15.07.2013 Views

FINDING N-TH ROOTS IN NILPOTENT GROUPS AND ...

FINDING N-TH ROOTS IN NILPOTENT GROUPS AND ...

FINDING N-TH ROOTS IN NILPOTENT GROUPS AND ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>F<strong>IN</strong>D<strong>IN</strong>G</strong> N-<strong>TH</strong> <strong>ROOTS</strong> <strong>IN</strong> <strong>NILPOTENT</strong> <strong>GROUPS</strong>... 587<br />

Theorem 7.2. (Zorn, 1936) Every finite Engel group is nilpotent.<br />

Theorem 7.3. (Gruenberg, 1953) Every finitely generated solvable Engel<br />

group is nilpotent.<br />

Theorem 7.4. (Baer, 1957) Every Engel group satisfying max is nilpotent.<br />

Theorem 7.5. (Suprenenko and Garscuk, 1962) Every linear Engel group<br />

is nilpotent.<br />

Proposition 7.6. The Heisenberg group is a 2-Engel group.<br />

Proof. We want to show that [[X,Y ],Y ] = I. Let X = A m B n C k =<br />

⎛ ⎞<br />

1 m k + mn<br />

⎝0<br />

1 n ⎠ and Y = A<br />

0 0 1<br />

uBvC w ⎛ ⎞<br />

1 u w + uv<br />

= ⎝0<br />

1 v ⎠. Then X<br />

0 0 1<br />

−1 =<br />

⎛ ⎞<br />

1 −m −k<br />

⎝0<br />

1 −n⎠<br />

and Y<br />

0 0 1<br />

−1 ⎛ ⎞<br />

1 −u −w<br />

= ⎝0<br />

1 −v⎠.<br />

Next, [X,Y ] = X<br />

0 0 1<br />

−1Y −1XY =<br />

⎛<br />

⎞<br />

1 0 −nu + mv<br />

⎝0<br />

1 0 ⎠. Finally, [[X,Y ],Y ] = [X,Y ]<br />

0 0 1<br />

−1Y −1 ⎛ ⎞<br />

1 0 0<br />

[X,Y ]Y = ⎝0<br />

1 0⎠.<br />

0 0 1<br />

Lemma 7.7. Every element in the Heisenberg group satisfies Y X 2 Y =<br />

XY 2 X.<br />

Proof. We will prove a more general case: in every 2-Engel group, yx 2 y =<br />

xy 2 x. To see this, note that<br />

[y,x][x −1 ,y −1 ] = [y,x]xyx −1 y −1 = x[y,x]yx −1 y −1<br />

= x[y,x]yx −1 y −1 xx −1 = x[y,x][y −1 ,x]x −1<br />

= x[e,x]x −1 = e.<br />

From this, we conclude that [y,x] = [x −1 ,y −1 ] −1 = [y −1 ,x −1 ], which is equivalent<br />

to yx 2 y = xy 2 x.<br />

There are other semigroup laws for other Engel groups. Here, we will discuss<br />

the laws for 3-Engel and 4-Engel groups.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!