20.07.2013 Views

464 Mass. 566 - Appellant Montoya Brief - Mass Cases

464 Mass. 566 - Appellant Montoya Brief - Mass Cases

464 Mass. 566 - Appellant Montoya Brief - Mass Cases

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

the motion to suppress that Corcoran was a reliable<br />

informant. Probable cause to arrest a suspect sed on<br />

rmation provided by an informant must meet the<br />

familiar two part test rived Spinelli v. United<br />

States, 303 U.S. 410 (1969) and Aguilar v. Texas, 378<br />

U.S. 108 (19640. See Commonwealth v. Upton, 394 <strong>Mass</strong>.<br />

363, 369 (1985). The formant must have a basis of<br />

knowledge for the information provided, Spinelli, 303<br />

U.S. at p. 410, and the informant must also be<br />

reliable, Aguilar, 378 U.S. at p. 108. The defendant<br />

concedes that the basis of knowledge prong<br />

satisfied in this case. See Commonwealth v. Montanez,<br />

410 <strong>Mass</strong>. 290, 299-300 (1991). However, the veracity<br />

prong has not been satisfi When the Commonwealth<br />

relies on a statement inst an informant's penal<br />

interest to prove that the in rmation is reliable,<br />

the Commonwealth must show that the police knew the<br />

informant's identity. Commonwealth v. Allen, 4a6<br />

<strong>Mass</strong>. 575, 579 (1990), and the informant a<br />

reasonable fear of prosecution. Commonwealth v.<br />

Melendez, 407 <strong>Mass</strong>. 53, 57 (1990). In this case,<br />

although the occupant of the pick-up truck was<br />

identified as Corcoran, there was no evidence at the<br />

hearing of the motion to suppress that Trooper Porter<br />

27

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!