18.07.2013 Views

rayuan jenayah no: a-05-120-2009 antara mohd kamal bin osman

rayuan jenayah no: a-05-120-2009 antara mohd kamal bin osman

rayuan jenayah no: a-05-120-2009 antara mohd kamal bin osman

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

9<br />

is <strong>no</strong>t concerned as to the ownership of the said motorcycle but rather the<br />

possession of the black coloured plastic bag (exhibit “P5C”) that contained<br />

the dangerous drugs found in the carrier basket of the said motorcycle.<br />

[24] The learned High Court Judge rightly referred to the Court of<br />

Appeal case of PP v. Letchumanan Suppiah [2006] 1 CLJ 557 and his<br />

Lordship then decided that section 114(g) of the Evidence Act 1950 did <strong>no</strong>t<br />

apply and it can<strong>no</strong>t be invoked against the prosecution for the <strong>no</strong>n-calling<br />

of the appellant’s wife. We are concerned here with the custody and control<br />

of the black coloured plastic bag (exhibit “P5C”) found in the carrier basket<br />

of the motorcycle which can<strong>no</strong>t be related to the ownership of the<br />

motorcycle on which the appellant was riding. That black coloured plastic<br />

bag (exhibit “P5C”) was within sight of the appellant as he rode the said<br />

motorcycle on that fateful day. There was <strong>no</strong>t even an iota of evidence<br />

linking the appellant’s wife to the drugs at all. There was <strong>no</strong> cross-<br />

examination of SP4 and SP5 that the drugs belonged to the appellant’s<br />

wife.<br />

[25] The prosecution’s case hinged on the evidence of SP4 whose<br />

evidence was corroborated by SP5. The totality of the evidence led by the<br />

prosecution pointed solely to the culpability of the appellant. No one else<br />

was involved. It is our judgment, even without calling the appellant’s wife,

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!