Before Jerusalem Fell

by Kenneth L. Gentry by Kenneth L. Gentry

12.07.2013 Views

298 BEFORE JERUSALEM FELL Pliny knew that for some time past the Christians had been legaIly regarded as the enemies of the state and that confession of the name meant outlawry. . . . The Rescript of Trajan merely confirmed in writing the practice, which had subsisted since the time of Nero, of treating the very name of Christian as a crime against the State.5G Angus comments on the view held by “Hardy (Christianity and th Roman Government, 77), Mommsen (Expos, 1893, 1-7) and Sanday (ib, 1894, 406K) – and adopted by the writer of this article – that the trial of the Christians under Nero resulted in the declaration of the mere profession of Christianity as a crime punishable by death. . . . [T]he Neronian persecution settled the future attitude of the Roman state toward the new faith. “5 7 Ancient evidence suggestive of the provincial persecution of Christianity is not of the earliest date, but is significant because of its reported reliance on Tacitus and perhaps even on Tacitus’s lost works. Orosius states that after Nero tortured Christians, he “ordered this throughout all the provinces, with the same excruciating persecution.”58 In the seventh book of Orosius’s history, in which he provides an account of both the fire and the persecution, “Orosius shows himself to be thoroughly acquainted with the writings of Suetonius, Tacitus, and Josephus, all of which he quotes by name.”59 Sulpicius Severus writes regarding Nero’s persecution that “in this way, cruelty first began to be manifested against the Christians. Afterwards, too, their religion was prohibited by laws that were enacted; and by edicts openly set forth it was proclaimed unlawfiul to be a Christian. At that time Paul and Peter were condemned to death, the former being beheaded with a sword, while Peter suffered crucifixion.”w Conclusion The evidence of a general persecution against Christianity under Nero is strong and almost universally recognized. Its cruelty, extent, and length are most compatible with the requirements of the Revelational record. Not only so, but the Domitkmic evidence is meager 56. Edmundson, Church in Ronw, p. 139, n. 1. 57. Angus, “Roman Empire,” ISBE 4:2607. 58. Oroshs, 7iie Seven Books of His~ Against the Pagans 7:7. 59. Edmundson, Church in Rorm, p. 143. 60. Severus, Samed Histmy 2:29.

The Perstzution of Christiani~ 299 and, if accepted, Domitian’s persecution pales in comparison. Interestingly, while admitting that “the evidence for widespread persecution under Domitian is not especially strong,” Mounce goes on rather boldly to add that yet “there is no other period in the first century in which it would be more likely” !Gl Furthermore, the very chronological occurrence of the Neronic persecution is more suitable to Revelation’s treatment. “To all appearance, at Rome, the Christian Church was drowning in its own blood in Nero’s reign. We must consider the feeling of the ordinary Christian – the man in the street, so to speak – and look at it from his point of view. In later persecutions men had got to know that the Church could survive the furious edicts of Rome. But that was just the doubt which presented itself to the mind of the average Christian man in Nero’s time. ”G2 No imperial persecution other than the very first would be more important to establishing the durability of the faith. No imperial persecution more than this one required a word of exhortation and consolation to the beleaguered faith. 61. Mounce, Revelatwn, p. 34. 62. Ratton, Apoca~pse, p. 87.

298 BEFORE JERUSALEM FELL<br />

Pliny knew that for some time past the Christians had been legaIly<br />

regarded as the enemies of the state and that confession of the name<br />

meant outlawry. . . . The Rescript of Trajan merely confirmed in<br />

writing the practice, which had subsisted since the time of Nero, of<br />

treating the very name of Christian as a crime against the State.5G<br />

Angus comments on the view held by “Hardy (Christianity and th<br />

Roman Government, 77), Mommsen (Expos, 1893, 1-7) and Sanday (ib,<br />

1894, 406K) – and adopted by the writer of this article – that the<br />

trial of the Christians under Nero resulted in the declaration of the<br />

mere profession of Christianity as a crime punishable by death. . . .<br />

[T]he Neronian persecution settled the future attitude of the Roman<br />

state toward the new faith. “5 7<br />

Ancient evidence suggestive of the provincial persecution of Christianity<br />

is not of the earliest date, but is significant because of its<br />

reported reliance on Tacitus and perhaps even on Tacitus’s lost<br />

works. Orosius states that after Nero tortured Christians, he “ordered<br />

this throughout all the provinces, with the same excruciating persecution.”58<br />

In the seventh book of Orosius’s history, in which he provides<br />

an account of both the fire and the persecution, “Orosius shows<br />

himself to be thoroughly acquainted with the writings of Suetonius,<br />

Tacitus, and Josephus, all of which he quotes by name.”59 Sulpicius<br />

Severus writes regarding Nero’s persecution that “in this way, cruelty<br />

first began to be manifested against the Christians. Afterwards, too,<br />

their religion was prohibited by laws that were enacted; and by edicts<br />

openly set forth it was proclaimed unlawfiul to be a Christian. At that<br />

time Paul and Peter were condemned to death, the former being<br />

beheaded with a sword, while Peter suffered crucifixion.”w<br />

Conclusion<br />

The evidence of a general persecution against Christianity under<br />

Nero is strong and almost universally recognized. Its cruelty, extent,<br />

and length are most compatible with the requirements of the Revelational<br />

record. Not only so, but the Domitkmic evidence is meager<br />

56. Edmundson, Church in Ronw, p. 139, n. 1.<br />

57. Angus, “Roman Empire,” ISBE 4:2607.<br />

58. Oroshs, 7iie Seven Books of His~ Against the Pagans 7:7.<br />

59. Edmundson, Church in Rorm, p. 143.<br />

60. Severus, Samed Histmy 2:29.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!