20.07.2013 Views

464 Mass. 566 - Appellant Montoya Brief - Mass Cases

464 Mass. 566 - Appellant Montoya Brief - Mass Cases

464 Mass. 566 - Appellant Montoya Brief - Mass Cases

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

easily distinguishable. In that case, a pol officer<br />

was allowed to testify at trial that one-eighth of an<br />

ounce of cocaine was the equival 3.5 grams and<br />

, that one-quarter ounce was seven The SJC held<br />

that this jury could extrapolate this that one<br />

hundred grams was less than ounces. Therefore<br />

when the large hard ball of coca was taken into the<br />

jury room, the jury could form a lay opinion that it<br />

weighed more than four ounces. Id. at pp. 831-832. In<br />

this case, there was no is r the jury to make a<br />

similar extrapolation. Although Detective Hyde, while;<br />

testifying how cocaine is ged for street sale,<br />

described an fteight " as one eighth of an ounce or<br />

3.5 grams, he did not testify that in his opinion the<br />

individually wrapped introduced into evidence as<br />

,<br />

Exhibit 5 were" ght balls flB • In fact, he admitted<br />

that he had not ewed any police reports nor had he<br />

even seen the s containing the alleged cocaine<br />

before taking (2/133-134): Furthermore, the<br />

motion judge's it finding that Detective Hyde's<br />

testimony provided reliable alternative evidence<br />

concerning weight of the alleged contraband<br />

8 Detective Hyde so stated that cocaine was samet s<br />

broken down into smaller lots for street s e in<br />

amounts one gram and half a gram. (2/128)<br />

35

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!