20.07.2013 Views

Supreme Judicial Court - Mass Cases

Supreme Judicial Court - Mass Cases

Supreme Judicial Court - Mass Cases

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

e<br />

0<br />

rn<br />

a<br />

a<br />

rn<br />

0<br />

Conunittee on Urban Airairs anti , Board . of AppcAls of<br />

Hanovcr .- v. Hous5.nq A~JJC~~S Corn., 363 <strong>Mass</strong>. 3:39, 342-<br />

342. Emphasis added-.. .I<br />

3.V. 'The Conditions Imposed . - by ttic . .- Ilmesbury Hoard .- of<br />

Appeals Were<br />

~~ . . Within Hoard's Power and the Ilousi- -.<br />

~~~<br />

Appeals Committee<br />

. Lacks .. the Aut.hority<br />

-. to strike -<br />

Condj %ions That Do NUL Render the Prpject .. Uneconomic. -.<br />

Thi. HAC struck twenty-Four (24) conditions<br />

iricluded in thc decision uL the Hoard of Appeals, each<br />

deletion irnpermi-ssibly upheld by t.he 'Trial <strong>Court</strong>.<br />

NuLably, the Trial <strong>Court</strong> distinqui shed Lhe cnndi tionr<br />

iriLu two qroups. The first group beinq thosc<br />

conditions identified by <strong>Mass</strong>Housiricj (conditions 23,<br />

26, 28, 29, 38, 39. 43E, 43k', 43G and 43H) (scc RA<br />

Vol.1, 67; the second group being thc remaining<br />

fourteen coriditi ons not idcriL if ied by<br />

M~~sHousjiig(coridit.ir)ns 18, 19, 20, 40, 42, 43, 43A.<br />

438, 43D, 43K, 43L, 43N, 43W and 59).<br />

As djsciissed in Section I.C. above, 760 CMK<br />

31.07(1) (f) provides 211 opportuniCy for the<br />

suhsidi ziriy agency (here, <strong>Mass</strong>Hoiisiny) to announce its<br />

rcLusal to fund a project "bccause of a coriditj.on<br />

imposed hy thc Board" subject to the rcyulatj on's<br />

procedures. (AB discussed, these requircments were<br />

not. sati-sficd in the present matter). In other words,<br />

if the HAC is correct t-hat. sonic areas of the<br />

29

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!