a critical evaluation on the concept of justice in planning process

Table 4. 42. Distribution of Demolition Decision Results According to Counties
County Result Total
Balçova Continues 3
No need to decide because of relinquishment 1
Acceptance 9
Partial Acceptance 2
Rejection 47
Limitation of action (duration) 1
Balçova Total 63
Narlıdere No information 4
Consolidation 1
Continues 1
No need to decide because of relinquishment 2
No need to decide 1
Acceptance 3
Partial Acceptance 1
Rejection 64
Narlıdere Total 77
Grand Total 140
As actions about demolition decisions have been examined in Balçova and
Narlıdere counties in general, it has been noticed that, there were 140 actions and 111of
these actions were rejected against plaintiff party. As actions evaluated according to
counties; 47 actions, through 63 actions regarding demolitions in Balçova settlement,
were rejected against plaintiff party and demolitions were approved. In Narlıdere
settlement, 64 actions through 77 actions in total were rejected against plaintiff party
and demolitions were approved. Numeric values of these actions show the concentration
of illegal buildings and buildings that were constructed against license and its annexes.
4.3.3.1. Demolition Decisions in Balçova
Distribution of demolition decisions taken by Municipality of Balçova inside
municipal boundaries is as follows:
1. Buildings that were constructed against building license in geothermal protection
area. Property owners existing inside protection zone (opposite Dokuz Eylül
University Hospital) have objected the decisions by stating that; their properties
have been in the protection zone and although they have not been expropriated, they
can not use their properties. On the other hand, constructions have continued.
149