VSA software’s new multi-measurement capability has been<br />

engineered to deliver the power of multiple signal analyzers with the convenience of a single, optimized user interface.<br />

The software’s advanced architecture will enable engineers to configure multiple measurements simultaneously.<br />

For more information, please click here.<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 10<br />

FEATURED PRODUCTS


14-Bit, 500MSPS ADC<br />

ISLA214P50<br />

The ISLA214P50 is a 14-bit, 500MSPS analog-to-digital converter<br />

designed with Intersil’s proprietary FemtoCharge technology on<br />

a standard CMOS process. The ISLA214P50 is part of a<br />

pin-compatible portfolio of 12 to 16-bit A/Ds with maximum<br />

sample rates ranging from 130MSPS to 500MSPS.<br />

The device utilizes two time-interleaved 250MSPS unit ADCs to<br />

achieve the ultimate sample rate of 500MSPS. A single 500MHz<br />

conversion clock is presented to the converter, and all interleave<br />

clocking is managed internally. The proprietary Intersil Interleave<br />

Engine (I2E) performs automatic correction of offset, gain, and<br />

sample time mismatches between the unit ADCs to optimize<br />

performance.<br />

A serial peripheral interface (SPI) port allows for extensive<br />

configurability of the A/D. The SPI also controls the interleave<br />

correction circuitry, allowing the system to issue offline and<br />

continuous calibration commands as well as configure many<br />

dynamic parameters.<br />

Digital output data is presented in selectable LVDS or CMOS<br />

formats. The ISLA214P50 is available in a 72 Ld QFN package<br />

with an exposed paddle. Operating from a 1.8V supply,<br />

performance is specified over the full industrial temperature<br />

range (-40°C to +85°C).<br />

Key Specifications<br />

• SNR @ 500MSPS<br />

= 72.7dBFS f IN = 30MHz<br />

= 70.6dBFS f IN = 363MHz<br />

• SFDR @ 500MSPS<br />

= 84dBc f IN = 30MHz<br />

= 76dBc f IN = 363MHz<br />

• Total Power Consumption = 835mW @ 500MSPS<br />

CLKP<br />

CLKN<br />

VINP<br />

VINN<br />

VCM<br />

March 15, 2011<br />

FN7571.1<br />

AVSS AVDD<br />

SHA<br />

SHA<br />

NAPSLP<br />

RESETN<br />

CLKDIV<br />

CLOCK<br />

MANAGEMENT<br />

14-BIT<br />

250 MSPS<br />

ADC<br />

VREF<br />

Gain, Offset<br />

and Skew<br />

Adjustments<br />

14-BIT<br />

250 MSPS<br />

ADC<br />

VREF<br />

+<br />

–<br />

CLKDIVRSTP<br />

CLKDIVRSTN<br />

I2E<br />

SPI<br />

CONTROL<br />

CSB<br />

SCLK<br />

SDIO<br />

SDO<br />

OVDD<br />

DIGITAL<br />

ERROR<br />

CORRECTION<br />

RLVDS<br />

OVSS<br />

CLKOUTP<br />

CLKOUTN<br />

D[13:0]P<br />

D[13:0]N<br />

ORP<br />

ORN<br />

Get the Datasheet and Order Samples<br />

http://www.intersil.com<br />

Features<br />

• Automatic Fine Interleave Correction Calibration<br />

• Single Supply 1.8V Operation<br />

• Clock Duty Cycle Stabilizer<br />

• 75fs Clock Jitter<br />

• 700MHz Bandwidth<br />

• Programmable Built-in Test Patterns<br />

• Multi-ADC Support<br />

- SPI Programmable Fine Gain and Offset Control<br />

- Support for Multiple ADC Synchronization<br />

- Optimized Output Timing<br />

• Nap and Sleep Modes<br />

- 200µs Sleep Wake-up Time<br />

• Data Output Clock<br />

• DDR LVDS-Compatible or LVCMOS Outputs<br />

• User-accessible Digital Temperature Monitor<br />

Applications<br />

• Radar Array Processing<br />

• Software Defined Radios<br />

• Broadband Communications<br />

• High-Performance Data Acquisition<br />

• Communications Test Equipment<br />

Pin-Compatible Family<br />

MODEL RESOLUTION<br />

SPEED<br />

(MSPS)<br />

ISLA216P25 16 250<br />

ISLA216P20 16 200<br />

ISLA216P13 16 130<br />

ISLA214P50 14 500<br />

ISLA214P25 14 250<br />

ISLA214P20 14 200<br />

ISLA214P13 14 130<br />

ISLA212P50 12 500<br />

ISLA212P25 12 250<br />

ISLA212P20 12 200<br />

ISLA212P13 12 130<br />

Intersil (and design) is a registered trademark of Intersil Americas Inc. Copyright Intersil Americas Inc. 2011<br />

All Rights Reserved. All other trademarks mentioned are the property of their respective owners.


Tradeoffs<br />

in New-generation<br />

ADCs Jason<br />

<strong>Dr</strong>iven by a widening range of<br />

high-performance application<br />

requirements, Analog-to-Digital<br />

Converters (ADCs) are becoming<br />

an increasingly pervasive design<br />

element, and numerous tradeoffs<br />

between performance, cost, and<br />

complexity are critical factors for the<br />

overall success of product designs.<br />

Although there will never be a<br />

simple one-size-fits-all solution<br />

for ADCs, a number of ongoing<br />

technology trends in ADC design<br />

now offer designers the ability to<br />

closely tailor ADC selection to<br />

optimize cost and performance<br />

for their specific application<br />

requirements. This article is<br />

intended to provide an overview of<br />

these technology trends, along with<br />

some design examples to provide<br />

context for understanding the real-<br />

world tradeoffs between different<br />

approaches.<br />

ADC Trends: Balancing<br />

between SNR, Resolution,<br />

Sample Rates, and Power<br />

ADC designs must achieve an<br />

appropriate balance between<br />

given performance criterion,<br />

such as signal-to-noise (SNR),<br />

resolution, and sample rates while<br />

also conforming to often very tight<br />

power budgets.<br />

One overarching trend in ADC<br />

capabilities has been the ongoing<br />

push for higher resolution and SNR<br />

performance at a given sample<br />

rate. For example, for 500 megasamples<br />

per second (MSPS),<br />

today’s newest high-performance<br />

ADCs can provide 72.5dB at 14bits<br />

compared to previous ADC<br />

Edward Kohler<br />

Strategic Marketing Manager<br />

Messier<br />

Staff Applications Engineer<br />

capabilities that were limited to<br />

66-67dB at 12-bits. This progress,<br />

enabled by the advance of both<br />

state-of-the-art design techniques<br />

and semiconductor processing<br />

capabilities, represents essentially<br />

a 100 percent improvement in<br />

achievable signal-to-noise ratio,<br />

evolving over approximately five<br />

years.<br />

Another trending axis of<br />

improvement has been to increase<br />

the available maximum sample<br />

rate for a given resolution and SNR.<br />

As recently as one year ago, there<br />

were only two major ADC vendors<br />

offering 14-bit ADCs that provided<br />

sampling rates above 155 MSPS.<br />

Now, most ADC manufacturers are<br />

pushing sample rates to 250 MSPS<br />

with 14-bit devices that can deliver<br />

70dB or better SNR performance,<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 12


TECHNICAL ARTICLE<br />

and some are providing a second<br />

generation that can deliver over<br />

73dB. Similarly, the maximum<br />

sample rate for 16-bit converters has<br />

been improved from 200 MSPS in<br />

2008 to 250 MSPS in late 2010 while<br />

maintaining SNR above 75dB. This<br />

continual improvement in sample<br />

rate of high-resolution ADCs is<br />

being driven by the increasing<br />

resolution and speed requirements<br />

of applications such as broadband<br />

communications test equipment<br />

and advanced medical imaging.<br />

Low-power operation is also an<br />

increasingly critical factor for many<br />

ADC applications. This is especially<br />

true for handheld devices that must<br />

live within a tight power budget as<br />

well as for designs that require many<br />

ADCs where the combined power<br />

usage becomes an important issue.<br />

As will be discussed in subsequent<br />

sections of this article, the ability to<br />

minimize power for a given level<br />

of SNR, resolution, and sample<br />

rate performance can be the vital<br />

linchpin issue in success of the<br />

overall product design, and at least<br />

one low-power ADC architecture<br />

has emerged to meet this need.<br />

Another arena of trending change<br />

within ADC designs is the variety<br />

of interface technologies for getting<br />

data on and off the chip. In the<br />

beginning, CMOS I/O was sufficient<br />

for supporting most applications.<br />

However, increasing performance<br />

requirements have led to an<br />

evolution of faster I/O approaches<br />

including DDR, LVDS, Serial LVDS,<br />

and potentially SERDES interfacing<br />

(While this article focuses primarily<br />

on the key performance and power<br />

tradeoffs, in a future article we will<br />

explore the ongoing ADC interface<br />

evolution in more depth).<br />

Scenario #1: Critical<br />

Goal: Achieving High SNR<br />

and Dynamic Range<br />

For many higher-performance<br />

applications, the overriding<br />

requirement is achievement of<br />

the SNR and dynamic range<br />

parameters without regard to power<br />

usage issues.<br />

Prime examples of these<br />

performance-first applications are<br />

mission-critical military designs<br />

such as radar signal processing.<br />

Among the key characteristics<br />

driving this type of design is the<br />

need to deal with both large and<br />

small signals simultaneously, and<br />

to be able to discriminate both,<br />

which requires excellent dynamic<br />

range and SNR performance. For<br />

instance, in a radar system, strong<br />

and weak return signals from both<br />

near and distant objects must be<br />

processed at the same time with<br />

consistent accuracy and speed. If<br />

the ADC does not have sufficient<br />

dynamic range, then the larger<br />

signals will completely dominate<br />

the entire range of the converter,<br />

and the system will not be able to<br />

see the weaker signals. Filtering<br />

out the large signals is typically not<br />

an option in these types of systems<br />

because of the inherently random<br />

and changing nature of the signal<br />

levels and mix.<br />

Another type of application that<br />

often falls into this category is<br />

high-performance measurement<br />

instrumentation, such as signal<br />

analyzers. The system designer<br />

typically has to create a robust set<br />

of capabilities, and a performance<br />

window that spans a wide range<br />

of signal sensitivity instead of pretailoring<br />

the box for a fixed set of<br />

parameters. Here again, building<br />

from the ground up around ADCs<br />

with maximum dynamic range and<br />

robust SNR characteristics at a high<br />

sample rate is the way to enable<br />

instrumentation platforms that can<br />

provide the widest performance<br />

window.<br />

Similar challenges exist in many<br />

communications applications such<br />

as wireless base stations that must<br />

distinguish between strong and<br />

weak signals to determine proper<br />

routing and handoff procedures.<br />

In all of these applications, the<br />

only option is to design with<br />

ADCs that provide the highest<br />

possible dynamic range and SNR<br />

characteristics at the required<br />

sampling rates.<br />

One advanced design approach<br />

that is proving very useful in these<br />

applications is the tight integration<br />

of multiple ADC cores that are<br />

interleaved using advanced on-chip<br />

hardware such as the proprietary<br />

Intersil Interleave Engine (I2E). In<br />

this approach, hybrid digital/analog<br />

background calibration techniques<br />

continuously adjust the gain, offset,<br />

and sample phase of the multiple<br />

interleaved ADC cores, removing<br />

inherent manufacturing mismatch<br />

as well as adjusting, in real-time,<br />

for any mismatches induced by<br />

temperature and voltage variations<br />

(See Figure 1).<br />

Interleaving lower-resolution<br />

ADCs at the system level (such as<br />

6-bit, 8-bit, or even 10-bit devices)<br />

has become a fairly standard<br />

practice, especially for time domain<br />

applications where spurious free<br />

dynamic range (SFDR) is not a<br />

major concern. However, for highperformance<br />

applications requiring<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 13<br />

TECHNICAL ARTICLE


TECHNICAL ARTICLE<br />

converter resolutions of 12-bits<br />

and above, interleaving ADCs<br />

can become very complex and<br />

are best implemented at the chip<br />

level. Die-level interleaving of the<br />

ADC cores overcomes the dynamic<br />

variances in performance that<br />

become roadblocks when trying to<br />

interleave separate ADCs at higher<br />

resolutions. Well-controlled process<br />

matching as well as common voltage<br />

and temperature characteristics<br />

provide inherently better uniformity<br />

between the cores that cannot be<br />

achieved with separate devices.<br />

To achieve nearly perfect<br />

matching, the on-chip I2E<br />

calibration transparently fine<br />

tunes performance on the fly<br />

to ensure consistency and to<br />

eliminate variances. The real-time<br />

adjustments by the I2E make use of<br />

arbitrary application sample data to<br />

estimate and correct for interleave<br />

mismatch of gain, offset, and<br />

sample time skew. This enables the<br />

multiple cores to perform together<br />

as a single high-performance<br />

ADC that can effectively multiply<br />

the sample rate by the number of<br />

cores, all without requiring any<br />

Figure 1: Intersil Interleave Engine (I2E)<br />

12E: Offset/Gain/Phase Error<br />

Estimation and Correction<br />

compromises on dynamic range,<br />

SNR, or robustness.<br />

As shown in Figure 2, ADC<br />

architectures with advanced<br />

interleaving can provide the highest<br />

levels of resolution, at high sample<br />

rates, as compared to Sigma-Delta,<br />

SAR, or pipelined architectures<br />

without advanced interleaving. For<br />

example, Intersil’s ISLA214P50<br />

incorporates two time-interleaved<br />

14-bit 250MSPS ADCs to achieve<br />

the sample rate of 500MSPS with<br />

SNR performance of 72.7dBFS.<br />

Scenario #2: Need<br />

Flexibility for<br />

Tradeoffs between<br />

Performance, Power,<br />

& Design Complexity<br />

In these situations, the designer<br />

typically has some flexibility<br />

to approach the application in<br />

different ways, thereby enabling<br />

tradeoffs in ADC selection between<br />

performance, power, and other<br />

design considerations. For example,<br />

this category includes applications<br />

where the signal level might<br />

vary, but the variations are either<br />

predictable or manageable, such<br />

that the system could be designed<br />

to adjust and accommodate the<br />

variability.<br />

For instance, a point-to-point<br />

microwave communications<br />

link between two stations would<br />

typically involve less signal<br />

variation because it uses focused<br />

antennas with minimal blockage<br />

between the sending and receiving<br />

points. However, signal levels are<br />

occasionally impacted by weather<br />

conditions (e.g., rain, sleet). This<br />

allows for multiple approaches to<br />

the system design. One design<br />

option would be to use a high-end<br />

ADC such as described in the<br />

previous scenario with sufficiently<br />

wide dynamic range to simply<br />

capture and process the diminished<br />

signal on the fly. Alternatively, the<br />

designer could tradeoff by selecting<br />

an ADC with lower dynamic range<br />

and using gain control circuitry<br />

to adjust the signal path based on<br />

weather conditions so that the signal<br />

is always provided to the ADC at<br />

a consistent level. Of course, the<br />

efficacy of one approach versus<br />

the other would depend on specific<br />

application requirements, such as<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 14<br />

TECHNICAL ARTICLE


TECHNICAL ARTICLE<br />

Resolution (bits, ~SNR)<br />

24<br />

22<br />

20<br />

18<br />

16<br />

14<br />

12<br />

10<br />

8<br />

Sigma-Delta<br />

ADC Architecture<br />

vs Resolution and Sample Rate<br />

SAR<br />

Pipeline<br />

0.1 0.5 1 5 10 50 100 500 1000 2000<br />

Sampling Rate (MHz)<br />

Pipeline with<br />

Interleaving<br />

Flash<br />

Figure 2: Comparison of ADC Architectures vs. Resolution and Sample rate<br />

the frequency and variability of the<br />

signal changes, as well as the power<br />

requirements for using a higher<br />

SNR ADC versus the external gain<br />

control circuitry.<br />

Another interesting application in<br />

this category could be laser range<br />

finders, where a signal of fixed<br />

strength is sent out in multiple<br />

directions and then both the<br />

strength and time signature of the<br />

return signals are used to perform<br />

distance measurements to create<br />

3D mapping of complex spaces.<br />

The signal measurements need to<br />

take into account both the surface<br />

reflectivity and the distance to the<br />

objects being measured. From a<br />

signal processing standpoint, a<br />

number of design tradeoffs come<br />

into play for such applications.<br />

For example, a higher-resolution<br />

ADC could be used to resolve the<br />

signals more quickly by eliminating<br />

the need to average when a lower<br />

resolution ADC is used, thereby<br />

allowing faster measurements<br />

with fewer pulses. With potentially<br />

millions of measurements required<br />

to map some locations, the amount<br />

of time per measurement can be<br />

a significant factor. On the other<br />

hand, the nature of laser mapping<br />

applications can require a certain<br />

degree of system portability or<br />

even require battery operated<br />

platforms for some outdoor<br />

applications such as mapping<br />

bridge supports. Depending on the<br />

specific application requirements,<br />

a designer might opt for lowerpower,<br />

lower-resolution ADCs in<br />

combination with external circuitry<br />

for averaging the results, or he<br />

or she might choose to build the<br />

system around higher-resolution<br />

ADCs to increase accuracy and<br />

speed while minimizing the number<br />

of measurements required.<br />

For these application areas that<br />

require a variety of tradeoffs in ADC<br />

capabilities, it can be advantageous<br />

to leverage pin-compatible families<br />

of devices that give the designer<br />

a broader range of choices than<br />

with single-point products. For<br />

example, a designer that needs to<br />

make tradeoffs between resolution<br />

and sample rate could start by<br />

prototyping with a 14-bit 500 MSPS<br />

part and, if needed, could move to<br />

a 16-bit 250 MSPS pin-compatible<br />

device within the same family<br />

without making any changes to the<br />

design.<br />

Similarly, if the designer needed<br />

to tradeoff SNR versus power for a<br />

given resolution and sample rate,<br />

it is helpful to use a pin-compatible<br />

family that provides multiple<br />

options. For instance, some families<br />

offer multiple performance grades<br />

that can provide two or more levels<br />

of SNR with the higher SNR coming<br />

at the price of increased power<br />

consumption. Product designs<br />

for increased battery life or higher<br />

performance can again be offered<br />

without making any changes to the<br />

underlying hardware.<br />

This flexibility allows designers<br />

to tailor and fine-tune the ADC<br />

capabilities to meet the specific<br />

application requirements without<br />

necessitating changes to the<br />

overall product design and support<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 15<br />

TECHNICAL ARTICLE


TECHNICAL ARTICLE<br />

circuitry. The ability to leverage<br />

pin-compatible families also opens<br />

up options for marketing multiple<br />

versions of the same basic product<br />

design at different performance<br />

levels to meet a broader set of<br />

market requirements.<br />

Scenario #3: Minimizing<br />

Power Usage is the<br />

Critical Factor<br />

In this final group of applications,<br />

providing ultra low-power operation<br />

is the overarching factor for design<br />

success. Typical products in this<br />

category are handheld devices that<br />

need higher bandwidth combined<br />

with portability, such as military and<br />

law enforcement radios, ultrasonic<br />

non-destructive scanners, and<br />

Voltage passed<br />

between stages<br />

2x gain<br />

portable cable TV signal analyzers.<br />

Sometimes also included in this<br />

category are applications where<br />

the shear number of ADCs being<br />

deployed has a cumulative power<br />

usage impact that needs to be<br />

minimized, such as some wireline<br />

communication systems with<br />

thousands of ADCs, where the<br />

overall infrastructure’s power<br />

budget becomes an important<br />

factor.<br />

In all of these cases, designers<br />

need to have a given amount<br />

of dynamic range but must<br />

achieve that performance at the<br />

lowest possible power level.<br />

ADC manufacturers therefore<br />

must deliver the performance<br />

requirements with ultra low-power<br />

Traditional ADC<br />

1-bit to DEC<br />

chip level architectures. In addition,<br />

the ADC architectures should<br />

provide designers with the flexibility<br />

to minimize power requirements in<br />

the support circuitry and the overall<br />

design.<br />

A significant step forward in the<br />

creation of ultra low-power ADC<br />

implementations is represented<br />

by Intersil’s FemtoCharge®<br />

technology, which fundamentally<br />

changes the approach for pipelined<br />

signal processing designs.<br />

For any pipelined ADC signal<br />

processing chain, gain is required<br />

between stages. In conventional<br />

architectures, signals in each<br />

gain stage have traditionally been<br />

represented by voltages. In contrast,<br />

the FemtoCharge architecture shifts<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 16<br />

2x gain<br />

2x gain<br />

1-bit DAC<br />

Stage N-1 Stage N +1<br />

1-bit ADC<br />

Charge passed<br />

between stages<br />

2*C fd<br />

Q<br />

V =<br />

C<br />

Femtocharge ADC<br />

C fd<br />

Stage N<br />

Stage N<br />

1-bit DAC<br />

Stage N-1 Stage N +1<br />

1-bit ADC<br />

1-bit to DEC<br />

Figure 3: Comparison of Voltage-based and Charge-based Pipeline Architectures<br />

1<br />

2<br />

C fd<br />

TECHNICAL ARTICLE


TECHNICAL ARTICLE<br />

the approach and represents signals<br />

using electrical charge. This may<br />

seem like a subtle difference but in<br />

practice, it has major implications<br />

for lowering power usage.<br />

In most pipelined ADC designs,<br />

the signal must be amplified from<br />

stage-to-stage to get the necessary<br />

conversion resolution. Voltagebased<br />

designs have two limitations.<br />

First, signal gain requires an<br />

operational amplifier (Op-Amp) and<br />

these have high power consumption<br />

and limit overall ADC performance<br />

due to the dual requirement of<br />

high speed and high accuracy.<br />

And second, voltage-based<br />

designs necessitate that the signal<br />

be recreated at each stage. By<br />

comparison, charge-based ADCs<br />

use the scaling of capacitance to<br />

achieve gain from stage-to-stage.<br />

In a capacitor, Voltage = Charge/<br />

Capacitance. Therefore the voltage<br />

gain needed in each successive<br />

stage can be created simply by<br />

reducing its capacitance in relation<br />

to the preceding stages. And, rather<br />

than having to recreate a voltagebased<br />

signal from scratch for each<br />

stage, in a charge-based pipeline,<br />

the original signal is conserved by<br />

simply transferring it from one stage<br />

to the next (See Figure 3).<br />

The FemtoCharge approach<br />

enables creation of high<br />

performance ADCs with ultra-lowpower<br />

characteristics. For example,<br />

the ISLA216P25IRZ, a 16-bit 250<br />

MSPS ADC, is the first and only<br />

16-bit converter with a sample rate<br />

over 175 MSPS that consumes less<br />

than one watt (786 mW at 250 MSPS).<br />

Furthermore, a charge-based<br />

ADC such as the ISLA214P50IRZ<br />

is not only the first 14-bit 500MSPS<br />

converter, but it also provides 73dB<br />

of SNR and consumes only 835-900<br />

mW, providing approximately 3dB<br />

more SNR at one third the power of<br />

its only competitor above 250 MSPS.<br />

Charge based designs are thereby<br />

giving system designers a whole<br />

new set of options for minimizing<br />

power without compromising<br />

performance.<br />

The Bottom Line: More<br />

Options Enable Better<br />

Design Tradeoffs<br />

Although new-generation product<br />

requirements continue to escalate<br />

and require more demanding<br />

signal processing at ever-lower<br />

power budgets, the good news for<br />

designers is that new-generation<br />

ADC architectures are staying<br />

ahead of the curve.<br />

New advances such as shared-die,<br />

multi-core interleaved architectures<br />

with transparent on-chip calibration<br />

now enable the creation of very<br />

high-resolution, high sampling rate<br />

ADCs that do not compromise SNR<br />

performance, while minimizing<br />

design complexity and power.<br />

In addition, breakthroughs such<br />

as FemtoCharge are enabling<br />

even greater power savings by<br />

fundamentally shifting the approach<br />

to pipelined ADC design.<br />

The bottom line for designers is<br />

a much broader set of options<br />

to choose from, which leads to<br />

better tradeoffs and more effective<br />

tailoring of the ADC functionality to<br />

meet overall design objectives.<br />

About the Authors<br />

Edward Kohler is Intersil’s strategic<br />

marketing manager for high-speed<br />

data converters and ADC drivers.<br />

To begin his career, Edward spent<br />

eight years developing high speed,<br />

charge domain, analog-to-digital<br />

converters and was one of the<br />

inventors of Intersil’s Femtocharge<br />

technology. He earned his<br />

bachelor’s and master’s degrees in<br />

electrical engineering at Michigan<br />

Technological University and the<br />

University of Michigan and his MBA<br />

from Yale University.<br />

Jason Messier works as a staff<br />

applications engineer in Intersil’s<br />

high-speed converter group. He<br />

holds a BSEE from Northeastern<br />

University, an MSEE from Carnegie<br />

Mellon University, and an MBA<br />

from Babson College. Jason spent<br />

eight years in the automatic test<br />

equipment industry before joining<br />

Intersil in 2006 to design and later<br />

support high-speed converters. ■<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 17<br />

TECHNICAL ARTICLE


©2011 Silicon Laboratories Inc. All rights reserved.<br />

OPTOCOUPLERS<br />

ARE OLD TECHNOLOGY<br />

VACUUM TUBES<br />

1910–1958<br />

DIGITAL ISOLATION SOLUTIONS FROM<br />

SILICON LABS—ISOLATION TECHNOLOGY<br />

FOR THE 21ST CENTURY.<br />

You can’t design for the future with yesterday’s technology. With a robust product portfolio,<br />

a proven track record of industry innovation and an unwavering commitment to engineering<br />

excellence—Silicon Labs’ technology is ready to meet your isolation needs.<br />

Find out what you need to know to reduce EMI for medical applications:<br />

www.silabs.com/low-emi-medical<br />

OPTOCOUPLERS<br />

1960s–2009<br />

Say hello to the Silicon Labs’ family of digital isolator and ISOdriver solutions and say goodbye to the limitations<br />

of optocouplers. Silicon Labs’ isolators feature ultra low power consumption even at incredibly fast data<br />

rates, robust multi-channel and bi-directional communications and reliability unachievable with optocouplers.<br />

ISOdrivers combine our digital isolator technology with gate drivers, delivering up to 4 A peak output current.<br />

THE LOWEST POWER<br />

CONSUMPTION EVEN AT<br />

VERY HIGH DATA RATES<br />

Based on our patented RF isolation<br />

architecture, Silicon Labs’ digital<br />

isolators offer the lowest power<br />

consumption at data rates up to 150<br />

Mbps. Power consumption stays low<br />

even as data rates increase.<br />

ROTARY PHONES<br />

1920s–1980s<br />

VHS TAPES<br />

1970s–1990s<br />

ROBUST AND RELIABLE<br />

OPERATION THAT YOUR<br />

APPLICATIONS DEMAND<br />

Silicon Labs’ isolators and ISOdrivers<br />

lead the industry in data rate,<br />

propagation delay, RF immunity,<br />

ESD and jitter performance. And<br />

they excel in even the harshest<br />

environments.<br />

FLOPPY DISKS<br />

1980s–1990s<br />

MULTI-CHANNEL AND BI-<br />

DIRECTIONAL COMMUNICATIONS—<br />

IT’S ALL IN THE FAMILY<br />

Silicon Labs’ digital isolators are<br />

designed for a wide range of demanding<br />

applications. With a small footprint,<br />

up to 5 kV isolation and up to 6 channels,<br />

we’ve got a solution for all of your<br />

isolation needs.


HEY,<br />

YOU!<br />

Rob Irwin<br />

Product Manager<br />

You know it’s a brave new world when board design<br />

and cloud computing get mentioned in the same<br />

breath. But it seems that internet-based services and<br />

ecosystems—also known as “the cloud”—and electronic<br />

devices are colliding with ever-increasing force. Today<br />

electronic products have evolved beyond the box that<br />

houses the chips and boards, and developed intelligence<br />

that transcends their inbuilt logic and programming.<br />

Devices are now intimately connected to remote<br />

services, and indeed the true value of electronic devices<br />

is shifting from the device itself to the online systems that<br />

support it.<br />

On the surface it would seem that electronics designers<br />

should be able to go about their business largely as<br />

usual, connecting components to provide a hardware<br />

infrastructure and developing the embedded software<br />

that provides the base functionality. After all, the hardware<br />

still needs to be built and function. But this value shift has<br />

some subtle but profound implications on the industry<br />

moving forward.<br />

Get into<br />

my Cloud<br />

IDC has predicted that there will be 15 billion connected<br />

devices by 2015. Ericsson has put the figure at 50 billion<br />

devices by 2020. Whatever the real number, the fact is<br />

the market is going to demand a real lot of devices real<br />

quick, all of them connected to the cloud and utilizing<br />

sophisticated web services to provide functions and<br />

features we haven’t even thought of yet.<br />

The question is, who will create these devices and the<br />

ecosystems that support them, and how can they build<br />

the systems fast enough?<br />

A Problem of Scalability<br />

If we shuffle back in time a little to when analog was<br />

king, an electronic system was effectively the board and<br />

the components sitting on it. The design engineer’s job<br />

was essentially to electrically connect the components<br />

in many and varied forms in order to make the electrons<br />

flow in useful ways. Fast-forward to the microcontroller<br />

era and the job not only involved connecting the<br />

components, but also providing the ones and zeros<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 19


TECHNICAL ARTICLE<br />

Connecting to<br />

other devices<br />

Embedded<br />

Software<br />

Connecting<br />

to people<br />

Programmable<br />

Logic<br />

Connecting to<br />

other ecosystems<br />

Figure 1: Today, the design of the humble PCB encompasses<br />

much more than the fixed components and copper it’s made of,<br />

relying on a complex interaction between hardware, software<br />

and online services to deliver features and functionality to the<br />

end user.<br />

that powered the processor and drove the system—the<br />

embedded software. The electronic system had evolved<br />

from a purely hardware problem, to a hardware and<br />

software problem.<br />

What we’re seeing now is the evolution of software<br />

development from being a purely embedded prospect,<br />

to one that is distributed between the intelligence built<br />

into a device and provided by its supporting online<br />

ecosystem. As well as that, the hardware itself is moving<br />

increasingly to reprogrammable platforms to cope with<br />

the rapid and ongoing development of devices beyond<br />

their initial release.<br />

What we have here is a problem of scalability. The<br />

challenges of marrying programmable hardware,<br />

embedded software, and web services can all be<br />

overcome with our current methodologies given time and<br />

suitable engineering and Web development resources.<br />

But if we’re to get 50 billion devices into production in the<br />

next ten years then we really need to radically rethink how<br />

we go about taking designs from concept to production.<br />

To Catch a Thief<br />

It’s interesting to reflect that one of the most important<br />

enabling elements in building today’s computers is in<br />

fact the computer itself. The earliest digital computers<br />

were designed with nothing much more than paper and<br />

drafting pens. But it wasn’t long before we pressed these<br />

basic machines into a service to aid us in building more<br />

complex computers. Repeat this cycle a few times and<br />

pretty soon you have a billion transistors on a chip and<br />

a complex system to support it—all delivered in a neat<br />

package with keyboard and mouse for a few hundred<br />

dollars. It’s fair to say computer-aided design (CAD) and<br />

electronics design automation (EDA) have revolutionized<br />

the process of capturing our ideas and turning them into<br />

manufactured products.<br />

As devices move into the realm of cloud connectivity,<br />

becoming far more complex distributed systems than<br />

we’ve ever designed before, it’s worth considering<br />

whether the cloud itself could provide a possible way<br />

forward in bringing scalability to next-generation device<br />

design. There’s an old saying that it takes a thief to catch<br />

a thief. In this case, perhaps it takes a cloud-based<br />

approach to design to build a mass market of cloudenabled<br />

devices.<br />

Taking EDA Into the Cloud<br />

Electronics design tool vendors have often been criticized<br />

for lagging the technology that they’re ostensibly charged<br />

with enabling. As devices become increasingly internetenabled,<br />

and depend more and more on back-end,<br />

cloud-based ecosystems to provide critical functionality,<br />

this criticism could justifiably be leveled again.<br />

That’s not to say EDA tool companies are ignoring the<br />

cloud. Many of the chip tool vendors are actively looking<br />

to provide some design functions, such as complex<br />

verification, as cloud-based services. So indeed, EDA<br />

companies are looking at how they can use the cloud as<br />

a way to deliver their tools in a more cost-effective and<br />

scalable way. While this is, on the surface, a reasonable<br />

course of action, it really ignores the bigger issue for<br />

EDA vendors when it comes to the cloud.<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 20<br />

TECHNICAL ARTICLE


TECHNICAL ARTICLE<br />

It’s not really about tool vendors using the cloud to<br />

simply provide the tools and services they currently offer<br />

in a better or more efficient way. The real game changer<br />

comes in the broader product development arena, and<br />

it will happen when the tool vendors ask themselves one<br />

simple question: How can they use the cloud to help<br />

their customers design for the cloud, and not just design<br />

the devices that connect to it?<br />

If we hark back to the computer design example<br />

mentioned earlier, simply using the computer as a<br />

glorified drafting table (which was essentially the basis<br />

AltiumLive<br />

Subscriber AltiumLive<br />

Subscriber<br />

Data<br />

Access Controlled via AltiumLive ID<br />

AltiumLive<br />

ID<br />

AltiumLive<br />

Satellite Vault<br />

Data<br />

Access Controlled via AltiumLive ID<br />

Figure 2: Design tool company Altium has launched its<br />

AltiumLive online portal that connects directly to its Altium<br />

Designer software and Design Vault technology to bring web<br />

services directly into the electronics design space.<br />

of first board design programs) didn’t really raise the<br />

abstraction level at which we could design. It just let us<br />

do what we’d always done, only a bit faster and more<br />

conveniently. It wasn’t until we used the computational<br />

power and logic available to automate processes and<br />

help make and enforce design decisions that we were<br />

able to move forward at the pace necessary to make the<br />

digital age a reality.<br />

Similarly, electronics designers today need tools that<br />

allow them to harness their device design experience<br />

Local Access Only<br />

Access<br />

Permissions<br />

Not an<br />

AltiumLive<br />

Subscriber<br />

Company Network<br />

Access Controlled via AltiumLive ID<br />

Data<br />

AltiumLive<br />

Subscriber<br />

and extend it to the design of device ecosystems. What’s<br />

needed is a unification of device and web applications<br />

development within a single tool framework. When<br />

we start to apply the power inherent in connecting<br />

devices and applications to Web-based services and<br />

infrastructure to actually developing new, internetconnected<br />

devices, we’ll see the ‘internet of things’<br />

really start to take shape.<br />

Cloud-Based Design for Everyone<br />

A simple example of the power of device-to-cloud<br />

connectivity is the way Amazon’s Kindle book reader<br />

system synchronizes itself across multiple platforms.<br />

Regardless of which device you use—Kindle for PC,<br />

Kindle for iPad, the Kindle device itself—when you open<br />

any device you’ll be presented with the last page you<br />

were reading, regardless of which device you were last<br />

reading it on. Amazon uses a person’s Kindle account in<br />

the cloud to transparently synchronize this information<br />

across all devices in the ecosystem.<br />

Now Amazon is a large company with huge resources<br />

available, so it has the ability to push through the<br />

development of such a system with the tools currently<br />

available by gathering together hardware, software and<br />

web development teams, each working within their<br />

individual realms of expertise.<br />

But imagine if cloud connectivity and a range of cloud<br />

service building blocks and templates were standard<br />

parts of an electronic product developer’s design tool.<br />

And imagine if the design environment on the designer’s<br />

desktop was part of a larger, cloud-based ecosystem that<br />

provided automatic hosting and deployment services<br />

(among other things) that allowed designers to connect<br />

the devices they design directly to the cloud and utilize<br />

the services they create.<br />

With such a system, even developers with limited<br />

resources could bring the potential of cloud-based<br />

services and functions directly and easily to their<br />

products and the people using them.<br />

The Shape of Things to Come<br />

One could argue that the entire history of solid-state<br />

electronics has been one of unification. Multiple<br />

transistors were brought together on a single piece of<br />

silicon. Functional circuit blocks have been combined to<br />

create large-scale integrated circuits. Software has been<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 21<br />

TECHNICAL ARTICLE


TECHNICAL ARTICLE<br />

unified with hardware to create programmable platforms.<br />

At each stage, the technology and the tools have evolved<br />

to raise the level of abstraction at which we can work. It’s<br />

this principle that has allowed us to achieve the many<br />

orders of magnitude increase in system complexity in<br />

the relative short lifetime of the industry.<br />

Today we’re reaching another technological turning<br />

point, and once again we need to unify processes<br />

and evolve the tools in order to progress. A number of<br />

companies and products have demonstrated the power<br />

of connecting devices to Web-based ecosystems.<br />

Increasingly, this cloud connectivity is automated and<br />

does not require human interaction. As we move forward,<br />

cloud connectivity will be a necessary part of all devices<br />

across the spectrum of markets from consumer and<br />

industrial through to military. This will happen because<br />

the potential of ubiquitous device connectivity is too<br />

great to ignore, similar to past state changes such as the<br />

digital and embedded software revolutions.<br />

For engineers and designers this will mean changing<br />

their mindsets to incorporate online components directly<br />

into the hardware and embedded design process right<br />

from the start of a project. For tool providers it means<br />

finding ways to utilize the cloud to provide “plug and<br />

play” access to online services, real-time connections<br />

into supply chain and manufacturing information via the<br />

web, and an expanded definition of design components<br />

to include functionality provided remotely to hardware<br />

devices via back-end, online ecosystems.<br />

Whichever way you look at it, electronics designers and<br />

engineers are headed for the cloud. The real question is,<br />

when they get there will they be able tap into that silver<br />

lining?<br />

About the Author<br />

Rob Irwin has a Bachelor of Engineering (Electrical)<br />

from the University of Sydney, Australia. He has over 20<br />

years of experience in the electronic design industry<br />

including several years as editor of Australian Electronics<br />

Engineering. Rob currently holds the position of Product<br />

Manager at Altium Limited. ■<br />

Altium Vault<br />

Design Space Supply Chain Space<br />

Flux_Triangulator.PrjPcb<br />

Feedback_Resonator.PrjPcb<br />

Coil Comparator.PrjPcb<br />

Schematics<br />

PCB<br />

Device Sheets<br />

Libraries<br />

Output Jobs<br />

Harness Definitions<br />

Annotation File<br />

Vault-Based Components<br />

Reusable Design Content<br />

Production Release Data<br />

Procurement<br />

Fabrication<br />

Assembly<br />

Testing<br />

Figure 3: Design tool company Altium’s Vault technology uses web-based services to connect components in the design<br />

space to the wider supply chain, allowing designers to get real-time price, availability, and other information on parts as they use<br />

them within the Altium Designer software.<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 22<br />

TECHNICAL ARTICLE


BeStar®<br />

ACOUSTICS & SENSORS<br />

PRODUCTS<br />

Speakers<br />

Buzzers<br />

Piezo Elements<br />

Back-up Alarms<br />

Horns<br />

Sirens/Bells<br />

Beacons<br />

Microphones<br />

Sensors<br />

INDUSTRIES<br />

Automotive<br />

Durables<br />

Medical<br />

Industrial<br />

Mobile<br />

Fire / Safety<br />

Security<br />

Consumer<br />

Leisure<br />

Teamwork • Technology • Invention • Listen • Hear<br />

Preferred acoustic component<br />

supplier to OEMs worldwide<br />

bestartech.com | sales@bestartech.com | 520.439.9204<br />

QS9000 • TS/ISO16949 • ISO14001 • ISO13485 • ISO9001<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong><br />

Electrical Engineering Community<br />

Contact Us For Advertising Opportunities<br />

1.800.574.2791<br />

advertising@eeweb.com<br />

www.eeweb.com/advertising


RETURN TO ZERO<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 24<br />

RETURN TO ZERO


RETURN TO ZERO<br />

<strong>EEWeb</strong> | Electrical Engineering Community Visit www.eeweb.com 25<br />

RETURN TO ZERO

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!