Leo Strauss - Pluto Huji Ac Il
Leo Strauss - Pluto Huji Ac Il
Leo Strauss - Pluto Huji Ac Il
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
: z k x r n d<br />
,xi`n dnly xn ,oecxeb oexy 'ab ,x"ei - xpiit l`eny 'text<br />
lhpciext lgx x"c ,oexin `ib 'text ,il`n sqei 'text<br />
dex xnz :oeyl zkixr<br />
itl ,hwqic sexiva ,x`eca e` ,l`ecd zervn`a zkxrnl gelyl yi mixn`n<br />
zkxrnl diipta lawl e` ,oeknd xz`a `evnl ozip oze`y zeigpdd<br />
milyexi wa e`il oekn - "miyecig"<br />
91082 milyexi 8298 .c.z ,93229 milyexi 33 i`pzqea 'gx<br />
02-5669505 :qwt ,02-5633790 :oetlh<br />
:ipexhwl` x`ec<br />
chidushim@gmail.com - zkxrnd<br />
leobaeck@netvision.net.il - xe`l `ivend<br />
Ï<br />
milyexi wa e`il oeknl zexeny zeiekfd lk<br />
2009 ,h"qyz milyexi<br />
dxev meya ,dpnn mirhw e` ef zxaeg uitdl e` wizrdl ,mbxzl oi`<br />
zlaw `ll ,dhlwd e` meliv zeaxl ,ipkn e` ipexhwl` ,ote` meyae<br />
xe`l `ivendn azka xeyi`<br />
978-965-7474-00-6 a"zqn<br />
milyexi wa e`il oekn :cenire xeciq
:סוארטש ואיל<br />
תונשרפ לש התולג<br />
ןייטשנייו דוד<br />
יאכז והיבא<br />
±≥<br />
ÌÈÏ˘Â¯È†˜·†Â‡ÈφÔÂÎÓ
(1998 ,h"pyz)<br />
(1999 ,q"yz)<br />
(2000 ,`"qyz)<br />
(2003 ,a"qyz)<br />
(2004 c"qyz)<br />
(2004 ,c"qyz)<br />
(2005 ,d"qyz)<br />
(2006 ,e"qyz)<br />
(2006 ,e"qyz)<br />
(2007 ,f"qyz)<br />
(2008 ,g"qyz)<br />
(2008 ,h"qyz)<br />
dk cr e`vi<br />
rexd lr giyde hcpx` dpg<br />
zihilet dibele`iz - cizrd on zepexkf<br />
zipnxbd zicedid zeaxzd oaxeg zra oexkife<br />
mipey`xd mipeivd xec<br />
ezexgaa zecdid<br />
zernyn lr<br />
onbxa d"y ly zencwend ezebdae<br />
bebctk xwegd - u"k awri<br />
- "ylg dk dyi`d ly dale fr iezitd"<br />
"mixtqd oex`"a divfipxcene jepig ,zxeqn<br />
19Îd d`na zeicediÎzeipnxbd zepad ly<br />
- zecici ly xetiq cer "ihqepbd zinrl"<br />
qpei qpde mley myxb<br />
yxid x"yx ly ezebda dicedid dyi`d oweic<br />
- xniidqclid zlekq`<br />
"zecdid rcn"l ziqkecezxe` daihpxhl`<br />
- yecwd lke ,xiee`l xnzen wvend lk"<br />
zxnd lr giya dad`e zepzlrez - "oilegl<br />
19Îd d`na dipnxba micedi ly zcd<br />
- "epzee`be epgek xewn `id zycewnd zixad"<br />
miztxve mipnxb micedi ly zeiheixhtd<br />
1871-1870 ,mdipia migznde<br />
zedfe dwih`et - mieeyd oeieey i` lr<br />
mr wa`na bxapixb iav ixe`l "`hqitrn"a<br />
zipnxbd zextqd<br />
miidy` oaihq<br />
hciny sehqixk<br />
oiwven l`ixab<br />
blt fx`<br />
jxka iav<br />
onbew lh<br />
mzeg mzei<br />
wezxy dnly<br />
dicici sq`<br />
oecxeb oexy<br />
xbexw .b dp`ihqixk<br />
xbxeaiep oxw<br />
.1<br />
.2<br />
.3<br />
.4<br />
.5<br />
.6<br />
.7<br />
.8<br />
.9<br />
.10<br />
.11<br />
.12<br />
aexwa xe`l e`vi<br />
oiihypii` hxal` ly 'zicedid zeyibxd' :meh`d zvvte izxag wcv ,ifpky` xtr<br />
x`niie zwilaetxn qe`xhy e`il ly zihiletd daygnd zegztzd :mip`iqe`xhyd iptl rbx ,oenxr icr<br />
zixad zevx` cr
3<br />
* zepyxt ly dzelb :qe`xhy e`il<br />
i`kf edia`e oiihypiie cec<br />
ziieeg mle` .dhytdl mixqnzn mpi` mde ,mileb miyp`l qgia zellkd zeyrl lw `l<br />
zeieegd zg` ef .daygn xxerzy ie`xd on ok lre ,zxqiin dke dgiky dk `id zelbd<br />
1<br />
.agxp dk ilnq yeniy dyrp `l zxg` dieeg meyae ,xzeia zeiceqid zeiyep`d<br />
zepya mvx`n zelbl evl`p dixhqe`ne dipnxbn miax micedi mil`ehwlhpi`<br />
daiqd .oehxy lr dzlr zipxcend dixehqiddy zra ,mixyrd d`nd ly miyelyd<br />
miifkxn miipicn zepeirxy mzyegza dax dcina dverp dziid mdn miax ly mzelbl<br />
miyayn mizeern miihilet zepeirxy<br />
did mgwl .zipqxd dxeva maizpn ehq mdiiga<br />
zipicnd daygnd ly oeq`d dxd dlelqn oewize mda wa`ndy o`kne ,dixehqidd z`<br />
.miitelg zepeirx zervn`a dxry dngln zayd miaiign mixyrd d`na<br />
zipicn diteqelita mipcd el`l cgeinae ,mnvr miazkl ef zipeirx dnglnae<br />
mil`ehwlhpi`d on miax xear .dax zeaiyg zrcep ,diteqelitd ly dixehqidae<br />
zpigaa zepyxtde iteqelitd oeird eid ,icedi `venn did lhean `ld mwlgy ,milebd<br />
qpd ,oenlh awri enk ,dtexi`n mileb mibed ly ef dveawa .xac lkl ihilet dyrn<br />
mgek z` qp lr dlrdy mc` cer did `l ,mixg`e hcpx` dpg ,xtet lxw ,oex`a<br />
,qe`xhy e`ilk zeidz zxxern dk z`f mre ziaihweaext dk dxeva zepeirxd ly<br />
zepeirxl ik orhe axrnd iexy eay il`ehwlhpi` xaynk epnfa xaynd z` d`xy<br />
ewa`ne qe`xhy ly ezelb ik oreh df xn`n 2.mfiytd<br />
cbp wa`na gztn ciwtz yi<br />
,mircnl zil`xyid dincw`d ,"meid mfixhilhehde oenlh awri" qpka ebved df xn`n ly ze`qxb<br />
.2007 lixt` ,oiileh zhiqxaipe` ,itxn oekn ,"ixeaiv ldpne dwiz`l fkxn"ae 2006 xanvc<br />
zetl`nde zelirend mdizexrd lr bxapiihy ozpeile wewet '` 'b 'bl ,odkd ik`lnl zecedl eppevxa<br />
.zencewd ze`qxbl<br />
Judith N. Shklar, Political Thought and Political Thinkers, ed. Stanley Hoffmann,<br />
Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998, p. 57.<br />
dtya zexewnl od qe`xhy ly eixeaigl zeiptdd lk zilbp`a exewna azkp xn`ndy xg`n<br />
*<br />
1<br />
2
diteqelitd z` yxit eay ote`d lr zrxkn dcina erityd zeixhilhehd cbpk<br />
xaynl jtd xy` ,zeipxcend ly llekd xaynd ik ze`xdl epzxhn .zihiletd<br />
zepyxt xayn mb gxkda exear did ,zelbl z`vl qe`xhy z` ripde mfiytd<br />
ely zelbd ziieege mfixhilhehl qe`xhy ly ezecbpzd .zepeirxd ly dixehqidd<br />
z` dkixcdy `id ef zecbpzde ,mfivixehqidl zvxgpd ezecbpzd lr zewenr erityd<br />
ipa mixg` micedi milebl dneca .gzity zicegiid zil`ehqwhd zepyxtd zhiy<br />
.diite` lre ezebd lelkn lr erityd deegy micwzd zexqg zeicbxhd ,exec<br />
mfivixehqidd zxrne zeipxcend xayn<br />
md zxkyne zxeepqn zeihpnex `l s`e zewizr zexivi zad` e` zinvr dgky `l<br />
zipicnd zebdd cenill zbieqn izla zepekpae zeadlzda zeptl epze` miripn xy`<br />
xaynd ,epztewz ly xaynd awr z`f zeyrl miaiig ep` .wizrd iqlwd mlerd ly<br />
3<br />
.axrnd ly<br />
xg`ly mipnxbd miteqelitd on miaxy drya zil`ehwlhpi` zexbal ribd qe`xhy<br />
divpbilhpi`de wenr xayna z`vnp dtexi` ik mirpkeyn eid dpey`xd mlerd zngln<br />
zine`l zealzyd oia dxxad ipta mipe` zxqg davip" dtexi` fkxn ly zicedid<br />
4."zelleazd<br />
oial<br />
eayg okle micwz zxqge dziran mikxc zyxt `ed deeddy epin`d mdn miax<br />
izla `id ,miihilet migpena daiygn zegtl e` ,zihilet zeaxernn zerpnidy<br />
ixitn` oeirx did `l xayn ly ipnxbd byend" ,dbelq qpd it lr .mxear zixyt`<br />
byen ."mlerd zqitz z` aviry ixeixtÎ` oezp ,oeekn © § l`ici` `l` yeyi`l dkgnd<br />
xaynd<br />
5."zihiletd<br />
mzeaxern z` oke ziteqelitd mzaygn z` jixcd" xaynd<br />
ly mixeaigdn miax ik zrcl `xewd lr .hqwha oievny itk mihrn mixwn zlef ,zilbp`d<br />
:milyexi ,xbpif cec mbxz ,dixehqidde zirahd zekfd ,qe`xhy e`il e`x .zixarl enbxez qe`xhy<br />
ced` xeqtext .`"qyz ,milyexi ,miazk xgan :dpez`e milyexi ,(jxer) fel ced` ;d"qyz ,mly<br />
.qe`xhy e`il ly ezebde eiig lelkn lr miaeyge mihxetn ze`ean elld mixtqd ipyl micwd fel<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, The City of Man, Chicago: University of Chicago, 1964, p. 1.<br />
Malachi Hacohen, "From Empire to Cosmopolitanism: The Central European Jewish<br />
Intelligentsia, 1867-1968", Simon Dubnow Institute Yearbook 5 (2006), p. 117.<br />
Hans Sluga, Heidegger's Crisis, Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1993, p. 61.<br />
3<br />
4<br />
5<br />
4
lr erityd xy` ,hiny lxwe xbciid oihxn ,z`f dpigane ,mzebd z` zexcwa st`<br />
5<br />
6.mibixg<br />
eid `l ,ekxc zligza qe`xhy<br />
ipnxbÎicedid iteqelitd oweicd z` miax mipaena lnqn qe`xhy ik xnel ozip<br />
meiwd ly iziirad ite`dn mlrzdl did leki `l icedi didy xg`n :df xayn ly<br />
hxta dipnxba dwenrd xaynd zyegz ipnxb didy xg`ne .ipxcend ipnxbÎicedid<br />
dipnxba xaynd zrcez .el dxf dziid `l `id s` ,llka dtexi` ly divfiliaivae<br />
icedid meiwd xayn zrcez mr cgi qe`xhy ly ezebda ,ok m` ,dkexk dziid<br />
ineiwd xaynd icnn ipy oia cxtd ilal zalyn ezebdy `et` dnz oi` .dipnxba<br />
:cxty oi'bei ixacke .cg`k ipnxbde icedid ,dfd<br />
zewelgna dax zeadlzda wqre x`niie zwilaetx ztewza icedi dbedk gnv qe`xhy<br />
xaynd zrcezy dlbn zil`ehwlhpi`d ezeiyi` zegztzd .exec ipa z` ewzixy<br />
rcn ,diteqelit ,zepn` ,dixehqid ,zc - oilneb zewif ilra miax minegzl dagxzd<br />
,mdl micbepnd el` s`e ,epnf za zipnxbd diteqelita miliaend minxfd .dwihilete<br />
meiwd ly iziirad eite`a wa`p `edy jez wlg mda lhp `ede ,eilr erityd<br />
ite` ilra md ef dtewza enqxtzdy qe`xhy ly eixeaig .ipxcend ipnxbÎicedid<br />
mfilxaild ly miixyt` izlad eicrie miaivi `ld eizeceqi cbpk oeeknd wdaen iqenlet<br />
7<br />
.zixehqidd dncwae dpeaza dlkydd zrepz ly dzpen` cbpk ipy cvne<br />
xayn xy`n zegt `l `ed x`niie zwilaetx ly mfilxaild xayn ,qe`xhy itl<br />
mfilxaild ik zibxh zeninza dpin`d zipbxead zitexi`d zecdid .zipxcend zelbd<br />
zpzip dpi` zicedid dl`yd ,dyrnl j` .zicedid dl`yl oexzt seq seq rivd<br />
.mlerl mled oexzt dl e`vni `l zepeivde mfil`iveqd mb ,mfilxaild wx `l .oexztl<br />
“Comments on Carl Schmitt’s Der Begriff des e`x qe`xhy lr hciny lxw zrtyd lr<br />
Politischen”, George Schwab (ed.), The Concept of the Political by Carl Schmitt,<br />
New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1976; Heinrich Meier, Carl Schmitt<br />
and <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>: The Hidden Dialogue, Chicago: University of Chicago Press,<br />
1995.<br />
Eugene R. Sheppard, <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong> and the Politics of Exile, Waltham, Massachusetts:<br />
zncwend ezebd lr rityd xy` ,bieevpfex upxt mb . Brandeis University Press, 2006, p. 17<br />
zncwend ezebda gznde yygd" ,cxty it lr .dzegt dcina j` df xayn deeg ,qe`xhy ly<br />
bieevpfex<br />
.(29 'nr) "dle`bd xg` yetiga bieevpfex x`izy mileztpn dax dcina erap qe`xhy ly<br />
,cqiiy zecdid ircnl dincw`d , Akademie für die Wissenschaft des JudentumsÎd<br />
z` d`x<br />
jlny mfivixehqidd lre x`niie ztewza icedid cqnnd ly zlleaznd zepp`yd lr xbiz z`xewk<br />
.zilxail dlgnk mfivixehqidd z` ote` eze`a swz qe`xhy ,jynda d`xpy itk .onf eze`a<br />
6<br />
7
`ide ,dzxagl zxg` dveaw lk zygexy zepierdn dpey dpi` micedid itlk zepierd<br />
lk icedid on zlley ef dcaer .iyep`d meiwd<br />
ly eqiqaa ,hiny orhy itk ,zavip<br />
x`yidl `ly ixyt` df oi`" :qe`xhy ly eizelinae ,icedi x`yidl `ly zexyt`<br />
diitivd .zicedid diral oexzt lk oi` ... e`ven lxebn gexal leki epi` yi` .icedi<br />
ik oreh cxty<br />
8."oexzt<br />
`vnidl aiig dira lkly dgpda dxewn ,df oirn oexztl<br />
xarn mipnxb micedi" dpkn miidy` oaihqy drtezl ipiite` dxwn `ed qe`xhy<br />
zerepz ik oin`d `l qe`xhy ,zexg` milina<br />
9."(<br />
Bildung)<br />
dlkydle mfilxaill<br />
diral mled oexzt rivdl zeleki zepeivde mfil`iveqd ,mfilxaild znbec zeixehqid<br />
.llekd iyep`d meiwd avnn wlg `id ef diray xg`n zicedid<br />
ixack ,"zelrl lgd ihqiytd leand" xy`k ,1932 zpya dipnxb z` afr qe`xhy<br />
mlerd zngln xg`l eiazk .a"dx`l ribd 1938 zpyae<br />
eweqirl xiyi jynd md<br />
10,oinipa<br />
xhle exec oa<br />
11,(1953)<br />
"dixehqidde zirahd zekfd" cgeinae ,diipyd<br />
xtq lr cirn dlil wxn .eiyxeyae zeixhilhehd xayna xwirae ,zeipxcend xayna<br />
zeclez ly xg` xe`iz lk mixikn mpi`y mihpcehql bivn" `ed ik df drtyd ax<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, "Why We Remain Jews: Can Jewish Faith and History Still Speak to<br />
Us?", Kenneth Hart Green (ed.), <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, Jewish Philosophy and the Crisis of<br />
Modernity: Essays and Lectures in Modern Jewish Thought, Albany: State University<br />
Steven Smith, Reading <strong>Leo</strong> ;122 'nr ,my , of New York Press, 1997, pp. 109-132<br />
eweqiry oreh 'zinq . <strong>Strauss</strong>, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006, pp. 23-24<br />
zirahd zekfd ,xzeia `xwpd extqay oeeik zwtqn dkxrdl dkf `l zicedid dieeda qe`xhy ly<br />
.zicedi ziteqelit zebdl hrnk qgiizn `ed oi` ,dixehqidde<br />
Steven Aschheim, "German Jews Beyond Bildung and Liberalism", ibid, Culture<br />
and Catastrophe: German and Jewish Confrontations with National Socialism and<br />
xy`a cxty lv` oeicd lr . Other Crises, New York: New York University Press, 1996<br />
'nr ,(7 dxrd lirl) cxty e`x ipnxbd icedid ly "icbpd lcend" z` oiit`n qe`xhy eay ote`l<br />
x`niie ztewza eyibcd "icbpd lcend"n micedi mil`ehwlhpi`y miidy` zprh z` mb e`x .84<br />
dpank zn`d ly zecea`d dizeiernyn zayda" zecwnzd jez miyxeyd ly l`ebd mgek z`<br />
“The Jewish Revival in the Weimar :"sygidl dkgnd ,ewlga ixhef`e i`nw ,ieag<br />
.jynda d`xpy itk ,dl` mi`yepa wqr qe`xhy .39 'nr ,miidy` jeza , Republic”<br />
myxb ,"miazkna zecici ly dxetiq ± wgxne daxw" ,iwvlcy dhi` lv` hhevn oinipa xhle<br />
,2008 ,bpilqx :aia` lz ,1940-1933 ,miazkn ztilg :mely myxb ,oinipa xhle ,(jxer) mely<br />
.305 'nr<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, Natural Right and History, Chicago: University of Chicago Press,<br />
.(2 dxrd lirl) df xtq ly ixar mebxz miiw .<br />
1953<br />
8<br />
9<br />
10<br />
11<br />
6
dpez` ly adfd xezn zil`ehwlhpi`d epzkirc xg` awerd it` xetiq diteqelitd<br />
12<br />
ezafk` z` "zevixrd lr" extqa x`zn envr qe`xhy ."ipxcend lfxad xezl cre<br />
ziilr z` zefgl dpicnd rcn iyp`e mil`ehwlhpi`d ly mpeiqip oelyikn dlecbd<br />
xarn dbxgy zevixr - epini za zevixrd len l` mipt l` mipt epavip xy`k<br />
dpicnd rcn gilvd `l - xzeia mixykend xard ibed ly xzeia mirextd mdizepeincl<br />
zevixrd gezipn eafk`zdy ,epxec ipan miaxy riztn df oi` jkitl .dzedfl eply<br />
eyxit ,dncp jk ,mday mitcd z` ycgn elib xy`k dlwd eyg ,eze` egce epini za<br />
13<br />
.20Îd d`nd zereef z` mixg` miiqlw mibede oehlt` epxear<br />
7<br />
:einia zevixrd<br />
sexih" `l` eppi`y ,mfivixehqida zyxyen zeixhilhehd ,qe`xhy ly ecicl<br />
lbd jixcixt mldlie bxe`b ly einin ,mfivixehqidd zqitz ly dceqia<br />
14."llek<br />
- cere diteqelit ,zepn` ,rcn - ziyep` zelirt<br />
lk ik dtwydd zavip ,jli`e<br />
edf .dixehqidd zervn`a wxe j` dpadl zpzip dzedny o`kne ,dixehqida zipzen<br />
."diteqelitd ly dixehqid `id diteqelit" lk ik lbd ly znqxetnd dxninl qiqad<br />
oiaexe d'vexw ehcpa ,dwpiin jixcixty itk mfivixehqidd byen z` oiad qe`xhy<br />
mitwyn e` miiqgi cinz md mikxre zepeirxy dtwydd :edepiad ceebpilew 'bxe'b<br />
eitly ixehqid mfiaihlx gipn mfivixehqidd ,xg` oeyl .miwenr miixehqid minxf<br />
15.odl<br />
ziqgie zeixehqid zeaiqpa zipzen zixqen zn`<br />
ly mipwixn`d eiciqg" lr dizertydy "zipkz" dixehqidde zirahd zekfd z` dpkn mb dlil<br />
Mark Lilla, “The Closing of the <strong>Strauss</strong>ian e`x .zlrez zxqgl dze` ektd "qe`xhy<br />
Mind”, New York Review of Books, November 2004, p. 56.<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, On Tyranny, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2000, p. 23.<br />
xexiaa rtyen diteqelitl zc oia xizt izlade cinznd wa`nl qe`xhy ly mqxetnd exe`iz<br />
“Jerusalem and exn`n z` dnbecl e`x .ezelbne ely zeihiletd zecxgdn ,eiig irexi`n<br />
lk" ik azek `ed eae , Commentary 43, June 1967, p. 45Îa<br />
mqxety ,1967 zpyn Athens”<br />
,dtiwr e` dxiyi dxeva zeqqean deedd ly zepkqde lealad jeza oda mifg`p ep`y zeewzd<br />
lkk ,xzeia zewenrde zevetpd z` ,dl`d zeieegd lkn .xard zeieeg lr ,dlilyl e` aeigl<br />
lr mb e`x ."dpez`e milyexi :mixr izy ly onya zepkl ozip ,iaxrnd mc`l rbep xacdy<br />
.my ,(13 dxrd lirl) zevixrd<br />
lxw ly mfivixehqidd zelc cbp qenlet eaexa `ed dixehqidde zirahd zekfd qe`xhy ly extq<br />
mipyd oia Economica zrd azka miwlg dyelya dligz rited xtet ly df extq .xtet<br />
dxeva mfivixehqidd z` oiad qe`xhy .1957 zpya ,xtqk mqxtzd okn xg`l wxe 1945-1944<br />
wx swyn xqendy xg`n dily` `id zixqen zn` eit lry ixehqid mfiaihlxk epiidc ,zlaewnd<br />
12<br />
13<br />
14<br />
15
zekfd ziibeq z` ycgn qe`xhy dlrd "dixehqidde zirahd zekfd" extqa<br />
`edy ,irahd oekpd epiidc ,aehd e` wcvd oexwr ly eneiw zexyt` z` ,zirahd<br />
epyi ze`ivna ik oreh `ed df xtqa .iyep` xcqd e` mkqd lk lr dlrpe ielz izla<br />
xevi `ed mc`dy zeid .dwihiletae dwiz`a rxl aeh oia dpgad xyt`nd aivi ceqi<br />
mled ,wiecna qe`xhy hxit `l eze`y ,irahd oekpdy ixd erahn ipicne izxag<br />
`l rnyn ,zeixqend zecinde zelrnd z` lnqn irahd oekpd .dfd rahd z`<br />
jxcend ixqen xevi mc`d ly ezeid `l` dxv ziyi` zlrez e` ikep` mfil`ecieeicpi`<br />
ixqendy xg`n 16."zixqend<br />
dlrnd `id miaehd miigd zxhn" .aehd e` wcvd ici lr<br />
zrcl ,yi jkitl .zilqxaipe` `id zirahd zekfdy ixd zr lka aeh envrlyk `ed<br />
lra `ed aehd" .el mitetk mc`d ipa lke elnq `ed wcvdy ,oeilr aeh ,qe`xhy<br />
lwyn yi xzeia aehd xhynl"e ,"envr mc`d ly efn xzei ddeab zinvr zeaiyg<br />
,zirahd zekfd z` ,irahd oekpd z` `han wcvd oexwr ."zclenl xy`n xzei dlrp<br />
,oreh qe`xhy okl .mc`d ipa z` mledd xzeia aehd xhynd z` xicbn xy` `ede<br />
dxagd zxhn" ik ,zeiexigae ytega dpcd ,zipxcend zipicnd diteqelitl cebipa<br />
`idy meyn zirnyn ec `id dxhnk zexigd .zixqend dlrnd `l` zexigd dpi`<br />
orhy ,mfivixehqidl dxiyid ezaebz dziid ef<br />
17."deey<br />
dcina aehle ryxl zexig<br />
.mieqn ixehqid xywda mipzen e` miiqgi md ziyep` daiyg lke oexwir lk ik<br />
oiite` lya ,dricid `"da dxagd ,daehd dxagd zl`y z` dgec mfivixehqidd"<br />
18."ziyep`d<br />
daygnd lye dxagd ly eceqia ixehqidd<br />
dpyi ziqlwd zirahd zekfd zxezl ik zexyt`d z` qe`xhy dlrd z`f jxca<br />
zipxcend daygnl cebipa ezrcl zavip ziqlwd zirahd zekfd .epxear zeaiyg<br />
dpey byen mfivixehqida d`x eznerl xtet .eqiqaa zeavipd zepzynd zeixehqidd zeaiqpd z`<br />
oke qe`xhy ly efl dz`eeyde xtet ly mfivixehqidd zqitz lr .zixehqid zeigxkd ± oihelgl<br />
lre ipicnd iteqelitd oepwd ly zip`ixtetd dipadd lr erityd zecdie zelb eay ote`d lr<br />
David Weinstein and Avihu Zakai, “Exile and e`x zil`ehqwh zepyxtl ezyib<br />
Interpretation: Popper’s Re-invention of the History of European Political Thought”,<br />
mb xe` d`x df xn`n . Journal of Political Ideologies 11 (June 2006). pp. 185-209<br />
dixehqidd ly ycgnÎdz`vnde xtet lxw :zepyxte zelb" ,i`kf edia`e oiihypiie cec e`x .zixara<br />
.27-14 'nr ,(2008 sxeg) 101 mipnf ,"zitexi`d zipicnd daygnd ly<br />
.112 'nr ,(2 dxrd lirl) dpez`e milyexi ,fel jeza ,"zipicn diteqelit idn" ,qe`xhy<br />
.109-108 'nr ,my<br />
.102 'nr ,my<br />
16<br />
17<br />
18<br />
8
zelble zeixehqidd zeaiqpl xarn bexgl dpeazd zleki z` zlnqn `idy xg`n<br />
ipeviw yehyhl ,ezrcl ,dkilen miiqlwd mibeddn zenlrzdd jkitl .zixqen zn`<br />
dxigad zlef qiqa lk oi` epizelert ly zepexwrly dgipn `idy meyn ,zn`d ly<br />
9<br />
.eply zxeeird<br />
rayd d`na lgd zipxcend zipicnd daygnd ixyan cbpk qe`xhy `vei extqa<br />
cigid z` ecinrd xy` ,epini ly mfilxaild cre wel oe'be qaed qnezn ,jli`e dxyr<br />
,wcvd z`ci` e` zirahd zekfd ,irahd oekpd zxeza cciv ,z`f znerl ,`ed .fkxna<br />
,miipiad inia mixvep mibede mipwi`ehq ,ehqix` ,oehlt` ,qhxweq icia dgzet xy`<br />
zipxcend zirahd zekfdn iepiy zilkz dpey `id ik orhe ,qpieew` qnez cgeinae<br />
diteqelitl zcbepn zirahd zekfd ly zipxcend dyibd .dxyr rayd d`na dgnvy<br />
dxagdy izxag xevi mc`a d`exd ,zilhehqix`d dqitzl e` ,ziqlwd zipicnd<br />
ixevik eply zeirahd zeaegd z` miybdl ozip dae erah z` znlede exear zirah<br />
zqitzl e` zirahd zekfl cebipa .ziyep`d epzedn yenin `l` dppi` ozilkzy ,yep`<br />
"miipey`xd mitgcd" lr ely zipicnd diteqelitd z` qaed qqia ziqlwd wcvd<br />
zeend cgt ly dni`d" ,ezhiyl ."invr xeniyl oevxd lr" ,mc`d ly "miikep`d"e<br />
mb oiad ,qaedk edenk ,wele .wcvd `le ,"zigxf`d dxagd yxr cvl zcnerd `id<br />
daex `weec e`l `ed invrd exeniy myl dpey`xae y`xa mc`l uegpy dn" ik `ed<br />
zipicnd dirad oexzt" `l` wcv `l rnyn ,"yekx - xzei illk geqipa e` ,oefn `l`<br />
19."miilklk<br />
mirvn`a<br />
eprahl ezedna jiiy - 'zirahd zekfd' - qe`xhy ly ezebda aeygd byend<br />
zilkz .eply mil`ci`d z` hetyl lkep exe`ly dcin dpw ynyne yep` ixevik<br />
,mfivixehqidl cebipa .ziyep`d epzedn znybd `id eply zeirahd zeaegd e` zeiekfd<br />
zn` zepexwr yiy qe`xhy orh ,mfilidipl xac ly eteqa `iane mfiaihlx gipnd<br />
daeygd zn`dy o`kne ,mc`k mc`d ly elky byida md elld ike miilqxaipe` wcve<br />
yiy `id ziqlwd zirahd zekfd zgpd .elky byida zeidl `id mb dleki xzeia<br />
lkyd .zixehqid dpigan ielze dpzen lekd `le ,zeilqxaipe` zeipnf lr zezn` ¦<br />
irah oekp edfy o`kne ,ea xikdl mileki lekde ,irahd oekpa oigadl leki iyep`d<br />
ozip mgekn wxe dixehqidl xarn mdy wcv e` zn` `han irahd oekpd .ilqxaipe`<br />
miaivny zeira xeztl lkep `l irahd oekpd zrici `ll .dixehqidd z` oiadl dyrnl<br />
.119-118 'nr ,(15 dxrd lirl) (zilbp`) i`kfe oiihypiie<br />
19
zepexwrd zrici `ll ,xg` oeyl .dxaga miniiwd miybpznde micbepnd mikxvd<br />
epizetcrdl setk lekd didi epizerxkd ly micnerde mireawd ,mihlgend<br />
.mfilidipl zirahd zekfd ziigc dliaed jk .zexeeirde zeiwlgd ,zeizexixyd<br />
.el mitetk eipiirne mc`d ikxev lky oeilr izxag aeha dxikd ziqlwd diteqelitd<br />
zeqqeand zeixqene zeaeh zecin lrak oitelgle zeirah zeaeg lrak qtzp mc`d<br />
ezedn z` miybn `ed oci lr zrawp ezebdpzdy zeide ,zirah daeg lr e` zekf lr<br />
zpbern dppi`y zirah zekf ly ycg byen gnv wele qaed mr j` .iyep` xevik<br />
`et` dnz oi` .envr mc`a wx `l` - rah e` l` - idylk zihpcpvqpxh zeyia<br />
daegde daehd dcind ly onewn z` ytegde zexigd ibyen eqtz jli`e o`kny<br />
eteqae ,mfivixehqidde mfiaihlxd eclep jk .axrnd ly zipicnd diteqelita zirahd<br />
.mfilidipd - xac ly<br />
lr zqqean dziid xaray ,ziaxrnd divfilieeivdy jkl `iad mfivixehqidd<br />
gxe`a wicvdl dlki `l aeye dnvra oen`de oeghiad z` ca`l dlgd ,mfilpeivx<br />
jixve ozip ik ayg ,z`f znerl ,qe`xhy .mdilr zqqean `idy zeceqid z` ipeibd<br />
diteqelitd ly miipepw mihqwha zeilqxaipe`de zeipnf lrd zezn`d ¦ z` `evnl<br />
ezrcl mi`han ,mfivixehqida milbecd mihqwhl cebipa ,dl` mihqwh .zipicnd<br />
zekfd .da zeielz opi`y o`kne dixehqidl xarn ze`vnpd zecnere zereaw zezn`<br />
mfiaihlxd z` qe`xhy lly z`f jxca .elld zezn`d on zg` `id ziqlwd zirahd<br />
lk qiqaa zgpen iqlwd irahd oekpd zyihpy oin`d `ed .mfivixehqida oenhd<br />
ly mfilidipde ixqend mfiaihlxde li`ed ,d`eyd mllkae ,miihiletd epizepeq`<br />
lr ,lkep .mfiytl o`kne zeplaeqd i` ly zeplaeql jxcd z` milleq mfivixehqidd<br />
zirahd zekfd ly ycgn driaz zervn`a zeierh oze` lr xefgln rpnidl ,ok<br />
zeipnf lrd zezn`d ly ycgn cenil zervn`a dzelble aeyl ozipy ,ziqlwd<br />
qe`xhy ly ezecbpzd .zipicnd diteqelitd ly miipepw mihqwha zeilqxaipe`de<br />
ezecbpzde ezelb ,exec zewevn ly xvez dax dcina `et` dziid mfivixehqidl<br />
zbieqn izla zepekpae zeadlzda zeptl" epilr<br />
:ely epeyla e` .mfixhilhehl<br />
xaynd ,epztewz ly xaynd" lya "wizrd iqlwd mlerd ly zipicnd zebdd cenill<br />
20."axrnd<br />
ly<br />
ipqxd did zilhehqix`d zirahd zekfd lr ipxcend xezieed ,qe`xhy ly ezrcl<br />
.1 'nr ,(3 dxrd lirl) mc`de xird ,qe`xhy<br />
20<br />
10
zelgn" iptn oqgl dieyr ef dxez ik zexyt`a dverp jkl daiqd .dtexi` xear<br />
.wele qaed ly zepzlrezde zizxagd dpn`d zxez oebk ,zeipxcen zeil`ehwlhpi`<br />
z` eizeaevxgn exxgy ef jxcae mfivixehqide zixqen zeiqgi egtih el` mibed<br />
sexihd ik oin`d qe`xhy ,cere z`f ."xlhid ly elv" zgz e`iyl ribdy ,mfilidipd<br />
mlerd zngln idlya cer a"dx` lr mb mii`l lgd mfivixehqidd ly iteqelitd<br />
[dipnxb] dne` day dpey`xd mrtd ef didz `l" ,azk ,"xrvd daxnl" .diipyd<br />
abypd ixtd z` diyaekn dlly zipicn zeyik lekiak dlqege axwd dcya dgvepy<br />
,qe`xhy itl<br />
11<br />
21."dzaygn<br />
iqetc ler z` mdilr dztky jka oegvipd ly xzeia<br />
22 xara m` .oihelgl ihqiaihlxl jetdl dqipe eay reawd ceqid z` yhp mfilxaild<br />
zn`d zqitz lr eal lka mgle "eizepeeka" xzei daxd "geha" mfilxaild did<br />
oeghia xqge oqqd jtd ,ekxc z` lilk cai` dpexg`ly ixd ,ely zicegiid zixqend<br />
,daivi izlae zipqxd dibele`ci` ,xzeia okeqnd beqdn dibele`ci`l oeepzde invr<br />
mipencwd oia aixd" ,azeke qe`xhy siqen ,ok` .zeplaeqd ly dnya z`f lke<br />
."'zeil`eciaicpi`'d cnrna ,eziy`xn s` ile`e ,xac ly eteqa epiipr ,miipxcenl<br />
dxab ,zipxcend zirahd zekfd zpixhwec zginv mr ,dxyr rayd d`ndn lgd<br />
23<br />
xezieea mfilxaild ligzd jk ."daehd dcinl db`cd" lr "zeil`eciaicpi`l db`cd"<br />
,mc`d ornl rahd lr xzie ,wel oe'b ly zeirahd zeiekfd zaehl irahd oekpd lr<br />
zepeibiyd oqx z` xxgy ef jxcae ,zelil`l zeplaeqd ly divwecx dyr seqaly cr<br />
mlerd zngln xg`l jtdy ,oilxa diryi ly ezebd<br />
24.xzeia<br />
miipendd miihiletd<br />
mfilxaild ,zeipxcend zekfa mixacnd xzeia miwdaend zelewd cg`l diipyd<br />
zilxaild daygnd zepeepzd zenlbzd qe`xhy xear dziid ,mikxrd<br />
ly mfilxeltde<br />
.mixyrd d`na<br />
ozilkzy ,eply zeirahd zeaegd e` zeiekfd z` mfilxaild xind eay rbxdn<br />
.2 'nr ,(11 dxrd lirl) (zilbp`) dixehqidde zirahd zekfd ,qe`xhy<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “Relativism”, Thomas L. Pangle (ed.), The Rebirth of Classical Political<br />
Philosophy, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1989, p. 17.<br />
.232 ,94 'nr ,(2 dxrd lirl) dixehqidde zirahd zekfd ,qe`xhy<br />
miilxaild eiyxey ztiyg ici lr mfiytd zeceqi zkxtda jk lk oiiprzd `l qe`xhy ,aewxh zrcl<br />
Nathan Tarcov, “Philosophy e`x ."jxted xak `edy dcaerl ihxe`z oexzt z`ivn"a `l`<br />
and History: John Gunnell and <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong> on Tradition and Interpretation”, John<br />
S. Nelson (ed.), Tradition, Interpretation and Science, Albany: State University of<br />
New York Press, 1986, p. 75.<br />
21<br />
22<br />
23<br />
24
xye`d ly izn`d ¦ ekxrn zigtd `ed lekiak "mc` zeiekf"a ,ziyep`d epzedn znybd<br />
mcwena zeiekfa miligzn ep` m` .biiq lk `ll encwl s`ey `edy mipt zcnrd jezn<br />
daxnle ghal un`p mihqivixehqidl jetdpy rbxdne .mfivixehqida miiqp xge`na e`<br />
qe`xhy rivdy zeipxcend xaynl xaqdd mle`<br />
25.ixqend<br />
mfiaihlxd z` dpkqd<br />
zyib oial dfd xaqdd oiay qgia weqrl epzpeeka .o`k ixwird eppiiprn eppi`<br />
xaynd cvik ze`xdl mivex ep` .dlebk elxebe qe`xhy ly zil`ehqwhd zepyxtd<br />
,zelbl z`vl qe`xhy z` sgce mfiytd xaynl jtd xy` ,zeipxcend ly llekd<br />
.zepeirxd ly dixehqida zepyxt ly xayn dcina da exear did<br />
zekfd z` dgec `edy jka dverp mfivixehqidd zelc ,qe`xhy zrcl ,xen`k<br />
ly mkxrn cixen" `ed ."zia ixqg" mikted ep` mfivixehqidl zeced .zirahd<br />
26<br />
jted mfivixehqidd ."miixehqid zepexwr mdipt lr sicrne miilqxaipe` zepexwr<br />
dixehqidd ly mirexi`d mxfa miiqgil ,llka zepeirx dyrnle ,miixqen zepexwr<br />
mipzipd miixehqid minxfa zipzend zipyn drtezk xqenl qgiizn `ed .zilqxaipe`d<br />
zetwzl oerhl dleki dpi` zipicn diteqelit meyy d`xn" `ed ef jxca .ieaipl<br />
27<br />
mfivixehqidd ,ok lr xzi ."dxeyw `id dil`y zixehqidd ze`ivnl xarn zipeibd<br />
`ed [zipicn diteqelit ly] zencew zexez xefgy"y qeqia lk `lle dbbya gipn<br />
mc`d" :azek qe`xhy ehqix` lr ely dqnd seqa .49 'nr ,(3 dxrd lirl) mc`de xird ,qe`xhy<br />
`edy jk ici lr `l ,izn` ¦ xye` xg` scex `edy jk ici lr wx [mc`d ly] xirl lrn dlrzn<br />
`vei qe`xhy my ,33 'nr mb e`x ."zxg` e` ef jxca [zeghaen zeiekf ly] xye`d xg` scex<br />
`ly xg`n ik zipxcend zra egipd jk" :qlex gqepa mfilxaild mr xywl milibx ep`y dn cbp<br />
dppi` daiqd j` .dpicnd ly dzxhn zeidl leki epi` dneciwy ixd daehd dcind z` zetkl ozip<br />
daehd dcinl dyic` zeidl dpicnd lr .zabype dlrp `idy `weec `l` daeyg `l daehd dcindy<br />
lr dpbd zlef ciwtz lk oi` mdly ,dpicnd iweg lr dxarn ¥ ,oaenk ,oihelgl dpeya ,rexle<br />
zipencw zirah zekf oia qgid ly zepaez xizr xe`izl ."gxf` lk ly yekxde zexigd ,miigd<br />
Daniel Tanguay, <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>: An Intellectual e`x qe`xhy lv` zipxcen zekf oial<br />
Biography, New Haven: Yale University Press, 2007, chapter 3.<br />
.16 'nr ,(11 dxrd lirl) (zilbp`) dixehqidde zirahd zekfd ,qe`xhy<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “Political Philosophy and History”, ibid, What is Political Philosophy,<br />
epi` mfivixehqidd ,ef dprh itl . Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988, p. 63<br />
ly cg` beq" silgn heyt `ed .zihqivixehqid `l zipicn diteqelit xy`n "zegt ihnbec"<br />
'nr ,my) "ozedna 'zeixehqid' od zeiyep`d zeaeyzd lky `ln oeghia jezn xg` beqa zehlgen<br />
gezipd z` dbivn ,ixard iteqelitd oeraxd :oeira 1946 zpya xewna dnqxety ,ef dqn .(72-71<br />
.eizepexqgle mfivixehqidl qe`xhy ly xzeia wiecnde cgd<br />
25<br />
26<br />
27<br />
12
28<br />
dxrnd lynl minec zeipxcend xayn jeza miigde ef mler ztwyd ."ixyt` izla<br />
oveni`e zenecw zerc ici lr dneqg zn`d l` mc`d ipa ly mzyib eay ,oehlt` ly<br />
miig ep` eay ihqivixehqidd ocira ,qe`xhy itl j` .zeieby zeipxcen zegpd ly<br />
mze` dlikdy dxrndn xzei daxd dwenr ,ztqep dxrna epnvr z` mi`ven ep`"<br />
qthl zpn lr dpey`xae y`xa dixehqidl miwewf ep` .qhxweq ly lfn ipa mixea<br />
mipeeidy micwn alyl miwewf ep` ;xe`l epze` liaedl leki qhxweq dpnny dxrnl<br />
29<br />
dxrn `ed ilwicxd mfivixehqidd ,xnelk ."d`ixw jxc cenill ,llk el ewwfp `l<br />
ote`a mipekpd mixtqd z`ixw wxe ,mc`d xtgzd day ,xzei cer dwenr ,diipy<br />
13<br />
.qhxweq l` dxfga epkxc z` zeyrle dpnn hlnidl epl riiql dleki oekpd<br />
,qe`xhy zrcl ,zkted ,znled jxca ziyrp `id ok` m` ,zil`ehwlhpi` dixehqid<br />
xayna ievn axrnd .mfilidipde mfivixehqidd ,zeipxcend cbp wa`na rixkn wypl<br />
znzken dziid `ly ,"ziqlwd dwizrd dtewzd ly zipicnd daygn"l daiy raezd<br />
ick ziqlwd zirahd zekfd zxez z` wfgle aeyl epilr .zihqivixehqid daiyga<br />
n"dixa ly dizeawra dkildn e` ipnxbd mfiv`pd ly oeq`d lr dxfgn rpnidl<br />
axrnd xayn ik orh qe`xhy ,dipexi`d daxnl .zitelg zeixhilheh ly medzl<br />
ote`a" ziqlwd zipicnd daygnd zpad ly zexyt`l `weec xac ly eteqa liaen<br />
zipicnd diteqelitd ly zezeernd zeycrd zervn`a `le "oprxe izxeqn `l<br />
zipicnd diteqelitd ly dyecig z` aiign eply xayndy cala ef `l .zipxcend<br />
epze` aiign xaynd ."dly digpena" dpiadle zeqpl epilr dtek s` `ed ,ziqlwd<br />
mnvr mdy itk miiqlwd miipicnd miteqelitd ly zexezd z` ycgn epnvrl reazl<br />
.oze` epiaiy epeekzd<br />
aeyl hedl did ,ely "deedd" oewizae zxewiaa ce`n oiiprzdy ,envr qe`xhy<br />
e` xtdl zeewl mileki epzydy miyp` wxy iptn ,dpey mc`k "eztewz iteg" l`<br />
zaygnn cenll mileki ep` .zeipxcend ly xzeia mirexbd dreefd iyrn z` oznl<br />
.60 'nr ,my<br />
zrcly oreh ieebph l`ipc .12 'nr ,(11 dxrd lirl) (zilbp`) dixehqidde zirahd zekfd ,qe`xhy<br />
miipxcen miteqelit exviy ztqep dxrn `l` oehlt` ly dxrnd epi` mfivixehqid ,qe`xhy<br />
zpyn qe`xhy ly ezxewia z` e`x ok enk . 45-44 'nr ,(25 dxrd lirl) i`eebph e`x .dizgzn<br />
“Review of Julius Ebbinghaus, On the Progress of Metaphysics”, Michael"<br />
:1931<br />
Zank, <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>: the Early Writings 1921-1932, Albany: State University of New<br />
.215 'nr ,my ,<br />
York Press, 2002, pp. 108-127<br />
28<br />
29
cenil ."eppnf ipa mibedn cenll mileki eppi`y dpeilr zeaiyg" ilra mixac xard<br />
ok m` jted ,"ziaihwiiae`" dxeva xnelk ,mnvr z` epiad mdy itk xard ibed<br />
efy oeeikn zil`ehwlhpi` zepeepzd ly ocira miigd miyp` xear zigxkd" dniynl<br />
"ceqi zeira ly znled dpad ycgn zelbl mileki md day<br />
dcigid<br />
ziyrnd jxcd<br />
.epzle`bl `l m` ,epzecxyidl oey`xd crvd `ed efky dpad ielib .(eply ybcd)<br />
recn xiaqdl - ztqep dniyn dixehqidl yi dl` oirn zeaiqpa :jiynn qe`xhye<br />
`ed oekp m` .dncwk ef dca` dbved recne ceqid zeira ly die`xd dpadd dca`<br />
ciwtzy ixd mfivixehqida e` diteqelitd ly divfixehqida e`iyl ribd df oca`y<br />
lral dricid `"da 'dixehqidd' ly ipxcend byend z` jetdl `ed dixehqidd<br />
30.ezexveeid<br />
ote` zpad jxc zernyn<br />
zeavipd zeirady oeeik icegii eppi` eil` eprlwpy yiad avn ,qe`xhy zrcl<br />
yecig yxec `l opexzt<br />
okle ,dixehqida zecnere zereaw zeira dyrnl od epipta<br />
mfivixehqida wa`idl zpn lr .ziqlwd zipicnd daiygd l` daiy `weec `l`<br />
jxc z`e ezeixwy z` dpey`xae y`xa xiaqdl yi eil` zeelpd zeihiletd zepkqae<br />
qgiizdle aeyl yxec xaqdde .ezxaqda ,ok m` ,jexk mfivixehqidd qxd .ezexveeid<br />
ernyn ,xiaqdle ,xiaqdl eyexit ,mglidl .ziqlwd zipicnd diteqelitl zepivxa<br />
.die`xd dxeva yxtl<br />
l` exaci mdizexezy dziid ehqix` lye oehlt` ly mzpeeky ayg qe`xhy<br />
zn`d ixaeck `le dricid `"da zn`d ixne`k mnvr z` e`x md .mi`ad zexecd<br />
xakn df slgy ocira dxvep znieqn zipicn diteqelity dcaerd .cala mztewz ly<br />
zipicn diteqelit .zizn` ¦ zeidl lekd zexnl dieyr `idy zexyt`d z` zlley dpi`<br />
ici lr dpey`xl dgzety zixwnd dcaerd lya wx zpyein e` dieby zkted `l<br />
`le ,"ehqix`e oehlt` itn" cenll mipken zeidl epilr okl<br />
31.ehqix`<br />
e` oehlt`<br />
,y`x caeka da oiirl yi [mdlyk] zipivx dxez oiadl zpn lr" ."mdilr" wx<br />
zexyt`d z` oeayga `iadl mipken zeidl epilr xnelk ,zepivxa dil` qgiizdl<br />
mileki ep` zn`k mdizexezl zipivx zeqgiizd ici lr wx<br />
32."zn`<br />
heyt `idy<br />
.epzle`ba ligzdl<br />
.585 'nr ,my<br />
.64 'nr ,(27 dxrd lirl) zihilet diteqelit ,qe`xhy<br />
.68 'nr ,my<br />
30<br />
31<br />
32<br />
14
dpigan zipzen miiqlw miipicn mibed ly "zipicnd<br />
15<br />
dxezdy"<br />
dcep m` elit`<br />
zipzen mdly "zipicnd diteqelitdy"<br />
jkn wiqdl ote` meya xeq` ixd ,zixehqid<br />
dpi` idylk zipicn diteqelit ly "zipicn dxez" .(eply miybc) zixehqid dpigan<br />
zeaexw mizrl ebivd miipicn miteqelit ,ok`e ."zipicn diteqelit" gxkda zpiivn<br />
zeixehqidd zeaiqpl dze` eni`zd s`e mdly zipicnd diteqelitd z` "mdizexez"a<br />
.mz`xeda dze` mixizqn mdy jez<br />
dn zbvdl mnvr z` eliabd `l md" ;zixezqn dxeva eazk mdy oiadl yi j`<br />
dbyd xak ,ievxk e`xy dn z` mb ealiy mzxez zbvda .zipicn zn` ea e`xy<br />
ebivd `l md ;zelaewnd zercd jnq lr dpadl ozipk e` zeniiwd zeaiqpd zxbqna<br />
zcreind daizk zervn`a mb `l` `cxb ¥ xedh 'iteqelit' ote`a mdizetwyd z`<br />
dzxard dyexit ,"xeaivl zcreind" dxeva zipicn diteqelit zbvd<br />
33."'xeaiv'l<br />
miipxcen mi`xew ,xrvd daxnl .(cala o"g irceil dxenyd) zixhef` ,zfnexn dxeva<br />
zn`d oial "xeaivl zcreind" oeyll zn`d ly zpeekn dn`zd oia elala miighy<br />
zn` zniiw `l odit lry zeihqivixehqidd<br />
zeily`d z` eadly df ote`ae dnvr<br />
,dxvwa .zixehqid dpigan zepzend zezn` wx `l` dielz izlae zwdaen<br />
.mihqwh ly dcecxe zighy d`ixw ixt `ed mfivixehqidd<br />
"zirah dpad"<br />
zhiy cbp yxetna d`viy zil`ehqwh zepyxt ly zicegii dlekq` cqii qe`xhy<br />
,eikiynne qe`xhyc `ail`<br />
34.ixehqidd<br />
mxywd xe`l mihqwh zpgead zepyxtd<br />
zeiernyn s` `l` zeilqxaipe`e zereaw zeiernyn wx `l yi miipepwd mihqwhl<br />
zeiernynd zxkdl xzeia daehd jxcd .ixehqidd xywdl xarn zebxegd ,zeieag<br />
zhiy `id ,qe`xhy it lr ,zixhef` d`ixw ."zxzqpd mzxez" zxiwg `id elld<br />
`l" ,zexg` milina .zil`ehqwhpew `l rnyn ,zihqivixehqid `l "zirah dpad"<br />
wx epnvr z` le`bl mileki ep` ."miipxcen milka zeipxcend lr xabzdl ozip<br />
.63 'nr ,my<br />
J. G. A. Pocock, Politics, Language and Time: Essays on Political Thought and<br />
History, New York: Atheneum, 1960; Quentin Skinner, “Meaning and Understanding<br />
in the History of Ideas”, History and Theory 1969, pp. 3-53.<br />
33<br />
34
35<br />
"mnvr z` epiad mdy itk weica xard ibed z`" zyxtnd "zirah dpad" zervn`a<br />
36<br />
dxwna - epiidc ,mze` epiaiy evxy itk mpiadl epl zxyt`n `id .(eply ybc)<br />
.dixehqidl xarn ze`vnpd zecnere zereaw zezn` ixaeck - ehqix`e oehlt` ly<br />
zirhend zepyxtd igitq z` miiqlwd miiteqelitd mihqwhdn zwlqn zirah dpad<br />
z` oiadl zepeirxd oeixehqid ly ezxhn" .zeipxcende mfivixehqidd mdilr etky<br />
,ixyt`d xzeia<br />
wiecnd<br />
epl zxyt`n zirah dpad<br />
ote`a dpiadl xnelk ,'zn`a dziidy itk' xard zaygn<br />
37.(eply<br />
ybc) "dyrnl dkld dibed dze` epiady itk<br />
dgkyp oday dpy miitl`l aexw xg`l ,ycgn jixrdl s`e ,ie`xk oiadle aeyl<br />
ibed cenil" .zn`a epzyd `l mlern zeiceqi zeiteqelit zeira ik dpadd epz`n<br />
idefy oeeikn zil`ehwlhpi` zepeepzd ly ocira miigd miyp` xear igxkd xard<br />
...ceqid zeira ly znlede zycegn dpadl ribdl dcigid ziyrnd jxcd<br />
daiygd ly irahd agxnd oca` z`e dgkyd z` ycwn ,z`f znerl ,mfivixehqidd<br />
`ed jk<br />
38."ceqid<br />
zeira ly ozeriaw z`e ozcnzd z` lley `edy jka ziyep`d<br />
milbecd mibedk ,mze` epiaiy epeekzd ok`y itk xard ibed z` oiadl epz`n rpen<br />
`edy xg`n zn`d zrici z` epz`n rpen `ed .zeilqxaipe`e zeipnf lr zezin`a<br />
.dil` ribdl mikxcd z` dyrnl yayne dze` zrcl epzlekia mbet<br />
itk weica ehqix`ke oehlt`k miiqlwd mibedd z` `exwl qe`xhy ly ezeywrzd<br />
,dyexit ,mixyrd d`nd zepeq` lr aeyln rpnidl zpn lr ,mnvr z` epiad mdy<br />
zehlnid drnyn ,"ziaihwiiae`" d`ixw ."ziaihwiiae`" dxeva mz`ixw ,ezhiyl<br />
lr miqqeand - miipxcend dxagd ircn ly zzeernde miicid ztxn dipenbddn<br />
,ezigyd xy` - mikxrl zecaer oia cixtnd mfiaihifet lre ihqiaihlx mfivixehqid<br />
.miiteqelit mihqwh ly mzepyxt df llkae ,il`ehwlhpi` lrtn lk ,xrvd daxnl<br />
zetvl ozip" :dxf zeaxz ly "ziaihwiiae`" dpadk weica `id "ziaihwiiae`" d`ixw<br />
mdy itk weica minrd e` zeieaxzd oeebn z` oiadl miqpn m` wx zeiaihwiiae`l<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “Correspondence Concerning Modernity”, Independent Journal of<br />
Philosophy 1983, p. 107.<br />
dxrd lirl) lbpt jeza , <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “How to Begin to Study Medieval Philosophy”<br />
.209 'nr ,(22<br />
.24 'nr ,(13 dxrd lirl) zevixrd lr ,qe`xhy<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “On Collingwood's Philosophy of History”, Review of Metaphysics<br />
1952, pp. 583-584.<br />
35<br />
36<br />
37<br />
38<br />
16
epiad `l eplyn mipey minilw`n e` mipcirn miyp` j` .mnvr z` epiad e` mipian<br />
miqgiin ep`y zernyna zeaxz byendy meyn zeieaxz oeebn ly migpena mnvr z`<br />
zecbpzda ,ok m` ,dkexk "ziaihwiiae`" d`ixw<br />
17<br />
39."llk<br />
mze` wiqrd `l meik el<br />
ly mipt zcnrd jezn zepey zeaiqpa elrty mibed l` epztewz ikxr zwzrdl<br />
d`ixw ,xac ly exeviw .mdiazka "zihnbec `l zegizt"ae zcgeyn izla d`ixw<br />
,hetiy zxqge "zipxizn zeipeieey" ly miipira d`ixw dppi` "ziaihwiiae`"<br />
40.zeilxaild<br />
"zegeztd zexag"l jk lk zipiite`d<br />
dpadd" `yepl qgiizn qe`xhy ,oetepqwa wqerd ,"zevixrd lr" exwgna<br />
lkk wiecna oetepqw zaygn z` oiadl iziqip [zirahd dpadd] df oexwirl m`zda<br />
jxcd ef oi`y xg`n ely 'zeixehqidd zeaiqp'l ezaygn z` xeywl iziqip `l .ozipd<br />
`l mlern oetepqw ,jk lr sqepa ;mkg zerc dbed ly ezcear z` `exwl zirahd<br />
epl wiprd xyken xagn ezeida ik `id izgpd .efky jxca eze` epiaiy epevxy oiiv<br />
xyt`d lkk izqqazd okl .ezcear zpadl yxcpd rcind z` ezleki ahink oetepqw<br />
lw ,ipevig rcin lr ozipd lkk hrne ,oitiwra e` oixyina ,xn` envr `edy dn lr<br />
z` oiadl `id zepeirxd oeixehqid ly dxhnd ...zeipxcen zexryd lr `l xnege<br />
eay ote`l xyt`d lkk dnecd ote`a xnelk ,'zn`a dziidy itk' xard zaygn<br />
zihqivixehqid dgpd qiqa lr xard zaygnl ybip hqivixehqidd j` .dixagn depiad<br />
cer dnvr z` dpiadyn xzei aeh dpiadle zeqpl aiig `ed ok lr .oihelgl dl dxf<br />
jxca ,ezbvd didz jke .dnvr z` dpiad `idy itk ,epiid - wiecna dze` oiad mxha<br />
41<br />
.zxewiae zepyxt ly zwtwetn zaexrz ,zxg` e` ef<br />
:"zirahd<br />
dxeva eze` epiaiy dvex didy yxetna mlern oiiv `l oetepqwy dcaerd j`<br />
,dleki dppi` ,llka eze` epiaiy dvex did cvik mlern oiiv `l dyrnle ,zixehqid<br />
,epztwydl ,dtwz ef dprh .ixehqid ote`a epiadle zeqpl `ly uexizk ynyl ,oaenk<br />
envr z` d`xe zil`ehqwhpew zepyxt dgc qe`xhyy dcaerd .envr qe`xhyl s`<br />
,ely icegiid ihiletde ixehqidd xywdd `ynn xxgeyne cizrd zexec xear azek<br />
,z`fn dxzi .il`ehqwhpew ote`a eze` `exwln rpnidl mikixv ep`y dyexit oi`<br />
.46 'nr ,(2 dxrd lirl) dpez`e milyexi ,qe`xhy<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “An Epilogue”, An Introduction to Political Philosophy, ed. Hilail<br />
Gildin, Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1989, pp. 145-153.<br />
.25 'nr ,(13 dxrd lirl) zevixrd lr ,qe`xhy<br />
39<br />
40<br />
41
envr `edy dn" qiqa lr oetepqw z` `exwl dqpn `ed ik oreh qe`xhyy rbxa<br />
.eyxtl dpekpd jxcd idn dl`yl cin yxcp `ed cala "xn`<br />
dktdy jka xxgynd dgekn dcai` zixehqidd dpadd" ,qe`xhy zrcl<br />
z` zpiivnd zinvr zxewia ly dpp`ye zpae`n dxev<br />
zeipnf lrd zezn`d z` `evnl epilr ik xeaq qe`xhy<br />
`l` epi`y<br />
,mfivixehqidl<br />
42."zeipxcend<br />
gex<br />
mil`ehwlhpi`d eli`e .zipicnd diteqelitd ly miipepw mihqwha zeilqxaipe`de<br />
zeccenzd lk lr ,"mipp`ye mipae`n" mzeida ,dyrnl exzie ,oreh `ed jk ,miipxcend<br />
.zeplaeqd i` ly zeplaeql jxcd z` milleqd ,mfilidipde ixqend mfiaihlxd mr<br />
zaehl mfivixehqidd z` sqd lr zegcl miipxcen mil`ehwlhpi` mze` lr dney<br />
zelewl mdipfe` z` meh`l"e miiqlwd eincewe dfepity ixaca<br />
zn`d<br />
xg` yetig<br />
43."mfivixehqidd<br />
ly minxevde mip`eqd<br />
d`ixw ,qe`xhy zrcl ,miyxec ,miixyt` md m` ,dz`ivne zn`d xg` yetigd<br />
44<br />
z` jtd ipxcend mfivixehqidd mle` .xenb "weic"a mixg`e dfepity ,oehlt` ly<br />
xywdl ziqgi `id mihqwh ly mzernyn ,ecicl ixdy ,seifl zwiecnd d`ixwd<br />
.mi`ad zexecle epl miyibp zeidl mileki md oi`y o`kne ,eazkp eay ixehqidd<br />
,lynl .ely zenecwd zercd zeycrn ulgidle deeddn xxgzydl epilr ,dyrnl<br />
azeky ink epiadl epilr eze` oiapy dvex didy itk dfepity z` oiadl miqpn ep`yk<br />
ecrepy ,xge`nd dfepity znbec miyp` ly mdixtq" ;mi`ad zexecd liaya zn`<br />
mi`xew ep`yk okl 45."mi`ad<br />
zexecl cgeina micrein ,mipnfd lk ly mpiipw zeidl<br />
micnel ep` ,`ly oia dnirp `idy oia , zn`d<br />
z` aezkl dqpny ink dfepity z`<br />
mihqwhde zn`d dit lry zpkeqnde dktktdd zihqivixehqidd dily`dn xxgzydl<br />
46.zixehqid<br />
dpigan miiqgi cinz md dze` mi`hand<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “How to Study Spinoza’s Theologico-Political Treatise”, ibid,<br />
Persecution and the Art of Writing, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988,<br />
p. 158.<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “Liberal Education and Responsibility”, Liberalism Ancient and<br />
Modern, Chicago: University of Chicago Press 1968, p. 25.<br />
.29 'nr ,(42 dxrd lirl) daizkd zepn`e dticx ,qe`xhy<br />
.160 'nr ,(42 dxrd lirl) dfepity ,qe`xhy<br />
seqal dleki mixg`e dfepity ly zihqivixehqid d`ixw `weec ik xeaq qe`xhy ,dipexi`d daxnl<br />
dxkda ezceara ligznd ,oeixehqidd :mzhiy z` gepfl mihqivixehqidd z` ul`l lekd zexnle<br />
ly iehia e` ilebqd dpnf igpena dxez lk ly dpad `id ziyep`d daygnd ly zizn` dpady<br />
42<br />
43<br />
44<br />
45<br />
46<br />
18
"zwiecn" zepyxt ipta leyknk `et` zcner zihqivixehqidd<br />
19<br />
mlerd ztwyd<br />
zy`ep dtexz" zpigaa `id zihqivixehqid ihp` d`ixw .zn`d l` dyibd z` znqege<br />
47<br />
zixyt` wx `l `id ziteqelitd zn`d l` dyib zxyt`nd zepyxt ."y`iin avnl<br />
miiqlwd miazkd z` aeye aey zexidfa cenll epilr .epzecxyidl zigxkd s` `l`<br />
48.mda<br />
mipenhd "mixzqpd zexve`d" xg` ytgle<br />
zwiecn d`ixw<br />
xwira mdy ,mihqivixehqidd ly cbpd zprhy jkl rcen did qe`xhy<br />
ly eteqa `id "zwiecn" zepyxty didz ,epnf ipa mil`ehwlhpi`d mipeixehqidd<br />
49.miiaihwiiae`<br />
mipeixhixw zlleyn `ide li`ed "izexixy yegip" xy`n xzei `l xac<br />
zepyxta epze` jixcdl dxe`kl milekid mipeixhixw drayn zegt `l dpn `ed jkitl<br />
d`ixwy oexwird z` x`yd oia millek elld mipeixhixwd .zizexixy `le zwiecn<br />
dziidy itkn<br />
zwiecn zegt<br />
didz mday mixwnd lka ixnbl dxeq` zexeyd oia"<br />
e` dwqt wegnl oi`" eitly oexwird e` (eply ybc) "zexeyd oia dziid `lnl`<br />
,`idy itk dpiadl zexiaqd zeixyt`d lk oeayga e`aed mxha dgeqip z` zepyl<br />
`evnl ozip jkl sqepa ."zipexi` dxeva daezk dwqtdy `id elld zeiexyt`dn zg`e<br />
ddf dppi` xagn ly zizn`d ezrc"y raewd oexwird z` mb elld mipeixhixwd oia<br />
eitly oexwird - seqale ."ze`wqt ly xzeia axd xtqna rian `edy efl gxkda<br />
z` sicrdl yi dxizq dfepity znbec lebc seqelit ly ezebda `vnizy mrt lka<br />
50."zipendd<br />
dtwydd z` zxzeqd dprhd"<br />
.mihqwh ly daeyg dinepehe` dgipn e` zyxec "zwiecn d`ixw" qe`xhy xear<br />
mitetke mixg` e` dl`k miixehqid miwnrn inxfa mipzen eidi mihqwhy okzii `l<br />
dxkdl ik dlbn `ed ef jxcae ,exwgn `yep eilr dteky dtwydd z` gxkda cnel ,znieqn dtewz<br />
cer lk xard zaygn z`<br />
oiadl ozip `ly dlbn `ed ,ok lr xzi .qiqa lk oi` ely zipey`xd<br />
dietv d`vez ,ok lr ,`ed mfivixehqidd ly invrd qxdd .ef zipey`x dxkd ici lr migpen ep`<br />
.oihelgl<br />
.154 'nr ,(42 dxrd lirl) dfepity ,qe`xhy<br />
.37 'nr ,(42 dxrd lirl) daizkd zepn`e dticx ,qe`xhy<br />
.32 ,27 'nr ,my<br />
lr cer e`x .147 ,143 'nr cgeinae 177 'nr ,(42 dxrd lirl) dfepity mb e`x .30 'nr ,my<br />
.27 'nr ,(13 dxrd lirl) zevixrd<br />
47<br />
48<br />
49<br />
50
mitwyn e` zizn` dixehqid dliaq dxeva mi`han wx `l mihqwh .oihelgl mdl<br />
miaiig md .mnvr zekfa micnere miielz izla ,mii`nvr gxkda zeidl mdilr ;dze`<br />
dcina qe`xhy didy itk ,mfiyta iteqelit wa`nl aiegny in xear dl`k zeidl<br />
itk ,eplyk zey`ep zetewzn df llkae ,mztewzn<br />
bexgl mihqwhd lr .zxg` e` ef<br />
xacl mdilr epze` livdl mileki md m` .epeekzd ,dfepity cre oehlt`n ,mdixagny<br />
,qe`xhy zrcl ,aiig mfivixehqiddy ixd epil` xacl mdilr m`e . zexiyi<br />
epil`<br />
51.ieby<br />
zeidl<br />
ipy cvn j` dax zxewia cg` cvn dxxer qe`xhy ly zepyxtd zxez ,dtevnk<br />
,iqtexw sfe'b enk ,"miip`iqe`xhy"d eikiynn :mihrn `l dpbd iazkl dzkf mb<br />
zepyxtd zxez zpadl zepey mikxc mibivn ,aewxh ozpe clitqpn ieexd ,mela ol`<br />
d`ixw' iepikl dkf minily dna ynzyd" qe`xhyy raew lynl iqtexw :mxen ly<br />
'dhiy' ,mixacd rahn oky 'dhiy' lk yixed e` gzit `l `ed j` ,eze` cnile 'dxidf<br />
meyii zervn`a dxexa zkted zwte`nd daizkd dziid el ,rnyn .zixyt` dppi`<br />
dziid miiteqelit mihqwh ly zepyxte ,`l eze otev dziidy ixd zepyxt illk ly<br />
xy`n xzei `l `id zwiecn d`ixw ,df oexwir itl<br />
52."miptv<br />
geprt ly dxev wx<br />
53.cinzne<br />
f`n exn` zten ixtqy dnl "daywd xwira" zllekd dxidfe daeyw d`ixw<br />
.ixehqidd xywdl zeyibx xqg did `l llk qe`xhy ditly zicegii dprh bivn aewxh<br />
ly dpady dced dyrnl j` xedh hqil`ehqwh did `l mpn` `ed ;oekpd `ed jtdd<br />
,mztewz ipa miiteqelitd mihqwhd ly xywda mzavd z` zyxec miiteqelit mihqwh<br />
cebipa ,qe`xhy" ,z`f mr cgi .ipepw cnrnl eribd `l mlerny dl` mllkae<br />
zeidl aiige [hqwh zpadl] ipeig ipevig rciny jk lr cnr ,mihqil`ehqwhpewl<br />
oexztd z` wtql el xeq` mlerl" j` ."xagnd wtqny zxbqnl dwecd dxeva setk<br />
Charles Larmore, “The Secrets of Philosophy”, e`x qe`xhy ly df xe`iza zknezd zecrl<br />
zekfd' ,qe`xhy zrcl" :lynl azek xenxl . The New Republic, July 3, 1989, pp. 32<br />
bexgl dpeazd zleki z` d`hiay xg`n zipxcend daygnl xenb cebipa davip 'ziqlwd zirahd<br />
."zixqen zn` zelble zeixehqid zeaiqpl xarn<br />
Joseph Cropsey, “<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>”, International Encyclopedia for the Social Sciences,<br />
Appendix vol. (1979), p. 750.<br />
dxrd lirl) ilxail jepig ,qe`xhy jeza , <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “What Is Liberal Education?”<br />
.7 'nr ,(43<br />
51<br />
52<br />
53<br />
20
mcwzdl zxg` zexyt` lk oi`y wtq lkl lrn gkedy xg`l wx `l` ,xagnd zxezl<br />
21<br />
54."'dze`<br />
bivdy itk ezxez zpada<br />
zepn`e dticx" oebk qe`xhy ly mixken xzeid eiazk lr xwira jnzqn aewxh<br />
"ceebpilew ly dixehqidd ziiteqelit lr" xken zegtd exn`na `weec j` ."daizkd<br />
(1943-1889) ceebpilew .aewxh zprhl xzeia zrpkynd zecrd z` qe`xhy wtiq<br />
ly xwga xywdd zeaiyg z` yibcd xy` drtyd ax ihixa oeixehqide seqelit did<br />
zcewpn .ely ditxbeixehqidd z` dpbn qe`xhyy dnz oi` okle ,dixehqida<br />
zepeirx<br />
qgiizn epi` `edy jkn zraep ceebpilew ly zixwird zerhd ,qe`xhy ly ehan<br />
mikxre zepeirxy oin`d xy` ,ceebpilew ,zexg` milina .zepivxa xard zaygnl<br />
zexyt`d z` ezrca dlrd `l ,miwenr miixehqid minxf mitwyn e` ,miiqgi cinz md<br />
ick .zizn` zeidl dleki ,lynl oehlt` ly aehd zixe`z enk ,xard zaygny<br />
."zixehqid zeiaihwiiae`" ,qe`xhy zrcl ,zyxcp efky zexyt` oeayga `iadl<br />
miwa`n oiadl miipicn mipeixehqid mikixv eay ote`l dneca mihqwh oiadl epilr<br />
dl` mze` epiady zenk mipezp micrie oezp avn zpada" mikexkk rnyn ,miihilet<br />
mipan ziipal "a`yn"k miipepw mihqwha "ynzydl" xeq` ."zeaiqpd oze`a elrty<br />
ick miiqlw mihqwh "xqiil"n rpnidl yi ,qe`xhy zrcl ,cere z`f<br />
55.miihxe`z<br />
dxwal e` idylk dprha ynzydl ozip" mxha cer .zeipxcen zel`yl zeaeyz lawl<br />
epiaiy rcena oeekzd dxagny itk dpiadl yi xnelk ,dze` oiadl lek mcew jixv<br />
zepivxa xard zaygn z` oiadl dqpn oyxtdy dcaerd" :lekn aeyg j` 56."dze`<br />
aeyi ik zetvl oi` .epnn xzqp eteqy rqnl `vei `ed .deedd z` afer `edy dcirn<br />
Nathan Tarcov, “Philosophy and History: Tradition and Interpretation in the Work<br />
aewxh ,epzprhl cebipae z`fn dxzi . of <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>”, Polit 16 (Autumn 1983), p. 13<br />
mnyiil oi` z`f zexnl j` ,zixhef` d`ixwl ce`n miwiecn millk rivd qe`xhyy jk lr cner<br />
dhiyd lr lpeb oe'b ly zxewial daebz eaexa `ed aewxh ly exn`n .(18 'nr ,my) ipkn ote`a<br />
“The Myth of the Tradition”, American Political ScienceÎa<br />
qe`xhy ly zipyxtd<br />
MachiavellianÎd<br />
lr aewxh ly ezxewia z` mb e`x . Review 72 (March, 1978). pp. 122-134<br />
Political Science Quarterly 91 (Summer 1976). pp. 380-382Îa<br />
wewet ly Moment<br />
“Quentin Skinner’s Method and Machiavelli’s Prince”, Ethics 92 exn`n z` ok enke<br />
(July 1982). pp. 692-709.<br />
.579 'nr ,(38 dxrd lirl) ceebpilew ,qe`xhy<br />
.581-580 'nr ,my<br />
54<br />
55<br />
56
zxewiak aygidl hlgda dieyr ezxewia ,ok` .mafr xy` mc` eze`k eztewz iteg l`<br />
57."xard<br />
zaygn ly hand zcewpn deedd zaygn<br />
zixhef`d ezepyxt lr epbde ekxc z` ekiynd ,aewxh `ivedl ,qe`xhy ly eicinlz<br />
"ipyxtd xn`nd" .miipepw mihqwh ly zwelgn zexxern zeiepyxt mixvei mdy jez<br />
.iqetih `ed oehlt` ly "dpicnd" xtql jxry dxecdna mela ol` ly iaihweaextd<br />
xtqd z` mi`xew xy`k ,ilelin hrnk ote`a qe`xhy z` jiynnd ,mela it lr<br />
mfil`ci` ly xzeia dtixgd zxewial" dyrnl jted `ed ,zexeyd oia ,zeyibxa<br />
,extq z` xaig oehlt` ,ef dprh it lr<br />
58."mrt<br />
i` dazkpy [ixhilheh] ihilet<br />
oky lk `l ,llka zixyt` zwcevd xirdy rbxl ele oin`iy ilan ,ipexi` ote`a<br />
dipad dyrnl `ed mela ly ihqipenewÎihp`d oehlt`d ik oerhl ozip<br />
59.dievx<br />
ibele`ci`Îihiletd xywdd z` jilyd heyt melae ,dxwd dnglnd ocir ly zilpeivx<br />
itk , epztewz<br />
ly xaynd oexztl eze` mezxl mewna .oehlt` ly eizepeek lr ely<br />
xaynl zexiyi eiazka lekiak qgiizny ink oehlt` z` `xew mela ,qe`xhy dyry<br />
mi`xg`d z` izeaxzd mfiaihlxae mfivixehqida d`ex ,qe`xhyk edenk ,mela<br />
dpigan "ce`n dvegp" dktd zipicnd diteqelita miifkxn mihqwh z`ixwy<br />
jkl<br />
la` ,zxeqnd ilecbl zeptl miaiig ep`" ik oreh `ed qe`xhyl dneca<br />
.df<br />
60.zihilet<br />
izla zenlern zeycg mi`iand mi`iap eid lyn ,epl mixf eid eli`k ,dycg gexa<br />
.583 'nr ,my<br />
Allan Bloom, “Interpretative Essay”, The Republic, New York: Basic Books, 1968,<br />
z`f xnel m`" :127 'nr ,(3 dxrd lirl) mc`de xirda z`f gqpn envr qe`xhyy itk . p. 410<br />
ihilet mfil`ci` ly xzeia wenrde agxd gezipd z` drivn dpicnd ,meid xzei xexa ote`a<br />
."mrt i` dyrpy<br />
jkn wiqdl mileki ep`" :qe`xhy oreh o`k .53-52 'nr ,(3 dxrd lirl) mc`de xird mb e`x<br />
,dyer daizk lky itk ,ixwn ote`a `l ± mipey miyp`l mipey mixac xne` ipehlt`d bel`icdy<br />
dxeva ipexi` `edy xyt`e ,mipey miyp`l<br />
mipey mixac xnel oeekzd oehlt` .oeekn ote`a `l`<br />
;'dxin`' wx `id" oehlt` ly zwcevd xird ik oreh qe`xhy eay ,121 cenr ,my e`xe ."zilwicx<br />
wcev `ed erahny dnl e` envr wcvl zeqgiizd jez y`xn dppkezy jkl zeced wx 'zniiw' `id<br />
dkenp dbxc `id zwcevd xirdy" it lr s` ."ipyd cvd on ,iyep` jk lk ,iyep`e cg` cvn<br />
xywl wx zetvl ozip .dppkezy itk xveeidl zlbeqn dpi` ef xir elit` ,envr wcvd ly lilra<br />
."xeaica wx `le dyrna zeniiwd mixr oial dpia<br />
Allan Bloom, “The Study of Texts”, Melvin Richter (ed.), Political Theory and<br />
Political Education, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1980, p. 118.<br />
57<br />
58<br />
59<br />
60<br />
22
- lekn aeyge .epzxiwg ipta cenrl mvl`l `le ayw aex mdl oif`dl yi .mixken<br />
epilr<br />
23<br />
61."mdly<br />
zel`yd eid dn zelbl zeqple cva epizel`y z` xizedl epilr<br />
zlleyd ,dxv zihqivixehqid zegizta `le dpk zegizta miizten mihqwh cenll<br />
itk dl` mihqwh oiadl zeqpl epilr .zn` exaic xard on mihqwhy zexyt`d z`<br />
okziiy zexyt`d z` oeayga mi`ian ep`yk" ,mze` epiaiy epeekzd mdixagny<br />
han" xy`n xzei yxcp `l jk myl<br />
62."zn`d<br />
z` ebiyde mdiiee`n z` eniybdy<br />
yi ;"zilqxaipe` dpigan mitwz zepyxt illk" oi` ."zn`d zad`e dibele`ci`n sg<br />
bef" l`k ezebd l` qgiizdle "miptan" miipicnd miteqelitd ilecbn cg` lk oiadl<br />
ly "jiqpd" z` lynl `exwl epilr<br />
63."mlerd<br />
z` mi`ex ep` mkxcy miitwyn<br />
xac" zetigca epl xyal dqpn `ed eli`ke "eppnf oa icia azkp eli`k" ilee`iwn<br />
64.eple<br />
el "szeynd dn<br />
ly ezyib lr miqqeand ,mela ly eiperih z` dpexg`l jiynd 'zinq oaihq<br />
dzkf xy` ,"zihxcphqd" zepyxtl cebipa .oehlt` ly eizepeekl rbepa ,qe`xhy<br />
dgeztd dxagd" extqle xtetl zeced diipyd mlerd zngln xg`l dax drtydl<br />
zepyxt xvei qe`xhy ,mfilxaild ly ihqiytd eaie` oehlt` did ditle ,"diaie`e<br />
oehlt`"l cebipa ."ipehlt` mfilxail" 'zinq ita dpeknd zeiewca dxiyre zrpkyn<br />
zegt ,ihilepen zegt ,ycg oehlt`" bivn qe`xhy ,xtet mciwy "ihqiyt lnqk<br />
miax eprhy itk ,daehd dlebqd ly ixhilheh hily eze`n ihnbec zegte iheleqa`<br />
ly erah ik" epl xikfdy jk ici lr .ipeeid dbedd ly "eixagn micg` s`e eiaie`n<br />
ixyt` xewnk ziqlwd diteqelitle oehlt`l qe`xhy ay mly `le iwlg `ed rcid<br />
oehlt`<br />
z` dpkn 'zinq xy`k ,z`f mr<br />
65."ihiletd<br />
mfilxaild ly eaie`k `le<br />
.123 'nr ,my<br />
.127 'nr ,my<br />
.131 'nr ,my<br />
.128 'nr ,my<br />
ynyn oehlt` ly dpicnd xtq ,'zinq zrcl .89 'nr ,(8 dxrd lirl) qe`xhy z` `exwl ,zinq<br />
.(99 'nr) "zitehe` zizxag dqcpd ly zepeiqipa zepenhd zepkqa xeriy" qe`xhy xear wcva<br />
onqexw 'c 'x ly extq lr ,1941 zpya ,dnglnd inin qe`xhy ly ezxewia df oiiprl daeyg<br />
dxrd lirl) zihilet diteqelit ,qe`xhy lv` ycgn dnqxet xy` , Plato Today 1939 zpyn<br />
xpeivw`x"le "qnepn" hqiytl oehlt` z` jtdy lr onqexw z` xwia qe`xhy .264-263 'nr ,(27<br />
icia oehlt` ly exe`iz lr rityd onqexwy gipdl xiaq ."ilxail oexwir lkl zevxgpa cbpznd<br />
Malachai Hacohen, Karl Popper:<br />
e`x xtet lr onqexw zrtyd lr .mfiytd xyank xtet<br />
61<br />
62<br />
63<br />
64<br />
65
ely ilxaild ienicd z` eilr dtek `ed ,`ly oia z`f dyr qe`xhyy oia ,lxail<br />
dziid `l cgi mb miienicd ipyl mle`e .xtet eilr dtky ihqiytd ienicd mewna<br />
leki `l oehlt`y myk .dxitqd iptl ziriaxd d`nd ly dpez`a zernyn lk oaenk<br />
ynn ,'zinq ly oehlt`dy o`kn .hqiyt zeidl did leki `l jk lxail zeidl did<br />
66.zycegn<br />
dipad lr qqean ,mela ly df enk<br />
zexizql xy`a qe`xhy ly ezprh z` ielba xwia mznerl xn`c`b bxebÎqp`d<br />
:xagnd ly zexzqpde zeielbd eizepeekle hqwha<br />
didi oekp edylk xagn lv` zexzeq zeprh mi`ven ep` xy`ky llk xexa df oi`<br />
od zexizq [...] qe`xhy xeaqy itk ,zizn`d zernynk zxzqpd zernynl qgiizdl<br />
miwqer ep`y lkk irnyn ec oeixhixw od ,xrvd daxnl la` ,zn`l oievn oeixhixw<br />
[...] ?htyn lka oeekzn `ed dnl weica rceid xagn epyi mpne`d [...] dwihiepnxda<br />
e` irnyn cg yexit yi iteqelitd xagnle ,dpekpd `id qe`xhy rivny dtelgd m`<br />
The Formative Years 1902-1945, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000,<br />
zepyxtd zhiy lre hxta oehlt`l xtet ly eqgia zexizqe oeinc ieew dnk lr . n. 67, p. 400<br />
.(15 dxrd lirl) i`kfe oiihypiie e`x llka xtet ly<br />
lynl ( Klosko)<br />
ewqelw 'bxe'b .mela rivdy oehlt` ly dpicnd yexit lr dqg `l zxewiad<br />
mela ,mdipy ."lilra dxiaq izla" `id ,qe`xhy ly efl dneca ,mela ly ezepyxty oreh<br />
wx `l ,oihelgl zwcven izla `idy oehlt` ly "znieqn gezip zxev"a miryrzyn ,qe`xhye<br />
cg`k mdipy .zeil`ehqwhpew zipevig zei`x zpigan mb `l` zeil`ehqwh zegked zpigan<br />
miipyxt x`t ipan miccea mihtyn z`ixwn zepal xzidk oehlt` dlrny zewtqa miynzyn"<br />
eizevlndy ,xwira mela dyery itk ,epipta oiivl ick jka ic oi` ,xzei rexb j` ."miakxen<br />
oehlt`y gikedl" yi .xgy lk zexqg od lynl oiipwle zegtyn ly dlidwl qgia oehlt` ly<br />
xqegl rcen didy dgpdd z` eil`n oaenk lawl" mi`yx eppi` ."zeniyi izla ody oin`d envr<br />
,"dl` zevlndl zepivxa qgiizdl did leki" ok` oehlt`y okzii ,xac ly ezn`l ."odly xgyd<br />
ik `ed xexa" :dnec dcewp dlrn led liic .eil` qgia zlaewnd dprhd z` `weec wfgny dn<br />
ixqene izxag xcq [oehlt` ly zil`ci`d xird] KallipolisÎa<br />
mi`ex melae qe`xhyy xg`n<br />
`id mzyib .xn`y mixacl oeekzd oehlt`y okzii `ly migipn md mled izlae ipeinc<br />
dipexi`d z` zelbl lkep eit lry oeixhixw lk wtql dgilvn dpi`e zixehqid izlae zihqipexkp`<br />
xqega dverp melae qe`xhy ly diebyd mz`ixw ik cer oreh led .(eply ybc) "oehlt` ly<br />
ly `yen epi` aehd" :azek led .miyegd inyxl eqgi z`e oehlt` ly ze`ci`d zxez z` mzpad<br />
m`ez mlerd ik oian seqelitd ezervn`ay oexwir `ed ;ely wx `l xrvnl e` ,ihzq` xedxd<br />
md .dyigl ozipy dn oial dpadl ozipy dn oia cixtdl ehp melae qe`xhyy d`xp .dpeazd z`<br />
diihqk iygend oeiqipa ezeaxernl seqal miqgiizn jke iynnd mlerdn seqelitd zafk`a minifbn<br />
."erahn<br />
66<br />
24
zecewp lr cala zg` zihiepnxd dklyd jkl yiy yyeg ip` ,ltxern oitelgl<br />
67<br />
.letxr yiy zexyt`d z` oeayga `iadl epilr :zepyxtd ly zwelgnd<br />
dprha ,dzegt dcina envr qe`xhy z` ik m` ,mip`iqe`xhyd z` riwed xn`c`b<br />
.lilra zexiaq izlad mdizeiepyxtl zepin` zegked ewtiq zewegx mizrl wxy<br />
wleg `edy oreh xn`c`b ."enewna epi`y [letlt]<br />
25<br />
cenlz"<br />
md mdize`ixw ,ezrcl<br />
ote`a dleki miiqlw mihqwh ly dxidf d`ixw ditly qe`xhy ly ezqitz lr xwira<br />
ocir ly eztya xacl ozip `l" .zeixewnd mdizeiernyn z` ycgn cekll edylk<br />
68<br />
ly zncwend eziigca d`xpd lkk mxewn ,qe`xhyl xn`c`b oia milcadd ."xg`<br />
dixehqidd zhiy z` ,bxeaxnn mixg` mixirv miteqelit mb mitzey eid dly ,xn`c`b<br />
.diteqelitd ly dixehqidd cenila - problemgeschichtliche Methode - zeirad ly<br />
odk onxd ekiizyd dil`y ,bxeaxna zip`ihpwÎe`ipd dlekq`l dxeywd ,ef dhiy<br />
zeiray dgipd ,(1921) qe`xhy ly hxehwecd zcear jixcn ,xxiqw hqpx`e<br />
dhiy qgiiln xnyidl epilr m` mb .xecl xecn exar zecinzne zereaw zeiteqelit<br />
,rnyn .da dverp zil`ehqwh zepyxtl zxbead ezyib ik d`xp ,qe`xhyl ef<br />
mihqwh xy` ,zereaw zeiteqelit zeira ly ozcnzd xaca dqitzd z` laiw qe`xhy<br />
d`ixwd zhiy z` aivn `ed .raw jxc onr miccenzn miifkxn miiteqelit<br />
onxd<br />
ly "zitxbeixehqidd"e xzei zizxeqnd dhiyd len ely "zizxewiaÎzixehqid"d<br />
ea j` "y`x caeka dze` zlweye zepivxa" dfepity ly dlin lkl zqgiiznd ,odk<br />
zicedid dlidwdn eyexib llek ,dfepity iig ly zeiyi`d zeaiqpa zcwnzn onfa<br />
dfepityy dn lk lawl mikixv eppi` ik xeaq qe`xhy ,odkl cebipa .mcxhqn` ly<br />
mihqwhd l` eiig zeketdz z` wizrdl epl l`e zeaiyg ly dcin dze`a azek<br />
69.ely<br />
xzia zeip`iqe`xhyd hqwhd zepyxt zehiy z` swz `l yi`y dnec ,z`f mr<br />
eize`ixw z` dcinrn qe`xhy ly ezhiy ,wewet zrcl .wewet oe'bn mfwxqe uxn<br />
zwelgnd zexxern eizeiepyxtn zlley ,"zxewiad ly [...] dci byidl xarn"<br />
Hans-Georg Gadamer, Truth and Method, New York: Seabury Press, 1975, pp.<br />
,(15 dxrd lirl) i`kfe oiihypiie e`x ;xn`c`b ly ef dcnrl mikqdl did ieyr xtet . 488-489<br />
.194 'nr<br />
“Gadamer on <strong>Strauss</strong>: An Interview”, Interpretation 12 (1984), pp. 3, 8.<br />
.(29 dxrd lirl) wp`f cgeina e`x df oiipra<br />
67<br />
68<br />
69
d`vezk<br />
70.zeiepyxt<br />
ly "mqew"l eze` zkted ef jxcae "miigxkd zxewia ipgan"<br />
qqal zpn lr qe`xhy ly zgprtnd zepyxtd zleki lr jnzqdl mivl`p" ep` jkn<br />
d`ixwy mikqn ok` qe`xhy<br />
71.zexeyd<br />
oia "dieag zeiernyn zty ly dneiw z`<br />
mdy dcen s` `ede ,"zeczi azka miaezkd mihqwh geprt"n dpey dpi` zixhef`<br />
zeibhxhq` m`d ,zixehx l`ey `ed ,mle`e .zei`ce `l zeiepyxt wtql hlgda mileki<br />
oia a'few xcpqkl` exag jxry d`eeydl eqgiizda ?ze`ce zewtqn zeitelg d`ixw<br />
dziid el eic xye`n didy zeripva raew qe`xhy ,yla ly eizehiy oial ezhiy<br />
epin`d xaray xg`l ,`l eze miryt ly mneiwa<br />
ceygl<br />
mipyxtl znxeb ezhiy<br />
ul`z" zixhef` d`ixw .md xy`a mihqwh ly "znlyend mzeninz"a mal lka<br />
zrcl mixniizn md day zepp`yd z` yehpl xge`na e` mcwena mipeixehqidd z`<br />
eaygy itkn xzei daxd zizcig xard zaygny zecedl ,milecbd mibedd eayg dn<br />
zn`d on zegt `l dbydl dyw dpi` zixehqidd zn`d m` zedzl ligzdle<br />
`l dprh lr i`ceea miwleg eid `l mixg` mixwane wewet<br />
72."ziteqelitd<br />
.ef zipeviw<br />
,( Mansfield)<br />
clitqpn ieex`d znbec ,qe`xhy ly eicinlzl wewet ly eqgi j`<br />
zeaygn" qe`xhy ly extql wleg clitqpny migayd lr .xzei daxd lhane lflfn<br />
:azek `ed "ilee`iwn lr<br />
megzl axwzdl `ly mi`nhd z` xidfne edxenl aiaqn ycwn miwn [clitqpn] `ed<br />
aiaq milxhtnd ezenk ahid miyengd mixneyd geehle dkeza zrbtpd<br />
zedel`d<br />
miizy e` zg` - zeneg ray swend df qcxtl e` ycwnl uextl dyw .dize`ean<br />
geztle miycewd ycewl axwzdl frnd lkl gzta zeaxe` zepkqe ,ze`xp opi` odn<br />
,dwizye wgxn lr xenyl xga epwlgy jk lr `ltzdl oi` okl .odekd mr giy eca<br />
ahink ilee`iwn elewipa weqrle ,zetely zeaxga epcbp mi`vei mik`lny dry<br />
73<br />
.ezleki<br />
J. G. A. Pocock, “Prophet and Inquisitor Or, A Church Built Upon Bayonets Cannot<br />
Stand: A Comment on Mansfield’s ‘<strong>Strauss</strong>’s Machiavelli’ ”, Political Theory 3<br />
(1975), pp. 385-401.<br />
.388 'nr ,my<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>, “On a Forgotten Kind of Writing”, What is Political Philosophy and<br />
Other Studies, Glencoe, <strong>Il</strong>linois, Free Press, 1954, pp. 231-232.<br />
.385 'nr ,(69 dxrd lirl) xehifieewpi`e `iap ,wewet<br />
70<br />
71<br />
72<br />
73<br />
26
`l j` ,'mipeir'ae 'jiqp'a zeieag zeiernyn yiy oaen" :xne`e jiynn wewet<br />
e` zeixezqn zehiy ly ziawr dxarda ixhef` libxz od dl` zexiviy llk xexa<br />
`edy oeeikn ,ilee`iwn ly mipyxtd lecb `ed qe`xhy ike zxzqp zernyn ly<br />
edyn xn` `l ilee`iwny mrt lka [...] zernynd z` gprte zehiyd z` dlib ecal<br />
mlrzdy mrt lka - qe`xhy ly eizegpd e` ely eizegpd jnq lr xnel did ieyry<br />
zipxzg zeixqen ly dklyd xg` aewrl epeiqipa lykp e` zlaewn zixqen driawn<br />
ilee`iwn aqd znieqn dxin` ly dzhnyd ici lry oerihd mr oken qe`xhy did -<br />
`ede ."dl zcbepnd dxin`d ly e` ,ef dxin` ly diehia zexyt`l epal zneyz z`<br />
;zepeekn `l e` zepeekn ,zeklyd ly oielib lr dlecb zekf" yi qe`xhyl :mkqn<br />
dktdnl cre qpqpxdn diteqelitd ly zgprtn zepyxt lr cala znieqn zekf el yi<br />
oeayg lr zixhef` zernyn zqgiiny zepyxt lr zekf mey el oi` j` ;ziztxvd<br />
qe`xhy ly zeizxivid zlef edylk leabl dtetk dpi`y zernyn ,dielb zernyn<br />
zepyxtd zyib z` aivn `edy okzii ,cva wewet ly zeihqwxqd z` gipp m` ."envr<br />
clitqpn oebk ,eikiynn enciwy dly zepey ze`qxb mr zg` dtitka qe`xhy ly<br />
mixvei mip`iqe`xhyy azek `edyk melal xwira oeekzn wewet ,z`f mr .melae<br />
,"ze`ivnd ly mihaidle milnql rbepa zewzxn zepaez" xzeid lkl mdy "miqezin"<br />
micen md oi` xy`k .mvra miyer mdy dn df ik zegtd lkl zecedl mdilr j`<br />
."zevltn"l mikted "iynnd ly ditxbeixehqidd lr" mitek mdy miqezind jka<br />
oaex ;oeixehqid ly dcear" dppi` elld zevltnd on zg` s`y xne`e jiynn wewete<br />
mdy eayg xy` xg` e` df beqn miizxag miteqelit ly mzxivi zext¥ eid olekk<br />
74<br />
seqelit `ed mela ,wewet zrcl ik oigadl lw ."mdizexhnl dixehqid witqn mircei<br />
27<br />
.zepeirx ly oeixehqid xy`n xzei bele`ci`e izxag<br />
,ok m` ,zraep qe`xhy ly zil`ehqwhpewÎihp`d mihqwhd zepyxt zhiy<br />
J. G. A. Pocock, “Political Ideas as Historical Events: mb e`x .399 ,392 'nr ,my<br />
.145 ,142 'nr ,(60 dxrd lirl) xhkix jeza , Political Philosophers as Historical <strong>Ac</strong>tors”<br />
Reading ,dpexg`l `viy ,'zinq l`kin ly extq lr ixexc dicy ly zxewiad xn`n z` mb eeyd<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong> Politics, “Philosophy and Judaism”, Political Theory 35 (February<br />
'zinq j`" :zazek ixexc xy`k lynl ,mizrl ihqwxq zegt `l `ed df xn`n . 2007), p. 66<br />
dni`znd zixcre zwte`n ,ziceq zelirt oirnl qe`xhy ly diteqelitd zeeir oaxw `ed envr<br />
,zexizqa ,zltxern zipkz'a zpiit`zn zixhef` daizky epl xtqn envr qe`xhy .zkl<br />
md dl` lk j` .dnecke 'mixfen miiehiaa ,zencew zexin` ly zewiecn `l zexfga ,mipeceeqta<br />
74
ixehqidd xywda mipzenk mihqwhl qgiizd mfivixehqidd .mfivixehqidl<br />
ezecbpzdn<br />
.ziqetih zihqivixehqid d`iby `id df ixehqid xywd xe`l mz`ixwy o`kne ,mdly<br />
zepyxtd zlekq`y dcin dze`a egekne cigid ze`nvr jxrn zigtd mfivixehqidd<br />
mre .mihqwh ly mze`nvr jxrn dxe`kl dzigtd 'bcixaniiw ly zil`ehqwhd<br />
zeixqen zezn` ly ilkk iqlwd oepwd ly ekxr mb zget mihqwhd ze`nvra zegitd<br />
,ok lr ,dziid mfivixehqidl qe`xhy ly ezecbpzd .miig zelivne zeixehqidÎlr<br />
.mfixhilhehl ezecbpzde ezelb ,exec zewevn ly xvez dax dcina<br />
zipicnd diteqelitd lye ,diteqelitd ly dixehqidd aexy oiiv qn`iliee cxpxa<br />
mekiq<br />
.zihilp` dxeva zazkp `id xy`k xwira ,"diteqelit ly ryryn beq" `id ,cgeina<br />
jka oiit`zn mpeic diteqelitd ly dixehqida mipc miihilp` miteqelity zni` lk<br />
oihelgl zepey zeira lr mdly zecgeind zeiteqelitd zeirad z` mikilyn mdy<br />
ly epepbql" dneca ,"mii`kx` zeceqi" mibivn md aexl .mdincew z` ewiqrdy<br />
mdy diteqelitd zeclez ,z`f zexnl ."( Pulcinella)<br />
dlpi'vlet<br />
hlaa iwqpieexhq<br />
75."zexcan"<br />
ic od ,xn`p xaky dn lr xefgl m` e` ,zeinihibl od mixvei<br />
wenr mzeg dxized zipicnd daygnd ly dixehqida qe`xhy ly ezyxen ,recik<br />
lv` ynn ly oeraiwl dktd zeip`iqe`xhyd ;zixad zevx`a cgeina otec `veie<br />
76<br />
ly eizertyda mipc eppi` df xn`na ,z`f mr cgi .dpicnd ly mipwihxe`z dnk<br />
mb minlrzn ep` .epini ly a"dx`a ziaihaxqpewÎe`ipd uegd zeipicn lr qe`xhy<br />
ok lre zpkeqn zn`dy a"dx`a miaihaxqpewÎe`ipd z` cnil qe`xhy m` dl`ydn<br />
z` qe`xhyn ewpi mipwixn` miaihaxqpewÎe`ip mze` m` dl`yd s`e ,dxizqdl yi<br />
.eppiiprn dppi` ziynn zixqene zihilet zn` oiadl ickn miytih mipenddy dtwydd<br />
zipicnd diteqelitd ly zip`iqe`xhyd dixehqiddy xnel dywy s` ik oiivl yi<br />
,zexida zyxec daeh diteqelit .zeipepia lye leala ly ,drexb diteqelit ly xkidd ipniq mb<br />
."zepcgt `l ,une` ;zeiceq 'zezin`' zvtd `l ,mirpkyn miperih ;oeekn letxr `l<br />
Bernard Williams, “Political Philosophy and the Analytical Tradition”, Political<br />
Theory and Political Education 73. pp. 122-147.<br />
df aeyg zwelgn `yep oiivl epilr ik epl xikfdy lr bxapiihy ozpeil zecedl mivex ep`<br />
.meik dwixn`a mip`iqe`xhyde qe`xhy ly ditxbeixehqidae dixehqida<br />
75<br />
76<br />
28
zegt `l zinihibl mb m` ,"zryryn" `idy wtq oi` ,ihilp` ote`a dazkp<br />
29<br />
.dizeaixin<br />
iabl zeicegiid mdizeprh lya wx `l zwelgn mixxern<br />
mip`iqe`xhyde qe`xhy<br />
zrcl .zil`ehqwhd zepyxtl mzyib meyn mb `l` zipicnd daygnd ly dixehqidd<br />
,dpekpd dxeva da miwqer m` ,zipicnd daygnd ly dixehqidl ,eikiynne qe`xhy<br />
uetp dke ilpae meh` dk jtd ihiletd rexdy xg`n .zeaeyg zeihilet zeklyd yi<br />
aiign mb j` ce`n dyw zwiecn d`ixw zervn`a zn`d xg` yetigd jtd oywre<br />
ly mzeaiyge ,zeaiyg yi mda miraend zepeirxle mihqwhl .zixqen dpigan<br />
`evnl epicia riiql mileki mdy meyn cgeina dax minieqn miycewn mihqwh<br />
jka ic ik qe`xhy ly ezpeekl ieebph ly zbiiqnd ezepyxt xe`l elit` ,dle`b<br />
,dyhipe ilee`iwn eyry itk ,icn © dax zegizta zn` zxin`y epl mixikfn mdy<br />
zexendndn epze` livdl mileki miycewn mihqwh .zihilet dpigan zipqxd `id<br />
xzeia mixeng miihilet miryt ollkae ,xzeia zerytpd zereefdn mb ile`e epkxca<br />
.mneiwa oky lk `l ,mgeka zegtd lkl xikdl epilr jk myl .mfiytd oebk<br />
xtet lxw ,oex`a qpd ,oenlh awri oebk ,exec ipa mitqep milebe qe`xhy zrcl<br />
ocird ly dnxcd j` .rxle aehl drtyd dziid mihqwhle zepeirxl ,hcpx` dpge<br />
oi` .eply xaynd eppi` mdly xaynde ,eply dnxcd cer dppi` dnglnd xg`ly<br />
miiteqelit mihqwh ly myexit ;zeaiyg zxqg `id zepeirxd ly dixehqiddy xne` df<br />
mkxc z` `evnl epz`n micg`l oaenk mixfer mdilr orypd ixehqid giy zxivie<br />
zpn lr m` dl`yl xyw `ll .mdly zeiveaiwd zeiedfd wefig ici lr deedd xayna<br />
77,"xzeia<br />
ipeviwd hqivixehqidd" ,xbciidn ziptz zyxcp df xayna jxcd z` `evnl<br />
l` mipt zeccenzd `weec e` xtet ly ef znbec zip`ihpwÎe`ip zeihiletÎenqewl<br />
zeieyr zipicnd daygnd ly dixehqidly ixd ,qe`xhy ly ekxck xbciid mr mipt<br />
zepeirx ly mipeixehqid ik mixeaq ep` ,ipy cvn .zeihilet zeklyd zeidl hlgda<br />
dn ik mnvr z` mirpkynd ,ip`ixbciidd cre ip`ihpwÎe`ipd on ,`edy dpgn lkn<br />
.dxzi dnfbda mi`heg ,epzecxyidl `l m` ,epzgeexl dlecb dcina ipeig miyer mdy<br />
erityd ely zelbd ziieege mfixhilhehl qe`xhy ly ezecbpzdy eprh mekiql<br />
zepyxtd zhiy lr drityd ef dcnre ,mfivixehqidd cbp ezcnr lr zxkip dcina<br />
zeicbxhd ,exec ipa mixg` micedi milebl dneca .gzity zicegiid zil`ehqwhd<br />
.102 ,(16 dxrd lirl) zipicn diteqelit ,qe`xhy<br />
77
eizecxg<br />
z` wizrd qe`xhy mb ,mdn miaxk .ezebd lr erityd deegy micwzd zexqg<br />
.extql yi eay<br />
ote`d<br />
l` mb `l` xtiqy aihxpd l` wx `l zewcvende zeizn`d<br />
x`iz eze`y ,zeipxcend xayn z` mfixhilhehd xayna d`x qe`xhy mb mdenk<br />
ly zepyxtde dixehqidd xaynk xwirae mzepyxte zepeirx ly dixehqidd xaynk<br />
.zepyxtd ly dzelb xayn xy`n zegt `l df did exear .zipicnd daygnd<br />
30
31<br />
Abstract<br />
The Exile of Interpretation Anti-totalitarianism and exile motivated (or<br />
at least powerfully influenced) <strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>’ anti-historicism, which, in<br />
turn, informed his equally idiosyncratic method of textual interpretation.<br />
<strong>Strauss</strong> wrote his political anxieties into his history of political thought and,<br />
less obviously but hardly less significantly, into his theory of how to go<br />
about correctly telling it. For <strong>Strauss</strong>, as for many other Jewish exiles of<br />
his generation, the crisis of totalitarianism was the crisis of modernity,<br />
which he viewed as a crisis of intellectual history and its interpretation,<br />
particularly the history and interpretation of political thought. And as a<br />
crisis of interpretation, it was no less than the crisis of its exile.
<strong>Leo</strong> <strong>Strauss</strong>:<br />
The Exile of Interpretation<br />
David Weinstein<br />
Avihu Zakai<br />
±≥<br />
ÌÈÏ˘Â¯È†˜·†Â‡ÈφÔÂÎÓ
Editorial Board:<br />
Prof. Shmuel Feiner – Chairman; Dr. Rachel Freudenthal, Ms. Sharon<br />
Gordon, Prof. Joseph Mali, Mr. Shlomo Mayer, Prof. Guy Miron<br />
Copy Editing: Tammar Raveh<br />
“Chidushim” – <strong>Leo</strong> Baeck Institute Jerusalem<br />
33 Bustenai Street, Jerusalem 93229, P.O.B. 8298 Jerusalem 91082<br />
Tel: 02-5633790, Fax: 02-5669505<br />
E-mail:<br />
Journal: chidushim@gmail.com, Publisher: leobaeck@netvision.net.il<br />
©<br />
All Rights Reserved<br />
<strong>Leo</strong> Baeck Institute Jerusalem<br />
Jerusalem 2009<br />
No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form or by<br />
any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording or<br />
any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing<br />
from the publisher<br />
ISBN 978-965-7474-00-6<br />
Typesetting: <strong>Leo</strong> Baeck Institute Jerusalem
zxkip dcina erityd ely zelbd ziieege mfixhilhehl qe`xhy e`il ly ezecbpzd<br />
zil`ehqwhd zepyxtd zhiy lr zeax drityd ef dcnre ,mfivixehqidd cbp ezcnr lr<br />
micwzd zexqg zeicbxhd ,exec ipa mixg` micedi milebl dneca .gzity zicegiid<br />
zewcvende zeizn`d eizecxg z` wizrd qe`xhy .ezebd lr zeax erityd deegy<br />
d`x `ed .extql yi eay ote`d l` mb `l` xtiqy aihxpd l` wx `l exec ly<br />
ly dixehqidd xaynk x`iz eze`y ,zeipxcend xayn z` mfixhilhehd xayna<br />
.zipicnd daygnd ly zepyxtde dixehqidd xaynk xwirae ,mzepyxte zepeirx<br />
.zepyxtd ly dzelb xayn xy`n zegt `l df did exear<br />
dpilexw ,hqxet wiie zhiqxaipe`a dpicnd rcnl xeqtext `ed oiihypiie cec xeqtext<br />
.bivtiil ,aepaec oerny oekna hiixalet oxw mrhn zinr xag dl` miniae ,zipetvd<br />
Equal Freedom and Utility, 1998; The New Liberalism, edited :eixtq oia<br />
with Avital Simhony, 2001; Utilitarianism and the New Liberalism, 2007.<br />
dhiqxaipe`a dixehqidl bega zncwen zipxcen dixehqidl xeqtext `ed i`kf edia`<br />
Jonathan Edwards’s Philosophy: of History: :eixtq oia .milyexia zixard<br />
The Re-Enchantment of the World in the Age of Enlightenment, 2003,<br />
zixehqid drceze zc :dqtilwet`e dixehqid ; reprint: Paperback edition, 2009<br />
Jonathan ,ehr ixtn sqep xtq .2008 ,dwixn`ae dtexi`a dycgd zrd ziy`xa<br />
Edwards’s Philosophy of Nature: The Re-Enchantment of the World in<br />
.aexwa xe` ze`xl cizr , the Age of Scientific Reasoning<br />
drivnd zixard dtya mineqxt zxcq `id dipnxb icedi zeclez xwga miyecig<br />
.mixikae mixirv mixweg ly mhr ixt miixewn mixn`nl dna