a critical evaluation on the concept of justice in planning process

problems in legal process, effects of judicial control on this process, approaches of
individuals and groups and influences of results on space can be evaluated in this
process.
Data concerning the actions reflected on judicial control in planning process
include necessary information that accompanies demands of urban rights and justice
discussions of problems/conflicts occurred with these demands of rights. These data
provide the possibility to explore the concentration of conflicts, subjects of conflicts,
claims of the parties and to examine the planning process in legal process. Concerning
the data obtained from court files, it is accepted that; subjects of data represent subjects
of conflicts, concentration of subjects represent the concentration of conflicts; actors
(plaintiff, defendant, experts, related institution and legal dimension) represent the
justice approach of different groups.
In this aim, municipalities of Balçova and Narlıdere have been selected as case
studies. Data regarding all actions proceeded between 1992 -2003 where mayoralties of
those municipalities were the parties inside their own municipal boundaries, have been
obtained under the following extent.
1.4.1. Extent of Obtained Data
1.4.1.1. General Evaluation:
In order to make a general <strong>evaluation</strong>, it is aimed to determine and classify the
subject, content and intensity of the problems concerning demands of urban right
proceeded in judicial process. For this aim, as the primary step of the study, data about
all of the cases proceeded between 1992 -2003 and registered in Directorates of Law
Affairs of Balçova and Narlıdere Municipalities were obtained. These data consist of
the following brief information existed in the registration books of related directorates;
plaintiff/defendant party, subject of action, proceeding year of the action, authorized
court, conclusion of the court. These can give necessary information to constitute a
general data and about fields of conflict and dimension of conflicts. While considering
actions as disagreement/conflict fields representing spatial problems, questions that
have to be answered in general <strong>evaluation</strong> process can be discussed as follows:
9