27.07.2013 Views

The Doctor Rostering Problem - Asser Fahrenholz

The Doctor Rostering Problem - Asser Fahrenholz

The Doctor Rostering Problem - Asser Fahrenholz

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Appendix C. Tests 99<br />

C.1.9 Instance 8<br />

JST PZH HP SDA HMM OSJ<br />

09-04-08 V14 09-09-08 FRI2 09-15-08 V12 09-01-08 FRI2 09-11-08 FERIE 09-01-08 FERIE<br />

09-08-08 FRI2 09-19-08 FRI2 09-01-08 FRI2 09-04-08 FERIE 09-12-08 FERIE 09-02-08 FERIE<br />

09-09-08 FRI2 09-29-08 V14 09-23-08 FRI2 09-21-08 V15 09-13-08 FERIE 09-03-08 FERIE<br />

09-13-08 V8 10-17-08 FERIE 09-26-08 FERIE 09-26-08 FERIE 09-14-08 FERIE 09-04-08 FERIE<br />

10-01-08 FERIE 10-18-08 FERIE 09-30-08 FRI2 09-29-08 FERIE 09-16-08 Ss 10-13-08 FERIE<br />

10-02-08 FERIE 10-19-08 FERIE 10-05-08 V13 10-16-08 V12 09-20-08 K14 10-14-08 FERIE<br />

10-03-08 FERIE 10-25-08 V6 10-07-08 FRI2 10-17-08 FERIE 09-21-08 V3<br />

10-04-08 FERIE 10-26-08 V2 10-09-08 V13 10-20-08 FERIE 09-25-08 K16<br />

10-05-08 FERIE 11-21-08 V11 10-23-08 FRI2 12-16-08 V13 10-17-08 K16<br />

10-06-08 FERIE 11-29-08 V4 10-27-08 FRI2 12-24-08 V3 10-18-08 K19<br />

10-07-08 FERIE 11-30-08 V9 11-11-08 FRI2 10-19-08 K19<br />

11-05-08 FRI2 12-27-08 V2 11-17-08 FRI2 10-31-08 K6<br />

11-07-08 FRI2 12-28-08 V6 11-18-08 FRI2 11-01-08 V3<br />

11-12-08 FRI2 12-30-08 FERIE 11-20-08 FRI2 11-02-08 K6<br />

11-13-08 V11 12-31-08 V14 12-01-08 V14 11-29-08 K4<br />

11-20-08 V15 12-05-08 FRI2 11-30-08 V12<br />

11-27-08 FRI2 12-08-08 FRI2 12-04-08 K6<br />

12-07-08 V10 12-13-08 V9<br />

12-16-08 FRI2 12-14-08 K5<br />

12-17-08 FRI2 12-28-08 K15<br />

12-22-08 V12<br />

12-30-08 FERIE<br />

C.1.10 Instance 9<br />

It is the empty instance, with no night- or evening shifts given, nor any wishes.<br />

C.2 Summarized results<br />

C.2.1 RCL performance<br />

Cons 17 Imps Z(S) V(S) Cons 13 Imps Z(S) V(S) Cons 17 Imps Z(S) V(S)<br />

Test 1 GRASP 1 19,625 5 32 Test 3 GRASP 1 16,8125 3,5 30,4375 Test 6 GRASP 1 14,5 4,1875 12,6875<br />

GRASP 100 15,3125 363,6875 27,875 GRASP 100 17,0625 468,1875 23,25 GRASP 100 12,0625 176,8125 10,1875<br />

GRASP 50 13,625 6,125 27,5 GRASP 50 15,25 4,3125 25,4375 GRASP 50 15,25 8,5625 9,1875<br />

SA 1 62,35938 185,9844 8,9375 SA 1 59,65625 162,5156 9,171875 SA 1 41,65625 96,71875 2,1875<br />

SA 100 78,57813 624,9688 11,51563 SA 100 74,14063 689,8906 9,984375 SA 100 53,40625 276,7188 2,234375<br />

SA 50 72,51563 151,8125 9,6875 SA 50 67,34375 221,5625 9,9375 SA 50 39,09375 95,15625 1,9375<br />

Ave: 43,66927 222,9297 19,58594 Ave 41,71094 258,3281 18,03646 Ave 29,32813 109,6927 6,403646<br />

Cons 13 Imps Z(S) V(S) Cons 13 Imps Z(S) V(S) Cons 13 Imps Z(S) V(S)<br />

Test 0 GRASP 1 17,1875 3,5625 25,9375 Test 4 GRASP 1 19,1875 4,375 55,0625 Test 7 GRASP 1 20,875 3,4375 45,8125<br />

GRASP 100 14,625 392,75 19,3125 GRASP 100 17,4375 731,5 37,75 GRASP 100 16,9375 508,9375 27,3125<br />

GRASP 50 13,5 5,625 21,125 GRASP 50 15 4,6875 44,5 GRASP 50 16,5625 6,75 29,375<br />

SA 1 57,40625 111,2344 7,125 SA 1 74,29688 124,2656 20,46875 SA 1 62,84375 87,45313 14,20313<br />

SA 100 54,42188 520,7344 6,15625 SA 100 67,48438 1049,969 17,54688 SA 100 61,82813 761,1563 10,5<br />

SA 50 58,07813 142,6875 6,640625 SA 50 72,875 179,6563 19,1875 SA 50 63,53125 113,7969 10,57813<br />

Ave: 35,86979 196,099 14,38281 Ave 44,38021 349,0755 32,41927 Ave 40,42969 246,9219 22,96354

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!