Full Report - Center for Collaborative Education

Full Report - Center for Collaborative Education Full Report - Center for Collaborative Education

26.07.2013 Views

SWD Primary Disability English Proficiency Level A student with a disability (SWD) is a student participating in special education programs: full inclusion, partial inclusion, and substantially separate classrooms. We report only on SWDs ages 6+, K-12. The nature of the primary disability of a student participating in a special education program. The English proficiency level of LEP students as measured by MEPA in 1 to 4 (SY2006-SY2008) or 1 to 5 (2009) categories. The English proficiency level of LEPs is used both as an individual descriptor and as an outcome when discussing progress in English language acquisition. Program Level Variables In ELL Program Student enrolled in a program for English language learners (and not in a general education program). A student in an ELL program may or may not also be a student with a disability receiving special education services or a student in an alternative education program. In SEI Student enrolled in a Sheltered English Immersion program. SEI programs in BPS are of two types: Multilingual (students in these programs speak different languages) or Language Specific (students all speak the same language and support for students and families is available in that language). BPS offers SEI Language Specific programs in Cape Verdean Creole, Chinese, Haitian Creole, In Two-Way Bilingual Portuguese, Somali, Spanish, and Vietnamese. Student enrolled in a Two-Way bilingual program. These are programs where fluent speakers of English and English language learners to learn to become bilingual and bi-literate in a second language. In BPS, all Two-Way Bilingual programs are English/Spanish. In TBE Student enrolled in a transitional bilingual education program. Transitional Bilingual Education models promote a gradual reduction of instruction in the primary language as students learn English. This model’s major goal is for students to build the capacity to Islander) and all Hispanic students are labeled as a 6th race/ethnicity category in a single variable. Constructed from SIMS DOE034 (SIMS DOE032 was inadvertently not requested). According to SIMS, this variable contains data for students ages 6+. SIMS DOE036 MEPA Database. For SY2006-2008, a student’s highest score on MEPA was identified for a given school year from the respective October and April MEPA test administrations and the corresponding performance level was selected for that student. When analyzing SY2009 MEPA data alone, the spring 2009 administration data (with the 5 proficiency levels) was used. In order to compare MEPA data over time, the spring 2009 MEPA data (1-5 proficiency levels) was converted to the 1-4 proficiency levels according to the concordance methodology in (MDESE, 2009b). When comparing MEPA data across time, the highest MEPA score for SY2009 was selected from the October 2008 administration and the April 2009 administration, with the corresponding proficiency level converted to the former levels when necessary. For SY2009, the research team compiled disaggregated program data from OELL administrative data source to assign an ELL program status to LEP students: Not in ELL program; SEI Cape Verde; SEI Chinese; SEI Haitian; SEI Portuguese; SEI Somali; SEI Spanish; SEI Vietnamese; SEI Multilingual; Two-Way Bilingual (Spanish); TBE (Chinese); HILT-SIFE Cape Verde; HILT-SIFE Haitian; HILT-SIFE Somali; HILT-SIFE Spanish; or SIFE Multilingual. 2 The disaggregated program data was entered into a school database by hand for each school. Then, SPSS syntax specific to each school with an ELL program was developed for the student-level database to recode the SIMS program and native language variables into the expanded list of programs for each student. In some cases, decisions were made about the program in which a LEP participated depending on the program present in the school. When this occurred, the research team consulted with OELL to decide the program placement for the student. This method obscured exceptions –such as a Portuguese speaker enrolled in a Spanish language specific SEI program- but we report on this data because those exceptions were not very numerous and OELL’s need for a baseline of outcomes on its programs outweighed the potential inaccuracies 110 Improving Educational Outcomes of English Language Learners in Schools and Programs in Boston Public Schools

In TBE learn solely in English. In BPS, all TBE programs are for native Chinese speakers. In SIFE Student enrolled in a program for students with limited and/or interrupted formal education and who do not have the educational skills that are needed to perform grade level academic work. High Intensity Literacy Training is available for SIFE students in language specific programs. These HILT-SIFE language specific programs include Cape Verde, Haitian, Spanish and Somali. Multilingual SIFE programs enroll students from Not in Program for ELLs Median Attendance Rate Out-of-School Suspension Rate Grade Retention Rate Annual Dropout Rate diverse linguistic backgrounds. A LEP student whose parent has opted out of enrolling their child in an ELL program, or, a LEP student who is otherwise not enrolled in an ELL program. A student not enrolled in an ELL program may or may not also be a student with a disability receiving special education services. Engagement and Outcome Variables The attendance rate measures the percentage of school days in which students have been present at their schools. The out-of-school suspension rate is the ratio of out-of-school suspensions to the total enrollment during the year. The proportion of students required to repeat the grade in which they were enrolled the previous year. See Table 3. posed by the infrequent exceptions. Because of the time intensive nature of this process and the inaccessibility of program for SY2006-SY2008, the research team only assigned this detailed ELL program data for students enrolled in SY2009. For certain analyses, the SEI programs were collapsed into a single SEI variable and also collapsed into a multilingual/language specific dummy variable. The same was done for the SIFE/HILT-SIFE programs. In addition, all students enrolled in any type of SEI, Two- Way Bilingual, TBE, or SIFE/HILT-SIFE program was also coded as being enrolled in an ELL program. For SY2006-SY2008, ELL program data was taken from SIMS DOE026. For LEP students not in ELL programs, codes 00 (not enrolled in an ELL program) and 04 (student’s parent consented to opt out of ELL program) were collapsed into a single category. For LEP students enrolled in an ELL program, codes 01- 03 were collapsed into a single category. Code 01 identifies all SEI students, code 02 identifies all 2-way students (LEPs only), and code 03 identifies students enrolled in any other bilingual education program. Because SIMS does not disaggregate SEI into SEI language specific or multilingual programs and does not disaggregate “other bilingual education” into TBE and SIFE/HILT-SIFE we were unable to report on ELL programs beyond the SIMS categories for SY2006- SY2008. When comparing ELL program enrollment across time, SY2009 ELL program variables were collapsed into SIMS categories so data from all four school years could be compared. Constructed from SIMS by dividing number of days in attendance as of the June SIMS (DOE017) by the number of days in membership as of the June SIMS (DOE018). If the student was not enrolled in BPS as of the June SIMS, the attendance rate was calculated from the corresponding variables in the October SIMS. An out-of-school suspension dummy variable was constructed from SIMS DOE046, which reports the number of times a student has received an out-ofschool suspension for a given school year. If the value was above zero, we counted the student as having been suspended. Constructed from SIMS by subtracting the student’s grade level (DOE016) in a given school year to his/her grade level in the prior school year. If the value was zero, indicating the grade levels were the same in both year, the student was coded as having been retained in grade. We are able to report grade retention for SY2007-SY2009. Improving Educational Outcomes of English Language Learners in Schools and Programs in Boston Public Schools 111

SWD<br />

Primary<br />

Disability<br />

English<br />

Proficiency<br />

Level<br />

A student with a disability (SWD) is a student<br />

participating in special education programs: full<br />

inclusion, partial inclusion, and substantially<br />

separate classrooms. We report only on SWDs<br />

ages 6+, K-12.<br />

The nature of the primary disability of a student<br />

participating in a special education program.<br />

The English proficiency level of LEP students as<br />

measured by MEPA in 1 to 4 (SY2006-SY2008) or<br />

1 to 5 (2009) categories.<br />

The English proficiency level of LEPs is used both<br />

as an individual descriptor and as an outcome<br />

when discussing progress in English language<br />

acquisition.<br />

Program Level Variables<br />

In ELL Program Student enrolled in a program <strong>for</strong> English language<br />

learners (and not in a general education program).<br />

A student in an ELL program may or may not also<br />

be a student with a disability receiving special<br />

education services or a student in an alternative<br />

education program.<br />

In SEI Student enrolled in a Sheltered English Immersion<br />

program.<br />

SEI programs in BPS are of two types: Multilingual<br />

(students in these programs speak different<br />

languages) or Language Specific (students all<br />

speak the same language and support <strong>for</strong> students<br />

and families is available in that language). BPS<br />

offers SEI Language Specific programs in Cape<br />

Verdean Creole, Chinese, Haitian Creole,<br />

In Two-Way<br />

Bilingual<br />

Portuguese, Somali, Spanish, and Vietnamese.<br />

Student enrolled in a Two-Way bilingual program.<br />

These are programs where fluent speakers of<br />

English and English language learners to learn to<br />

become bilingual and bi-literate in a second<br />

language. In BPS, all Two-Way Bilingual<br />

programs are English/Spanish.<br />

In TBE Student enrolled in a transitional bilingual education<br />

program.<br />

Transitional Bilingual <strong>Education</strong> models promote a<br />

gradual reduction of instruction in the primary<br />

language as students learn English. This model’s<br />

major goal is <strong>for</strong> students to build the capacity to<br />

Islander) and all Hispanic students are labeled as a<br />

6th race/ethnicity category in a single variable.<br />

Constructed from SIMS DOE034 (SIMS DOE032 was<br />

inadvertently not requested).<br />

According to SIMS, this variable contains data <strong>for</strong><br />

students ages 6+.<br />

SIMS DOE036<br />

MEPA Database.<br />

For SY2006-2008, a student’s highest score on MEPA<br />

was identified <strong>for</strong> a given school year from the<br />

respective October and April MEPA test<br />

administrations and the corresponding per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

level was selected <strong>for</strong> that student. When analyzing<br />

SY2009 MEPA data alone, the spring 2009<br />

administration data (with the 5 proficiency levels) was<br />

used.<br />

In order to compare MEPA data over time, the spring<br />

2009 MEPA data (1-5 proficiency levels) was<br />

converted to the 1-4 proficiency levels according to<br />

the concordance methodology in (MDESE, 2009b).<br />

When comparing MEPA data across time, the highest<br />

MEPA score <strong>for</strong> SY2009 was selected from the<br />

October 2008 administration and the April 2009<br />

administration, with the corresponding proficiency<br />

level converted to the <strong>for</strong>mer levels when necessary.<br />

For SY2009, the research team compiled<br />

disaggregated program data from OELL<br />

administrative data source to assign an ELL program<br />

status to LEP students: Not in ELL program; SEI<br />

Cape Verde; SEI Chinese; SEI Haitian; SEI<br />

Portuguese; SEI Somali; SEI Spanish; SEI<br />

Vietnamese; SEI Multilingual; Two-Way Bilingual<br />

(Spanish); TBE (Chinese); HILT-SIFE Cape Verde;<br />

HILT-SIFE Haitian; HILT-SIFE Somali; HILT-SIFE<br />

Spanish; or SIFE Multilingual. 2<br />

The disaggregated program data was entered into a<br />

school database by hand <strong>for</strong> each school. Then,<br />

SPSS syntax specific to each school with an ELL<br />

program was developed <strong>for</strong> the student-level<br />

database to recode the SIMS program and native<br />

language variables into the expanded list of programs<br />

<strong>for</strong> each student. In some cases, decisions were<br />

made about the program in which a LEP participated<br />

depending on the program present in the school.<br />

When this occurred, the research team consulted with<br />

OELL to decide the program placement <strong>for</strong> the<br />

student. This method obscured exceptions –such as<br />

a Portuguese speaker enrolled in a Spanish language<br />

specific SEI program- but we report on this data<br />

because those exceptions were not very numerous<br />

and OELL’s need <strong>for</strong> a baseline of outcomes on its<br />

programs outweighed the potential inaccuracies<br />

110 Improving <strong>Education</strong>al Outcomes of English Language Learners in Schools and Programs in Boston Public Schools

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!