463 Mass. 353 - Appellee Commonwealth Brief - Mass Cases
463 Mass. 353 - Appellee Commonwealth Brief - Mass Cases
463 Mass. 353 - Appellee Commonwealth Brief - Mass Cases
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
See <strong>Commonwealth</strong> v. Upton, 394 <strong>Mass</strong>. 363, 369-377<br />
(1985). "Where an unnamed informant's tip is relied on<br />
by the police as supplying probable cause to arrest and<br />
to search, art. 14 requires that the information<br />
satisfy the two-pronged standard set forth in Aguilar<br />
v. Texas, 378 U.S. 108 (1964), and Spinelli v. United<br />
States, 393 U.S. 410 (1969) ." <strong>Commonwealth</strong> v. Welch,<br />
4 2 o <strong>Mass</strong> . 6 4 6 , 6 50 . ( 19 9 5 ) . "As a rule, the<br />
<strong>Commonwealth</strong> must demonstrate some of the underlying<br />
circumstances from which [a] the informant gleaned his<br />
information [the "basis of knowledge" test] , and [b]<br />
the law enforcement officials could have concluded the<br />
informant was credible or reliable [the "veracity"<br />
test]." Id. Corroboration can compensate for any<br />
deficiencies in either or both prongs of the Aquilar<br />
Spinelli standard. <strong>Commonwealth</strong> v. Cast, 407 <strong>Mass</strong>.<br />
891, 899 (1990). The motion judge's findings "are<br />
binding in the absence of clear error" and this Court<br />
will "view, with particular respect, the conclusions of<br />
law which are based on them." Welch, 420 <strong>Mass</strong>. at 651.<br />
The veracity test may be satisfied in a number of<br />
ways, including if: (1) the informant has previously<br />
provided information leading to arrests and subsequent<br />
convictions, <strong>Commonwealth</strong> v. Byfield, 413 <strong>Mass</strong>. 426,<br />
17