a critical evaluation on the concept of justice in planning process

Relinquishment for Road, Determination, Taxes (entertainment, real estate,
environmental), Objections to the Decisions No.8049-8050-10168 of zmir No.1
Committee of Protection of Cultural and Natural Heritage. 67
According to the data obtained from this classification, total number of actions
under “spatial” title regarding planning and space is 965. Total number of actions under
“others” title which have the characteristic of administrative transaction but do not
include spatial subjects and actions that have juridical contents but not spatial subjects is
250. If this is considered according to percentage distributions; through totally 1215
cases, percentage of actions in “spatial” category is 79,42% and actions in “others”
category is 20,58 %.
In total, 1215 actions are evaluated in county basis; in Balçova settlement, 112
of juridical actions (9,22%) have “others” and 79 juridical actions (6,5%) have “spatial”
contents; 19 of administrative actions (1,56%) have “others” and 546 administrative
actions (44,94%) have “spatial” contents. Totally in Balçova settlement, 625 cases are
in “spatial” and 131 cases are in “others” categories through all administrative and
juridical actions.
In Narlıdere settlement, 82 of juridical actions (6,75%) have “others” and 112
juridical actions (9,22%) have “spatial” contents; 29 of administrative actions (2,39%)
have “others” and 228 administrative actions (18,77%) have “spatial” contents.
Furthermore, 8 more actions exist in “others” category. In Narlıdere settlement, 340
actions (27,99%) have “spatial” subjects and 119 actions (9,8%) have “other” subjects
through 459 administrative and juridical actions in total.
Examination in distribution of action subjects indicates the intensity of actions
regarding space through all administrative and juridical actions. These results in both
two settlements, which are indicators of spatial disputes in urban space and demands of
right on urban space, state that urban procedures/arrangements applied by related
municipality and committee of protection are not considered as fair and also state the
amendment demands in procedures done by judicial control.
67 Data about the distribution of these actions according to authorized courts are shown in App.A and
App.B
114