20.07.2013 Views

Supreme Judicial Court - Mass Cases

Supreme Judicial Court - Mass Cases

Supreme Judicial Court - Mass Cases

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

. . ..<br />

specific statute that. the Lagfslat.ure did not p ~ ~ t<br />

t-here, ei.ther by i nadvcrtent Lomissiuri iir by desI.qn. "<br />

- Taylor v. Hoard of Appeals of Lcxington,<br />

. .. . - 4.51 <strong>Mass</strong>.<br />

270, 2'/Y (2008) citing ~. Sinunons v. Clerk-MagisLraLe<br />

-. .. . of<br />

the f3ostoI'i Div. .- of the Hour;. -<strong>Court</strong>. bept., 448 <strong>Mass</strong>.<br />

57, 64 (2006).<br />

Notwi thstandiny the Tri a1 CourL' ,s cioncern, the<br />

lirnj.ts of the Housing Appeals Committee's authority it;<br />

clearly framed by the statut-e and - Wohrn. . .<br />

13<br />

. . .<br />

I ,<br />

d. 11 e<br />

Housing Appeals ComiLtee is an ;iycncy wit.h limited<br />

authorit.y and thaC authority docs not j.ncliide strikiny<br />

those conditions imposed by a board of appeals<br />

pursuant to G.L. ~.40B, s.20-23 unless the cor.iditions<br />

l3 "The position of the Hoiisiny Appea1.s Commi ttee<br />

seems, at mosL, to be t.hat such a power would bo<br />

helpful in eficctuatinq the lcyislat.j.ve purpose<br />

underlying ss 20-73. That is qu1t.e possibly true, but<br />

it is not a basis fur Lhis court to irivcst the Housj.ng<br />

Appeals Committee with powers beyond those yi'ven it by<br />

the Legj.sl.ature. " Board of Appeals of North -. Andover<br />

v. , .,. Housinq Appeals -. Committee,<br />

.. 4 <strong>Mass</strong>.App.Ct. 676,<br />

680 (19.76) (Goodman, ,I. and Brown, J. djssenti.ng) (<strong>Court</strong><br />

concluded that the HAC lacked the power to impose<br />

speciiic condition on ordcr Lo board of appeals). Sce<br />

also, El.ectronics Corp. of America v. CoIrunissiuncr . . . .- of<br />

Revenue, 407 <strong>Mass</strong>. 672 (1988), 676-6'/'/, yuotiriy Bureau<br />

of 01d Age Assistance of Natick v. Commissioner or<br />

. ., .. -. ... .~<br />

- Pub. Welfare, 326 <strong>Mass</strong>. 121, 124 (1950). "[Aln<br />

admini.stra'Live board nr officer has no authority to<br />

promwlgate rules arld regulations which are in mnfl ict.<br />

with the stdLutes or exceed the authority conferred hy<br />

the statutes by whjch such board nr office was<br />

crealed. ''<br />

21

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!