Appellant McCowen Brief - Mass Cases
Appellant McCowen Brief - Mass Cases
Appellant McCowen Brief - Mass Cases
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
process, Change of venue, jury<br />
county, or sequestration should<br />
selection from another<br />
have been ordered. See<br />
Commonwealth v. Aldoupolis, 390 <strong>Mass</strong>. 428 (1983).<br />
VI1I.TAE COURT ERRED IN THE RESTRICTIOW OF DR. BROWN'S<br />
TESTIMONY AND ADMISSIOW OF BAD ACTS EVIDEUCCE.<br />
It has been stated "[h}ow far the cross-examination<br />
of a witness may be deemed helpful and relevant . as<br />
well as to what extent the accuracy, veracity or<br />
credibility of witnesses may be tested, must be Left<br />
largely to the sound discretion of the presiding judge,<br />
and is not open to revision, unless ... such di,scretion<br />
has been exercised in a way that results in the<br />
prejudice of a party ... by reason __ of too narrow<br />
restriction or too great breadth of inquiry.<br />
Commonwealth v. Vardinski, 438 <strong>Mass</strong>. 444 (2003);<br />
Commonwealth v. Civello, 39 <strong>Mass</strong>, App. Ct. 313 (1995).<br />
However, I' [ c ] ross- examination for the purpose of showing<br />
falsity of other testimony of the witness or bias and<br />
prejudice on his part is a matter of right." Commonwealth<br />
v. Russ, 232 <strong>Mass</strong>, 58, 79 (1919), The court may not bar<br />
examination about material matters, even if it elicits<br />
testimony not otherwise admissible.<br />
The prosecutor asked psychologist Eric Brown about<br />
<strong>McCowen</strong>'s ability to sketch the interior of Worthington's<br />
home during his interrogation. Tr. 3286-87,3291-3306.<br />
-59-