5.4 Conclusion Chapter 5 The values <strong>of</strong> K1 obtained from two separate experiments are the same within experimental error. This is a further indication that the reaction scheme <strong>and</strong> resulting rate law provides a good underst<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>of</strong> the formation reactions studied here. The value <strong>of</strong> K2 is three orders <strong>of</strong> magnitude smaller than K1 (e.g. at 25.0 °C, K1 = 1975 (201) M -1 vs K2 = 2.0 (5) M -1 ). This is to be expected since the rate-determining ring- closure is slow. Similar examples, where this has been observed, are known for bidentate <strong>complexes</strong>. 7 The relative rate <strong>of</strong> the ring-closure is best illustrated by comparing k1 to k2. The rate data cannot be compared simply by looking at the results in Table 5.2, since the k2 rate constant is only measured in s -1 . The rate constant, k1 (at 25.0 ° C), is converted to a first-order rate constant by multiplying k1 (237 (4) M -1 s -1 ) with [acacH] (0.05 M) <strong>and</strong> adding k-1 (0.12 (1) s -1 ). When this value <strong>of</strong> 11.97 (2) s -1 is compared with k2 (3.7 (3) x 10 -5 ), a difference <strong>of</strong> 6 orders <strong>of</strong> magnitude is obtained. The difference between k2 <strong>and</strong> k-2 is between 1.5 <strong>and</strong> 2 times at all the temperatures studied. This is also a very good indication <strong>of</strong> the small value obtained for the equilibrium constant, K2. Comparison <strong>of</strong> the kinetic data obtained for this <strong>study</strong> with that <strong>of</strong> the corresponding tantalum <strong>study</strong> 8 yielded the following: Similar rate laws were obtained for both studies, except that no k-2 step was observed for the tantalum <strong>study</strong>. The values obtained for the rate constants, k1 <strong>and</strong> k2, <strong>of</strong> the tantalum <strong>study</strong> (316 (9) M -1 s -1 ; 4.43 (7) x 10 -5 s -1 ) was slightly higher than that obtained for the <strong>niobium</strong> <strong>study</strong> (237 (4) M -1 s -1 , 3.7 (3) x 10 -5 s -1 ) at 25.0 °C. The equilibrium constant, K1, for both studies are, within experimental error, similar at ± 2000 M -1 . The high positive value obtained for ∆S ‡ (k1), points strongly towards a dissociative type mechanism for the first step, as expected for octahedral substitution reactions. 7 H. J. van der Westhuizen, R. Meijboom, M. Schutte, A. Roodt, Inorg. Chem., 49, 20, 9599, 2010. 8 R. Koen, H. G. Visser, A. Roodt, M.Sc. Thesis, <strong>University</strong> <strong>of</strong> the Free State, 2012. 93
Chapter 5 However, more information (such as high-pressure kinetic data) is required to make a more reliable conclusion <strong>of</strong> the type <strong>of</strong> mechanism. The large negative value obtained for ∆S ‡ (k2) might be misleading. It is expected that a η 1 -acac lig<strong>and</strong> will free rotate quite substantially <strong>and</strong> that the resulting ring-closure, to form η 2 - coordination, could override the observed enthropy for the dissociation <strong>of</strong> the chlorido lig<strong>and</strong>, thus resulting in a more ordered transition <strong>state</strong> for the second step. 94